Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my DC would stick out like a sore thumb in the North East?

321 replies

Rainallnight · 14/03/2022 08:33

We are a two mum family and we adopted our DC.

We are contemplating a move to the North East, where DP is from.

My major concern is that our DC wouldn’t be at school with any other kids from a same sex family and, because it’s more unusual, would be more likely to be made to feel different. I also worry about bullying.

Any thoughts from anyone in that part of the world? AIBU?

OP posts:
kittensinthekitchen · 14/03/2022 17:42

And for those who think that homophobia is gone in this country…

@Lovelteers

Who said that?

He’s from Yorkshire, but maybe that’s a coincidence.

Hmm🙄

saraclara · 14/03/2022 17:39

As a pp said, "the NE" is so big a region that it makes the question in the OP impossible to answer. As a region, it's not statistically more or less likely to have a sizeable gay community than, say, the South or the East. There's nothing in the air that prevents people being born gay up there.

Now if you asked about a particular town, or area of a city, you might get more helpful answers. It's not that gay couples move entirely away from a whole swathe of the country, but they might well find particular areas have a more comfortable vibe than others.

JaninaDuszejko · 14/03/2022 17:37

Where do you live at the moment that you are so convinced there are more LGB parents than average? Hebden Bridge?

The NE is no better or worse than most areas for homophobia. In our NE town there are LBGT groups in all the secondary schools so there is support and while there are homophobic comments made by stupid kids (DD is in Y9 so exposed to the peak horrible behaviour) I'm not aware of systematic targetted bullying. The gay kids all seem to have a pretty tight friendship group anyway.

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2022 17:30

@Lovelteers

‘But then Hebden Bridge has more lesbians per capita than any other place in the UK. Yes, more than Brighton.’

Hebden doesn’t have more lesbians than Brighton. A larger percentage of the population are lesbian but it’s a much smaller population.
It’s also not in the North East…

Try re-reading, I quite clearly wrote "per capita".
Maireas · 14/03/2022 16:58

Seriously, OP - you're worried for your children, but there are plenty of people from the NE on here who advise that it won't be a problem.
Just make sure that if they come across it, they report it, as I'm sure you have encouraged them to do.

TravellingFrom · 14/03/2022 16:54

@DdraigGoch there has also been people like myself who said it is unusual.
(But that it didn’t seem to attract any bullying). Racism and xenophobia on the other hand……

Selecting the posts that happen to agree with your pov doesnt help.

Maireas · 14/03/2022 16:54

@TheCatWearsPrada

Of course you shouldn't move! Everyone knows that the NE round up all same sex couples and ship them off to London
I heard they get pelted with avocados
Maireas · 14/03/2022 16:53

@Wavypurple

It’s the NE of England not Saudi Arabia
Exactly!
Lovelteers · 14/03/2022 16:50

‘But then Hebden Bridge has more lesbians per capita than any other place in the UK. Yes, more than Brighton.’

Hebden doesn’t have more lesbians than Brighton. A larger percentage of the population are lesbian but it’s a much smaller population.
It’s also not in the North East…

Jansobieski · 14/03/2022 16:34

Lol. To read the comments about trans people on here let's hope most of the UK isn't like MN Hmm

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2022 16:23

@Lovelteers

‘ Or are you somehow suggesting London simply has more gay people?’

Yes, London has more gay people! And Brighton as a % of the population has something like 4/5 times the National average .
Because what happens is gay people leave often leave their home villages, towns or even cities and go to places with reputations for tolerance and where they’ll meet other gay people.
It happens all over the world, not just in the U.K.

But then Hebden Bridge has more lesbians per capita than any other place in the UK. Yes, more than Brighton.

It's not black and white (South good, North bad), you could have two outwardly identical ex-mining villages, one with half a dozen same-sex families, one where the doctors are still applying leeches. Just like two neighbourhoods in London may have very different attitudes.

The OP is worried that her children may be the only ones with their type of family. Rather than asking about the whole of the NE - there have been plenty of posts from residents to say that it's not unusual where they live, including some first-hand anecdotes from posters who are in same-sex relationships, and who are bringing up kids - she'd be better off being a little more specific about where they are thinking about. Especially as while officially the "North East" only starts at Darlington, many people also count Yorkshire.

Branleuse · 14/03/2022 16:21

@DefaultParent

Noone is trying to minimise your concerns OP. BUT your post is basically accusing everyone from the North East of being backward homophobes. Which is pretty ridiculous and small minded. Maybe you could specify where you are hoping to move and get some proper accounts of people that live there?
Of course people are minimising her concerns. If OP actually thought the entire NE was homophobic then it wouldnt even be consideration enough to even start the thread. Her partner is from the NE and is gay so clearly they do get gays up there. Surely its actually sensible to try and determine whether a new area might have more homophobic bullying culture than others. Its hardly an uncommon prejudice unfortunately. I was really careful when looking for secondary schools for my gay kid that i got a good feel for not just staff attitudes but asked kids and parents stuff too. It meant i decided against the catholic school that my other kid went to as i felt the amount of strictly religious eastern european kids and kids from african countries where being gay is illegal, might mean less acceptance than at some of the other local schools. That isnt me saying that everyone from those places or everyone who is catholic is going to be a massive homophobe because clearly that isnt the case. Its me being realistic about whether my kid would find a peer group and be welcomed, or whether theyd have to pretend they werent gay or be bullied. Noone needs to rush to defend the north east from some anonymous mumsnetter worried about being asked to move areas
Lurking9to5 · 14/03/2022 16:16

I think the OP was roasted here and yet, isn't it a thing that anybody different heads to the bright lights and the big city. I'm not from the North East, I'm from Ireland but I think it's definitely a thing here that anybody gay or mixed race would take their dc to the city. So I get where OP is coming from. Saying that, my son is at an Educate Together school and I think the fundraisers for LGBTQ+/- kids don't raise an eyebrow in Dublin, there would be no cake sales for LGBTQ+/- in the tiny national schools still under the patronage of the catholic church.

SarahAndQuack · 14/03/2022 16:11

@mudgetastic

Why does she say they will stand out? Remind me ?

Was it . Same sex parents

What do you call the bullying of people based on sexuality ? Was it homophobic?

So you are saying that the bullying as a result of same sex parents is not homophobic?

I don't understand what you're struggling with (or pretending to struggle with) here.

In her OP, she doesn't presume to speculate about homophobia, which personally I think is probably appropriate when you're talking about children. But children sometimes do pick on another child who is 'different', and it can be hard to be the child who's the odd one out.

It's a perfectly natural worry to have.

mudgetastic · 14/03/2022 16:09

Why does she say they will stand out? Remind me ?

Was it . Same sex parents

What do you call the bullying of people based on sexuality ? Was it homophobic?

So you are saying that the bullying as a result of same sex parents is not homophobic?

SarahAndQuack · 14/03/2022 16:08

@mudgetastic

Why does she think they will be bullied???? What does she say ... remind me ...

Because ... the north east .....????

Stop making excuses - originally I thought it was just badly worded but this doubling down makes me think that there are some horrible attitudes towards the north

Why should those children be more likely bullied in one region than another?? Please spell it out

She says why.

She's worried they will stand out, and therefore be bullied.

It's perfectly clear.

CavernousScream · 14/03/2022 16:07

The North East is a big place with huge differences in the population. There’s a huge difference between a Durham pit village and somewhere like Jesmond. Pick the right area and your children won’t stand out at all.

Lovelteers · 14/03/2022 16:07

‘ Why should those children be more likely bullied in one region than another?? Please spell it out’

They’re more likely to be picked on for being a Rainbow Family in places where LGBTQ+ people and families are rarer.
It’s why we’ll never move back to my home city. We’d be unusual, an oddity and that comes with attention, both good and bad.

PigsyChibsy · 14/03/2022 16:06

NW here and know several Same Sex parents, kids are completely unfazed. At high school it appears to be seriously uncool to be anything but accepting and tolerant, I would suggest if they are going to be bullied that this is not the topic that will be picked on.

Handsnotwands · 14/03/2022 16:05

I live in the most conservative, least diverse country town you could possibly imagine and both my DC have friends with same sex parents. I think the gays are out and proud pretty much everywhere these days Wink

mudgetastic · 14/03/2022 16:04

Why does she think they will be bullied???? What does she say ... remind me ...

Because ... the north east .....????

Stop making excuses - originally I thought it was just badly worded but this doubling down makes me think that there are some horrible attitudes towards the north

Why should those children be more likely bullied in one region than another?? Please spell it out

Lovelteers · 14/03/2022 16:04

‘ Or are you somehow suggesting London simply has more gay people?’

Yes, London has more gay people! And Brighton as a % of the population has something like 4/5 times the National average .
Because what happens is gay people leave often leave their home villages, towns or even cities and go to places with reputations for tolerance and where they’ll meet other gay people.
It happens all over the world, not just in the U.K.

SarahAndQuack · 14/03/2022 16:02

@mudgetastic

That is exactly what the op is worried about - that the homophobic north east is going to be a bad place to raise their kids - that they shouldn't move to the north east because the kids will be bullied due to homophobia , that no school in the north east will have kids with same sex parents
It might be that she's worried about that, but what she's actually saying is that she's worried her children will stand out, and be bullied.

You are just making up nonsense when you claim she said no school in the north east will have kids with same-sex parents. She didn't even begin to say this.

polkadot25 · 14/03/2022 16:00

There are 2 types of "Northern" folk, though I am sure this could be applied to all areas of the country. There are the ones that have lived in the area their entire lives and think they know the world but are very insular and narrow minded, for that very reason - they have never left. This tends to be more the small ex mining type communities. Yes these places can be very non welcoming of anything different.

If you are thinking of moving to Newcastle itself, then it will be more accepting as it is a relatively large city with a diverse mixture of people.

I grew up in West Cumbria (not the NE, but a small ex mining community) until I was 18 then moved to the North East for uni. The difference in the people was stark. A lot of these communities are isolated geographically and politically and they just haven't got a clue about how the world is now. It's not their fault, it just the way it is. More open minded people leave which exacerbates the issue as the population just gets older and older with no new ideas or concepts to deal with.

Pluvia · 14/03/2022 15:58

@EdithRea

I wasn't aware London had more sets of gay parents than the North East. What do the gay parents here do, move to London? Or are you somehow suggesting London simply has more gay people?

You know, I thought the constant snippy comments about the North not having running water, or jobs, or Ikea, or television were annoying, but I think "I'm just not sure the North has gay people" has taken the biscuit.

See the ONS statistics cited upthread. The proportion of LGB people in London is significantly higher than in other areas. The North East has lower percentage of gay people than several other comparable areas, including Wales. LGB people have always traditionally left more provincial areas for the bright lights of big cities where their sexuality isn't such an issue and it seems that it's still happening.

I'm presuming you didn't pause for a moment to think it through rationally before lashing out.