Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

21 years old boy - what would you have done?

60 replies

Possiblynotever · 14/03/2022 07:06

My parents live in another country. They have been asked to give shelter to a 21 years old boy. He had just finished his compulsory military service in Ukraine and took a holiday to see his nan. War started and he wanted to go back to fight. His grandmother hid his passport and talked him out of it.
My parents are happy to give him a room, he seems a great boy. But my DF has pointed out that, the way things are going, he will probably feel guilty for all the rest of his life and that not fighting for his country will probably result in him never to return back. He also argues that it will affect his mental health taking into account that all his mates are fighting.
I somehow agree and I think that his grandmother should keep his passport, as in this way the choice is out of his hands and he can blame it on someone else in the future.
I would not care to be blamed for something like this.
My DF argues (and I see the logic) that he is a man and that he should be free to choose his life.
AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 19:50

@dworky

Your husband is insane.
Why?

What she do you think a person had the right to decide what they do!

Possiblynotever · 14/03/2022 19:43

And for those who wonder whether he is really 21...I do not understand what difference does ot make whether he is 21 or 25.
My DF analysis comes from a different angle: he used to be an army officer, and he probably knows that the guilt will be with him forever.
If I were the grandmother I would feel guilty forever not having hidden his documents.
My parents will give him shelter and a bicycle and he will probably find a job soon enough.
They will not mention this to anyone and nor will I.

OP posts:
Possiblynotever · 14/03/2022 19:33

Sorry, very busy day!
His grandmother is a carer and cannot host him.
You are all right he is an adult.
No, he cannot travel without a passport.
No, they will not give him another one quickly as the Embassy cannot access the database.

OP posts:
CaptainMyCaptain · 14/03/2022 17:43

@MedSchoolRat

OP asked "WWYD"

I doubt that I would hide a passport to stop my son or grandson from going off to fight. I might cry for hours about it, try to make them think hard, wait some days to decide, but I wouldn't hide a passport.

Yes. I would do this.
MedSchoolRat · 14/03/2022 17:19

OP asked "WWYD"

I doubt that I would hide a passport to stop my son or grandson from going off to fight. I might cry for hours about it, try to make them think hard, wait some days to decide, but I wouldn't hide a passport.

VelvetChairGirl · 14/03/2022 12:36

@FacebookPhotos

because this is all reminding me of all those girls who ran off to isis.

Returning home to fight for your own country against an invader is just not the same thing at all.

how is it not? we are all the same except for our beliefs and ideology.
Easterbunnyiswindowshopping · 14/03/2022 12:27

My ds is 20 yo solider .. He is going to Poland in a week or so. Wish it was as simple as hiding his passport....
Sad

HikingforScenery · 14/03/2022 12:23

He’s an adult but yes, I’m 100% with the grandma. I wouldn’t care if he hated me forever because of this.

GreenWhiteViolet · 14/03/2022 12:17

I wouldn't want any of my family members to fight in a war, but he's 21 and a grown man. It's his decision and as others have said, confiscating an adult's passport is completely wrong.

That's true regardless of why he wants the passport and where he's going. In response to the suggested hypothetical scenario that he were going to fight for ISIS, say, the reasonable response for a worried relative would be to tell him that you'd notify the police if he insisted he was going. Not take his passport.

Shamima Begum et al. were 15 years old - a very different situation.

ChampagneLassie · 14/03/2022 12:06

I agree with your DF - I'm pretty confident if I were a young Ukrainian man I'd want to fight not flee, its not her decision to make. If grandma won't give him his passport I'm pretty sure he could go to a Ukrainian embassy and they'd sort him out whichever country you're in

FacebookPhotos · 14/03/2022 12:00

because this is all reminding me of all those girls who ran off to isis.

Returning home to fight for your own country against an invader is just not the same thing at all.

CaptainMyCaptain · 14/03/2022 11:59

If he was my son or grandson I wouldn't want him to fight either but he is a grown man and can make his own choices. It is wrong to take someone's passport and I believe, in the UK at least, it is actually illegal.

VelvetChairGirl · 14/03/2022 11:52

Can I ask all the people saying he should go and fight if he wants, if their view would be the same if he wanted to fight for Russia?

because this is all reminding me of all those girls who ran off to isis.

Hoppinggreen · 14/03/2022 11:34

Also, for people talking about schengen/passports etc this man and OPs parents are NOT in The UK

Hoppinggreen · 14/03/2022 11:33

Do your parents know his story is true?
He could be 25+ and have hidden his own passport or anything and unless your parents can verify who he is then there is no way they should have him in their home. Even then I don’t know why they would

OfstedOffred · 14/03/2022 11:29

Dont get me wrong, I would do everything to try and verbally persuade my son not to. But to actually take another adults passport - not ok. What you consider protecting them is actually just denying them freedom.

Gowithme · 14/03/2022 10:20

Maybe he didn't want to go and fight at all, he just felt obliged to and the grandmother has actually just enabled him to make the choice he really wanted. No one should have to fight in a war if they don't want to, and there's no way for anyone here to know what he really wanted.

OrlandointheWilderness · 14/03/2022 09:14

He is an adult. He should be allowed to make his own choices.

OfstedOffred · 14/03/2022 08:54

You do if you don't want them to be killed by Russians when it's avoidable

You don't get to choose what risks other adults take, even your own children.

GreenClock · 14/03/2022 08:54

The grandmother acted inappropriately but the young man needs somewhere to stay so I wouldn’t send him away. He will have to deal with the mental health repercussions when the war is over.

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/03/2022 08:51

Do your parents want to house him? He could possibly get a job pretty quickly or even help out with refugees to assuage his guilt for example. He would need his passport for this. This MAN should be allowed to make his own choices.

As for travelling to Warsaw. We opted out of shengen, which is why there were systematic boarder control. There are still sometimes spot checks if travelling by road between countries. With the Ukraine situation, I would wonder if patrols have restarted between certain countries.

How would that flight work for a Brit? He needs a passport to board a plane in the EU. He isn’t even an EU citizen so has the same status as anyone with a passport from a third country.

loislovesstewie · 14/03/2022 08:50

Sorry I will clarify.

The Schengen Zone abolished travel restrictions, so it became one big country to all intents and purposes. The UK wasn't in the Schengen Zone, so UK nationals have always needed their passports. Some other EU countries have not implemented the Schengen rules, so people still require passports. Ireland and Romania haven't for example.
And there are non-EU countries, like Iceland who are in the Schengen zone.
The UK is in a Common Travel Area with the Republic of Ireland, so nationals of those countries don't require passports to go between them.
Hope that helps.

girlmom21 · 14/03/2022 08:50

@OfstedOffred

He's an adult. You do not fucking confiscate another adult's passport.
You do if you don't want them to be killed by Russians when it's avoidable
Lollyfalalalalalalalalaaahhhhh · 14/03/2022 08:49

I would do the same for my child/grandchild. Its senseless death to send him there

herecomesthehotsteppa · 14/03/2022 08:47

@girlmom21 yes it's true. French nationals can use their carte d'identité for example. We don't have an equivalent so it was always passports for us.
Now we are out of Europe, French must use a passport to come to the UK

Swipe left for the next trending thread