Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your best retorts when told to smile

162 replies

tympanic · 14/03/2022 04:41

I'm over it. I even get it from my husband. Not my fault I have resting bitch face. I know the hive will have some witty retorts so let's have them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cas112 · 17/03/2022 10:02

@Kanaloa

For strangers, none. That’s what they want. I just completely ignore, and if it persists I would say ‘leave me alone.’

For a husband? I’d say stop saying that, I don’t like it. If it continued I’d have a look at why my husband treated me like that.

‘Witty retorts’ are generally just a bit embarrassing in my opinion and only enter into ‘banter’ with someone being rude to you. I prefer a dignified silence or asking someone not to speak to me.

I would ignore this OP and just tell them all to fuck off haha
OneTC · 17/03/2022 09:31

I'm a (seemingly) perpetually miserable looking small man and men say it frequently, sometimes women but not frequently

It's a power play regardless of who says it.

I say "fuck off and die

gingerhills · 17/03/2022 09:24

@Oldbird69

I work in a supermarket, and it's amazing how many times a day it gets said to us. Maybe because they know we can't say much back. I usually just stare at them, then ask if they'd like a carrier bag, totally ignoring the comment.
Do women ever say it or is it always men?
Oldbird69 · 16/03/2022 17:53

I work in a supermarket, and it's amazing how many times a day it gets said to us. Maybe because they know we can't say much back. I usually just stare at them, then ask if they'd like a carrier bag, totally ignoring the comment.

bemusedmoose · 16/03/2022 13:46

i get it a lot - my resting face just looks f#cking miserable! But it depends who said it and how they said it. 'F#cks sake - cheer up love' pees me right off so does 'oi - give us a smile' like being told to smile is going to make me burst with joy 'hey - smile' in a soft voice with a smile and lifted eyebrows says ' i've noticed you look like you need a pick me up'

Usually i just say - sorry that's my face. But more often than not it's a slimey old bloke having a pop and usually when im having a really bad day so i tell them exactly why i'm not going to smile especially on demand.

But sometimes - i'm feeling a bit down and it does actually make me smile and feel like i count, and i always say thanks - i needed that. Because actually that person just lifted my day and that is a big deal.

However my estranged husband use to do it daily and it made me want to knock his block off. But then he was abusive and loved to chip at the emotions. If that's the case - i would look hard at what it really means.

RavenofEngland · 16/03/2022 12:59

@HereBeFuckery

I intend to buy this t shirt and wear it daily.
I love how that model has RBF while wearing the tshirt
Theflamingnerd · 16/03/2022 12:50

This happened to me recently I simply replied "No", the guy became visibly agitated and said "You'd be prettier if you did". I told him I don't owe him pretty or a smile, this happened on a train platform so I moved away from him but he proceeded to follow me and told me I'm an ugly cunt anyway. I had to ask a station attendant to intervene as the guy was becoming really threatening.

Whilst I'm glad I stood up for myself, in hindsight just ignoring may have been a better approach. I hate this smile bollocks and how weak it makes me feel.

gezzab33 · 16/03/2022 12:42

I have said " My mother just died." That put their gas at a peep.

TurquoiseDragon · 16/03/2022 12:28

People who do the smile love bullshit, have zero concern. They do it for attention. Why is itdirected at women?

Some women do it to other women (and it's internalised misogyny from them), but generally it's from men to women, IME. It's not about concern at all, it's about men expecting women to be subservient and decorative, and not displaying any real feelings.

I'm in my 50s, and I'd thought this was behind me now. But no, had some older bloke say "Smile, it might never happen" at me this week.

I normally ignore them but my dad died 10 days ago, and I was feeling a bit raw while remembering him. So I ended up snarling "my dad died, so fuck off" at him. He stalked off muttering "you don't have to be like that".

Wazzock.

DameHelena · 16/03/2022 12:27

@ItsNotJustCharlieWhoSeesYou

If it's a stranger look slightly over the top of their head and whisper into your sleeve MI5 style "hold fire!...I repeat, hold fire, it's not the target!"
Love this Grin
aveline161 · 16/03/2022 12:03

@LovelaceBiggWither

Once in a cafe, the cafe owner who was holding an adorable baby looked at me and I thought oh god please do not. I knew I still looked pregnant. He came over with a huge smile and said would cuddling the baby make you feel better? I burst into tears and said my baby was stillborn last week.

So yeah that went well for all of us.

That’s heartbreaking, I’m so sorry Flowers
Ntrd · 16/03/2022 11:50

@Dnaltocs

No need to be rude. Someone may be concerned about you. Why the need to be rude or aggressive?
People who do the smile love bullshit, have zero concern. They do it for attention. Why is itdirected at women? If you're concerned about someone you can ask if they're OK or if they need help.
AryaStarkWolf · 16/03/2022 11:02

@gannett

I once hissed, like a cat, at a man who told me to smile. It was at a house party in my 20s, I was quite drunk.

Best sober daylight response I've heard of is a friend of mine who responded to every "Smile!" with "Dance!" It confused the hell out of men apparently. Always wanted to put it into practice myself but big headphones tend to mean I don't clock anyone telling me to smile in the first place.

I like the "Dance" one Grin

How about :

"You never said Simon Says"

gannett · 16/03/2022 08:56

I once hissed, like a cat, at a man who told me to smile. It was at a house party in my 20s, I was quite drunk.

Best sober daylight response I've heard of is a friend of mine who responded to every "Smile!" with "Dance!" It confused the hell out of men apparently. Always wanted to put it into practice myself but big headphones tend to mean I don't clock anyone telling me to smile in the first place.

MCamp10 · 16/03/2022 08:52

Look him straight in the eye, Smile sweetly and say “Fuck off!”

yzed · 16/03/2022 04:24

Trying to think of a good retort.
How about
"I was smiling until i saw you"
or
"... until you said that"
?

TomPinch · 16/03/2022 01:25

@MrFsAunt

Have you got dodgy gnashers then Tom?

I do, but it's more about not wanting to look like Bela Lugosi.

TomPinch · 16/03/2022 01:23

“Give the man a hug, Dad.” Said I

Brilliant!

Mamanyt · 15/03/2022 23:47

@ItsNotJustCharlieWhoSeesYou

If it's a stranger look slightly over the top of their head and whisper into your sleeve MI5 style "hold fire!...I repeat, hold fire, it's not the target!"
I am going to shamelessly use this! Repeatedly!
Motherofone163 · 15/03/2022 23:26

Fuck off and don’t speak to me! I rarely curse, about once a month, so when I do I really mean it.

thenightsky · 15/03/2022 23:13

@Bearyhumcrack

Usually a "why don't you go fuck yourself", or an aggressive "what did you fucking say" puts them off their stroke.

Handily, these two phrases work for any "heckle" so I don't have to worry about being spontaneous.

Be careful with aggression. I was in a city centre pub with a female friend one saturday afternoon and she used 'what did you fucking say?'. The bloke flew at us with both fists up! I thought I was going to be seriously hurt. It was terrifying.
EliyanahM · 15/03/2022 23:00

Break down in tears, if you can.

SarahBellam · 15/03/2022 22:29

‘What?’
‘Don’t be a dick’
‘Fuck off’
‘Who the fuck are you? The smile police?’

chopsadoodle · 15/03/2022 22:25

@Dnaltocs surely if someone is concerned they'd simply ask if I'm ok, not a "smile love, it might never happen"
"Oh that'd be a pretty face if it didn't look so miserable"
"Your day would probably be better if you smiled, pet"
"Men like smiley girls, why not give it a go"
Etc.

chopsadoodle · 15/03/2022 22:21

"Get to fuck" works for me. Once I did ask them who they thought they were to barge into my day with such utter drivel of an opinion regarding how my face should look. Arseholes.

Thankfully I'm approaching the age of becoming invisible to those who insist on telling women to smile so it isn't as much of an issue. The silver lining Grin