Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be totally confused (cost of living crisis)

518 replies

LittleBitHeiressLittleBitIris · 13/03/2022 23:48

AIBU to not be able to understand/ grasp the scale of impending disaster that is building over the increased cost of living?

I genuinely don't see how millions of people with outgoings that are about to be actually higher than income is going to play out.

I'm not trying to be goady and obviously realise no-one has a crystal ball but am I missing something? Has this ever happened before in other recent times/ other cultures and what was the result. I can't even imagine what could happen.

I feel really clueless! Any ideas/ opinions/ further reading much appreciated 👍

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/03/2022 17:35

I think people don't always allow wiggle room for cost rises etc and then become unstuck but planning is a great idea!

This is true, but on mortgages it's been said that loans are now "stress tested" for affordability if rates go up

I didn't know about that (and with too many lenders I'm not entirely convinced), but if it's correct it should hopefully be some help at least

alltheapples · 14/03/2022 17:34

Poorer women were working.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 14/03/2022 17:31

what did people do in the 20's; well simple meals, extra clothing and nothing new. homes were tiny and furniture sparce. people used their time making and selling. no tv, no "nail art", no phones in most homes, people added things to meat to stretch it out (oatmeal in ground beef, eggs and breadcrumbs). oil filled lamps for a couple hours after sunset and in bed by 8-9. awake with the sun. they used scraps of material to make rugs in the winter. but everyone was in the same situation (although some were very wealthy).

sounds grim and very boring. I think people accepted this at the time, as it was a lot better than what their parents/grandparents had. But for us, it will be very hard to go back to living like this after what we've gotten used to

Also (sorry if this point has already been made) living like this was,only possible because women weren't working. So they had time to shop around for cheap food, spend ages cooking cheap cuts of meat, making and mending clothes etc. Is someone on a zero hours contract going to want to work on their rag rug after they get home at 7pm? Are they bollocks.

alltheapples · 14/03/2022 17:30

I think being cold in the 1970s was common, but nit having enough to eat wasnt.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/03/2022 17:30

The bank of England's policy of increasing interest rates to encourage saving was spectacularly mistimed, it has increased housing costs at a time when very few can afford to save

That was done because of inflation rising, but if rates were anything like the historical average of 3-4% I'd agree
However they're not, and after years of near-zero rates pushing house prices up still further, there's only one way they were going to go

Blossomtoes · 14/03/2022 17:25

If I had to go back to the childhood I remember from the 70's long term, I think I'd just rather not be here! Freezing cold, never enough to eat, never anything to look forward to. Just surviving

That wasn’t the norm. My son was born in 1975. We didn’t freeze and we always had enough to eat. And we didn’t have two ha pennies to rub together.

Terfydactyl · 14/03/2022 17:21

Pil have an allotment but they are retired and have family willing to help with heavier stuff like digging, they are still not self sufficient for fruit and veg although they do get a fair bit of produce, the allotment costs about £120 a year to rent. Then add composters or buying compost, seeds and bulbs, gardening equipment and some kind of shed/ building and that's too much for most of us to start.
Friends have an allotment not far away, its £150 a year rent, they have no building but wheelbarrow everything to and from, needs the same as pil plus wheelbarrow. They have gluts of veg (that I benefit from as well as others) but still they are not self sufficient.

Canning, jarring, freezing all require equipment that costs money to buy or run and space to keep it.

I've always grown stuff in my garden, but 15 tubs of potatoes gained me a small sack full.
I'm better with courgettes and squash and tomatoes and spinach but after a summer and autumn eating them I cant face any more.

Plus the potential of bugs eating whatever you grow or floods where it all lost, big outlay for maybe not much food. Unsustainable for a lot of people.

DressingPafe · 14/03/2022 17:18

If I had to go back to the childhood I remember from the 70's long term, I think I'd just rather not be here! Freezing cold, never enough to eat, never anything to look forward to. Just surviving. But I guess that is how it will be for so many people.

I'm doing every bit of overtime I can get my hands on. Then stashing the money, as it is "extra". But obviously not everyone is in that position, or has the opportunity, to do that.

I think what makes me most angry is the NI rise (especially as I'm a contractor so have to pay both my NI and the employer contribution). That is something that at the very least could be postponed for a year or two. That, on top of everything else, is just too much for many people.

Blossomtoes · 14/03/2022 17:15

The bank of England's policy of increasing interest rates to encourage saving was spectacularly mistimed, it has increased housing costs at a time when very few can afford to save.

That wasn’t why they increased the interest rate, it was because inflation was rising. It wasn’t the last either, I can see several rate increases coming.

Ceci03 · 14/03/2022 17:14

@fallfallfall

what did people do in the 20's; well simple meals, extra clothing and nothing new. homes were tiny and furniture sparce. people used their time making and selling. no tv, no "nail art", no phones in most homes, people added things to meat to stretch it out (oatmeal in ground beef, eggs and breadcrumbs). oil filled lamps for a couple hours after sunset and in bed by 8-9. awake with the sun. they used scraps of material to make rugs in the winter. but everyone was in the same situation (although some were very wealthy).
sounds grim and very boring. I think people accepted this at the time, as it was a lot better than what their parents/grandparents had. But for us, it will be very hard to go back to living like this after what we've gotten used to :(
lightand · 14/03/2022 17:10

[quote Ariela]@alltheapples

We're not going to be too badly off because, over the years we've been in this house we've not had a new kitchen or new bathroom, or even any new furniture other than replacing a secondhand 3 piece suite we got 20 years previously, and a bed. We've gone abroad for a holiday once (and that was paid for us), and generally don't have holidays.
Instead, we've invested in quality thickness double glazing, loft insulation, thick heavily lined curtains all round (I made them), new more efficient boiler, replaced all lights with LED, outdoor lights are all ow PIR operated or solar, and solar panels (which so have have luckily paid out enough to cover all our energy bills + £2-400 per year. Our initial investment will therefore have paid off after about 14 years. Our energy costs are minimal.
We grow lots of our own veg and fruit. We freeze and bottle a lot, so we spend very little other than this time of year (potatoes have run out, no peas/beans left).
We are efficient with our vehicle use - we save up outings and complete them all on one trip (unlike one of our neighbours who WFH same as us, they go in and out all day, not for work I was nosey so I asked: they collect their breakfast coffee from Costa, and go again at least once or twice more per day), so a tank lasts 3 or 4 weeks.

We're going to be relatively affluent because of this. Not because we earn a fortune, we don't. Is this so very wrong of us to have made the right choices?[/quote]
What if coucil tax becomes £6000k?
Loaf of bread £10
Shoes £300
Insurance, silly money and the government insist on us paying it?

UKRAINEwearewithyou · 14/03/2022 17:09

@Ariela

I'm not sure many people would have enough land to grow sufficient fruit and vegetables to take them through almost all the year with only a bit of spending on potatoes!

tkwal · 14/03/2022 17:09

I believe our problems are being exacerbated by the massive expenditure the government took on during covid lockdowns, mostly loans . Meaning we cannot now afford to borrow any more to support the economy. And now supply problems deliberately initiated by the Russians..fuel supply price increases influence the cost of everything. The bank of England's policy of increasing interest rates to encourage saving was spectacularly mistimed, it has increased housing costs at a time when very few can afford to save.

Parpophone · 14/03/2022 17:09

"But I hope that before they do that they will - if they currently have them - cut back on streaming subscriptions, expensive new mobile contracts, nails, takeaways, new clothes etc etc. Things which are undoubtedly enjoyable and make life easier and more fun, but are not essential."

See also: Washing clothes/towels/bedding every 30 minutes.

Ted27 · 14/03/2022 17:06

@Lilac57

You're absolutely right , for most people growing your own is an expensive hobby.

I've had an allotment for about 7 years. Its only in the last 2 -3 that I've had real success - after spending a lot of money to sort it out.

I spent huge amounts of time there during lockdowns which has really paid off. Last year we were reasonably self sufficient in basic salad stuff (tomatoes and cucumber) for about 5 months, spuds and onions about the same amount of time. Peas and beans for about 3 -4 months.
We always do well with soft fruit - I still have raspberries in the freezer from last summer, and a years supply of jam.
We do well but we are a long way off self sufficient and across the year I still probably spend more on it than I save

UKRAINEwearewithyou · 14/03/2022 17:06

"But I hope that before they do that they will - if they currently have them - cut back on streaming subscriptions, expensive new mobile contracts, nails, takeaways, new clothes etc etc. Things which are undoubtedly enjoyable and make life easier and more fun, but are not essential."

I agree with some of this. Priorities are strange for some. Mobiles are a priority now (although doesn't have to be top of the range). Lots of the other items could easily be cut to pay rent/mortgage and utilities.

UKRAINEwearewithyou · 14/03/2022 17:05

I imagine that people that have overstretched themselves with huge mortgages will struggle unless they have fixed the rate since interest rates going up and also everything else.

I think people don't always allow wiggle room for cost rises etc and then become unstuck but planning is a great idea!

There seems to be a lot of people who appear to need new everything and follow the trends etc so if any of that is borrowed may struggle.

Some I feel sorry for and others are just silly with finances.

PuzzledObserver · 14/03/2022 17:03

I agree with pp who said that people will default on unsecured debt - arguably they should do this - or rather, take action quickly to get their repayments reduced to a token minimum).

They should certainly default on unsecured debt rather than mortgage/rent, council tax and utilities, no question there.

But I hope that before they do that they will - if they currently have them - cut back on streaming subscriptions, expensive new mobile contracts, nails, takeaways, new clothes etc etc. Things which are undoubtedly enjoyable and make life easier and more fun, but are not essential.

(For clarity: mobiles are close to essential now, but it can be your existing phone on £5 a month SIM only rather than a £40 contract for a new phone; clothes are essential, but can be worn for longer/bought second hand, you don’t need a new outfit every time you walk out the door)

I would look askance at someone who defaulted on a loan but was still doing all the lifestyle leisure stuff.

gracedentssketty · 14/03/2022 17:01

Earlier last year we almost took out a stupidly large mortgage (the max we could borrow) and all our cash to buy a house. I was quite nervous and uncomfortable about it. It fell through.

We bought a different house a few months ago - whilst it’s still a silly mortgage, it wasn’t the max we could borrow and didn’t take all our cash in addition (it will take a fair chunk of it in modernisation however but we have choices there). I’m now so grateful we didn’t max ourselves out as we have a lump sum of cash in case the shit hits the fan (as we are unlikely to be able to get a builder until end next year/early 2024 anyway due to demand)

Larryyourwaiter · 14/03/2022 16:56

I don’t think it’s just a benefits thing. I definitely have a few working friends who have spent years spending every penny they earn and having expensive cars and massive mortgages with no wriggle room who are feeling the pinch now.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/03/2022 16:54

By this logic we'll eventually regress to the Stone age and spend our days hunting prey with sharpened sticks and huddling together in a cave for warmth. A life expectancy of 30 will save the NHS a few quid though I suppose.
Isn't this what the climate change campaigners also want though?
Also what NHS?
:)

PupInAPram · 14/03/2022 16:49

@fallfallfall

what did people do in the 20's; well simple meals, extra clothing and nothing new. homes were tiny and furniture sparce. people used their time making and selling. no tv, no "nail art", no phones in most homes, people added things to meat to stretch it out (oatmeal in ground beef, eggs and breadcrumbs). oil filled lamps for a couple hours after sunset and in bed by 8-9. awake with the sun. they used scraps of material to make rugs in the winter. but everyone was in the same situation (although some were very wealthy).
By this logic we'll eventually regress to the Stone age and spend our days hunting prey with sharpened sticks and huddling together in a cave for warmth. A life expectancy of 30 will save the NHS a few quid though I suppose.
Oldtiredfedup · 14/03/2022 16:30

@Ariela

You’re ‘right’ choices required the means to make them in them first place.

ThreeRingCircus · 14/03/2022 16:09

I'm so torn on this issue, on the one hand I agree with the poster that said years of poverty porn television programmes created a climate of thinking people on benefits were workshy scroungers....programmes like Benefits Street are a classic example of this. I watched the programme last night about the Jeremy Kyle show and looking back it was absolutely awful....people on there, often at the poorer end of society were offered up as entertainment, with Jeremy screaming "get a job" at them. Watching it felt like it was programming from the distant past but really it's only a few years ago and these programmes ran for YEARS. I feel like it created the climate of people voting Tory and for austerity, although that may be unfounded.

On the other hand I see so much waste and materialism, at least in the area I live. We live totally different lives now than when I was growing up and I'm only mid 30s. So many massive cars, meals out, huge children's parties with professional photographers etc. DH and I earn a decent amount between us and still are trying to tighten our belts..... trying to really cut back on food spending for example and eating things like tinned tomatoes on toast for dinner. Then at the same time I was talking to a mum in the playground at school the other day about smoking, I used to smoke and quit because it was just ridiculously expensive and I genuinely felt I couldn't afford it. She replied in all seriousness "thank God for child benefit because it pays for my fags." It made me quite angry to be honest. I don't know what the answer is.

RedWingBoots · 14/03/2022 16:06

@FlowerArranger

when you pay taxes for the majority of your life and get taxed AGAIN when you come to draw your pension on money that's already been taxed when you are working

@PurpleThursdays - You don't pay tax on pension contributions or NI...

Which is why you get taxed when you take it out.

Pensions are a tax free wrapper to save for old age.