Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be totally confused (cost of living crisis)

518 replies

LittleBitHeiressLittleBitIris · 13/03/2022 23:48

AIBU to not be able to understand/ grasp the scale of impending disaster that is building over the increased cost of living?

I genuinely don't see how millions of people with outgoings that are about to be actually higher than income is going to play out.

I'm not trying to be goady and obviously realise no-one has a crystal ball but am I missing something? Has this ever happened before in other recent times/ other cultures and what was the result. I can't even imagine what could happen.

I feel really clueless! Any ideas/ opinions/ further reading much appreciated 👍

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 14/03/2022 08:17

The problem is that utility prices have been disproportionately cheap for a number of years. The deal May cut re energy prices about 5 years ago has ended at the worst possible time and we are paying for it now.

I think people have lost sight of the fact that things like inflation, interest rates, food, white goods, etc., have been very cheap for a very long time. It was never going to continue. I believe we will enter a depression. There is very little any government will be able to do about it.

douper · 14/03/2022 08:15

People may end up being forced to emigrate to countries where the cost of living is cheaper?

I think young people will do this, far too much burden on them & little reward as housing is so expensive. I expect many will look for opportunities abroad, obviously this will only exacerbate things here.

NettleTea · 14/03/2022 08:14

also, for the poor, not having a phone isnt an option, as you need one to keep on top of your universal credit account. If you dont live in town its probably cheaper than having to get a bus (if they run) into the local library to check your account, which is another option. Bus fares are astronomical round here.

Recycledblonde · 14/03/2022 08:13

My Dad was born in the early 1920s. I remember him telling me about his Mum having a cup of crusts with hot water, pepper, salt and a knob of marge for meals because once she'd fed the children and my granddad there was nothing left. They kept a goat and chickens which made things better for part of the year. He told me how angry he was that his Dad always managed to have his tobacco each week while his Mother went hungry.
When Dad and my Uncle joined up in 1939 they were given extra rations as they were diagnosed with malnutrition.

keepingtheheaton · 14/03/2022 08:13

It is going to be tough for many many people who need to plan ahead now. The NI rise should not go ahead- 1.5% on top of the energy crisis and what is likely to be 8-10% RPI (not the lower CPI the govt likes to quote) means.

Speaking personally, we had very very tough times around 2008 so have done this before. The difference is that after struggling last time we vowed we would never again take out car leases (90% of new cars are leased/ PCP), use credit cards for holidays etc when we had got through the worst. Can cars be handed back these days and cheaper cars bought?

This time round we switched off the central heating a month ago and just heat the living room with a stove. We have halved our gas consumption.

The energy companies don't advertise this fact, but you can switch to variable monthly direct debit bills, so you don't have to accept their plans and you just pay for what you have used that month. We've done this as our gas use has plummetted but they wanted to hike our monthly payments. Take meter readings frequently though so you don't get behind

There are so many money saving websites now and doing a massive review of absolutely everything can make a huge difference.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 08:13

@JudgeRindersMinder I don’t think Boris would be calling for general strikes do you ?

SarahBellam · 14/03/2022 08:12

@Polyanthus2

If people can't afford their mortgages more houses should go back on the market - if everyone isn't airbnb ing as they can't afford holidays, those houses also might go back on the market. If the cost of keeping your empty airbnb house aired is higher due to increases oil prices then again some homes might go back on the market. If the oligarchs give up their homes/estates they might appear on the market. If lots of houses go on the market the prices should fall.
That’s wishful thinking. There are too many people with enough money who will easily snap up those cheap houses to rent out to the people who will need them when they default on their mortgages. There is a shortage of decent rental property and this will tip the scales more firmly in a landlord’s favour. Add that to the number of people who will no longer be able to afford to move to larger properties and I think will see far fewer houses coming to market. We are already finding it in our area - almost daily postcards from local estate agents inviting us to have our home valued, but there’s no way I’d move at the moment - taking on more debt when there’s a potential risk to one or both jobs would be madness. So house prices may stagnate, but I don’t think there’ll be a swathe of bargain homes to be had.
AppleBlueberryPie · 14/03/2022 08:12

People may end up being forced to emigrate to countries where the cost of living is cheaper? Uprooting your home due to living costs is nothing out of the ordinary for millions of immigrants/second generation immigrants. For many, it's normal to be working in one country and send money home to your family in another. The situation OP is describing has existed for decades in many other countries and the logical answer is to move until you find an arrangement that's bearable. Many immigrants still live on the poverty line in their host countries but it's better than the real risk of starvation, cold or crime.

If things get bad enough in the UK/Europe then families might be forced to find similar arrangements. They might be able to do remote jobs that ensure an income and then live somewhere cheaper. Or one person takes on whatever job they can find in another country and sends extra money home. Budget might not stretch to travel, so once you move you accept that you will not see your relatives & friends for many years. People are resilient and it's not the end of the world to start anew somewhere. Having your immediate family with your (spouse & kids) is already a huge privilege. A common scenario is to start a business somewhere (shop, restaurant, cleaner etc) and have the whole family pitch in. This means you're not reliant on an employer and will have some kind of income.

JudgeRindersMinder · 14/03/2022 08:11

@Bringsexyback

Well are we going to force a general election? If its going to be that bad ? In the 1920 they had general strikes. If people think we are returning to those days I suggest we return to those mentalities as well sharpish. It’s actually going to be nowhere near as bad as people are making out at all. Lots of people have had decent pay rises this year that will come to balance any increase in food and fuel prices if you haven’t I suggest you ask for one but I’ve been suggesting that on about 13 threads over the weekend and I just get we can’t …..well then it’s your own fault then.
Ok then Boris. Your ignorance is staggering
ancientgran · 14/03/2022 08:05

@fallfallfall

what did people do in the 20's; well simple meals, extra clothing and nothing new. homes were tiny and furniture sparce. people used their time making and selling. no tv, no "nail art", no phones in most homes, people added things to meat to stretch it out (oatmeal in ground beef, eggs and breadcrumbs). oil filled lamps for a couple hours after sunset and in bed by 8-9. awake with the sun. they used scraps of material to make rugs in the winter. but everyone was in the same situation (although some were very wealthy).
Many many people went hungry. I remember my mother saying she didn't realise when she was a child that when her mother sat them down to a meal and had nothing herself it was because there wasn't enough food to go round. She would tell them she had eaten before them and have a slice of bread.

My granny was a cook, she could make a delicious meal with scraps but starvation in the 20s ruined her health.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 08:05

@Terfydactyl I actually see nothing but sweet shit in the trolley at Aldi in Sainsbury’s buyers you looking at sometimes and you genuinely worry that there’s no nutritional value in any of the things being donated it’s all rubbish sugar filled cereal, packets of biscuits, little cakes. Christmas couldn’t move for all the selection boxes that have been added in there, I did wonder what the hell anybody was gonna have for dinner.

douper · 14/03/2022 08:04

Costs of welfare will rise so will taxes.

This had to happen anyway due to social care/NHS costs but they cannot target income any further so where will the tax come from?

ButtockUp · 14/03/2022 08:04

@AppleButter

And we all know what happened across Europe at the end of the twenties . . . . .

Seriously, malnutrition in Britain in the inter-war years was so bad that there were barely enough fit soldiers for the army (this fact made people in charge finally take notice, general poverty they didn’t care so mich for). When rationing kicked in during the war, SOME groups actually had better nutrition than before the war.
So no, it isn’t going to be an arte povera idyll, but really damaging for years to come, and with long term political danger if not remedied quickly (turning to extreme political ideologies, scapegoating, the rise of neo-facism).

I wish you were wrong, in your last paragraph... sadly I think you're spot on.
ButtockUp · 14/03/2022 08:04

@AppleButter

And we all know what happened across Europe at the end of the twenties . . . . .

Seriously, malnutrition in Britain in the inter-war years was so bad that there were barely enough fit soldiers for the army (this fact made people in charge finally take notice, general poverty they didn’t care so mich for). When rationing kicked in during the war, SOME groups actually had better nutrition than before the war.
So no, it isn’t going to be an arte povera idyll, but really damaging for years to come, and with long term political danger if not remedied quickly (turning to extreme political ideologies, scapegoating, the rise of neo-facism).

I wish you were wrong, in your last paragraph... sadly I think you're spot on.
douper · 14/03/2022 08:03

Costs of welfare will rise so will taxes.

This had to happen anyway due to social care/NHS costs but they cannot target income any further so where will the tax come from?

douper · 14/03/2022 08:03

Costs of welfare will rise so will taxes.

This had to happen anyway due to social care/NHS costs but they cannot target income any further so where will the tax come from?

douper · 14/03/2022 07:58

I think there is some truth re being able to live more simply BUT for most the big expenses are housing, utilities & transport, not food or easily cut treats

Yes! Giving up avocado or cereal is not going to save hundreds of pounds 🙄

OMG12 · 14/03/2022 07:57

Well do what they’ve done for centuries I suppose in the endless cycle of feast and famine.

Maybe we should have paid more attention on the theatre trip to see Joseph and his amazing techni coloured Dream coat rather than thinking life would just keep getting better and better.

But yes, there will be a lot of suffering esp in a world which is defined in material wealth,

Costs of welfare will rise so will taxes. People will need to learn to cut their cloth or face crippling debt where available.

But didn’t take long for Utopian France to raise its head lol

Theeyeballsinthesky · 14/03/2022 07:55

I grew up in a house with no central heating or double glazing and do you know what? It was fucking cold & miserable! I’ve no time for the “well we were just more stoical & it didn’t do us any harm” crap. Thete was ice inside the windows in winter, you woke up aching from the cold if it was below freezing, the day we finally got central heating, it was like nirvana!

Also bluntly we had an open fire, someting which the vast majority of houses don’t have anymore. Even if ppl do switch off all their heating, it’s not like they can do what we did and light a fire. They’ll just be really cold.

Terfydactyl · 14/03/2022 07:54

@fallfallfall

what did people do in the 20's; well simple meals, extra clothing and nothing new. homes were tiny and furniture sparce. people used their time making and selling. no tv, no "nail art", no phones in most homes, people added things to meat to stretch it out (oatmeal in ground beef, eggs and breadcrumbs). oil filled lamps for a couple hours after sunset and in bed by 8-9. awake with the sun. they used scraps of material to make rugs in the winter. but everyone was in the same situation (although some were very wealthy).
They also didnt have contracts for phones or TV or internet that cant be got out of, maybe at a push suspended for a few months, which will help but only til the next increase.

I've been this dirt poor, it's not healthy, I've done the heat or eat, I lived on microwave meals because they were quick to heat up. Living on microwave meals is not healthy at all. (Actually previously to that time I was even poorer and lived on oatmeal and the odd banana)
Missing out for years on micronutrients and feeling hungry for the same years is beyond shit.

Getting up before the sun is not an option for many many people, we cant all lie in bed, some of us have jobs to go to before the sun has risen. And still even with a job people will struggle to pay this round of increases, wait til the next round hits.

For anyone reading who can help, if your donating to a food bank, think about the packaging. Can it be opened easily (ring pull tin, tear bag no scissors required) can it be eaten cold, can it be carried easily and even poor people who need food banks should be given some luxuries. Can you stretch to small jars coffee, some biscuits or little cakes, or the like.

I would've given a limb some days for something sweet with a coffee, so I try to help that way.

TheHaveN0ts · 14/03/2022 07:53

@TheHoptimist true though. Folk who live a life that looks great on Instagram often are paying through the nose for it and have feck all to buy stuff they actually need

HardbackWriter · 14/03/2022 07:52

It either won't hit as hard as currently predicted or the government will have to take some action, however reluctantly. It's a bit like very early in Covid before furlough was announced and people were saying that the government would just leave people to lose their homes etc on UC because that would be typical of a Tory government. But actually - and with hindsight this is completely obvious - they had no choice but to act or to see the entire economy collapse. This is the same. They don't want to act and they're going to put it off if they can. But ultimately, just like it turned out we suddenly had bottomless money for Covid, help will be found if it's that or total economic collapse and that's what no intervention under the scenarios currently being bandied about would mean.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 07:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

lollipoprainbow · 14/03/2022 07:46

Imo though it's not down to the government to ensure people have good lives .

We're not talking about 'good lives' we're talking about people being barely able to survive so yes that is down to the government. They have no intention of scrapping the upcoming NI tax it's a disgrace.

Keepitonthedownlow · 14/03/2022 07:45

@AppleButter

And we all know what happened across Europe at the end of the twenties . . . . .

Seriously, malnutrition in Britain in the inter-war years was so bad that there were barely enough fit soldiers for the army (this fact made people in charge finally take notice, general poverty they didn’t care so mich for). When rationing kicked in during the war, SOME groups actually had better nutrition than before the war.
So no, it isn’t going to be an arte povera idyll, but really damaging for years to come, and with long term political danger if not remedied quickly (turning to extreme political ideologies, scapegoating, the rise of neo-facism).

Spot on on all accounts, sadly.