Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be totally confused (cost of living crisis)

518 replies

LittleBitHeiressLittleBitIris · 13/03/2022 23:48

AIBU to not be able to understand/ grasp the scale of impending disaster that is building over the increased cost of living?

I genuinely don't see how millions of people with outgoings that are about to be actually higher than income is going to play out.

I'm not trying to be goady and obviously realise no-one has a crystal ball but am I missing something? Has this ever happened before in other recent times/ other cultures and what was the result. I can't even imagine what could happen.

I feel really clueless! Any ideas/ opinions/ further reading much appreciated 👍

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 14/03/2022 11:45

[quote alltheapples]@Blossomtoes congratulations on being well off. We both work and by the time we pay the mortgage, we don't have that much more than we would get in a state pension plus benefits anyway. On full state pension you are unlikely to be paying council tax or very little.[/quote]
There’s no need to be rude. I wasn’t rude to you. I appreciate I’m fortunate.

parboil · 14/03/2022 11:44

I agree with @ChickenStripper at least to an extent. Her description of modern consumerist lifestyles - sure, there might be lots of people who don't live like that, but most of the people I know do (affluent area). Some people will be able to keep affording this lifestyle - but there will be a significant number who can't. I know people who live like this (huge amount spent on 'lifestyle') who walk to work at the end of the month because they literally can't afford to put petrol in the car until payday - they have no savings or financial buffer whatsoever. In some ways, it's not a bad thing if those kinds of lifestyles change (mainly because they're helping to wreck the planet with endless consumption and tat), but there will also be lots of people on lower incomes who depend on that lifestyle spend to pay the bills. Plus, the less people spend, the less tax revenue will be available to support those who really are on the breadline.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/03/2022 11:40

@Nicholethejewellery

The Tories in 2019 got just under 44% of votes cast which represented about 30% of the electorate as a whole. I can understand it being pointed out that some people did vote for a party who we always knew were going to be more interested in their corporate mates than anything else, but the fact is that the clear majority didn't.

The majority didn't - but more people voted Tory than anything else. That's the trouble, the opposition is too divided. If Labour/Lib Dems/SNP/PC/Green etc all got together and agreed to field one candidate per constituency to represent all of them then maybe the Tories wouldn't win. They won't because they all have their own individual interests and spend as much time justifying why THEY are the best alternative to the Tories, as opposed to justifying why anyone would be a better alternative.

In any democracy I can think of it's not a straightforward case of the majority having to vote for something for it to win. In the Brexit referendum something like 38% of people voted for Brexit (I'm plucking that figure from memory), so 62% didn't. But that 62% was split between people who voted against it, people who spoilt their ballot and people who weren't motivated enough to bother to vote at all.

On the cost of living crisis, I think the 1920s comparisons are valid but actually it will be more like the 1930s. In the 20s there was something of a boom, consumer borrowing increased, and in the 1930s it all went wrong. People struggled to find work, those that did were poorly paid, and many had to rely on state benefits that were not really enough to live on.

What I think will happen is that people will mostly just cut their spending or borrow more. While people remain in work things will more-or-less carry on, but as people cut their spending businesses will go under and more will be out of work - leading to less spending, more businesses failing, more unemployment and the cycle repeats.

Actually the Brexit vote was much more reflective of the wishes of the electorate than any General Election.

It was a simple majority - you either got what you wanted or not, and at 77% it had a higher turnout than most General Elections.

You can't count people who didn't vote as "not voting for Brexit" - they didn't vote for anything but you can't assume they would all have voted one way.

alltheapples · 14/03/2022 11:37

@Blossomtoes congratulations on being well off. We both work and by the time we pay the mortgage, we don't have that much more than we would get in a state pension plus benefits anyway. On full state pension you are unlikely to be paying council tax or very little.

Tilltheend99 · 14/03/2022 11:36

@GreenNewDealNow

What a miserable little country we are.
The gov literally put a bill through parliament to prevent us all from protesting
GatoradeMeBitch · 14/03/2022 11:34

So people.may have to cut their cleaners hours or give up the aupair

Or don't even have to, but decide it would be prudent to anyway, piling more misery on people with low wages.

MrsAJCrowley · 14/03/2022 11:27

To the PP saying that the public sector should just strike to get the pay increases. I am in the public sector. We have been on strike very recently. And we were battered by the public at every turn. There was zero support from the general population and we were pilloried and lambasted as lazy and workshy. We aren’t. We just on our knees like the rest of the public sector thanks to over a decade of cuts and underfunding.

alltheapples · 14/03/2022 11:27

And the pandemic has eroded savings for many of the poorest while the rich have saved more money than ever.

Blossomtoes · 14/03/2022 11:26

I don’t think you can do much more than survive on a state pension plus pension credits. It wouldn’t be living and I wouldn’t want to try.

Onionpatch · 14/03/2022 11:26

Austerity was a political choice of how to respond to the last crash - other options were followed in other countries. Austerity has left no give in the system so now we are facing another global problem - but with less safety net across society, and with more individuals who have been ground down before this crisis even starts to bite.

alltheapples · 14/03/2022 11:25

@ChickenStripper but you get benefits as well. I understand if you are well off though it seems impossibly low.

ChickenStripper · 14/03/2022 11:21

[quote alltheapples]@ChickenStripper thanks for that link. Interestingly I still hear the myth about pension pots disappearing if firms go bust, because that did happen to many people until the government provided guaranteed backing. I spoke to one woman in MN who had twice lost a private pension pot in this way.
You may be right. But I am personally pretty cynical. And the idea that no one can live on a state pension plus benefit top ups is clearly false.[/quote]
I suppose it depends on your definition of "living". I don't have a mortgage and would struggle on it - my utilities and Council Tax are about 350/400 and going up before I start thinking of anything else.

Handsnotwands · 14/03/2022 11:20

My mother was surprised we’d not seen an increase in our disposable income during the pandemic. The thing is if your budget was already cut to the bone, no holidays, no Netflix, no eating out, which is the norm for a great many people then there is no give, no cutting back. We pay our housing bills, we have £10 a month sim only deals, the only thing that can be cut from our budget is the £28 a month for swimming lessons. That’s a shit place to be in. And we both work full time.

alltheapples · 14/03/2022 11:18

@Blossomtoes it is global, but the government has a choice of how to respond. Do you continue pumping money to your friends through dodgy public service contracts and continue funding white elephants like HS2? Or do you actually spend the money you have to help people who need it the most?
The price cap level on utilities is also a choice. Power companies are making record profits. The price cap could be much lower.

ChickenStripper · 14/03/2022 11:15

@Blossomtoes

I’m as far from a Tory supporter as it’s possible to get but we’d be where we are whoever was in power. This is global, just like the 2007 crash that Tories are still trying to blame on Labour.
Of course it is. Some people are very naive and blinkered.
Blossomtoes · 14/03/2022 11:10

I’m as far from a Tory supporter as it’s possible to get but we’d be where we are whoever was in power. This is global, just like the 2007 crash that Tories are still trying to blame on Labour.

VampireMoney · 14/03/2022 11:07

The Tories have done what they always do. Those on low income start clawing their way up the ladder a bit, trying to have a better lifestyle for their children than they had themselves, and they get knocked back down into their 'place'.

They wore us down with endless lockdowns, businesses closed, small businesses went under, people lived on what bit of savings they might have had, and then as soon as we start clawing our way out of it.. boom. Get back in your lane. Oh and a nice anti protesting law brought in just in case we decide to revolt.

ancientgran · 14/03/2022 11:05

@Tanith

"We have been through this before, anyone remember the 70s and three day weeks? Or the 80s when base rate went up 4 times in one day to 15%"

Yes, I do. In the 80s, I remember suicides and people posting their keys through the banks' letterboxes because they could no longer afford their mortgages and couldn't sell their houses.

I also remember that the Conservative party was in Government for both.

I remember loads of women on antidepressants in the 70s. I think they got referred to as "mother's little helpers." It is miserable to never have a treat, to never have the food you'd like, to always have to say no to kids.
alltheapples · 14/03/2022 11:02

@ChickenStripper thanks for that link. Interestingly I still hear the myth about pension pots disappearing if firms go bust, because that did happen to many people until the government provided guaranteed backing. I spoke to one woman in MN who had twice lost a private pension pot in this way.
You may be right. But I am personally pretty cynical. And the idea that no one can live on a state pension plus benefit top ups is clearly false.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 10:59

@MaryAndHerNet

No Mary they can’t store the data *@MaryAndHerNet**

If you say so... And as it's evident your putting yourself forward as a GDOR and recruitment expert, I'll let you continue.

I've answered and explained and provided links how parasitic agencies can make money, my point is made and backed up for anyone to read.

GDPR does not specify retention periods for personal data. Instead, it states that personal data may only be kept in a form that permits identification of the individual for no longer than is necessary for the purposes for which it was processed. @MaryAndHerNet And it’s funny how all the agencies are parasites until somebody needs a job and then they get on the phone to them expecting them to act like the flaming job centre.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/03/2022 10:57

[quote alltheapples]@Bringsexyback yep I regularly see fake job adverts on my line of work too. They are fishing for people who they can try and match up to other jobs that do exist.[/quote]
So do I.

I even see adverts for jobs that can't possibly exist.

It's hilarious people who I assume are in the industry claiming this doesn't happen.

To be clear - I am not accusing any company or person - it's possible Hays don't do this as a larger responsible organisation, but it definitely 100% does happen.

MaryAndHerNet · 14/03/2022 10:57

No Mary they can’t store the data @MaryAndHerNet*

If you say so... And as it's evident your putting yourself forward as a GDOR and recruitment expert, I'll let you continue.

I've answered and explained and provided links how parasitic agencies can make money, my point is made and backed up for anyone to read.

alltheapples · 14/03/2022 10:55

And more unemployment in some areas as hospitality suffers.
We didn't use to have a large hospitality industry in this country. Fish and chip shops, Chinese takeaways and cheap cafes with Formica tables, was for most people where they went unless it was a special occasion. Places like McDonald's that are cheap will still be fine. And high-end places will still be fine as the rich will still be doing well. It will be mid level that will be affected.

ChickenStripper · 14/03/2022 10:54

[quote alltheapples]@ChickenStripper my parents live on the state pension. My Uncle has a tiny pension and is worse off than my parents as he is not eligible for things like free prescriptions or benefit top-ups.
And only 44% of retiring people at the moment even get the full state pension. So it is easy to be in the situation where a small private pension is simply replacing what you would have got in benefits.
You need a decent pension to make a pension worthwhile.[/quote]
Why does your Uncle not get free prescriptions ? Is he not over 60?
I myself was not going to get a full pension so did some calculations and paid some back payments. It was a better investment that the current interest rate. I was lucky in that I had the money to do so and I'm aware not everyone can. This article is useful.

www.workplacepensions.gov.uk/employee/workplace-pension-myth-buster/#it’s_not_worth_saving_into_a_pension

ancientgran · 14/03/2022 10:54

[quote alltheapples]@ChickenStripper my parents live on the state pension. My Uncle has a tiny pension and is worse off than my parents as he is not eligible for things like free prescriptions or benefit top-ups.
And only 44% of retiring people at the moment even get the full state pension. So it is easy to be in the situation where a small private pension is simply replacing what you would have got in benefits.
You need a decent pension to make a pension worthwhile.[/quote]
If he's pensionable age he gets free prescriptions, they aren't means tested. I think at the moment it is free for anyone over 60 but if changing to retirement age soon.