Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…to ask if you decided to have HRT, & whether you’d recommend it?

129 replies

VenomHost · 13/03/2022 20:18

I’m 52 & menopausal. Symptoms fairly mild but include weight gain, hot flushes & some insomnia & anxiety, although the last two likely to be partly due to a very stressful couple of years

Am considering HRT to hopefully ease these symptoms & also because I have read that HRT can be beneficial for bone & cardiovascular health & reduce risk of dementia.

If you decided to have HRT how easy was it to get, are you worried about any side effects or associated risks and have you benefitted / are you glad you’ve had it?

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 15/03/2022 08:53

HRT is not magic.

No, but the affects from taking it can be magical.

As you've seen on this thread, many of us were on utter despair, before starting HRT. Taking it has been life-changing.

That's a pretty powerful thing.

Regarding the 'feminist' point, it bloody is. Not because it's all male doctors holding it from us, but because so little was done in healthcare to understand perimenopause & menopause, to educate doctors, and to appropriately invest in services to care for women at this stage.

So many women in previous decades suffered hugely, with no support or recognition.

It's only now that we are informed & healthcare practitioners are catching up.

My own GP (who is wonderful) spent most of 2 years telling me my symptoms were linked to my lifestyle, that I was too young, that my periods were regular so I couldn't be perimenopausal, and that it was liked to my hypothyroidism. I accepted all of this as she was the expert.

A radio programme (in Ireland) about a year ago blew the lid on all this, with woman after woman calling in to discuss their problems, many terribly sad stories.

Queues of women went to their GPs, who were overwhelmed. GPs pushed for training. Having got it, my own GP changed tack completely, and has been so supportive.

The other reason it's a feminist issue is that many of the symptoms traditionally got tagged as 'hysterical women' style issues, and not taken seriously.

No bloody way men would be treated like this.

So not all women need HRT, and HRT won't address everything. But it really can feel like magic for those of us it does work for.

Sarahcoggles · 15/03/2022 08:43

Took it for a month, some improvement in symptoms but gained half a stone so I stopped it. It wasn’t worth it. I just rode the storm - 5 years now and the flushes and night sweats only happen every couple of days.

For some bizarre reason the media have turned menopause and HRT into a feminist issue, as if we’re all desperate women being denied HRT by evil male doctors. And it’s being marketed as a magical cure-all, which has led to women in their 30s with PMT asking for HRT as they think they’re “peri”. The fact is, doctors are more than happy to prescribe HRT if it’s indicated. We also prescribe it for longer than is recommended, if women want to stay on it and are prepared to accept the risks. In fact only yesterday one of my late-50s patients who chose to accept the risks was diagnosed with breast cancer.

HRT is not magic.

Snog · 15/03/2022 08:32

I've found it highly effective for sleep, hot flashes and skin. It also resulted in me being sent for a hysteroscopy due to post meno bleeding so there can be a downside.

If you currently think you "have to wake up in the night to pee" you probably don't. You probably just need HRT.

CounsellorTroi · 15/03/2022 08:27

I think if we stopped calling it menopause and called it something like reproductive hormone deficiency, it would be taken more seriously with fewer taboos because it wouldn't sound like a middle aged woman thing.

That would make it sound like a disorder, which it is not. Any more than periods are.

HRT isn’t the be all and end all in preventing osteoporosis either - a healthy diet and strengthening exercise are just as important.

Middersweekly · 14/03/2022 21:13

My DM swears by HRT and has been taking it for 15 years! (she’s now 65). We have a family history of osteoarthritis so DM also takes it for this reason. When my time comes I will also be taking it 100%.

CosmicComfort · 14/03/2022 20:56

I’m just about to start HRT.
I went down the private route because of cervical cancer history and a lack of faith in my GP.
I paid £250 for an hour consultation and some follow up emails and calls. Am about to start oestrogen patches.
I have horrible brain fog, awful insomnia, increased migraines, joint aches, weight gain, continence issues, prolapse issues…..it goes on. I need to try something as I feel like a shadow of my former self.

Justgorgeous · 14/03/2022 20:49

You can have HRT if you are in menopause and you have not been menstruating for a while. My friend of 58 has just started HRT

Octopus37 · 14/03/2022 20:34

TBH hasn't made a massive difference to me. I cannot remember what I was first on, but I've been on Femoston 2mg since September. Bleeding still a bit irregular, very tired, achey joints just recently, mood and anxiety not great. I spoke to my GP last week, I'm having a pelvic scan to check my womb lining, but may need to rethink things.

Satsumaeater · 14/03/2022 19:44

Until there is better evidence, the potential benefits of HRT as a way to reduce the risk of Alzheimer's disease do not outweigh the potential risks of HRT, which includes an increased risk of certain types of cancer, heart disease and stroke

This is quite misleading of the Alzheimers website. The benefits of HRT categorically outweigh the risks except for women with certain conditions eg a genetic risk of breast cancer. And the cancer risks were greater from the tablets - most women take it via a patch these days.

As for "delaying onset of symptoms", menopause is a hormone deficiency. Those hormones don't come back, so you either continue with HRT until you die, or the symptoms come back or you're lucky and they don't. My mum is still on a low dose in her 80s.

I am experiencing sporadic and very brief hot flushes and haven't had a period since before Christmas so should look into getting it myself.

I think if we stopped calling it menopause and called it something like reproductive hormone deficiency, it would be taken more seriously with fewer taboos because it wouldn't sound like a middle aged woman thing.

vjg13 · 14/03/2022 19:15

@MorganBrocklehurst thanks for you reply. Smile

LizzieSiddal · 14/03/2022 19:12

I too have had a great experience with HRT.
After a couple of years of sweats, awful sleep, grumpiness and brain fog I asked for it via telephone and was given it. Been on it 10 months and it has been life changing, the best being no sweats and a full nights sleep! Another great thing has been, I’ve suffered from terribly painful bunions for 5 years, always thought it was just one of those things, about 5 months after starting HRT the pain hs completely gone- I’m able to wear whatever shoes I like again. I’d highly recommend HRT to every woman.

bythebanksof · 14/03/2022 19:01

Not surprised by all the positive responses here!

Are there any reasons why it would not be an option for everyone? I remember many years ago it was associated with cancer risk, but I believe that has essentially been debunked? Or maybe different range of options for different individual cases?

Sarahlou252 · 14/03/2022 18:58

Six months in, feel better than I have done in over two years.
Brain fog gone, no hot flushes, I actually feel the cold now, which is very strange. Sleep through the night, hair has stopped falling out, weight stabilised. My patches will need to be wrestled off me when I'm old and grey!
Total game changers.

user1471538283 · 14/03/2022 18:52

As you cannot work out relatively simple stuff that's a touch of brain fog and anxiety. I would honestly give it a go if I were you. It also protects your bones.

Even with some trial and error it's worth it.

user1471538283 · 14/03/2022 18:48

HRT saved me! Initially my symptoms were not too bad but oh my god when they kicked in!

I would wake up soaked through several times a night. I had brain fog, low mood, aching joints. I initially had a low dose and them moved onto gel and tablets.

It saved me.

Notreallyhappy · 14/03/2022 18:46

I am so much happier taking it...talked to the gp told her I was like a mad woman, could cry etc..not depressed..had a blood test.. 1 month later I was a new person.

ButterfliesandMoths · 14/03/2022 18:45

I asked my doctor as I was having menopause symptoms. I originally started on tablets but went on to patches. I've been on it now for about 8 years and don't want to sound dramatic but it saved me from a life of misery. Definitely worth having a chat with your doctor and seeing if it's the right thing for you.

MorganBrocklehurst · 14/03/2022 18:44

@vjg13

I'm peri menopausal/menopausal but not had a period for about 10 months, do your periods restart with HRT?
No they don’t.

However, to have reached menopause, if you are over 50, you need to have had a whole 12 months without a period, and if you’re under 50, 24 months. I know a few people whose periods suddenly restarted a few days/months short and suddenly found themselves menstruating regularly and for a few more years.

MorganBrocklehurst · 14/03/2022 18:40

@TeeBee

Thanks. Yeah, I'm already doing that. The usual tricks for losing weight just don't seem to be helping as much as they usually do. Already doing weights/HIIT so will keep up with that. Thanks. It might be worth a try.
HIIT might be the issue as it raises cortisol levels which can inhibit weight loss, and in some instances, actually cause weight gain. LISS and weights/resistance training is far more effective for losing weight during perimenopause.
collieresponder88 · 14/03/2022 16:04

@VenomHost

Thanks for the responses! I’ve learnt a lot - seems my achy joints, which I’ve put down to just getting older, may be another menopausal symptom. I was totally unaware of that possibility before reading this thread. Also had a complete panic at the weekend when under pressure I couldn’t work out how to call some one in my contacts on my phone … is that what people mean by brain fog or am I going bonkers after all?
Achy legs and knee pain was the worse for me. I went on hrt talblets 2 months ago and it's completely gone !
Terfydactyl · 14/03/2022 16:01

Been on it for years now with a break between and a different type.
I could not carry on without it. Not blowing smoke up your ass, I simply could not function anymore.
Brain fog is gone although words escape me often, I no longer get the aches that made it impossible to walk or drive. Sweats reduced massively from several times a night to probably 7 this year so far and they are manageable sweats, not sleep on several towels and hope it doesn't get through them all or have a shower and change whole bedding a few times each night.

Hair has definitely thinned and I dont think that's coming back now, but all in I'm happier, currently on novofem cannot remember previous but it was patches that then became unavailable.

ProudAlly · 14/03/2022 16:01

I started last september and after 6 months I can honestly say the impact was marginal. I went back to my GP 2 weeks ago and changed from the patch to the gel and upped the dose. I'm waiting for the benefits to really to kick in but I do think that my concentration is a bit better already and I feel less fatigued - though of course that could be as much to do with a bit of sunshine than the treatment. I REALLY wish I was one of the "game changer" group but so far I'm not.

Redcrayons · 14/03/2022 15:48

Also had a complete panic at the weekend when under pressure I couldn’t work out how to call some one in my contacts on my phone … is that what people mean by brain fog or am I going bonkers after all
This is a great description of brain fog. I thought I had early onset dementia.

jeaux90 · 14/03/2022 15:45

Life changing. Do it.

vjg13 · 14/03/2022 15:38

I'm peri menopausal/menopausal but not had a period for about 10 months, do your periods restart with HRT?

Swipe left for the next trending thread