Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I agree to moving schools?

36 replies

Christmaswindows · 13/03/2022 14:34

Advice please!

My son is in Year 8 at secondary school.

He enjoys school and generally gets on well.

He chose this school despite being only one of four from his primary school going, he didn’t know the four well as they were in a different class.

He has become part of a group of boys who all went to the same primary school and have been friends since Reception. My son became the 7th member of this group.

This group of boys are all very nice and they generally get on really well.

As this group have been friends since Reception, they are very close as are all of their parents. They spend lots of time together at the weekend as a group of 6 with and without the parents.

This weekend they have all gone swimming and then had a sleepover. My son hasn’t been invited.

I have no issue with him not being invited as that’s life, but he is finding it hard to deal with. When he messages the group, to see if they want to meet, some of them just say they are busy or some don’t reply. He then sees on social media they are altogether doing an activity.

My son will then spend his weekends with a separate group who all go to the same school but a different school to him.

My son, would like to move schools, to be with these other boys.

I’m reluctant to agree.

Reasons:

He absolutely hated the other school when we went to visit.

He’s lucky to have a group of school friends and a group he can be social with out of school.

He can be fickle.

I don’t like the other school.

COVID has meant they haven’t really had an opportunity to get to know each other properly or get to know their peers due to bubbles etc so the original group of 6 haven’t naturally met others or splintered off into other groups.

I have agreed, to phone the school and see if their are spaces and if so, I don’t really want him moving until September.

  1. Phone new school, if spaces, let him move from next term.
  2. Phone new school, if spaces, let him move from September.
  3. Encourage him to stay where he is and broaden his school friendships.

Ultimately he has to go every day so I want him to be happy but I know him as a person and I’m not convinced it’s the best thing to do.

What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HelloDulling · 13/03/2022 17:50

If you want him to stay, contact the parents you do know, arrange to meet for dinner/coffee/whatever. You can help him build stronger bonds by doing the same.

Whitecushion · 13/03/2022 17:44

As time moves on friendships may well reshape and change, especially as the boys move further away from their parents involvement. There is no way I would move him especially as you say he is fickle!

Jovanka · 13/03/2022 17:01

It’s quite unusual I think for kids in Year 8 to still have their social lives revolve around their parents and parents’ friends. Kids in primary are often friends with the kids of whoever their parents have bonded with. But that will change and as you’ve said the usual and natural dilution of those groups was disrupted by the pandemic.

For in-year transfers in our area, once you have started the process and been offered a place, you have to take up that place within 3 weeks. There’s no way they would allow you to wait until September.

MargosKaftan · 13/03/2022 16:55

I would make an effort again, invite them to yours, including parents. But don't completely dismiss his feelings because he's in a better school. Being an outsider and lonely at school can have long term confidence issues. If he'd be happier in the other school, it would be a better fit for him.

Christmaswindows · 13/03/2022 16:44

The parents of these 6 are all really good friends….. I know 4 out of the 6, but I don’t hang out with them or anything.

I really think it’s habit and nothing malicious or that they dislike him. They walk to and from school together and play games online.

On further investigating, some of these boys aren’t actually interested in going out unless it’s a group activity with parents. Some aren’t really allowed out unless to the local park which is minutes away from our houses.

OP posts:
Christmaswindows · 13/03/2022 16:39

He’s just come downstairs full of more tales of woe….

I understand where he’s coming from.

I can see his point of view BUT he is fickle! So fickle! Next week he could be complaining about something else on top of this!

He’s so lucky to have a school social circle and other friends to hang out with should he wish too.

He’s hurt he’s not invited and not in the go to 6, that’s ok, he can feel hurt, upset, jealous, but these people have been friends since they were 4! It’s going to take time, more time than before because of COVID. He hasn’t done a full school year since Year 5!

Technically, although Year 8, he only been free to roam since January. It’s not long enough.

In Year 9 there is always a huge friendship shift as well.

The more I listen to him moaning the more I think I should say absolutely not. You are not moving.

OP posts:
lanthanum · 13/03/2022 15:44

They're obviously good friends within school, which shouldn't be knocked. I think a lot of the problem is that it's harder for parents to start including the child whose parents they don't know - and of course the parents may be less aware than you are that there is a seventh child in the group now. They're doing what is easy and that they're used to. My daughter went up as part of a threesome, who are still close. They used to be the "go to"s for doing things together at weekends, and it just took a little longer before other kids became as natural a choice (and of course the new friends don't live as near, so transport is needed).

Try to issue more invites, I think. They're at that difficult age of moving to making their own arrangements, but perhaps something more organised would give the excuse to get you and parents in direct contact. eg he texts saying "would you like to come to - my mum can drive us, here's her number so yours can get in touch".

We had a birthday party (movie and ice cream parlour at our house), and invited parents to come early for pick up and have some ice cream in the kitchen. It was a great chance to meet other parents - and actually, if they can see that the party is just their six plus your son, they might realise that he needs to be included in their invites. You can always say when chatting how lucky he is to have got to know their sons and join their little crowd - he'd love to spend more time with them out of school too.

Spudyoulikeit · 13/03/2022 15:42

I don’t know they can’t be that good friends if they’re not inviting him out with them- I can see why he’s hurt. Sounds like you’ve made an effort too. If results are ok in the new school then I’d move.

Hankunamatata · 13/03/2022 15:24

Mine has made friends close to where we live doing different afterschool activities. Might be an idea

Mumofone2021 · 13/03/2022 15:23

I had school friends, and then my out of school friends were a completely different group. There were 6 of us and we all came from different schools but had a hobby we all shared. I think it did me the world of good keeping things separate and it meant I didn’t have to keep up appearances all the time. I could do things at the weekend that wouldn’t get talked about at school.

Friend groups can change so quick so I would say keep him where he is, especially if the other school is not very good.

TheMoth · 13/03/2022 15:22

The thing is, it doesn't mean his weekend friends will be his friends in school iyswim. There will be a different dynamic. My best mates lived by me and went to the local school. I had friends by yr 10 in high school, and did the odd thing outside school with them.

I would suggest he's lucky to have 2groups to flit between. It's not a bad place to be. Ds is finding that the kids he went up with are making new friends and leaving him out, but he hasn't made any new ones either. I've wondered about moving him, but it might just be the way he is.

Loopytiles · 13/03/2022 15:18

Social things can ‘turn on a dime’, so I wouldn’t move schools in the hope of having the same friends at school/out of school.

For example, DS old friends might not respond to him joining them at school in the ways DS envisages. The new group could ‘splinter’.

cherryonthecakes · 13/03/2022 15:14

Can you also remind him why he didn't like it when he visited? He may have conveniently forgotten little details like school 2 does rugby or doesn't have X as a choice for GCSE.

KindergartenKop · 13/03/2022 15:13

I'd ask for him to move to a different class/side of the year next academic year

cherryonthecakes · 13/03/2022 15:12

I would contact the school tomorrow about spaces. We are also a school where options are picked in year 8 and started in year 9 and they have afternoons where they can try subjects that they've never studied before like psychology.

I'm not sure he'll be socially sorted if he moves but happy socially makes a big difference to motivation with regards to moving school. Make sure your son understands that he can't move back when he realises that the grass isn't greener and he can't change schools until year 12.

lollipopsandrainbows · 13/03/2022 15:11

@BankingOnChange perhaps not where you're located, but we had the options evening last week and decisions have to be made by the end of March to start sets in September.

OnTheBenchOfDoom · 13/03/2022 15:04

Both of mine chose options in year 8, started all the new option subjects in year 9. The neighbouring school allows you to drop some subjects but continue with others through year 9 before choosing your final ones for year 10. Depends on the school. Both of mine started GCSE content in year 9.

TeenPlusCat · 13/03/2022 15:03

@BankingOnChange

Y9 they go into their option sets

No they don't, they choose options in Y9 but go into them in Y10.

Although if you are going to move him, the sooner the better really - I wouldn't wait until Sept, if he is to move I'd arrange if for after Easter, at the start of the summer term.

OP. Some schools do a 3 year GCSE so choose in y8 and start in y9. Other schools just do the standard 2 year GCSE for options, though may still start something like science at some point in y9.
OnTheBenchOfDoom · 13/03/2022 15:03

I think this is where ideas about friendships differ, your son sees himself as part of his new friendship group but they all hang out together on weekends without him. So to them he is still on the periphery as they have a long standing friendship possibly still facilitated by their parents too. He is a friend within school time.

But he also has another set of friends he sees on the weekend so really he has the best of both worlds. If he wanted to see those friends on a weekday why isn't he?

I wouldn't want him to move schools, you chose it for a reason, remember what those reasons are. Plus he isn't unhappy in school but on weekends when he doesn't see those friends but he does see other friends.

Tulipvase · 13/03/2022 15:02

@BankingOnChange

Y9 they go into their option sets

No they don't, they choose options in Y9 but go into them in Y10.

Although if you are going to move him, the sooner the better really - I wouldn't wait until Sept, if he is to move I'd arrange if for after Easter, at the start of the summer term.

At my secondary school they choose options in year 8 and go into groups from year 9 - so it does vary.
noblegiraffe · 13/03/2022 15:00

Some schools do options, or some options end of Y8.

BankingOnChange · 13/03/2022 14:58

Y9 they go into their option sets

No they don't, they choose options in Y9 but go into them in Y10.

Although if you are going to move him, the sooner the better really - I wouldn't wait until Sept, if he is to move I'd arrange if for after Easter, at the start of the summer term.

LittleOwl153 · 13/03/2022 14:57

This year's yr 8 have had a real tough time on the friendship front. They didn't get the transition to secondary or the mixing in arrival which shakes up the friendship groups. My dd is just starting to make other friends through Subject groups - and I suspect it will be a whole different game in yr10 when subjects split them. It's hard. I've asked my dd about moving tutor group to be with her friends but she is happy with the separation.

I think I would phone the new school and find out the situation. But it will be a live offer - move now not in Sept unless there is loads of space.

I'd then be decisive. OK you can move. / No you can't shut up about it - go make some new friends.

My dd has groups in and out of school and it works well for her. But she is not a straight forward kid....

Christmaswindows · 13/03/2022 14:57

Excellent point re: options!

OP posts:
Christmaswindows · 13/03/2022 14:56

Yes I’ve taken several of them out for the day during weekends and half term. He’s closer to one boy in particular so does spend time with him 121 occasionally. He’s only really invited as a group if it’s something for this particular boy.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread