Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think holiday homes could be used to house lots of refugees

660 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 13/03/2022 13:54

Uk has a LOT of holiday homes and empty second homes. Surely they could be used to take a lot of Refugees aswell as spare rooms? It could support local economies all year round too rather than just in peak tourism seasons? The crisis is going to escalate rapidly in Ukraine- there are 44 million people in the country and so far it’s about 2 million who have fled and now countries like Moldova and the Poland are starting to struggle so we need to step up.

Aibu? It seems like an obvious solution. Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference.

I read an article about a woman who gave her French holiday home to a refugee family.

OP posts:
HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:55

[quote StolenYourStollen]@HELLITHURT

Bit you also speak English? So not really that fucking useful? More a pastime?

I'm not Welsh or English, but couldn't ignore this bit of ignorant nonsense. Language is part of one's identity. It doesn't matter if it's 'useful' outside of your country. English people are extremely privileged that English is now a lingua franca, so they can get away with not speaking any foreign languages at all. I'm not surprised that you don't see a point in preserving Welsh, but PLEASE read about the concept of identity and why it's so important to preserve the minority languages in communities.[/quote]
This thread is about Ukrainian refugees, please tell me how useful the welsh language would be to them?

We've got posters banging on about how it's better to have Ukrainian refugees rather than "English masters" as they'd speak welsh!

What's more beneficial welsh or English,..

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/03/2022 21:52

How useful is welsh?

Well I've no doubt it's useful to the speakers themselves, but my point was that it's of little use outside Wales - so unless any refugees who arrive there never want to go anywhere else, it might be better for them if the more widely used language is prioritised

It also interests me that the % of those who speak Welsh is taken from the self-declarations on the last census, and tell us little about whether folk are fluent or it's just a case of being able to sing the anthem and manage a few words.
It varies by area, but given that an overall large majority say they can't speak it, I wonder just how many fluent speakers there are

StolenYourStollen · 14/03/2022 21:51

@HELLITHURT

Bit you also speak English? So not really that fucking useful? More a pastime?

I'm not Welsh or English, but couldn't ignore this bit of ignorant nonsense. Language is part of one's identity. It doesn't matter if it's 'useful' outside of your country. English people are extremely privileged that English is now a lingua franca, so they can get away with not speaking any foreign languages at all. I'm not surprised that you don't see a point in preserving Welsh, but PLEASE read about the concept of identity and why it's so important to preserve the minority languages in communities.

Elphame · 14/03/2022 21:49

@Bunnyfuller

The only jobs are in hospitality and tourism because the second/holiday home owners have proved locals out of living there and they’re miserable ghost towns out of season. People moving in will create jobs by being there, and unlike so many brits will be happy to work and get on their feet.
Rural depopulation in Wales has been a problem for many many years. Chronic underinvestment and a lack of opportunity meant that many moved away.

It's naive and overly simplistic to blame it on second home owners. They are a symptom rather than the cause.

HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Bunnyfuller · 14/03/2022 21:34

@IchabodCrane

There are plenty of jobs. What the uk lacks is a universal work ethic.

HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:31

@IchabodCrane

Also *@HELLITHURT* knock it off. Language and culture must be preserved. It's not utilitarian. I despair at the lost of sweet Gaelic and Scots. I'm not even from the UK but this highhanded attitude towards languages is astonishing. Everyone else in the world speaks multiple languages
Ok, I'll ask again! Who sold there homes to "outsiders"?

It's all about who bought the honed are they are vermin, but the welsh sellers??? What about them?

So my house is worth £50k, the son of my dads best friend offers that, an"English" person offers £60k, so I that it!

So the welsh are benefitting? Not innocent parties?

So hey, they are selling their soul, so you knock it off?

Cheeseplease1976 · 14/03/2022 21:30

@Mellowyellow222 yes you are probably right. But it was the attitudes on this thread that is triggering- this ‘but I’ll lose my 3 k a week’ - it makes me rage because it’s what has destroyed my home. Money at all costs. Fuck the people- Ukrainian or anyone.

IchabodCrane · 14/03/2022 21:26

Also @HELLITHURT knock it off.
Language and culture must be preserved. It's not utilitarian.
I despair at the lost of sweet Gaelic and Scots. I'm not even from the UK but this highhanded attitude towards languages is astonishing. Everyone else in the world speaks multiple languages

Mellowyellow222 · 14/03/2022 21:26

But you are conflating two very different issues.

You are right to be proud of your culture and community and it is understandable that you feel frustrated.

But it’s not selfish of people to need an income from holiday homes they have bought. Some people will be willing to (and can afford to) sacrifice income to help. But expecting a huge sacrifice from a small percentage of the population because they have bought homes where you don’t want them to is a twisted logic.

The problem
Is far more complex than that. You have a huge level of hostility against these home owners - and if anything you are being disingenuous by pretending you want to help refugees. You don’t. You want to punish people who have bough up Homes in your home village. Even if they gave these homes to refugees for sox months or a year I don’t think that would appease you.

HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:24

[quote Cheeseplease1976]@Mellowyellow222 yes you are right. I am angry because I see people I went to school with living in caravans while houses lie empty for months of the year. It’s outrageous.
I see our local school closed because locals can no longer afford to live here & raise their kids when they want to.

I see people coming in and thinking it’s their private playground, that its quaint and pretty for their 2 weeks of the year while the locals are struggling to exist.

I see people changing the Welsh names of houses to anglicised ones and erasing our history and culture.

So yes, I am pretty pissed off. And it grates on me when people are complains they might not get their £1000 a week if they took a Ukrainian while my friends live in caravans as there are no houses locally they can afford.

So yea, I am pretty fucked off.[/quote]
Who sold their homes to these people?

The welsh?

IchabodCrane · 14/03/2022 21:24

[quote Cheeseplease1976]@Mellowyellow222 yes you are right. I am angry because I see people I went to school with living in caravans while houses lie empty for months of the year. It’s outrageous.
I see our local school closed because locals can no longer afford to live here & raise their kids when they want to.

I see people coming in and thinking it’s their private playground, that its quaint and pretty for their 2 weeks of the year while the locals are struggling to exist.

I see people changing the Welsh names of houses to anglicised ones and erasing our history and culture.

So yes, I am pretty pissed off. And it grates on me when people are complains they might not get their £1000 a week if they took a Ukrainian while my friends live in caravans as there are no houses locally they can afford.

So yea, I am pretty fucked off.[/quote]
You have every right to be pissed off, but you're conflating 2 separate issues. FWIW I'm also against owning second homes only to leave them empty. I think they should be made so expensive to own that it's cheaper to sell. To locals.

But... the issue is really about:

  1. Requisitioning people's property
  2. The slippery slope. Why all the fuss about Ukrainian refugees? Why not house homeless people, or refugees from other countries?
HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:23

@Cheeseplease1976

“How useful is welsh?”

@HELLITHURT well pretty fucking useful to those of us that speak it!

Bit you also speak English? So not really that fucking useful? More a pastime?
Cheeseplease1976 · 14/03/2022 21:22

Genuinely can’t imagine anyone asking ‘how useful is French or Italian or Japanese or swahili’

But hey, when it’s Welsh.... Jesus the ignorance is ASTOUNDING!

Cheeseplease1976 · 14/03/2022 21:20

“How useful is welsh?”

@HELLITHURT well pretty fucking useful to those of us that speak it!

Cheeseplease1976 · 14/03/2022 21:18

@Mellowyellow222 yes you are right. I am angry because I see people I went to school with living in caravans while houses lie empty for months of the year. It’s outrageous.
I see our local school closed because locals can no longer afford to live here & raise their kids when they want to.

I see people coming in and thinking it’s their private playground, that its quaint and pretty for their 2 weeks of the year while the locals are struggling to exist.

I see people changing the Welsh names of houses to anglicised ones and erasing our history and culture.

So yes, I am pretty pissed off. And it grates on me when people are complains they might not get their £1000 a week if they took a Ukrainian while my friends live in caravans as there are no houses locally they can afford.

So yea, I am pretty fucked off.

IchabodCrane · 14/03/2022 21:17

@Bunnyfuller if the presence of people alone is enough to create jobs... then why is so much of the NorthEast impoverished.. former mining towns... there are plenty of people, and people == jobs, innit?
For Christ's sake

HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:16

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Oh god I didn't understand all the welsh rules!!!

Few of us do, HELLITHURT Wink

On your question about who's helped by learning the language though, I imagine most would agree that becoming familiar with a local tongue is an excellent thing, even if (depending on area) very few may speak it fluently themselves

However with incomers who have no western language at all, I can't help feeling that prioritising English might be a better option, if only because it's of use outside a relatively small area

Of course prioritising English is preferable.

How useful is welsh?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/03/2022 21:11

Oh god I didn't understand all the welsh rules!!!

Few of us do, HELLITHURT Wink

On your question about who's helped by learning the language though, I imagine most would agree that becoming familiar with a local tongue is an excellent thing, even if (depending on area) very few may speak it fluently themselves

However with incomers who have no western language at all, I can't help feeling that prioritising English might be a better option, if only because it's of use outside a relatively small area

Mellowyellow222 · 14/03/2022 21:10

[quote Cheeseplease1976]@HELLITHURT honestly it’s your ignorance that is embarrassing to be honest. You just don’t understand the issues here.

This whole thread is full of entitlement around holiday homes- entitlement that says that people couldn’t possibly let their home to a Ukrainian as they’d lose their 3k a week. It’s exactly that entitlement that I see every day of my life.[/quote]
While I don’t really want to Wade into this …. Is it entitled that people want the income from their own business?

Sorely when someone is accused of being entitled what we mean is they think they have a right to something they haven’t earned? If people have bough holiday homes they have earned them and there is nothing entitled about running a business?

Did people call small shop owners entitled when they were worried about loss of earnings during Covid?

I think you are so angry about your specific local issues it is clouding your judgement.

Yes it is sad that some rural communities have been destroyed by people owning second homes. But that doesn’t mean people who own holiday homes should be forced to give them up. It’s not entitled or greedy to fight for your livelihood - and there is nothing morally wrong with running a holiday accommodation business. Hotels, cottages and b&bs have been a thing for hundreds of years. We encourage people to holiday local to help local economies.

I think your logic is flawed

HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:09

[quote Cheeseplease1976]@HELLITHURT Byddaf yn siarad cymraeg os yw'n well gennych?

I assume you don’t siarad cymraes so it’s probably better I speak English on here isn’t it![/quote]
Where do you holiday?

HELLITHURT · 14/03/2022 21:07

[quote Cheeseplease1976]@HELLITHURT Byddaf yn siarad cymraeg os yw'n well gennych?

I assume you don’t siarad cymraes so it’s probably better I speak English on here isn’t it![/quote]
Happy holidays.... see you in June!

Cheeseplease1976 · 14/03/2022 21:06

@HELLITHURT Byddaf yn siarad cymraeg os yw'n well gennych?

I assume you don’t siarad cymraes so it’s probably better I speak English on here isn’t it!

Nelliephant1 · 14/03/2022 21:01

They already are the world over.