Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think holiday homes could be used to house lots of refugees

660 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 13/03/2022 13:54

Uk has a LOT of holiday homes and empty second homes. Surely they could be used to take a lot of Refugees aswell as spare rooms? It could support local economies all year round too rather than just in peak tourism seasons? The crisis is going to escalate rapidly in Ukraine- there are 44 million people in the country and so far it’s about 2 million who have fled and now countries like Moldova and the Poland are starting to struggle so we need to step up.

Aibu? It seems like an obvious solution. Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference.

I read an article about a woman who gave her French holiday home to a refugee family.

OP posts:
M0RVEN · 13/03/2022 18:02

@RealBecca

I wish people would stop these threads. Six months ago it was all "poor Arthur, I'd have taken him in" - how many more people actually went on to be foster carers?

Now it's all "if people have holiday homes they have a moral obligation to give them to refugees". I'm not saying people sont mean well but these kinds of emotional posts miss all the practical points and almost always seem to volunteer private individuals up for action. Sorry but of it's not your asset it's not your right to put it up to support a cause.

Exactly. People like the Op who are so full of good suggestions for everyone else to do while at the same time refusing to do anything themselves.

I guess it makes them feel that they have “ done something “ by starting a ranty thread on MN criticising others. Rather than taking any concrete action.

Or maybe it’s just attention seeking?

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 18:02

And yet you want to police what others post?

Not policing. Just highlighting their absolute meaningless bullshit as most other people are on this thread. You can’t argue with stupid as they say. YASC. 👍

supercallafragilicious · 13/03/2022 18:00

I haven't read the full thread, but we are wrestling with our consciences at the moment with what action to take.

Prima face we want to help a refugee family, and thinking back to eg WWII would probably have had no hesitation as it was such a different world.

Things we need to investigate and resolve include:

Insurance- covers holiday guests up to 4 weeks. In this litigious world, if a refugee injured themselves and sue us or they accidentally set fire to the house we could lose everything?

Tenure: it is a holiday home. As I understand it refugees will be able to stay for 36 months+. If we offered accommodation for eg 6 months but then needed it back, would the'r social worker/ housing officer advise them to stay put, or else they would be deemed intentionally homeless? So we would have to go to court etc?

Bills: when rented out the energy bills are approx £300 per month. Would refugees, who I believe will be entitled to full benefits, be expected to pay energy bills, council tax etc? Otherwise it would not be giving them housing for free, it would be losing a lot of money paying their bills

Income tax: is the (paltry) £350 taxed as income? If so only a fraction would be available to offset bills?

We would have to cancel bookings and suffer the consequences for future business.

Our holiday home is a business that supplements our income.
We really want to help but are struggling with how everything could work.

It is really not that simple but the government is quite clever in offloading all of the responsibility to the population.

Bunnyfuller · 13/03/2022 17:58

We have a housing crisis in this country which in no small part is caused by ‘second homes’. People who can afford it, buy a second property then rent it to other people at way over what is cost them to own it. If they were forced to only make a very modest income from it, this ‘method of making money’ (exploiting those with less than you) would cease. It is only attractive because if you have the capital to do it, it’s way easier than having to do an actual job for a living.

Rents are so much more than the mortgage and upkeep on a house, but renters don’t get a chance to save the required deposit because they’re screwed paying rent. Do not talk about the UK homelessness issue if you own a second home - you are part of the problem. I’d imagine you’d have also been horrified about being forced to home a dirty little east end child evacuee during WW2.

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 17:55

FlouncerSIT

I’ve never voted Tory in my life and I never will. I have always voted Labour but I won’t from now on as they don’t stand for women. I shall maybe vote for the Green Party, at least they seem to care for animals because none of the other parties give a fuck about most people or animals.

Just because people don’t believe the answer to this crisis is OPs poorly thought out ‘solution’, doesn’t mean they are unkind. Just as posting this poorly thought out ‘solution’, which conveniently will involve OP and other posters like her not giving up their non existent second home, doesn’t make OP kind.

HELLITHURT · 13/03/2022 17:53

[quote Letshaveablackcelebration]@Notimeforaname if I had a second home then yes I would. And I am happy to host a family too.[/quote]
Have you filled out the form?

HELLITHURT · 13/03/2022 17:53

[quote Letshaveablackcelebration]@Notimeforaname if I had a second home then yes I would. And I am happy to host a family too.[/quote]
Of course you wound 🙄! Everyone that doesn't have a holiday home would do it.

Mines been let for months already, I won't be cancelling my guests. It's not realty suitable for car users anyway.

However, I am looking into using my spare room to help, does that meet with your criteria?

tedgran · 13/03/2022 17:53

Loads of empty flats in Vauxhall.

AngelinaFibres · 13/03/2022 17:53

@caringcarer

After 6-12 months if they can work and get a job, have their children settled into school, and claim benefits including entitlement to housing benefit, I would expect they could move into a private rental same as anyone else. Why do you think this would be wrong? There are private rentals available where I live.
My son and his wife have professional jobs, excellent credit ratings, excellent references. They live in Cardiff. The rental market is huge. They fancied moving from the flat they are in to a different part of the city nearer to friends. Looking at Rightmove you would think finding a property would be a piece of cake. Most places had gone before they were even advertised. Others had a waiting list of 20 viewings and weren't taking anymore because the first viewer would take the property. Landlords can be as picky as they like. It is a vanishingly small possibility that a refugee on benefits, with children and possibly pets and in a, probably, low paying job, would be the first choice when other easier options are available. I worked with a Hungarian couple. They had a flat that was tired and very, very cold. They desperately wanted to move but the husband said that as soon as people heard his accent they didn't want to know.My son and DIL tried for months and have now given up trying to move. If your tenants cannot move until they have found alternative accommodation they may never be able to move.What will you do then ?
MySoCalledL1fe · 13/03/2022 17:51

If everyone in my area gave up tourism there’d be a lot fewer jobs around. There is so much nonsensical simplistic thinking in here it’s unbelievable. Renting out holiday accommodation is my business and my job and it provides jobs for others, directly and indirectly. Tourism is the biggest industry where I live. If people see my attitude to bankruptcy and think that says something about the UKs attitude to refugees then they’re clearly not appreciating the complexities of the situation 🤷🏻‍♀️

DonaPatrizia · 13/03/2022 17:47

OP you sound resentful. And I don’t think you’ve thought it through. Expropriation of people’s private homes is a dangerous route, even along the temporary and seemingly deserving lines you suggest, and even if they are second homes. If people want to offer their holiday homes they can. Forcing them to give up holiday homes to Ukrainian refugees might sound great - make the over-privileged help these desperate people. But it sets a very bad precedent. Once the government embarks on the compulsory requisition of private property (you’d have to change the law btw) for Ukrainian refugees and second home owners, it is a fundamental undermining of property rights. That could lead to a very bad place.
Oligarchs may be different matter. Assets purchased with the proceeds of crime can be forfeit.

douper · 13/03/2022 17:46

The genuine people won’t be on mumsnet telling others what they are doing or what others should do, they will be doing it without telling anyone. Quietly helping, not using it as an opportunity to look good

That's rubbish. It was a thread on here that saw about the etsy & air bnb thing which I hadn't thought about. doesn't mean i'm an amazing person though

woodhill · 13/03/2022 17:46

Yes it's really unfair on the young people already here. Don't they deserve an affordable home when the wages are so rubbish

we have always taken so many people from overseas especially since the 90s which has made affordable housing more scarce and property expensive

OohRahhMaki123 · 13/03/2022 17:45

As for the urban V rural location issue, this is often a reason for relocation requests from the asylum seeker or refugee themselves.

It is one thing living in a lovely rural area when you have money for a car or transport. When you have strong community ties and a nice job where you can WFH.

However, if you are being placed temporarily in a rural area you will massively struggle with isolation, lack of cultural support, lack of transport, lack of education / ESOL, lack of job opportunities.

I work in a big city that houses asylum seekers. It is so difficult to house people in certain areas because of the above reasons. And these areas are suburbs of a large city, not the middle of nowhere!

EeeICouldRipATissue · 13/03/2022 17:44

I've voted YABU, even though it's a good idea in principle.
You don't get to decide what people do with their own bought property, it should be personal choice.

douper · 13/03/2022 17:44

It’s a forum, I’ll stay thanks.

And yet you want to police what others post? 😆

douper · 13/03/2022 17:43

Why is it a sad state of affairs that this is how I earn an income, pay tax, feed my family and provide work for people?

I don't believe housing should be used like this either. Not when we have young people struggling to buy & wage stagnation. QE which had inflated assets is not a good thing, you can disagree of course.

KeepingAnOpenMind · 13/03/2022 17:42

Maybe they need them to provide income so they can er, live?

FlouncerSIT · 13/03/2022 17:42

"When I read some of the replies here, the fact that we have such a self-serving and ruthless government in power is very clear."

This. With bells on. I used to wonder who voted the Tories in, time after time after time. I don't wonder any more. It's one of the reasons I read mumsnet; it reminds me that the mostly reasonable and kind people I encounter in the real world, including my job, have their voices constantly drowned out.

We are genuinely not in a position to help, space wise, with accommodation for refugees but we will help in other ways, as far as we can. And that has also applied in previous campaigns to help refugees from other parts of the world (including the ones where their homes were bombed into oblivion with British-made and British-sold weapons).

Oh, and anyone who thinks we're never going to be affected in Britain by becoming refugees (especially those in coastal areas and/or the south) might like to take a look at the flood map projections.

I don't care, particularly, I'll be long gone.

But in some ways this is yet another a dress rehearsal for the longer-term effects of climate change. I know I wouldn't be kindly disposed to help the British (English) after our behaviour over those needing help who come from the Ukraine, Afghanistan, Syria...(I could go on).

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 17:42

Just don't engage then

It’s a forum, I’ll stay thanks. HTH. 😇

Hyenaormeercat · 13/03/2022 17:41

There are also deserted holiday camps in this country that could be revamped.

ShaneTwane · 13/03/2022 17:41

Shakey ground if the government suddenly decides it can take people's private homes that they have purchased off them for a refugee crisis. There is always going to be refugees unfortunately. There would be uproar if the government started taking people's private property off them.

Bunnyfuller · 13/03/2022 17:39

It’s actually the fact that they’re empty half the year that is killing the holiday areas. Not enough homes for locals to buy, and they’re priced out of the market because of all the holiday homes raising prices.

What people are basically saying is ‘I’m not sharing! It’s mine! I paid for it!’ I’m not sure how owning more than one property creates jobs? People have cleaners/renovations etc. regardless.

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 17:39

I never said it did but none of us know whether the OP is a good person or not.

The genuine people won’t be on mumsnet telling others what they are doing or what others should do, they will be doing it without telling anyone. Quietly helping, not using it as an opportunity to look good.

TheOnlyMrsMac · 13/03/2022 17:39

Thank you for what you, your son and your tenants are going to try to do @caringcarer - and to similar other pps on this thread too. Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread