Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think holiday homes could be used to house lots of refugees

660 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 13/03/2022 13:54

Uk has a LOT of holiday homes and empty second homes. Surely they could be used to take a lot of Refugees aswell as spare rooms? It could support local economies all year round too rather than just in peak tourism seasons? The crisis is going to escalate rapidly in Ukraine- there are 44 million people in the country and so far it’s about 2 million who have fled and now countries like Moldova and the Poland are starting to struggle so we need to step up.

Aibu? It seems like an obvious solution. Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference.

I read an article about a woman who gave her French holiday home to a refugee family.

OP posts:
anotherday85 · 13/03/2022 19:14

English people are just unbelievable. Ukrainians are fleeing WAR and people here are giving endless excuses, asking who will replace their £3k a month holiday rental earnings (!), moaning about wear and tear and not wanting 'strangers' in their home! 'What if they take a loan in our name?'!!! Hmm

While Poland is taking in hundreds of thousands of refugees, housing them in their homes and rushing legislation to allow them to live and work there, Germans are waiting at the border with coaches ready to take refugees home and poor European countries are opening their doors, but the English, as always, are too precious, insular and selfish to think of ANYONE but themselves, even in a major European crisis like this.

For all the doom mongers hosting a refugee really isn't that hard, and you can specify whether you want to host a woman or a man. We had a Congolese woman in our spare room for a year through a hosting scheme, a refugee who had had to leave her child behind, was traumatised and didn't speak English, but she was a lovely young woman and we got on well, and in the end she was given a flat of her own. We didn't get paid anything for having her but it also didn't really cost us anything, beyond what we voluntarily chose to help her with. She got a living allowance and was entitled to GP services etc, which I imagine the Ukrainian refugees will too if they are allowed here.

We are registering to host again tomorrow and I would encourage you to do the same. As others have said a time may come when we will need help and compassion from others.

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 19:04

Yes maybe if my mum had said she felt vulnerable and was worried about the workload I'd of understood. However her attitude about having "those people in my house" she was implying they would be dirty thieves. As I said, I'm not expecting everyone with the means to do it, but atleast think about it. She thinks she's above having common muck in her house. She says refugees like it's a swear word. These aren't normal refugees looking for a better life, these are literally women and children with nowhere to go. I think it's tragic for a woman who had so many kids of her own to her think she's above helping. Sorry but stand by what I said.

If those are her views on refugees or people from other countries, of course that’s not a pleasant view and I obviously don’t agree with her. But if those are her views, it seems odd that your dad wouldn’t know this about your mum and therefore odd of him to ask it of her. And clearly if your mum holds those views, why on earth would you still fight for her to take in a family. As if they haven’t been through enough, you want them to deal with your mother and her views. It’s unlikely she’ll change her views...but also odd that your dad feels so differently from her. Doesn’t add up to me.

5zeds · 13/03/2022 19:03

That simply isn’t true. Refugees are almost exclusively women and children. The men are staying behind to fight. I thought the men weren’t allowed to leave?
As I said refugee status takes a loooooong time to achieve. So when people are describing these people as refugees what they mean is “asylum seekers”, who cannot work and like the asylum seekers that are already here need housing. Are people saying that they will house asylum seekers if they come from Ukraine but not from the Middle East?

Yebs · 13/03/2022 19:03

You don’t like your Mum much, do you?

You can love people but not agree with or like how they are about certain things. I don't excuse racism just because I'm related to you. Ukraine is a poor country and her opinion of these people is based off that. I think that's wrong.

x2boys · 13/03/2022 19:00

@Mangogogogo

Do you think people would start trying to pick and chose who stayed in their home though? I mean understandably you’d prefer a mother and child over 5 20 year old lads for example, but will this then be pushed to ‘I will only take Ukrainian refugees and not others’? How far could we go? Would the homeowners have rights? Would they push these rights because the tenants are not paying rent? I’m just kind of pondering out loud here. I don’t own a second home so I don’t really know what my actual answer would be
I imagine you would have some say over who you would offer your spare room too ,it could all work out beautifully But on the other hand there might be awful personality clashes ,I would find it difficult enough to stay with family and friends for more than a few days ,let alone complete strangers ,it's going to be difficult for both those offering shelter and refugees .
Natfemale · 13/03/2022 18:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 18:57

It's not quite that easy with a near full mortgage, very young children and being pregnant. Not to mention we live three hours away from them and all have jobs, schools and lives here. They have the means, a fully paid off mortgage and so much empty space and I think it's a shame that he's so keen and she's not even thinking about it. That's my point. My dad rightly says they are in the perfect position to do it, it is a shame she is shutting it down for the wrong reasons.

You and your dad have decided your mums reasons aren’t valid. I know what I’d be saying to both of you.

Natfemale · 13/03/2022 18:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 18:55

Yes maybe if my mum had said she felt vulnerable and was worried about the workload I'd of understood. However her attitude about having "those people in my house" she was implying they would be dirty thieves. As I said, I'm not expecting everyone with the means to do it, but atleast think about it. She thinks she's above having common muck in her house. She says refugees like it's a swear word. These aren't normal refugees looking for a better life, these are literally women and children with nowhere to go. I think it's tragic for a woman who had so many kids of her own to her think she's above helping. Sorry but stand by what I said.

RancidOldHag · 13/03/2022 18:54

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Has anyone else noticed that there have been no replies to the many questions about "What happens at the end of the 6 months"?

I'm aware that Refugees at Home (and probably others) sat they "aim" to find alternative accommodation once time's up, but what's to be done if there isn't any?

I won't hold my breath ...

Well quite.

Holiday cottages to be rented out across the whole peak summer season for £350. When in the peak season it could easily be per week, and that income is needed to counterbalance the winter when there are next to no bookings.

So slash the summer income, and have no plan for the winter - that's not a good proposal.

Anyone know how many host families have volunteered a room? And how much other accommodation is being offered (eg second homes, converted office blocks etc).

How much more do we think the country should aim to find?

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 18:50

My dad wants to do it. He can more than afford it. How is it so unreasonable to say that it's wrong my mum won't even humour a conversation about it?

Do you really need to have the vulnerabilities your mum may feel as a woman explained to you that your dad being a man will never have felt. And I presuming your parents aren’t young, your mum may just not have the energy required to do this. I’d put money on any work involved falling at your mums feet more than your dads. Men are often keen to hire out the tie wives time and effort. It’s your mums home and she has the right to close the door to the world and feel safe. Find a way of giving your own house up if you want to. If I was your mum I’d have simply told your dad that although it’s a nice thought, he’s being naive. If he’s gone on at her, which he may have, prompting her to ask for your help, I’d have told him to fuck off. I wouldn’t have involved you, it’s none of your business.

Mangogogogo · 13/03/2022 18:48

Do you think people would start trying to pick and chose who stayed in their home though? I mean understandably you’d prefer a mother and child over 5 20 year old lads for example, but will this then be pushed to ‘I will only take Ukrainian refugees and not others’? How far could we go? Would the homeowners have rights? Would they push these rights because the tenants are not paying rent?
I’m just kind of pondering out loud here. I don’t own a second home so I don’t really know what my actual answer would be

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2022 18:45

Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference

Not going to happen
If there was any chance it might, the Tory party - already awash with Russian money - would find itself in receipt of even more in order to get it stopped

DemBonesDemBones · 13/03/2022 18:44

'who the hell do you think you are? You know nothing about me- don’t come on here so you can make vile statements about me.'

😆😆😆 Sorry, just picked myself up off the floor. You're accusing her of EXACTLY what you've done!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2022 18:43

Has anyone else noticed that there have been no replies to the many questions about "What happens at the end of the 6 months"?

I'm aware that Refugees at Home (and probably others) sat they "aim" to find alternative accommodation once time's up, but what's to be done if there isn't any?

I won't hold my breath ...

RancidOldHag · 13/03/2022 18:41

I don’t think it’s really sunk in yet the scale of this crisis

Perhaps not. But remember that there were 2.5million Europeans displaced by war from 1992. And we coped.

Yogagrandmum · 13/03/2022 18:40

@Letshaveablackcelebration

Uk has a LOT of holiday homes and empty second homes. Surely they could be used to take a lot of Refugees aswell as spare rooms? It could support local economies all year round too rather than just in peak tourism seasons? The crisis is going to escalate rapidly in Ukraine- there are 44 million people in the country and so far it’s about 2 million who have fled and now countries like Moldova and the Poland are starting to struggle so we need to step up.

Aibu? It seems like an obvious solution. Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference.

I read an article about a woman who gave her French holiday home to a refugee family.

I agree.
Natfemale · 13/03/2022 18:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Bunnyfuller · 13/03/2022 18:36

No. I mean you don’t look to make exorbitant profit from your property, and rent it to the government at a reasonable amount.

In that case most landlords would sell up, creating a serious housing shortage. Only the very worse landlords with the worse housing stock would remain.

There would also be a huge shortage of labour in many parts of the market. Teaching, NHS etc in cities would collapse , as they couldn’t get staff.

The universities will struggle without the income of overseas students, who won’t want to come and live in slums in the UK. Many Uk students would also go to study overseas die to shortages of accommodation here.

Most overseas nationals who work here will return to their own counties, creating more job vacancies which can’t be filled by Uk nationals as they can’t move house.

Women and children would be forced to stay in abusive marriages as they couldn’t move out and rent anywhere else.

No. With less houses owned by landlords with multiple properties, there would be more on the market, making the housing market accessible. Rents would need to be competitive.

So telling the first reaction was ‘well, if we can’t make shitloads we’ll just sell’.

And the little holiday villages with a shop only open 6 months a year is BECAUSE of all the fucking holiday lets. They’ve killed the villages, because no one can afford to buy or rent there all year round. Even the little twee shop is run by out of towners selling over priced ‘artisan’ scones and cream from the local supermarket.

Dress t up all you like, we all know there’s a housing crisis in the uk which BTRs are the biggest cause of. It may be your ‘income’ but you are making your ‘income’ on the back of people with less than you needing a roof over their head. Or providing a cut above a nasty little caravan to those who like one of their annual holidays to be in the UK. It’s about money. You’re scared you’ll lose out if it goes to refugees. Own that, instead of all the ‘because’.

douper · 13/03/2022 18:36

disagree that should say

douper · 13/03/2022 18:36

Because this isn’t the best way to help traumatised people. And it isn’t the best for the families with spare rooms or houses in many cases.

I don't agree there are problems but the gov are going with "give your spare room to a refugee" so it is a thing regardless whether you like it or not.

What is the best way to help them?

SundayTeatime · 13/03/2022 18:35

I know several people with holiday homes that don’t let them to holiday makers. It’s more common than not. They give them out free to friends, or people from church, or poorer people who wouldn’t have a holiday otherwise. At least one is planning to hand over the holiday home to refugees..

douper · 13/03/2022 18:33

@Yebs unless you are going to give everything you have to a refugee & swapped lives you can't have an opinion 😆

Yebs · 13/03/2022 18:31

@PourSomeLove

If you and your family moved in with her and your father you could give your house over to a Ukrainian family. What a beautiful solution for everyone

Awaits excuses. 😂

Christ alive. Is this everyone's attitude? Someone saying that people who have the means should atleast think about helping out, automatically means those people just don't want to do it themselves and will have excuses. Of course a family with multiple young children are in a very different situation to two retired people with a huge house and paid off mortgage. My dad wants to do it. He can more than afford it. How is it so unreasonable to say that it's wrong my mum won't even humour a conversation about it?
douper · 13/03/2022 18:30

In that case most landlords would sell up, creating a serious housing shortage. Only the very worse landlords with the worse housing stock would remain.

There would also be a huge shortage of labour in many parts of the market. Teaching, NHS etc in cities would collapse , as they couldn’t get staff.

Key workers are already priced out. Rather than relying on generous landlords we need a lot more social housing.