Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think holiday homes could be used to house lots of refugees

660 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 13/03/2022 13:54

Uk has a LOT of holiday homes and empty second homes. Surely they could be used to take a lot of Refugees aswell as spare rooms? It could support local economies all year round too rather than just in peak tourism seasons? The crisis is going to escalate rapidly in Ukraine- there are 44 million people in the country and so far it’s about 2 million who have fled and now countries like Moldova and the Poland are starting to struggle so we need to step up.

Aibu? It seems like an obvious solution. Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference.

I read an article about a woman who gave her French holiday home to a refugee family.

OP posts:
alltheapples · 13/03/2022 19:39

@Puzzledandpissedoff they get jobs and sort out their own accomodation.

Comedycook · 13/03/2022 19:38

These aren't normal refugees looking for a better life

Huh...they are refugees. They're fleeing war. Those looking for a better life are often economic migrants

maddening · 13/03/2022 19:38

I think that there are lots of unused spaces - eg empty offices, empty retail spaces that could be adapted, whereas holiday homes are either a functioning business and therefore in use.

Bunnyfuller · 13/03/2022 19:35

@AngelinaFibres we have one teeny spare bedroom and a biggish office/living room down stairs so whatever we’re allowed to in those. We also have the worry that DHs elderly parents are in Georgia, and we know Putin has his eye on them too, so that adds to how we feel about this all.

I’ve been helping out with Chernobyl children (interpreting) for several years, that country has been through so much already.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/03/2022 19:34

These aren't normal refugees looking for a better life, these are literally women and children with nowhere to go

I agree with this completely, but just to mention that people simply "looking for a better life" aren't necessarily refugees

From the United Nations:
Article 1(A)(2) of the Refugee Convention defines a refugee as someone who:
^…owing to well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection
of that country; or who, not having a nationality and being outside the country of his former habitual residence as a result of such events, is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to return to it^

Madwife123 · 13/03/2022 19:31

I think the poster is being very naive here to think it’s that simple.

Being a refugee comes with a whole host of problems. Imagine being suddenly uprooted from your country and dumped somewhere else where you know no-one and don’t speak the language. Are you going to just adjust back to normal life?

The hotel where I am getting married took in refugees over the lockdown while they were closed. I don’t know what happened there but it’s now trashed and is currently undergoing million pound refurbishments ready for the weddings they booked prior to lockdown. I don’t think they were wrong to help but it’s very worrying and sad to see the state of this once beautiful 4 star hotel. How would a normal person afford to fix problems when their holiday homes that provide essential income can’t be rented out as a result?

Comedycook · 13/03/2022 19:31

Yabu. If someone doesn't want to open their home to a refugee or hand over their holiday home, then that's absolutely fine.

ValkyrieVik · 13/03/2022 19:31

So telling the first reaction was ‘well, if we can’t make shitloads we’ll just sell’.

So you are saying that people are greedy then? For what? Wanting to make money from their job?(ie being a landlord). Usually not shitloads either, often a modest income in the case of those who own one or two properties.

Do you not think people who manage properties and all the legal shite that comes with it should earn a living from it? (My dh works 12 hour days most days).

If people don't make a living from their job, they will have to give it up (ie sell their properties) thus taking those properties from the rental market.
What do you think will happen then? In a country where there is already a housing crisis?

There's just no thought at all gone into some of these comments - just people who don't know their arse from their elbow.

Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 19:30

@AngelinaFibres

Ah sorry I must have missed that. It’s just funny how many of these people telling everyone else how they can help are tragically unable to help themselves.

LastTrainEast · 13/03/2022 19:30

Lots of good points made including that it's not as simple as a roof over your head as if it were we could just put up tents in the parks. Taking people in requires taking on so much more with food, clothing, transport, medical treatment, advice/support and so on.

I love the "loads of empty homes" idea as if they just sit there unused and unwanted. As most people have pointed out they are mostly already being used to make enough money for some family to live on.

As for the emotional prod "we need to step up." I'm not sure that's very well thought through.

For one thing as others have pointed out there are homeless on the streets here and no one wants us to 'step up' for them. I guess worrying about the fate of refugees is 'cooler' and earns more points on social media.

If someone sees refugees and feels genuine sympathy that is a good thing and shouldn't be discouraged, but even if we had the means to move the population of Ukraine to the UK it wouldn't make much sense to do so.

We could empty the whole country and Putin could move in and then attack the next country over. Do we evacuate them too?

Better to do something about the cause rather than trying to treat the symptoms.

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 19:29

But you want to basically railroad her into having total strangers in her home whilst thinking of/ hiding behind lots of reasons why you can't .

Yep. And she certainly isn’t thinking of the refugees at all, having to live with her mum who would think they are thieves and is racist.

But I suppose she would get attention for saying ‘my parents took in Ukrainian refugees’, and claim glory by association., cheered on by all the others who would have given up their second home....if they had one of course.

AngelinaFibres · 13/03/2022 19:28

@Bunnyfuller

There’s a war going on that has the potential and looks like it will displace many, many millions of people. The future for the world has changed irrevocably. We have to stop thinking about trying desperately to hang onto everything we have, and instead start looking to think about what we have that can be shared. Not just by giving to charity and saving the tax. Not by baking cakes and raising funds for the church. By genuinely. GIVING. We have so much, it’s utterly heartbreaking that we are determined to have it all, make the right noises, but genuinely giving, because you have 2 and they have none, it’s just not there.

The fact that this thread very quickly got so vitriolic and spiteful speaks volumes about the skewed sense of compassion to other humans. I doubt those poor people dragged into this can think much further than the next day, why are people here using ‘but after 6 months’ as a reason against using empty property? Of course culture and familiarity will be hard, fucking hell, they’ve been bombed out of their homes! But some acceptance and compassion would help, surely?

Obviously, if they’re met with the prevailing mood of ‘just not here’ then the UK will continue its reputation of being racist and unwelcoming.

How many families will you be signing up for ?
Bunnyfuller · 13/03/2022 19:28

@mumwon

Did you read the previous post? The legislation can be changed, the insurance can be changed, everything is possible - how are the other countries managing?

Polish and Russian have similarities but are NOT the same. Ditto Moldovan. German and Ukrainian/Russian are completely different. Why is it only UK who uses language difficulties as a reason to not help?!

Why can Poland, Moldova etc help with the mental issues? Health needs?

Those who rent offset their maintenance costs against their tax bills so that doesn’t wash either. You have no idea what rules will be applied around Right to Work etc (we are desperate for workers in this country - you know - the ones who go to a job rather than make their money out of making profits from providing basic shelter for fellow humans, those kind of workers).

Of course you would rather give money - keeps all that nasty mess away and the accountant can write it off the tax bill.

Butchyrestingface · 13/03/2022 19:27

@anotherday85
English people are just unbelievable

I quite agree with your point about the English. Wink

I am Scottish but, in the words of little George Washington when he chopped down the cherry tree, I cannae tell a lie - I won't be signing up to host a Ukrainian refugee chez moi either. I will help in other ways, but not that one.

AngelinaFibres · 13/03/2022 19:24

[quote Kanaloa]@Yebs

If you and your dad feel strongly about this and your mum doesn’t want refugees in her house, what about if your family moved in with your mum & dad and you gave up your home to a refugee family?[/quote]
Previous page this is answered. Not at all possible tragically ( conveniently)

Butchyrestingface · 13/03/2022 19:23

[quote Letshaveablackcelebration]@CannaBelieve you have offered nothing constructive to this debate at all. Apart from insinuating that I am somehow stupid. This thread just exposes how really, most people in the U.K. don’t want refugees here at all.[/quote]
You think what a few posters on a parenting website think about renting second homes to refugees can be generalised to most of the UK population?

AngelinaFibres · 13/03/2022 19:22

@Yebs

You don’t like your Mum much, do you?

You can love people but not agree with or like how they are about certain things. I don't excuse racism just because I'm related to you. Ukraine is a poor country and her opinion of these people is based off that. I think that's wrong.

But you want to basically railroad her into having total strangers in her home whilst thinking of/ hiding behind lots of reasons why you can't .
PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 19:21

I doubt those poor people dragged into this can think much further than the next day, why are people here using ‘but after 6 months’ as a reason against using empty property?

Because anyone who has any experience of this will tell you that what they need is stability, not more upheaval after a few months when they’ve been through such trauma already.

HELLITHURT · 13/03/2022 19:20

@caringcarer

Well, I suppose we will find out more once scheme opens up. We can all help in different ways. When the Afghanistan refugees came over I offered to take an unaccompanied child but was told they need Muslim households who can take them to prayer. Instead I bought one of the teen children who joined a local cricket club his cricket kit, so he could play in matches.
That's lovely.
Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 19:19

@Yebs

If you and your dad feel strongly about this and your mum doesn’t want refugees in her house, what about if your family moved in with your mum & dad and you gave up your home to a refugee family?

caringcarer · 13/03/2022 19:19

Well, I suppose we will find out more once scheme opens up. We can all help in different ways. When the Afghanistan refugees came over I offered to take an unaccompanied child but was told they need Muslim households who can take them to prayer. Instead I bought one of the teen children who joined a local cricket club his cricket kit, so he could play in matches.

HELLITHURT · 13/03/2022 19:17

@anotherday85

English people are just unbelievable. Ukrainians are fleeing WAR and people here are giving endless excuses, asking who will replace their £3k a month holiday rental earnings (!), moaning about wear and tear and not wanting 'strangers' in their home! 'What if they take a loan in our name?'!!! Hmm

While Poland is taking in hundreds of thousands of refugees, housing them in their homes and rushing legislation to allow them to live and work there, Germans are waiting at the border with coaches ready to take refugees home and poor European countries are opening their doors, but the English, as always, are too precious, insular and selfish to think of ANYONE but themselves, even in a major European crisis like this.

For all the doom mongers hosting a refugee really isn't that hard, and you can specify whether you want to host a woman or a man. We had a Congolese woman in our spare room for a year through a hosting scheme, a refugee who had had to leave her child behind, was traumatised and didn't speak English, but she was a lovely young woman and we got on well, and in the end she was given a flat of her own. We didn't get paid anything for having her but it also didn't really cost us anything, beyond what we voluntarily chose to help her with. She got a living allowance and was entitled to GP services etc, which I imagine the Ukrainian refugees will too if they are allowed here.

We are registering to host again tomorrow and I would encourage you to do the same. As others have said a time may come when we will need help and compassion from others.

English people are unbelievable?

Not some English people all of them?

Geezabreak82 · 13/03/2022 19:16

I’ve not read the whole thread but just wanted to say that this basically happened in the Balkans during the 1990s. People displaced by the war in Yugoslavia would live in hotels and holiday accommodation during the winter and then during the summer they’d be moved out of town into tent villages so that tourists from across Europe could use the holiday accommodation. It’s no way to live. All this talk about a six month commitment is nonsense too. People won’t be going home in six months - I expect most people will be displaced for years, if not forever. Where do people think everyone is going to go after six months? What they need is a safe place to live where they can recover from the trauma they’ve been through and then start to plan the rest of their lives. Being moved on after six months is unlikely to be in their best interests.

Bunnyfuller · 13/03/2022 19:16

There’s a war going on that has the potential and looks like it will displace many, many millions of people. The future for the world has changed irrevocably. We have to stop thinking about trying desperately to hang onto everything we have, and instead start looking to think about what we have that can be shared. Not just by giving to charity and saving the tax. Not by baking cakes and raising funds for the church. By genuinely. GIVING. We have so much, it’s utterly heartbreaking that we are determined to have it all, make the right noises, but genuinely giving, because you have 2 and they have none, it’s just not there.

The fact that this thread very quickly got so vitriolic and spiteful speaks volumes about the skewed sense of compassion to other humans. I doubt those poor people dragged into this can think much further than the next day, why are people here using ‘but after 6 months’ as a reason against using empty property? Of course culture and familiarity will be hard, fucking hell, they’ve been bombed out of their homes! But some acceptance and compassion would help, surely?

Obviously, if they’re met with the prevailing mood of ‘just not here’ then the UK will continue its reputation of being racist and unwelcoming.

mumwon · 13/03/2022 19:15

@caringcarer you do not seem to understand the rules that residential landlords' have to obey with tenants
You cannot simply move the tenants (Refugees or not)from one rental to another - you have to give them notice & they do not have to move out until you do a section22 & get a bailiff via the courts. & I am sure that the said refugee would get legal advice to do this, because if they are a single parent, on UC & probably do not have permission to work or live there except as an emergency will cause all sorts of issues. They cannot after 6 months (unless the rules change & who knows with our incompetent government) claim housing benefit. & technically is the money you receive rent? You can't get a deposit so any damage done to your furniture or rental won't get paid for. How this work insurance & if you have holiday rental won't you still have to pay out for: electrical safety cert & necessary updates from same, gas servicing & safety checks, upkeep of property, callouts for things not working, & of course the property has to a be a minimum of D which you will have to test for - bong you are now in debit from the so called rent (which isn't rent but a reward & how does this work tax wise???) You could have a family of 4 living in your property & be paid for basically the cost of a single person in a single room (the government housing level not commercial please note)
Know what I think? The government is doing their famous " we can't afford this lets get the mugs to volunteers who have have no idea of what they are expected to do (act as social workers deal with families who may need medical or mental health support & not being able to speak the same language)
Its done on the cheap & without any recognition of problems that could arise. The countries that border the Ukraine often have assess to or understanding of a common language & we don't know how much support their governments are giving
I would rather give money to help & pressurise the government to do this support & accommodation properly - not the least because I can see the refugees being taken advantage of in their vulnerable state by crooks or by people who really don't know what they are getting into