Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think holiday homes could be used to house lots of refugees

660 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 13/03/2022 13:54

Uk has a LOT of holiday homes and empty second homes. Surely they could be used to take a lot of Refugees aswell as spare rooms? It could support local economies all year round too rather than just in peak tourism seasons? The crisis is going to escalate rapidly in Ukraine- there are 44 million people in the country and so far it’s about 2 million who have fled and now countries like Moldova and the Poland are starting to struggle so we need to step up.

Aibu? It seems like an obvious solution. Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference.

I read an article about a woman who gave her French holiday home to a refugee family.

OP posts:
Yebs · 13/03/2022 20:10

@Kanaloa

And you say you ‘had the conversation’ but obviously your parents did too for you to know your mother doesn’t want to. You had a conversation and said you couldn’t, so did your parents. You just think yours is more justifiable.
My dad said to me that he mentioned it and my mum instantly shut it down in seconds saying "I could never leave those people alone in my house, we'd be ransacked"

He was really disappointed her first thought was so disrespectful. As was I.

I don't know why I'm being made out to be unreasonable for that. If you want to excuse racism that's on you Smile

MySoCalledL1fe · 13/03/2022 20:10

@anotherday85 That's fantastic that you did that, I hope I can do the same one day when DC have left and I have space. You said it didn't cost you much, if I lost the income from my holiday rental business then it would cost me everything. Can I come and stay with you when my home is re-possesed?

The rental income has mortgage payments, bills, yes - wear and tear which means funding maintenance and replacements, business rates, laundry, cleaning. Do I not have a right to be concerned about how I would cope and to wonder why people are seeing that as a sad indictment of the English?

Sometimeswinning · 13/03/2022 20:09

@Letshaveablackcelebration why would you offer up holiday homes then? You have read one story. This is a shocking idea on the whole, expecting people to do this and have a single clue what they are letting themselves in for.

You're not even willing or able to help with the exact situation you are talking about!!

Yebs · 13/03/2022 20:07

I'm not telling others what they should do - I'm saying people should spare a thought. I've repeatedly said of course there will be plenty of valid reasons why people can't.

Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 20:07

It's just virtue signalling to say "I'd do it if I could, but due to x, y and z, I can't".

UglyModernWindows · 13/03/2022 20:07

OP and some others are banging on how rest of the Europe is willing to house all the refugees. I'm from an European country and as far as I know, there is no inclination whatsoever to house refugees in people's home.

Some vegetable/berry farmers are offering accommodation for some families but these people are known to them as they have been employed as a seasonal staff over the years. But that's it, individual families would not be up for it.

Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 20:06

And you say you ‘had the conversation’ but obviously your parents did too for you to know your mother doesn’t want to. You had a conversation and said you couldn’t, so did your parents. You just think yours is more justifiable.

Creameggs223 · 13/03/2022 20:06

@girlmom21

You can't just force people to give up their properties.

Who's going to pay the mortgages, the water rates or to fix any damage?

Who is staying their would pay their own bills they will have an address so can claim benefits including housing benefit.
Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 20:05

Because it’s stupid to say ‘I would help of course, but…’

I mean I could say that easily. I would help but I have four kids and a small home and - but it’s irrelevant. My ‘could have’ is no good to anybody and I don’t even know if it’s true. It’s easy to say what you would do when you don’t have to, and it doesn’t give you the right to tell others what they should do.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 20:04

Anyway I'm not spending my night arguing that we should be compassionate and atleast think about how we can help people. With a small house, young children, a baby on the way, struggling with our increasing bills without factoring in more people etc we aren't in a position to help but we had the conversation. All I'm saying is people should do the same. Anyone who says they wanted to help but couldn't you will belittle into saying they are just using excuses so it's wasted time. Ciao

Malibuismysecrethome · 13/03/2022 20:02

My holiday home is a Park home. Only family allowed to stay.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 20:01

But we are all privileged in a way, to not be able to relate to the situation these people are in. The people who have been fleeing the Middle East for so long. The difference between us and all of these people is luck. We were lucky to be born here and too many people have the mentality that we are above these people who have ended up in these situations and we aren't.

Badbadbunny · 13/03/2022 19:59

@Yebs

I want people in a place of privilege who have the means to think about it. Manipulate my words as much as you like. That is my stance.

There are very few "privileged people" who don't have mortgages to pay on their second properties. Most people I know with second properties rent them out as holiday homes to get an income to pay the costs, i.e. mortgage, insurance, power, maintenance, rates, etc etc. Yes, I know "some" people only use their holiday homes for themselves and leave them empty for a lot of the time, but I think the number in that position will be tiny and irrelevant.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 19:58

@Kanaloa

Don’t your kids have bedrooms? You could move them in with you.
You seen the size of new build bedrooms before? I think 5 people in a double bed might get child services phoned on me 😂
Yebs · 13/03/2022 19:57

@Kanaloa

I want people in a place of privilege who have the means to think about it. Manipulate my words as much as you like. That is my stance.

But your mum has thought about it. She was asked and said no. She doesn’t want to. She’s worried about what type of people the refugees may be, or maybe about something else. Same as you’ve thought about it and decided you absolutely can’t because you’re pregnant and have kids. You’ve both thought about it, you’ve both said no.

She didn't think about it. She wouldn't even have a conversation about it. She said she didn't want those people in her house. Pure snobbery with not a single valid reason (there are plenty - she didn't give any)

But ok. I'm bored of arguing. So you're right. It's absolutely a-ok for people to shut down the thought of helping people in need without any consideration. It's alright. It'll never be us so who cares right? Until it is, that is.

AngelinaFibres · 13/03/2022 19:54

But @yebs you won't be doing the work( for all the reasons you gave on p14, including living 3 hours away) your mum will. Your dad will presumably retreat to another part of their home and leave her to deal with it all. And, when it inevitably goes pear shaped, he will turn it into being her idea and wash his hands of it. Once their house is full of total strangers you won't be able to stay over with your children and new baby and she won't be able to visit you because she won't be able to leave her house. ( or is that actually why you are so keen)

Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 19:54

Don’t your kids have bedrooms? You could move them in with you.

Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 19:54

I want people in a place of privilege who have the means to think about it. Manipulate my words as much as you like. That is my stance.

But your mum has thought about it. She was asked and said no. She doesn’t want to. She’s worried about what type of people the refugees may be, or maybe about something else. Same as you’ve thought about it and decided you absolutely can’t because you’re pregnant and have kids. You’ve both thought about it, you’ve both said no.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 19:53

@Kanaloa

Also still don’t get why having kids yourself would preclude you from offering up a room. As others in this thread have said it’s not that hard and only for 6 months. You could move the kids into your bedroom/use a downstairs room or similar.
Because I have no empty bedrooms?!
ThePrincessSleptFor100Years · 13/03/2022 19:52

God I’m sorry but there is simply no way I’d be up for housing complete strangers for an indeterminate amount of time. Particularly not in my actual home.

I’d donate money and food, clothes whatever. But no, I don’t want to take anyone in. I need to put my two young children first and for me that is not inviting random strangers into our home. So so many reasons. You don’t know what issues this will bring to your doorstep. I don’t know how to help a traumatised person.

The people who actually do this (not just the ones that say they “totally would” and actually totally wouldn’t when push comes to shove) are bloody sainting heroes in my view.

Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 19:52

Also still don’t get why having kids yourself would preclude you from offering up a room. As others in this thread have said it’s not that hard and only for 6 months. You could move the kids into your bedroom/use a downstairs room or similar.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 19:51

@Theluggage15

You don’t want to do anything because you’re pregnant and a mother but you want your mum to look after people for who knows how long. And it would be your mother of course not your father doing the running around let’s be honest.
I want people in a place of privilege who have the means to think about it. Manipulate my words as much as you like. That is my stance.
Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 19:51

Oh yes. Easy for the father to volunteer his wife as much as it’s easy for someone with no second home to offer other people’s second home.

Theluggage15 · 13/03/2022 19:49

You don’t want to do anything because you’re pregnant and a mother but you want your mum to look after people for who knows how long. And it would be your mother of course not your father doing the running around let’s be honest.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 19:43

@PourSomeLove

But you want to basically railroad her into having total strangers in her home whilst thinking of/ hiding behind lots of reasons why you can't .

Yep. And she certainly isn’t thinking of the refugees at all, having to live with her mum who would think they are thieves and is racist.

But I suppose she would get attention for saying ‘my parents took in Ukrainian refugees’, and claim glory by association., cheered on by all the others who would have given up their second home....if they had one of course.

Oh get a bloody grip. Yes I want my mum to take in Ukrainian women and children so that I can brag about it to people. Of course that is far more logical than me, as a pregnant mother, feeling compassion for the mothers and children who have had everything bloody ripped from them. They're being spoke about like nothing more than inconveniences. Funnily enough I didn't know my mum would react that way when faced with the possibility, hence why I've said I was disgusted by it. She obviously didn't think I'd react the way I did when she seemed to think I'd also think it was awful. My dad obviously didn't know she'd be so against it when he suggested it. Funnily enough, a lot of middle class people do a pretty good job hiding their racism. All I am saying is that this could so, so easily be us one day. If my children and me were desperate it would break my bloody heart to read this thread where women, mothers, even the bloody government are talking about us like a problem to pass on to someone else. The people who can help, should think about it. That is my point. I know some people on mumsnet have to disagree with absolutely everything people say but it's true. We are lucky we were born here, we are lucky we have never been in this situation, there will be valid reasons to, and not to, do it. But it should be thought through. Imagine this was you and your kids.