Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think holiday homes could be used to house lots of refugees

660 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration · 13/03/2022 13:54

Uk has a LOT of holiday homes and empty second homes. Surely they could be used to take a lot of Refugees aswell as spare rooms? It could support local economies all year round too rather than just in peak tourism seasons? The crisis is going to escalate rapidly in Ukraine- there are 44 million people in the country and so far it’s about 2 million who have fled and now countries like Moldova and the Poland are starting to struggle so we need to step up.

Aibu? It seems like an obvious solution. Obviously using the empty homes of oligarchs too is a preference.

I read an article about a woman who gave her French holiday home to a refugee family.

OP posts:
ValkyrieVik · 13/03/2022 20:42

But what about the war in Yemen?

Why is everyone so keen to insist others (not they themselves of course, they haven't the room) open their houses to Ukrainian refugees?

What about all the darker skinned refugees fleeing from wars that've been going on for years? Who's been starting umpteen threads this week about that?

alltheapples · 13/03/2022 20:39

Slightly above-average earnings? 40k?

Yebs · 13/03/2022 20:39

I'm pointing out racism because it's going to be a huge factor in why lots of people won't help.

And I think it's ironic to quote Churchill to me in a conversation about how I was disappointed by my mum being racist.

MySoCalledL1fe · 13/03/2022 20:38

@Genegenieee
But you did get your holiday, so that's nice.
I'm not talking about losing a holiday, I'm talking about losing my income and everything I've worked for because OP thinks it's an obvious solution.

user1471428785 · 13/03/2022 20:37

OP YAB very U. Lots of second property owners like me have to rent them out - in my case, it's my sole source of income apart from a zero hours contract job which pays peanuts. Rent on my second property goes directly to help support my student daughter. I just can't afford to stop renting it to put a refugee in despite being very sympathetic to their plight. I imagine there are many people in my position.

Yebs · 13/03/2022 20:37

@ValkyrieVik

I'm not sure if a quote from a documented racist who committed genocide and let millions of people starve to death is meant to inspire me?

You try to divert the conversation at every turn Yebs

You seem obsessed with turning this thread into a one about racism?

Ok then, Did you know the Saudi Arabians have killed around a million people in the Yemen? It's happening now.

Why haven't you insisted your parents take refugees from that part of the world?

Why does no-one talk about the war in Yemen?

I've maintained the exact same point about the exact same situation throughout, you are the one throwing different situations and quote photos at me. One of us has stayed on topic here and it isn't you.
Billandben444 · 13/03/2022 20:37

So, the OP thinks holiday homes 'could be used for refugees' ? Surely that's up to the individual owners to offer them up if they want to? This is a very random post, what gives you the right to make this very generous offer of other people's property?
(HRTWT as the suggestion is so ludicrous)

ValkyrieVik · 13/03/2022 20:34

I'm not sure if a quote from a documented racist who committed genocide and let millions of people starve to death is meant to inspire me?

You try to divert the conversation at every turn Yebs

You seem obsessed with turning this thread into a one about racism?

Ok then, Did you know the Saudi Arabians have killed around a million people in the Yemen? It's happening now.

Why haven't you insisted your parents take refugees from that part of the world?

Why does no-one talk about the war in Yemen?

Genegenieee · 13/03/2022 20:31

@AllOfUsAreDead

I can just imagine the threads on here already..

'we've had our holiday booked for YEARS, scraping every penny together, and now it's been given to refugees so we can't stay there. Aibu?'

Not saying you're wrong, but I can imagine the outrage from the average British person. Its all well and good helping them until it interrupts their life.

Actually this has happened to us, air bnb in France we had booked has been used to house a Ukrainian family. We thought the owners did the right thing, and booked another - but if we hadn't been able to, I'd still be happy. My need for a holiday is significantly less important than someone having a roof over their head
MySoCalledL1fe · 13/03/2022 20:30

@alltheapples

LidlMiddleLover · 13/03/2022 20:29

Who pays for heat electricity damage et ? If the government pay its just the smae txpayers who Re already sruggling

MySoCalledL1fe · 13/03/2022 20:27

I have a mortgage on 2 homes which is partly paid by my holiday rental business, alongside another business which is also dependent on tourism. I have very slightly above average earnings, if I'm rich then so are nurses. I don't have a pension so that will be provided by the sale of my business. I'm sorry if that doesn't fit your narrative.

caringcarer · 13/03/2022 20:24

@mumwon, I am not inexperienced as a LL. I have been a LL for 17 years. All necessary expenses such as electrical certificate and energy performance certificate I already have only gas certificate and insurance is annual. Those expenses can be written off against my tax bill as less earnings means I would pay less tax. I do t see topuch difference between loosing 40 per cent of income to tax man or only getting £350 per month so possibly 60 percent less than I could get. The refugees are fleeing war and having to queue for up to 60 in as low as minus 10 temperature and snow with just a coat on. At end of 6-8 months I would help them find another private rental, give them reference, and help them furnish it. I have several friends who are LL too. My tenants are from Maldova, speak Russian and very keen to help. They think Putin will not stop at Ukraine and will go into Maldova next. I know £350 is meant for single room but there will be families, Mums with 2 or 3 children and perhaps a grandparent who won't want to be split up. I can afford to help such a family for 6-8 months. House is in a large town with good job prospects, and I know it does not make commercial sense but I want to help and do something meaningful.

RoseAndRose · 13/03/2022 20:22

@Geezabreak82

I’ve not read the whole thread but just wanted to say that this basically happened in the Balkans during the 1990s. People displaced by the war in Yugoslavia would live in hotels and holiday accommodation during the winter and then during the summer they’d be moved out of town into tent villages so that tourists from across Europe could use the holiday accommodation. It’s no way to live. All this talk about a six month commitment is nonsense too. People won’t be going home in six months - I expect most people will be displaced for years, if not forever. Where do people think everyone is going to go after six months? What they need is a safe place to live where they can recover from the trauma they’ve been through and then start to plan the rest of their lives. Being moved on after six months is unlikely to be in their best interests.
Exactly.

2.5 million people

Europeans displaced by war in Europe.

girlmom21 · 13/03/2022 20:22

@Creameggs223 you can't treat them like normal tenants if they're being placed in accommodation. They're not going to be immediately entitled to benefits and housing benefits only pay so much. They're not going to cover the losses the owners of holiday rentals would experience

Yebs · 13/03/2022 20:22

@ValkyrieVik

You seen the size of new build bedrooms before? I think 5 people in a double bed might get child services phoned on me 😂*

It's so easy for people who don't have the means, to sign away the free-will of others though isn't it?

Reminds me of this Churchill quote..

I'm not sure if a quote from a documented racist who committed genocide and let millions of people starve to death is meant to inspire me?
alltheapples · 13/03/2022 20:20

[quote MySoCalledL1fe]@alltheapples You don’t have to be pretty rich to own a holiday home, I own a holiday home and that is part of how I make a living and save for a pension, presumably you don’t think everyone with a job is rich? You have to be pretty rich to own a 2nd home which you don’t rent out and just keep for when you feel like popping in.[/quote]
Of course you are rich if you own two homes.

MySoCalledL1fe · 13/03/2022 20:18

@Creameggs223
"Who is staying their would pay their own bills they will have an address so can claim benefits including housing benefit"
That's great, will the housing benefit cover the peak August rental I projected in my business plan that the bank wanted to see when I borrowed the money to renovate the building? Will there be compensation for the cleaners and laundry I don't use any more, or for the pub down the road who lose income from all the guests I send there Or the woman who makes the local produce in my welcome hampers? Or have you not really thought it through that much?

Kanaloa · 13/03/2022 20:17

That’s right. I’m a racist because I don’t think performing hypothetical charity and generosity gives you the right to stand judge over whether other people’s reasons for not doing things are ‘valid.’

ValkyrieVik · 13/03/2022 20:15

we aren't in a position to help but we had the conversation

Ah well, as long as you had the conversation...
😂

AlwaysLatte · 13/03/2022 20:13

Too complicated with our holiday home (shared family space) but we're already in the process of trying to accommodate a family in our home.

ValkyrieVik · 13/03/2022 20:13

You seen the size of new build bedrooms before? I think 5 people in a double bed might get child services phoned on me 😂*

It's so easy for people who don't have the means, to sign away the free-will of others though isn't it?

Reminds me of this Churchill quote..

To think holiday homes could be used to house lots of refugees
Dreamstate · 13/03/2022 20:12

[quote Letshaveablackcelebration]@SparklyLeprechaun but this is my point- these are empty homes! If the government was willing to pay then what is the problem? It’s an enormous crisis that’s set to get a lot worse[/quote]
I'd rather the government paid to house our homeless people first!

Hayisforhorse · 13/03/2022 20:11

We are looking at doing this. Two issues we have to overcome first:

  1. House isn't in UK and local rules give renters right to remain in your house if they wish to stay (you can't eject them in winter), so until the legal position is clear, we can't risk it because we might never get the house back but have to keep paying for it (it's a well known problem in the country, people spend years trying to get someone to leave).
  1. Whilst house is empty now, it will be full in a few weeks, and then on and off until September. We need the income from the seasonal let to pay for the renovation we've just done. If the legal situ gets sorted, and houses are still needed in September then we will hopefully be able to welcome some refugees then.

A number of friends are doing similar, as well as organising fund raising etc. And all the people I know who are trying to help are those who have also been helping the Syrians in Calais, the Afghan refugees in Eastern Europe etc, for years.

DH is the grandson of a Ukrainian refugee who escaped war there years ago. The entire family was wiped out except for the grandmother, great grandmother and an uncle.

PourSomeLove · 13/03/2022 20:11

Yebs

Did your dad not want to house a refugee from Afghanistan? They needed help very recently. Surely he would have wanted to and then he would have already been aware of your mums views and so would you? 🤔