Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about future of care in the UK?

186 replies

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 12:24

I just wrote a v long post which I lost due to phone battery fading!

In a nutshell, what do we do when there are no longer any carers or anyone willing/able to care for our elderly and those in need of support?

I currently work for a care provider in a finance/admin role and it’s scary how: understaffed we and many other care providers in the area are; few people want to actually work in care and ;few younger people want to do it, and will only do so if threatened by sanctions etc.

In my company, most carers are aged between mid-40s and late 50s.

I previously worked in care on and off for much of my working life partly because (not going to lie) I couldn’t find anything else and was over or under qualified for other career paths. I know it’s crap in many ways: the pay, the hours and working conditions and the personal care is not for the squeamish (this was my issue!), but how do you get people to want to work in care?

Seriously, what do we do when the numbers fail to tally: many people in need, too few carers? Do people go off to hospitals long stay? But we also have a nursing recruitment crisis…

And before anyone suggests that I rejoin the carer ranks, as said I’ve done it before (for years), and it wasn’t for me. That’s kind of my point- no one really wants to do it!

OP posts:
AnImposter · 13/03/2022 14:30

I'd get rid of private care companies, consolidate all resources into one large LA run, not for profit and plough money into training and progression.

Having 5 people on one street pay 5 different companies for 10 different carers is madness. More mileage, inconsistent costs, inconsistent care. That one street could belong to one care team and absolve all travel costs and travel time that carers don't even get paid for. Madness.

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 14:30

Yes, @MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife and @JessieLongleg, it looks incredibly bleak. Every couple of years or so this sort of chat comes up, but nothing is ever done.

Those pathetic adverts by the government on getting into care/Made with Care just seem so patronising. I’d love to see our MPs do all the work in care as described by pps- personal care, feeding, dressing, lifting- for £9.91 an hour and still be smiling, energetic and plenty of money for that hefty mortgage.

I’m so fed up of people I meet saying how “rewarding” care is, yet would never try it themselves. Or complaining about the care their family members receive, yet would never lift a finger to help.

OP posts:
JessieLongleg · 13/03/2022 14:14

@Cherryade8

I just people frustration with people like that but really not someone I come into contact with in London.

Even my friend that moves to west country said she get much les hassle of the job centre there than in London.

When next door was off as lost his teaching job of 14 years due to cuts he noticed people less qualified being pushed into lower paid jobs and he was given a bit more grace. And now has another teaching contract.

My experience of the job center once as a teenage was told I couldn't apply for jobs higher than experience anyway. And 15 years later it was agreed I would look for jobs around 25k, my last being 45k. By the next visit was being pushed to take jobs at 16k.

My mum thinks I would be great in a caring position of management but I don't like the was the people I would manage would get paid so badly and the private and quite money grabbing ownership of care home. It's shocking how much it cost to keep someone in a care home. In comparison to carers wages even more so.

As the poster said above is doing if going to place to place has a high petrol cos and you don't get paid for that time. My friend who did it as a second job was spending way to much time siting in traffic between jobs to chase low paid hours of work.

As salesperson or someone that has to travel for work through a office job get to claim travel and food and is limited so don't take more than use. Like to poster says why would somone give that up by choice. And notes a lot of carers are older. Can't help think it because they have less job opportunities as whole. Known people in 50's to take on caring jobs as struggling to find office work, not out of choice and because £70 a week job seekers plus £100 housing benefit in West London is rubish money.

I don't know how anyone can live of it for 15 years and have any kind of fun.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 13/03/2022 14:11

We are going to have to make some hard decisions about healthcare spending, medical interventions and assisted dying, but it basically comes down to the fact that if we want people to be carers, we need to pay them more and treat them better.

In the end, that money needs to come from the people being cared from themselves - if they want a better standard of care, they are going to need to have saved up for it while they were working, to sell their houses, not expect to leave anything to children or grandchildren, etc, etc.

Rich and poor don't get equal consideration or standards of living when they are under 70 so why should that change when you are suddenly over that age?

It would be lovely if we could treat everyone equally but, let's be real, that isn't the system we live in and unless something dramatically changes then I'd suggest we all either start saving to pay for our own carers when we get old or decide on how and when we want to check out early.

TimBoothseyes · 13/03/2022 14:07

[quote Cherryade8]@JessieLongleg you're right, caring should be done well and with kindness. If carers are overstretched then surely requiring people who are claiming unemployment benefits to assist them in some way would be useful though? I have a relative who refuses to do any cleaning/caring/vaguely unpleasant work yet has claimed benefits for 15 years now. What a waste.[/quote]
So how would forcing your relative to go into caring benefit those she would have to care for? Do you think having someone stood over them tutting/gagging/sighing (or whatever way the carer showed their displeasure at being there), is going to calm a dementia patient, be compassionate to someone at end of life, encourage somebody to eat? All they will do is cause more suffering and stress to people than is necessary.

JockTamsonsBairns · 13/03/2022 13:56

Make it a requirement of claiming unemployment benefits that if roles like care are available then then you can't claim dole? I often see care roles advertised with flexible hours etc, people shouldn't be paid not to work.

Jesus wept. Really? Is this really how little you think of the role I do?
In a typical morning, I start at 7, changing a stoma bag and a fistula bag for a disabled woman, before dispensing 17 tablets for her.
45 minutes later, I'm at a very elderly man with advanced dementia, helping him to shower and have breakfast, and possibly change soiled bedding.
45 minutes after that, I take a woman shopping - a 48 year old woman with acute depression due to losing her husband and three children in an accident eight years ago.
Two hours later, I arrive at my next client, a 64 year old woman with stage 4 cancer. I help to gently wash her in bed, rub cream into her acutely ulcerated skin, and help her into fresh nightclothes. We talk - a lot, about her fears for her disabled son, and what will happen to him in the next weeks/months when she dies.
Then I'm at a double up call with another carer, this time at a 96 year old woman who requires hoisting to a commode, personal care given, and hoisted safely back to bed. She then needs fed with a soft food diet and thickened drinks, before possibly requiring hoisted to the commode again.

I do this 5 days a week from 7am until 10pm. To be a carer requires compassion, integrity, and a massive amount of commitment. All this for minimum wage.
So please don't sit there behind your keyboard and insult us by suggesting that any Tom, Dick or Harry can be forced into doing it.
Is that the standard that people really want for the most vulnerable members of our society?

SilkySuky · 13/03/2022 13:55

@Hospedia, that was an excellent post.

Cherryade8 · 13/03/2022 13:55

@JessieLongleg you're right, caring should be done well and with kindness. If carers are overstretched then surely requiring people who are claiming unemployment benefits to assist them in some way would be useful though? I have a relative who refuses to do any cleaning/caring/vaguely unpleasant work yet has claimed benefits for 15 years now. What a waste.

JessieLongleg · 13/03/2022 13:48

@Cherryade8

First most people in bigger cities don't use benefits not to work.

Secondly I don't want anyone going into care job. It's takes someone with a certain amount on personal skills to do care jobs. It's not just about being caring but thinking on their feet, a whole lot of patience and none judgement views. We are talking about people having adult incontinence pads changes, washing people etc not just basic care of shopping etc.

Thirdly it's is a job that needs better pay and conditions so people that have these skills feel it can be a career path rather than a dead end job.

We could do a whole lot more that force people into these jobs in areas where benefit claiments are high. And not always in higher areas of population where they need more carers.

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 13:46

@PomBearWithoutHerOFRS, you’re not wrong. It’s heartbreaking.

Now, what do we do when we’ve run out these selfless people willing to do just this? We don’t look after our own parents at home in this country (no judgement; I won’t be volunteering to do this myself!), so where does the decent care come from?

OP posts:
Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 13:39

@Akire, I totally agree with you. And it’s embarrassing to see how some carers resent being there, whilst others are incredible.

OP posts:
PutinsMicropenis · 13/03/2022 13:37

It's terrifying. I work in the NHS now but started my career in care, it was looking after these people that made me want to pursue a career in the NHS because I really enjoyed many aspects of it.

The trust where I work is currently on black alert because of a lack of care when patients go home, they simply cannot discharge patients because there is no one to look after them! No patients out = no patients in.

I think it would be good if it was a pre requisite of doing nursing training for all students to have done at least a year of care work prior to starting training. This would also sort the problem of many nurses coming through training who are too focused on the paperwork side of things rather than actually caring for the patients.

Other than that, apart from massively increasing pay and improving working conditions to make care work a more attractive option, I don't know what the answer is. The current system is absolutely fucked.

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 13:37

What a shame the industry is losing you, @JockTamsonsBairns- you sound amazing. I wish I could’ve been more like you!

OP posts:
Thatswhyimacat · 13/03/2022 13:36

Health interventions aimed at extending people's healthy years as opposed to just adding more years of disability onto the end of life, and generally increasing the health of the population as a whole. Covid really showed just how shockingly unhealthy we are as a country.

Pay pay pay for carers.

Make assisted suicide legal.

PomBearWithoutHerOFRS · 13/03/2022 13:33

Flexible hours doesn't mean flexible to suit the carer. It means they can be on shift any time any day 24/7/365.
Shifts are almost always minimum 12 hours. 24 hour sleep over shifts aren't paid for the "sleep" hours, but the carer cannot leave, or often even sleep soundly.
Would you work 9am - 9am for 14 x £9 ? Handing out medications and completing the paperwork, cleaning, personal care and cleaning every bodily fluid you can think of, be bitten/kicked/slapped/verbally abused?
Spend hours studying, because care is NOT unskilled, and requires various certificates to be passed.
Work say 50 hours overtime, but told you can have time off in lieu "soon" rather than be paid overtime?
Hold someone's hand as they die, then lay them out, then be the one to call their family and tell them ?

TimBoothseyes · 13/03/2022 13:33

@Cherryade8

Make it a requirement of claiming unemployment benefits that if roles like care are available then then you can't claim dole? I often see care roles advertised with flexible hours etc, people shouldn't be paid not to work.
Would you want a child to be looked after by somebody forced to do it? No you wouldn't, so why is it ok for the elderly?

I used to work in care but left due to the long hours (between 10 and 15 hours a day most days), the impossible time constraints, woeful pay and complete lack of work/life balance. My shifts were 6 days on 1 day off, 4 das on ,2 days off. It was not sustainable and something had to give so I left and won't be returning to it anytime soon. Plus the increased cost of fuel means that even the 45p a mile allowance wouldn't cover the costs of travel to each client.

Supersimkin2 · 13/03/2022 13:30

Yep, boils down to too little £ and too many severely disabled elderly with too many decades of care needs each.

Trouble is, in terms of £ investment, zero return is at least the best option.

Part of the cause is medicine - the NHS is bloody good at staving death off, useless at keeping you functioning. There’s more to life than a heartbeat, yet that’s all a lot of a care users have got.

Dobbysgotthesocks · 13/03/2022 13:30

@Cherryade8

Make it a requirement of claiming unemployment benefits that if roles like care are available then then you can't claim dole? I often see care roles advertised with flexible hours etc, people shouldn't be paid not to work.
Yes because what people needing care need is people completely unsuitable to do the role and who don't want to be there. 🙄😡

Seriously it's attitudes like this that are the reason we are in this mess!

Akire · 13/03/2022 13:30

I’m disabled I’ve used agency’s. Some carers are great others have been dreadful. You don’t want someone in your home because job centre says so. The attitudes, the looks, the gagging at personal care. Would you want someone to get your washed dressed like that every day?

I’ve seen amazing carers 20y experience great skills get all hard clients. Because yes they are great with people with dementia or other disabilities that can be challenging. You know what they got paid same someone who done it for 6months and since so awful you only asked them to do bare mim just so they would leave.

We need at least levels like NHS or bands that you can level up as you can experience and skills. Some places have senior carers on 50p on hour more than a new person. We don’t value nursing or people skills. If it’s a proper job you need to be able work up. Sadly in care this often means “working in the office” on a much higher rate.

We need accept we can’t ask people to pay decent wage for care and the state will have to make up the difference. The new care cap coming will not help me as I have no savings or assets but still use benefit income and take massive chunk. So once I reach £86000 I’d still be paying same as before. It’s not clear how hike NI will be used despite all Facebook posts I see about investments in care.

EdgeOfSeventeenAndThreeQuarter · 13/03/2022 13:29

Is flexible code for “we have no fucking idea what your shifts will be from one week to the next?”.

I enquired about a role at my local care home. Not my ideal job, but an honourable job and a way to give back to the community.

I’m a LP to primary age children. Now if they’d said EVERY Thursday night, I could’ve somehow found a way - but it was going to be a rolling shift pattern - and that’s NEVER going to work for a LP with school-aged children.

megletthesecond · 13/03/2022 13:24

I would not want to see people being forced to do it for benefits. It would be a safeguarding catastrophe. Shitting hell.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/03/2022 13:19

Really Bush? Grin

Rubbish, obviously.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/03/2022 13:19

Cherryade8
Make it a requirement of claiming unemployment benefits that if roles like care are available then then you can't claim dole? I often see care roles advertised with flexible hours etc, people shouldn't be paid not to work“

Really bush. Caring is a skilled profession. You honestly think anyone is capable of it?
I don’t want care when I’m old. certainly don’t want care delivered by someone forced into it who.

Maverickess · 13/03/2022 13:13

@Cherryade8

Make it a requirement of claiming unemployment benefits that if roles like care are available then then you can't claim dole? I often see care roles advertised with flexible hours etc, people shouldn't be paid not to work.
And this attitude, in a nutshell, is what's wrong with social care.

I assume that you would want excellent care delivered? That you want standards met and exceeded?

You don't achieve that by forcing people to do a job that deals with human beings that rely on others for their basic needs, you do that by investing in the people that want to do it, training them, respecting them, paying them a decent wage, not bullying them into extra work for free or trading on their compassion to get it, paying them the least that's allowed legally and blaming them for everything that goes wrong.

The attitude that it's a job that anyone can do is the problem, there's very little stopping anyone being in a care role and doing the job, but in order to do it well, to a standard most people want and to ensure people are cared for well, you need people that have or can develop a certain skill set and continue to improve on that.

We're supposed to value everyone, including the most vulnerable in society, and that should include ensuring they are cared for by people who are invested in them, it doesn't though, as long as you're upright and have a pulse, you'll pretty much do.

Hospedia · 13/03/2022 13:05
  • increase Carers Allowance and increase the earnings limit. There are people who would care for disabled/elderly family members themselves if it was financially viable.

At the moment Carers Allowance is £67.60 a week. To get this you must be caring for someone who meets the qualifying criteria (e.g., in receipt of high rate PIP/DLA) and you must be caring for them a minimum of 35hrs a week. You cannot be in full time education and you cannot be earning more than £128p/wk (roughly 14hrs p/wk at NMW). The care provided can be a mix of direct care such as cooking meals or helping with personal needs and indirect care such as doing their shopping or advocating for then with various services.

Taken over 35hrs that equates to £1.93 p/hr.

As many unpaid carers will tell you, it never stops at 35hrs and 24/7 is more in line with the reality of it. Taken over 24/7 it equates to just 40p an hour.

To make even worse it is a taxable benefit and so lowers the amount of other benefits and it doesn't count as a 'gateway' benefit so does not entitle you to things like free prescriptions or help with health costs such as dentistry or optical services (caring has a huge impact on the physical and mental health of carers).

  • in line with the above, give incentives to employers to offer career breaks for the purpose of providing care to a family member in the same way they offer maternity/paternity/adoption leave. If someone's spouse, parents, child, or other direct relation becomes unwell/disabled and needs care then offer a minimum of six months paid leave with protected return to work and Statutory Care Pay for those who qualify (companies could then choose to offer enhanced packages in the same way they do maternity/paternity/adoption leave). Six months isn't going to resolve all of the care needs but it would allow the carer time to assess the support needed, look at the viability of various options, and so on without running themselves frazzled trying to juggle work, family, and caring (and let's face it, many of these people are women in their 40s/50s/60s). In other cases it would allow for people to provide end of life care to a loved one without having to also worry about work.
  • change the idea that it is unskilled work. Offer Health and Social Care NVQs in sixth forms alongside apprenticeships in caring. Add caring to the curriculum for nursing and HCA courses so that alongside ward placements they also do placements in care home settings and community care roles
  • pay carers properly with realistic pay scales for length of service and take steps to promote its value as a career. It should be brought under the same banner as health care assistants and nurses. Offer training, career and education progression for those who want it (e.g., experience as a carer counting towards entry criteria for nursing and HCA courses), and so on. Hell even a reality documentary like the ones that follow junior doctors around would help to show people the depth of the role.

Basically a lot of it boils down to money and no one is willing to spend the money to improve things.