Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about future of care in the UK?

186 replies

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 12:24

I just wrote a v long post which I lost due to phone battery fading!

In a nutshell, what do we do when there are no longer any carers or anyone willing/able to care for our elderly and those in need of support?

I currently work for a care provider in a finance/admin role and it’s scary how: understaffed we and many other care providers in the area are; few people want to actually work in care and ;few younger people want to do it, and will only do so if threatened by sanctions etc.

In my company, most carers are aged between mid-40s and late 50s.

I previously worked in care on and off for much of my working life partly because (not going to lie) I couldn’t find anything else and was over or under qualified for other career paths. I know it’s crap in many ways: the pay, the hours and working conditions and the personal care is not for the squeamish (this was my issue!), but how do you get people to want to work in care?

Seriously, what do we do when the numbers fail to tally: many people in need, too few carers? Do people go off to hospitals long stay? But we also have a nursing recruitment crisis…

And before anyone suggests that I rejoin the carer ranks, as said I’ve done it before (for years), and it wasn’t for me. That’s kind of my point- no one really wants to do it!

OP posts:
dipdye · 14/03/2022 01:28

Pay them more. Fairly simple.

pringlelips · 14/03/2022 00:06

I am care manager

We have some amazing carers who are worth so much more than money we pay but it's not as simple as just pay them more . Most private care companies will have have contracts with the LA , they have a fixed amount of how much they will pay per hour and will do anything to cut a package down to save money . In some areas this is as low £15.50 per hour , take out the £8.91 add 20% for annual leave , pension contributions etc , mileage allowance, the wages of the people who are needed to coordinate the care ,general business over heads , training ( currently 40+ courses a year to stay compliant) it doesn't leave much left to increase the wage of the person actually out in the field doing the job .

We do have more complex packages but you try fighting the LA to pay anymore than the standard rate so you can pay the staff a little bit more to be bitten ,punched and general abused all day .

To be a good carer you need care , thought, tolerance and resilience and a bloody good sense of humour . We want to pay more , we want good staff retention , we want the industry to be recognised as a good carer choice and something to aim for , not as something that people do when they are not good enough for anything else .

For us it starts with the LA's paying a rate that allows us to pay what the staff are really worth and stop using the care providers as scape goats when something bad happens because they decided 15 minutes was all the service user needed 15 minutes was all they were willing to pay for .

dangermouseisace · 13/03/2022 23:58

Local authorities need to pay more- a lot more. They can't do this without increased funding from central government. There needs to be better conditions for carers, they need enough time to do their job, pensions, sick pay etc. It needs to be an attractive option as a job. It's hugely rewarding but unsustainable for many people. I went back to domicilary care work between jobs and my God it was hard. The clients were lovely and I am not at all “ick” about personal care- we are all human! But the time pressures, the rushing from one job to another, the amount of things you are expected to doing a short space of time. It was really unnecessarily hard work.

hellywelly3 · 13/03/2022 23:52

What puts me off is the fact that it’s shift work. I’d like 3/4 days a week but set days. I like to know what I’m doing. Also I can imagine that’s a lot of pressure to do more hours all the time

womaninatightspot · 13/03/2022 23:43

@DockOTheBay

Also unpopular opinion but make assisted suicide legal and allow people to sign to say they want AS if they get to a certain stage of e.g. dementia
This tbh not a popular opinion as PP said but given my family history (dementia) I have no desire to live a long lingering end where I wouldn't recognise the shell of a person that I've become.

Politicians are twitchy about it who wants to go out on a limb as killing granny?

It does need better wages and more career progression. I'd also agree trhat it needs to be brought back under local authourity control/ some sort of national care service. This idea that you don't pay travel time between clients and just over minimum wage for what is a difficult job is ridiculous.

Rachie1973 · 13/03/2022 23:30

@makingmiracles

Forgot to add we have to do a lot of training as well, especially around eating and drinking, Gdpr, fire safety, food safety, epilepsy training and medication training. A lot of which has to be updated every year.
I think you might work for the same company as me lol.
Rachie1973 · 13/03/2022 23:25

@Cherryade8

Make it a requirement of claiming unemployment benefits that if roles like care are available then then you can't claim dole? I often see care roles advertised with flexible hours etc, people shouldn't be paid not to work.
Seriously? Some people can’t do it!

I might just be a ‘carer’ but I’m trained to give medication, including controlled drugs, give personal care and maintain dignity, learn safeguarding skills and end of life care. We shouldn’t get ‘too involved’ but that’s just impossible.

When your loved one is covered in faeces, vomiting and scared do you really want an unwilling carer who can’t do the job properly caring for them?

Stroppypeople · 13/03/2022 23:13

@Maverickess….agree with every word you have written!

Stroppypeople · 13/03/2022 23:07

Improve pay ,treat staff with respect ,acknowledge how hard the carers work ,remember they are human beings ,take notice of their concerns, stop guilt tripping staff to work longer hours because the company loose staff so quickly due to all of the above!!
Remind the owners of care homes to stop being so GREEDY!

BettyBag · 13/03/2022 22:53

There is a fundamental misunderstanding in this thread and indeed among most people of what adult social care spend their money on.

Is not the elderly. The majority of ASCs budget is spent on younger people with life long or acquired disabilities.

So yeah. All this talk of assisted suicide and ending life prolonging treatment to save money is fucking vile.

Maverickess · 13/03/2022 22:44

@bebanjo

Iv been in care for 18 months, I’m leaving next week. We had a team meeting last week, I said I want to be issued with 3 uniforms a year, we get one when we join and then have to pay £15 each for more. Can we be paid for meetings, can we be paid for training. No, no and no, they know they can do this as they have employed a company to see if it’s legal.
It's this that is the hardest to take for me - and the knowledge that it happens because it's mainly mainly profit driven.

I'm not asking for a massive wage, I'd be happy with enough to live on, have a decent life with a holiday now and again and not have to worry about having the heating on or work 50 hours a week to just scrape by.
I'd be happy with enough staff to enable me to spend time with people like I'm supposed to, not rush through everything because it's a choice between everyone getting the basics or half getting good care and half getting none.

I'd be happy with better training - and the staff ratio's to achieve the standard we're supposed to be reaching.

I'd be happy with not being made the scapegoat for systematic, provider, healthcare and government failures in social care and to be listened to when I raise concerns rather than fobbed off and then blamed.

And I'd be happy with a bit more respect from employers, from managers, from families, from the government, from society at large, from other HCPs (nurses can be awful towards care workers ime).

For starters these things need to change, followed by -
The 15 minutes at the start of every shift for handover (for every carer, every shift) - essential enough to demand you're there but not essential enough to pay for, the mandatory training that you have to legally do, yet don't get paid for, and some companies charge you for it, the mandatory uniforms - that you have to pay for yourself, the staying back to complete paperwork (because it's a legal requirement) yet you don't get paid - you've been too busy looking after the people you're meant to be looking after - because there aren't enough staff to meet the residents needs - and have to wait for the next shift so you can complete it so they can do the care, the short staffed shifts that are more and more common, numbers made up by cleaners, management and domestics on paper, but in reality you just work harder and faster - not giving the care you want and should be giving and the company pockets the last persons wage for that shift and then get the blame when something goes tits up and safeguarding get involved.

Social care (like the NHS, education etc) has been run on too little investment and an abundance of good will - what we're seeing is that good will is running out, we know we're having the piss taken out of us and so people are leaving, and after covid it's not so much that people don't want to give more, it's that there's nothing left to give, the tank is empty and on fumes.

Lampface · 13/03/2022 22:39

I think the pay is what lets it down. It's horrifically badly paid and known for it. Carers deserve much, much more.

Smellyporcupine · 13/03/2022 22:35

My MIL hires private carers they might have 2-3 clients in total, rather than ones that have multiple jobs a day. They get paid pretty well, I think its £20 - £25 per hour.

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 22:25

Can’t believe you have to pay for another uniform, @bebanjo- atrocious. The tight gits ought to get their priorities in order. And they don’t pay you for mileage? Wtaf??

OP posts:
bebanjo · 13/03/2022 22:10

Iv been in care for 18 months, I’m leaving next week.
We had a team meeting last week, I said I want to be issued with 3 uniforms a year, we get one when we join and then have to pay £15 each for more. Can we be paid for meetings, can we be paid for training.
No, no and no, they know they can do this as they have employed a company to see if it’s legal.

Mumofsend · 13/03/2022 22:06

I used to do it and loved it. My hours were 7am-11am and then 4pm-9pm.

Impossible now as a single parent. Zero willingness to be flexible on account of the company. It wasn't so much about the pay but the hours. 5 minutes to do a 20 minute journey was standard too.

Shame as I loved it.

Asdf12345 · 13/03/2022 21:31

As supply dwindles the purchaser has to increase what they pay.

Those in private arrangements pay more or get by with less, the state has to chose to cover less or pay more.

As a society we have decided wealth stored in property should be protected unlike any other asset type. Sooner or later this will have to be reconsidered.

makingmiracles · 13/03/2022 21:26

Forgot to add we have to do a lot of training as well, especially around eating and drinking, Gdpr, fire safety, food safety, epilepsy training and medication training. A lot of which has to be updated every year.

makingmiracles · 13/03/2022 21:23

I think people need to watch panorama episode “crisis in care-follow the money” on bbc iplayer and then it will become clear why carers are not paid a fair wage.

13 yrs ago I was working for an agency, one of the few who paid well, we got £9.18 an hr, £12.50 on weekends and £18 on bank holidays, £35 a night sleep in rate. Most agencies were invoicing clients for £30+ out of which the carers got around £6-8 (can’t remember what min wage was back then) and the £24ish pounds over was profit for the agencies.

I had a decade break from work due to childcare responsibilities but went back in may 2020, I work for an organisation now not an agency and am paid £9.50 an hr. The responsibility I have for that pay is insane, I arrange drs appointments, hospital visits, district nurse care, change catheters, apply dressings, personal care, I’m dysphasia trained by SLT, I administer medication, I thin and thicken foods and drinks to safely drink, I do housework, shopping, I’m responsible for their finances and spending, record keeping, medication ordering…….all for £9.50 an hour.

My organisation wants people 7am -10pm in the daytimes, however they are so short staffed they accept me coming in between school hours-because a carer is better than none/short staffed. I do occasional weekends although when I started I only did weekends for 1yr, we do not get additional pay for weekends or bank holidays.

The care system needs an overhaul, to be based heavily around investment is shit and a lot of providers will do the bare minimum to get bodies in rooms without much thought for residents or staff.

everybodystalking · 13/03/2022 21:03

I find it both devastating and outrageous that cost of care is being brought up as a reasonable argument for assisted dying...there is a real debate to be had for and against this but REALLY finances are the worst possible grounds.

The well aged are increasing too....equivalent people who required care at 75 due to ill health when I was a young adult are now travelling the world, healthy aging is much more common BUT the increased age of the upper end of the demographic mean that frailty plus ill health plus the numbers born have caused a care and NHS crisis,

Poor funding and work force planning over the last 20 years, the embracing of the program of austerity by all parties have left us in this spot compounded by brexit and a pandemic (predicted for years by the way).

The only way out is financial commitment, proper wages and conditions, respect for the work done and workforce planning and recruitment.

Sadly I don't see any appetite for this
even Jeremy *unt thinks we have missed the boat......

Saracen · 13/03/2022 20:42

I know some people who love being carers. So if we made the job viable for them, they would do it. Raising pay for sure, and improving working conditions - I guess the latter is a catch-22 though, because I suppose while staffing remains an issue, whoever does work as a carer is going to be overworked in a stressful job...

I have no idea whether, if the working conditions were attractive enough, there would be enough people wanting to do it.

twominutesmore · 13/03/2022 20:30

The only way to improve recruitment is to pay more, and then charge the elderly more for services.

Or recruit from abroad, and hope they'll accept lower pay.

Or raise the threshold for support. If you've got family within a certain distance, they have to do it.

Or raise taxes. Or reallocate tax money from elsewhere.

Probably a combination.

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 20:20

Hi @hugr, if you’d read my original post, you’d have seen that I did once work in care, and it was admittedly not for me. I wrote this with that point in mind: that people don’t really want to work in care (and sadly, I understand why!)…

OP posts:
GreenNewDealNow · 13/03/2022 19:36

Care wages don't pay the rent.

Maverickess · 13/03/2022 19:01

@notanothertakeaway

It terrifies me how many people suggest that assisted suicide is the solution. We should be improving patients' quality of life, not killing them off

If AS is introduced, then strict legal safeguards would be watered down over time, people would feel guilty for being alive in poor health, relatives with an eye on their inheritance would say that "Dad always said he would wish to die if he had alzheimer's"

Back to OP's question, raising wages would make the role more attractive

And it's very telling that people would rather talk about that than how to improve it now. It's certainly an option for the future, but as we don't have it and are actively keeping people alive with a range of illnesses that reduce quality of life, it's not going to solve the crisis happening now, right now and affecting people right now. We need to change things now, but people would much rather talk about popping off to Sweden than increasing pay and conditions for care staff doing this job - and then wonder why they feel undervalued.