Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about future of care in the UK?

186 replies

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 12:24

I just wrote a v long post which I lost due to phone battery fading!

In a nutshell, what do we do when there are no longer any carers or anyone willing/able to care for our elderly and those in need of support?

I currently work for a care provider in a finance/admin role and it’s scary how: understaffed we and many other care providers in the area are; few people want to actually work in care and ;few younger people want to do it, and will only do so if threatened by sanctions etc.

In my company, most carers are aged between mid-40s and late 50s.

I previously worked in care on and off for much of my working life partly because (not going to lie) I couldn’t find anything else and was over or under qualified for other career paths. I know it’s crap in many ways: the pay, the hours and working conditions and the personal care is not for the squeamish (this was my issue!), but how do you get people to want to work in care?

Seriously, what do we do when the numbers fail to tally: many people in need, too few carers? Do people go off to hospitals long stay? But we also have a nursing recruitment crisis…

And before anyone suggests that I rejoin the carer ranks, as said I’ve done it before (for years), and it wasn’t for me. That’s kind of my point- no one really wants to do it!

OP posts:
douper · 14/03/2022 08:20

The biggest issue we are facing in my rural area is that there are far more elderly here than young people to look after them,

This is really important & is only going to get worse.

"In the next 25 years, the number of people older than 85 will double to 2.6 million"

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:19

@Disfordragon

To the PP who mentioned assisted dying. We don’t need to go that far….we could just stop keeping people alive who are trying to die. This country has a huge issue with allowing people to die…..and I don’t mean 30 year olds with terminal cancer I mean over 80 year olds with dementia living in nursing homes with 24 hour care. How about we stop all their medications and, shock horror, don’t treat their urinary tract infection or chest infection (or give them Covid vaccinations)and allow them to die as opposed to treating it to keep them alive but in an ongoing negative trajectory in terms of quality of life until they get an infection that we can’t treat. 20 years in health care and I’ve had 4 families ask me to allow ‘nature to take its course’……the rest say ‘do everything’…..so the misery of living with dementia in a care home can continue for the patient, the relative, the carers and society at large.
I am going to keep pointing this out because people really need to understand it.

75% of adult social care funding is spent on people under the age of 64.

The NHS refusing life prolonging treatment to 80+ year old is not going to make the difference you think it will. Its a drop in the ocean. And FYI they very often do this anyway.

Maverickess · 14/03/2022 08:19

@Bringsexyback

But what about now? What about the people who are in need of care now, that can't get it because there's not enough people willing and able to provide it? Or the people that are currently recieving care that's patchy and delivered by people who are overstretched?
This has been an issue for a long time and it's been brought to a head by covid and Brexit. Part of the workforce sent home, part of it burned out because of the pay, conditions and workload and part gone due to mandatory vaccination - no matter what you think of those things, the number has been significant enough to cause a bigger problem than already existed, and there isn't an influx of people coming in to replace them.

I agree that AS is a discussion to be had, but as there are currently no plans to introduce it, it won't help the crisis now, and you can't suddenly start making decisions for people that already have a diagnosis that means they lack the capacity to make that decision themselves.
I could almost guarantee that if you asked every one of the people I care for if they wanted to die they'd be as horrified with the idea as I would be should I be asked now - because by and large they have little concept of what is wrong with them due to the illness, they are all going home soon, they are getting up and getting ready for work, wanting to go and pick the kids up from school - would you have someone like me hold them down to make it happen?

Talking about AS is not going to solve the problems now, that are going to get worse in the next few years unless something changes, and part of the issue is that people would rather bury their head in the sand and insist that a solution that is not yet being considered is the answer, rather than see that we've got a serious problem right now and it urgently needs addressing.

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:16

@Bringsexyback

But the OP is what to do about the future of care in the UK. Not what you will do when you need care.

So many people are suggesting assisted suicide as a solution and yet I am still unclear on how they think this will improve the social care sector.

Disfordragon · 14/03/2022 08:14

To the PP who mentioned assisted dying. We don’t need to go that far….we could just stop keeping people alive who are trying to die. This country has a huge issue with allowing people to die…..and I don’t mean 30 year olds with terminal cancer I mean over 80 year olds with dementia living in nursing homes with 24 hour care. How about we stop all their medications and, shock horror, don’t treat their urinary tract infection or chest infection (or give them Covid vaccinations)and allow them to die as opposed to treating it to keep them alive but in an ongoing negative trajectory in terms of quality of life until they get an infection that we can’t treat. 20 years in health care and I’ve had 4 families ask me to allow ‘nature to take its course’……the rest say ‘do everything’…..so the misery of living with dementia in a care home can continue for the patient, the relative, the carers and society at large.

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:12

@BellatrixOnABadDay

I think it is a generational thing, but not in the way you are suggesting.

Younger people see older people as different to them. They don't know that many and the ones they do come into contact with seem broadly the same. Being elderly seems a long way off and horrifying. It's easy to make pronouncements about how you will off yourself rather than become frail when it's some distant thing for the future.

I wonder how you would feel if you or one of your friends was struck with a stroke or injury that gave you the physical ailments of the elderly without the old age. Quite differently I would l. Indeed, as I said, I work in this sector and young people with those needs tend to demand good care (and rightfully so) rather than an overdose of morphine.

Alexandra2001 · 14/03/2022 08:07

[quote BettyBag]@Bringsexyback

How is it a solution?

Draw me a line from assisted suicide to better social care.[/quote]
a handful of the terminally ill killing themselves isn't going to make the slightest difference, Covid killed far far more and made no difference.

Perhaps better health prevention would help but thats a very long term thing.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 08:07

[quote BettyBag]@Bringsexyback

How is it a solution?

Draw me a line from assisted suicide to better social care.[/quote]
For me I’m not specifically looking at assisted suicide but I am going to weigh up very carefully what life prolonging treatment I accept. I think more people will do that too. I have life insurance that pays out until I’m 80 and I intend to win that bet.

Alexandra2001 · 14/03/2022 08:05

But we don't want to pay more to provide care that's the problem

Thats not true, its the Govt that wont pay them more... however, thats understandable, a substantial pay rise for Carers would put them above HCAs and very close to fully trained nurses with 3 years in Uni and a degree!

My DD did care work whilst at Uni, its highly skilled with a great deal of responsible, people are living in the community, who ought to be in a medical facility.
You need a car, extra insurance, no help with wear n tear, she got paid travel and mileage rate but even so, her agency was handing back council contracts.
The owner wrote to Johnson and Hancock (it was a brilliant letter) and received no reply.

But we are also an aging workforce, its not a problem that will go away and its causing the NHS huge issues as folk are not being discharged appropriately.

Polyanthus2 · 14/03/2022 08:04

Yes, but who is the 'assistant' to the suicide - the long lost son who will inherit the big house, your doctor, one sibling but which one???

Polyanthus2 · 14/03/2022 08:04

Yes, but who is the 'assistant' to the suicide - the long lost son who will inherit the big house, your doctor, one sibling but which one???

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:01

@Bringsexyback

How is it a solution?

Draw me a line from assisted suicide to better social care.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 07:54

@DockOTheBay

Also unpopular opinion but make assisted suicide legal and allow people to sign to say they want AS if they get to a certain stage of e.g. dementia
Literally that is the only answer to this in my opinion. I’ve already made that decision that the first sign of it I will be off
Calandor · 14/03/2022 07:52

We pay people more to do the job. If it paid better people would be willing

SpicePumpkin · 14/03/2022 07:51

Essentially the working conditions for carers is diabolical. I did full time home care work for years before I went back to uni. I was out from 6am to 11pm, so 15ish hours a day, 5/6 days a week but only being paid for 7 of those hours I was 'out'. I didn't get any time between calls to get from one village to the next in morning rush hour traffic and no support from management when that client complained every.single.time. I did a live in care package where I was supposed to get up at 3am to turn the gentleman. I was in the package for 24 hours a day 4, but you don't get paid for when you're sleeping or for getting up at 3am. So I was only paid for 8 hours a day, 4 days a week. I was there for 98 hours a week and came home with £256 a week, £800 a month for living and caring for someone 24 hours a day. Most carers don't get proper mileage paid, they don't get enough time between calls to get to the next one, they get harassed on days off to cover extra shifts, they get their rota changed at the very last minute. All these issues, and the list is endless, need addressing. I absolutely loved being a carer, I loved all my service users. I worked for a small local company, had regular families I went to help and it was at times the best job I've ever had. Care needs to be made into a real career though. It isn't just some crap job you can pick up if you have no skills, qualifications and don't know what to do. You need real passion for helping people. And the only way to find this is making it something to aspire to be, with excellent working conditions, qualifications and proper pay.

BellatrixOnABadDay · 14/03/2022 07:35

@BettyBag well hats off to you for working in that sector because it is a job I couldn't do, for many reasons. The time I have spent in care homes with my grandparents is in part what has informed my own opinion that I would much, much rather choose to end my life when I feel there is no quality left to it. And maybe it is a generational thing- I'm in my 30s and most of my friends feel the same. Although my parents feel the same too.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 14/03/2022 07:26

The biggest issue we are facing in my rural area is that there are far more elderly here than young people to look after them, highest number of elderly in Scotland believe. The young here leave for better opportunities unless they want to work in healthcare or agriculture there is nothing here for them

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 07:14

@bellatrixonabadday

As you pointed out many if not most people have witnessed this so it baffles me why you are telling me this as if it were new information that will chasten me.

The OP talks about poor care and a crumbling system and the answer is "kill the vulnerable". That's fucking vile. Along with my personal experience I have worked in this sector for years and the number of people expressing a wish to die rather than receive support is vanishingly small especially compared to the percentage of people offering this up as a solution in this thread.

My point about the misunderstanding of were the financial pressure is was to point out that even if we kill off the elderly it really wouldn't help that much and isnt the silver bullet people seem to think it is. Unless the suggestion of assisted suicide and refusal of medical care is intended for those younger people with life long disabilities.

gogohm · 14/03/2022 06:53

@MrsSkylerWhite

The problem is it is technically unskilled - ex mil is a carer, she's got no qualifications and her training consisted of shadowing another carer for the week plus some lifting training, she bragged how easy it was to get work. What carers need is the right personality and lots of common sense which can't be trained for

gogohm · 14/03/2022 06:49

It needs to be better paid and properly respected basically. Currently carers are treated like cheap nurses with none of the advantages, worse hours, lower pay, poor ongoing training, no perks/discounts, low pension etc by the employer and families often treat them poorly too

danni0509 · 14/03/2022 06:41

@JockTamsonsBairns

Make it a requirement of claiming unemployment benefits that if roles like care are available then then you can't claim dole? I often see care roles advertised with flexible hours etc, people shouldn't be paid not to work.

Jesus wept. Really? Is this really how little you think of the role I do?
In a typical morning, I start at 7, changing a stoma bag and a fistula bag for a disabled woman, before dispensing 17 tablets for her.
45 minutes later, I'm at a very elderly man with advanced dementia, helping him to shower and have breakfast, and possibly change soiled bedding.
45 minutes after that, I take a woman shopping - a 48 year old woman with acute depression due to losing her husband and three children in an accident eight years ago.
Two hours later, I arrive at my next client, a 64 year old woman with stage 4 cancer. I help to gently wash her in bed, rub cream into her acutely ulcerated skin, and help her into fresh nightclothes. We talk - a lot, about her fears for her disabled son, and what will happen to him in the next weeks/months when she dies.
Then I'm at a double up call with another carer, this time at a 96 year old woman who requires hoisting to a commode, personal care given, and hoisted safely back to bed. She then needs fed with a soft food diet and thickened drinks, before possibly requiring hoisted to the commode again.

I do this 5 days a week from 7am until 10pm. To be a carer requires compassion, integrity, and a massive amount of commitment. All this for minimum wage.
So please don't sit there behind your keyboard and insult us by suggesting that any Tom, Dick or Harry can be forced into doing it.
Is that the standard that people really want for the most vulnerable members of our society?

You don’t get paid anywhere near enough x
Polyanthus2 · 14/03/2022 06:37

Imv it's the oldies (include myself in this) who are desperate to hang on to their homes, to pass it on to their DCs. The dementia tax (thanks Corbyn) might have worked but T May lost a lot of seats over that and imv it was the oldies voting against it that caused that.
Likewise the deathtax in ? 2009.
How people can be so daft when they can see friends/ relatives etc moving into care homes for years of their lives at 1,000 a week.
So we end up with young people paying increased NI.
Another factor is keeping very poorly babies alive. I don't think all premature babies are kept alive in some countries. If they can't breath unaided they are allowed to pass away.
And you can't commit suicide once you have dementia, or I've never heard of it - you can't fly to Switzerland as you must have the faculty to demand that.

Going crazy 'protecting' our care home residents during Covid - forcing Care homes to keep residents shut up, wrapped in cotton wool because the inspectorate will lambast them/close them if anything happens eg resident falls out of bed.
Hence the miserable lives the residents live and I'm sure their condition detiorates due to acute boredom.
Other European countries seem to do better, perhaps they have more immigrant workers doing the work.

BellatrixOnABadDay · 14/03/2022 06:33

@BettyBag

There is a fundamental misunderstanding in this thread and indeed among most people of what adult social care spend their money on.

Is not the elderly. The majority of ASCs budget is spent on younger people with life long or acquired disabilities.

So yeah. All this talk of assisted suicide and ending life prolonging treatment to save money is fucking vile.

There may be a fundamental misunderstanding about the pressures on finances on this thread but on your point about the discussions on assisted dying being 'fucking vile':

Many of us if not the majority have witnessed parents/grandparents as they become frail and elderly require more and more care. It is absolutely horrific to see, when someone you love is in constant pain and has no quality of life left at all, no dignity, cannot get out of bed, no control over anything that happens to them. Out of my four grandparents, only one had what I would call a 'good death'. Never needed care, could still do everything for himself, was a bit frail and tired but doing ok. And then one morning had a massive stroke and was gone by late afternoon. My other GP's on the other hand have had long, drawn out, painful deaths where they have lost all quality of life long before they actually died. One is still alive but in a care home, in constant pain with no ability to do anything for himself. His mind is unaffected but physically he cannot move out of bed at all now. He has said many times himself he just wants to go. I've also seen the mental and physical toll that caring for him took on my parent, prior to him going into care.

He is in his 90s- a pp mentioned about improving the quality of life rather than talking about assisted dying, but how do you improve quality of life for people who have lived well past life expectancy and are basically then suffering the horrible consequences of all the medical interventions that have got them there? It's great if people can live very long lives in better health these days- but I don't know why it's 'fucking vile' to discuss AD only for those who would CHOOSE this- nobody thinks it should be forced upon anyone. I rather think it's an absolute disgrace that it doesn't exist for people who would choose it rather than suffer constant pain, indignity and misery. After seeing what happened to my grandparents its absolutely what I would choose for myself.

RBKB · 14/03/2022 06:31

@DockOTheBay your assisted suicide 'solution' is chilling. All types and ages of people suddenly develop care needs...if this happens to you tomorrow would you tidily end your life? You just might want to continue!!

My young adult daughter has eorked in care whilst at uni. It was exhausting and stressful (she loved her clients...it was the racing around with no travel time that did her in, also being given 30 mins to make lunch for elderly who would then have to rush through their meal before she had to insist it was time for their shower so she could dash off to the next call)

rwalker · 14/03/2022 05:57

@dipdye

Pay them more. Fairly simple.
But we don't want to pay more to provide care that's the problem