Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about future of care in the UK?

186 replies

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 12:24

I just wrote a v long post which I lost due to phone battery fading!

In a nutshell, what do we do when there are no longer any carers or anyone willing/able to care for our elderly and those in need of support?

I currently work for a care provider in a finance/admin role and it’s scary how: understaffed we and many other care providers in the area are; few people want to actually work in care and ;few younger people want to do it, and will only do so if threatened by sanctions etc.

In my company, most carers are aged between mid-40s and late 50s.

I previously worked in care on and off for much of my working life partly because (not going to lie) I couldn’t find anything else and was over or under qualified for other career paths. I know it’s crap in many ways: the pay, the hours and working conditions and the personal care is not for the squeamish (this was my issue!), but how do you get people to want to work in care?

Seriously, what do we do when the numbers fail to tally: many people in need, too few carers? Do people go off to hospitals long stay? But we also have a nursing recruitment crisis…

And before anyone suggests that I rejoin the carer ranks, as said I’ve done it before (for years), and it wasn’t for me. That’s kind of my point- no one really wants to do it!

OP posts:
BellatrixOnABadDay · 14/03/2022 09:18

@Maverickess we had those conversations about my gran when she was getting infections etc- so I can understand treating with antibiotics if the infection is just going to cause discomfort etc. it was things like cancer medication etc that was surprising. Although after the conversation, they did stop this.

FatherDickByrne · 14/03/2022 09:11

@DockOTheBay

Also unpopular opinion but make assisted suicide legal and allow people to sign to say they want AS if they get to a certain stage of e.g. dementia
You’re telling me! I find this repugnant. And I say that as a full-time carer for my 90yo old mother who has advanced dementia.
Gowithme · 14/03/2022 09:04

I 100% agree that assisted suicide should be available. How is it acceptable to have people woefully cared for by understaffed agencies or have carers who sometimes don't give a shit about them, they can be upset, terribly confused, angry, violent, have no recollection of any of their family and yet they are made to stay alive in this sort of hell - for what? Why don't people have a choice over how they die?

Maverickess · 14/03/2022 09:02

I agree with the PP about treating every single ailment and just prolonging the suffering. Until we questioned the ethics of it, HCPs were still giving my GM medication for cancer (not pain relief) after she suffered a horrific accident in her 90s which resulted in her being paralysed from the neck down and in a lot of pain- she died as a result of the accident 4 months later. It's the treat everything culture that I just do not understand.

I asked this once when being trained in end of life care by a specialist as it's something that I feel strongly about.
His answer was that it's not clear cut, when looking at something like a chest infection for example, the antibiotics can provide symptomatic relief to the person by removing the infection, same with a UTI, and there's no guarantee that the infection will kill them if they're not treated, especially in someone who is otherwise physically healthy, leaving someone with a painful and distressing set of symptoms that further reduce quality of life, without ending it quickly. Even good quality care without medical intervention can extend someone's life, being offered food and fluids regularly for example. The Liverpool pathway sought to address this, but from my understanding is now deemed unsuitable because people were further suffering towards death by being thirsty or hungry and those needs not being met.
There are massive safeguards around eol medication, so much so that I believe that it's swung too far towards letting people suffer so the administrator or prescriber doesn't get into trouble for giving medication that effectively ends their life peacefully. And I think the same applies to sedation medication in people who are distressed with something like dementia, it's become about the carers not wanting to deal with the behaviour (without enough resources to do so btw) rather than alleviating the symptoms of the illness.

darlingdodo · 14/03/2022 09:00

I've just applied for carer's allowance, £67 per week which will be split with my sibling and spent on petrol to drive to Dparent's, spend 4 days a week with them (sib does the other 3 days), do cooking, cleaning, shopping, some personal care including emptying commode, cleaning up after toilet accidents, all legal/banking/household management, dispensing 8 medications, looking after ulcerated legs etc etc etc.

We thought we'd be able to cope on DH's wage but with prices for everything skyrocketing, we can't. So I will need to get a job. So DParent will have to have carer's going in several times a day, or will have to go into care. At a much higher cost than my paltry £67 per week.

If we, as carer's for a family member, received say £200 per week, we could probably manage. But not on £67. Risible.

HowIsThisRight · 14/03/2022 08:54

I worked in a care home last year. Some people were paying over £1000 a week to be there. The building was run down. The place is subject to yearly inspections and has been for years because it scores so low every single year. There's rarely hot water. The food is shit. Damaged things like doors or light fittings aren't repaired. (At all, nevermind in a timely manner) There weren't enough basic items for each client, from essential washbasins to suitable drinking cups that they can lift by themselves. The equipment is still not regularly inspected yet the law says any worker using an out of date inspected hoist, or a sling with an unreadable label is in danger of a £5000 fine and up to 2 years imprisonment if anything goes wrong. We still had to use them.
There were (and I believe still are) often just two workers for a dozen clients and most require two people to move, clean and dress them.
Carers go to work knowing full well that they'll be doing a 12 and a half hour shift with not a single break for a measly tenner an hour, AND payroll won't pay them for break times totalling over an hour which they don't even get.
Between your 12+ hour shifts of slogging your guts out and breaking your back trying to lift a whole person by yourself because there's no one to help you, you're expected to do untold amounts of unpaid training. You've to pay for memberships and accreditations of certain organisations too. In house training for new staff consists of following other inadequately trained people around and picking up what they do each day because management won't pay you to have real training days. You're just expected to work and follow rules you don't know about from day one. Management are under pressure to comply with Care standards so will berate staff each shift for not doing the work needed despite the fact that there's no way in hell the poor staff can get it done by themselves in the time they have. The clients suffer. The carers suffer. The owners drive the latest Teslas.

No wonder they can't get staff in the care business.

Winter2020 · 14/03/2022 08:54

It's interesting that when there is a shortage of lorry drivers there are 5k "golden hellos" and rising wages, and when there are a shortage of carers ideas are "force someone to do it or lose benefits".

I can't help but think the female work force has a lot to do with poor conditions - why no fixed shifts that allow people to manage their own family life and caring responsibilities, why no fixed days in a 24/7 industry - supermarkets can do it why not care? Why no company cars or at least pool cars for jobs that are on the road/fuel cards?

What people don't seem to realise is for privatised providers massive staff shortages probably suit the owners and shareholders very well. It provides a justification for short, rushed visits when people are paying for more and they are supposed to just be grateful they get any visit at all. Less staff training costs as less staff. If staff on a zero hour, or 9 hour or 20 hour contract are off sick they are paid based on their contract not the 60 hours they actually work saving money (if they het any sick pay over statutory of course). Also holiday pay. Despite the law saying holiday pay or amount of holiday should include regular overtime I haven't known this to happen so holiday entitlement based on 20 hours when you work 60 resulting in staff that can't afford to take a weeks holiday due to the pay drop. They take holiday for one shift and work other one so no week off.

A care home running a shift 2 staff down is saving the wages of those 2 staff. If that's the case on every shift that is a lot of money saved = profit.

There are many solutions to encouraging people into care but the very basics start with decent contracts for a regular working pattern so that people can be a carer and also have a home life and get the sick/holiday pay that they are entitled to.

Onionpatch · 14/03/2022 08:51

Whilst i see that assisted suicide is something i would want when my quality of life had reduced to a certain point, there would presumably be a number of years before that point where, with good quality care, I would still enjoy life. Therefore assisted suicide isnt much of a solution.

I think improved pay and conditions are the obvious answer, alongside proper career pathways backed with training. I also think 'status/respect'. People dont view it as having value because you dont need lenghty academic qualifications so are suggesting things like anyone who cant get a job, all school leavers etc.

douper · 14/03/2022 08:39

75% is the proportion spent on long term support

yes that what I read.

www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/key-facts-figures-adult-social-care

My mistake to include children.

douper · 14/03/2022 08:37

@BettyBag your link doesn't mention children?

BellatrixOnABadDay · 14/03/2022 08:37

@HoldingTheDoor you articulated in much better than me, agree 100%.

HoldingTheDoor · 14/03/2022 08:35

I've worked with a lot of elderly people and personally cared for two elderly relatives. It's familiarity with what many suffer, particularly those with dementia, that makes me pretty certain that I'd rather not have any lifesaving/life-prolonging measures in place if I had a very poor quality of life.

What my Grandmother suffered with dementia was 100x worse than death. It was barbaric. Thankfully a fall meant that she developed pneumonia after breaking her death and died very peacefully, just when we were at the stage of having to look at nursing homes because her dementia was rapidly advancing.

I have another relative who is currently in a care home with dementia and though the staff are great with her, she has very little quality of life and is nothing like her former self. She's constantly distressed and agitated. The sooner she dies, the kinder it'll be for her.

I've watched quite a few former clients(I haven't worked in care for years) begging and some literally screaming to die. No, they don't all feel that way but a significant number with dementia or severe health issues do. I had another who was so distressed, scared and confused that she seemed to regard everything we did to her(basic care) and to be honest, it felt like we were torturing her, especially when giving her medication prescribed that'd prolong her life.

It isn't just an age thing either. There are conditions that I'd find utterly intolerable now in my 30s let alone in my 80s. Of course what's intolerable for one person may be tolerable for another so you can't have blanket policies but I do think that we need to consider that prolonging the lives of people with dementia with antibiotics and heart medication may be causing more suffering than good.

BellatrixOnABadDay · 14/03/2022 08:35

*My response was to your suggestion that support for assisted saying is a generational thing. I was just pointing out that the reason for this isn't as simple as young people having different ideals but rather this being an issue that only affects young people hypothetically.
*
Fair enough, I get that, but depending on what younger people have witnessed, they may well have drawn the same conclusions as me. Seeing what happened to my grandmothers and what is currently happening to my GF is horrific. My mum and uncle both say that with my other GF, they were so relieved he didn't survive when he had his stroke- he would have been left with no quality of life and would have absolutely hated it. He already struggled a bit mentally with aches and pains, not being able to do everything he did when younger. Far kinder he went. I think it's sadly very unusual for the elderly to have quick, kind deaths the way he did and it has been awful witnessing what has happened to my other three grandparents.

I agree with the PP about treating every single ailment and just prolonging the suffering. Until we questioned the ethics of it, HCPs were still giving my GM medication for cancer (not pain relief) after she suffered a horrific accident in her 90s which resulted in her being paralysed from the neck down and in a lot of pain- she died as a result of the accident 4 months later. It's the treat everything culture that I just do not understand.

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:35

@douper

About 50% is spent on children, young people and adults with complex health needs.

yes that was my understanding, not 75%

Your understanding is wrong. 0% of Adult Social Care funding is spent on children, the clues in the name.
mudgetastic · 14/03/2022 08:34

The link below implies that over. Half if spent on the 18 to 64 and the rest on the older
75% is the proportion spent on long term support
Children are not mentioned

douper · 14/03/2022 08:29

About 50% is spent on children, young people and adults with complex health needs.

yes that was my understanding, not 75%

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:29

@hugr

No, none of Adult Social Cares budget is spent of children.

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:28

[quote BellatrixOnABadDay]@BettyBag don't presume to know that I would want treatment if I had a stroke tomorrow. I have my own thoughts and feelings on the quality of life I would want at any age, young or old. Of course not everyone feels like this but I feel how I feel for numerous reasons; possibly as a result of witnessing 'life' for my grandparents and also knowing what my own mental health could possibly tolerate.

If I'm lucky enough to be elderly, I know I'd rather die quickly rather than live with no quality of life. I've seen too many young people in my family die- all of these things probably contribute to my feelings on this. I'm not articulating it well but I know what I mean anyway. [/quote]
My response was to your suggestion that support for assisted saying is a generational thing. I was just pointing out that the reason for this isn't as simple as young people having different ideals but rather this being an issue that only affects young people hypothetically.

hugr · 14/03/2022 08:28

@douper

75% of adult social care funding is spent on people under the age of 64.

Is it?

I know working age have more spent on them but there are more older people so as a whole just under half of the costs are spent on working age.

About 50% is spent on children, young people and adults with complex health needs.
douper · 14/03/2022 08:26

75% of adult social care funding is spent on people under the age of 64.

Is it?

I know working age have more spent on them but there are more older people so as a whole just under half of the costs are spent on working age.

BettyBag · 14/03/2022 08:26

[quote Bringsexyback]@BettyBag if your numbers are correct then it’s going to make a 25% difference in fact, which could potentially be an enormous number - I don’t know.[/quote]
My numbers are correct and publicly available.

Your numbers are wrong.

I thought you were suggesting stopping life prolonging treatment for 80+ I a care home with dementia. Not killing all over 64 year old who have social care support, because that's what you would need to do to hit that 25%.

Your original suggestion would be a fraction of 25%.

alexdgr8 · 14/03/2022 08:25

@OneTC

I don't think the business model (charge loads and pay peanuts) is sustainable or ethical.

If pay was realistic then people would do it gladly I think

yes. wave my magic wand: there is a national care service, well organised, with recognised qualification and career progression, and suitable pay. free at the point of need. financed by levy on higher rate tax payers. this would encompass both residential care and domiciliary.
BellatrixOnABadDay · 14/03/2022 08:22

@BettyBag don't presume to know that I would want treatment if I had a stroke tomorrow. I have my own thoughts and feelings on the quality of life I would want at any age, young or old. Of course not everyone feels like this but I feel how I feel for numerous reasons; possibly as a result of witnessing 'life' for my grandparents and also knowing what my own mental health could possibly tolerate.

If I'm lucky enough to be elderly, I know I'd rather die quickly rather than live with no quality of life. I've seen too many young people in my family die- all of these things probably contribute to my feelings on this. I'm not articulating it well but I know what I mean anyway.

Bringsexyback · 14/03/2022 08:20

@BettyBag if your numbers are correct then it’s going to make a 25% difference in fact, which could potentially be an enormous number - I don’t know.