Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about future of care in the UK?

186 replies

Flawedperfection · 13/03/2022 12:24

I just wrote a v long post which I lost due to phone battery fading!

In a nutshell, what do we do when there are no longer any carers or anyone willing/able to care for our elderly and those in need of support?

I currently work for a care provider in a finance/admin role and it’s scary how: understaffed we and many other care providers in the area are; few people want to actually work in care and ;few younger people want to do it, and will only do so if threatened by sanctions etc.

In my company, most carers are aged between mid-40s and late 50s.

I previously worked in care on and off for much of my working life partly because (not going to lie) I couldn’t find anything else and was over or under qualified for other career paths. I know it’s crap in many ways: the pay, the hours and working conditions and the personal care is not for the squeamish (this was my issue!), but how do you get people to want to work in care?

Seriously, what do we do when the numbers fail to tally: many people in need, too few carers? Do people go off to hospitals long stay? But we also have a nursing recruitment crisis…

And before anyone suggests that I rejoin the carer ranks, as said I’ve done it before (for years), and it wasn’t for me. That’s kind of my point- no one really wants to do it!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maverickess · 16/03/2022 09:02

[quote AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii]@Maverickess I completely agree and so AI won’t replace those sectors but it could be the answer to helping those who need help with ADLs, this may then free up some people who could then visit so give human contact instead of being held back by the time constraints of timed client visits[/quote]
Yes, there's a positive application there, extending what is already on offer in the way of technology to provide practical support to someone with needs that can be met adequately with machines and robots.
Unfortunately though, as I've said on similar threads about AI and it's application to caring for people, I think the cost of setting it up and maintenance would be a barrier - especially if you can't afford it yourself, and I could forsee (if attitudes and systems stay the same as they are wrt funding, provision etc) some becoming more isolated as they rely on technology for day to day living tasks, and as those tasks are met, the social side of it is forgotten, the people freed up by not having timed visits etc will not be deployed for human contact, they'll be deployed where AI can't fill in.
I could forsee someone being given a robot and a number to call if something goes wrong and that's it.

Of course the idea that we could free up people to provide the more human needs is a lovely one, but,
the government, society and individuals already don't want to pay for the inadequate care system we do have, it's part of the reason it's inadequate, the pay and conditions for the people delivering the care aren't attractive enough and in all honesty, off putting to many, and that's why there's a shortage. I honestly can't see care providers or local government spending on both AI and human contact, to improve the standard of care. They have a fairly simple answer to that already - improve pay, training and conditions, there's no will to though unfortunately.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/03/2022 07:42

@Maverickess I completely agree and so AI won’t replace those sectors but it could be the answer to helping those who need help with ADLs, this may then free up some people who could then visit so give human contact instead of being held back by the time constraints of timed client visits

Supersimkin2 · 15/03/2022 22:25

AI would be great. But whether the robot and the demented could get on is another question.

Maverickess · 15/03/2022 21:04

@AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii

Why do you think that if robots can't show empathy and compassion or negotiate the way humans can, that they'd be a solution to social care issues?
I spend a lot of my time at work negotiating with people to take medication, get washed, get dressed (appropriately or at all) or to eat/drink. I agree that robots would lack certain characteristics that are needed when dealing with people, but disagree that these characteristics are not needed in social care - they are the very heart of it.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 15/03/2022 17:13

@Nicholethejewellery robots will never replace nurses or doctors, they will never be able to negotiate the way humans do not when they are programmed to work and behave in a particular way. Robots will never have empathy or show compassion, I agree they could be a possible answer to social care problems, they could help with washing and dressing, medication and meals and could all be controlled by a central office with helplines.

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2022 13:34

I hope I’m long dead before that happens @Nicholethejewellery.

Nicholethejewellery · 15/03/2022 12:01

Hopefully artificial intelligence and robots will be able to solve the care problem. Once we get to the point where AI is able to learn and perform practical care skills better than humans we will see the landscape change very quickly. Obviously previously manual work is already being automated, the process has been ongoing for a thousand years or more, but the rate of change is getting ever faster.

We'd probably need to have realistic-looking robots in the care sector for people to feel comfortable. There will come a time when robots can be created to look and feel and behave exactly like a real person. Once this happens, combined with advanced AI, most human jobs will be able to be done better by robots than by humans - we're effectively making ourselves obsolete.

Maverickess · 15/03/2022 11:53

I could really see that if/when AS happens, people like me will be just as poorly trained, paid, treated and respected to carry it out, with no support for the workforce doing it and seen as a job that only someone who can't do any better does - it'll just be trading roles really.

I really do believe in AS and advance directives being the right thing to introduce, I have seen and been a part of (because of my job) keeping people alive with very little quality of life, to the point where I've felt relief when someone dies because it's a release for them, as have their families. It's horrible watching another human (well, several humans) 'live' like that. You either crack or become desensitised, because there is no support, we're just a resented, essential part of it all.

But as a pp articulated, suggesting it's the answer to the problems we're seeing now, when it's not even possible option right now, isn't addressing the actual problems, that people are suffering now with a lack of availability of good care that values all people, because ultimately most at least subconsciously believe that not all people are worth valuing.

ralanne · 15/03/2022 11:10

@Blossomtoes

If you want to end your life, that is your decision. I wouldn't want you to suffer. Equally, I wouldn't want anyone else to be compelled to assist with taking a human life.

You're right, I shouldn't presume what you want, but personally I wouldn't want anyone to feel they had to end their life because of staff shortages or because they were a burden.

I wouldn't want anyone to be killed because they there was no one to look after them or because someone else had decided that their life was not worth living. We are talking about young learning disabled people here as well as older people, who have many years left, and the terminally ill.

In cases where someone has stated an advance intention, I think it's very difficult to get informed consent. At the point at which someone has lost the capacity to articulate their wishes, they may have changed their mind. This is not just a theoretical position. I have been at the bedside and witnessed this play out.

For these reasons, I am against assisted suicide, I make no apology for that, and I will continue to speak against it, and I hope it will never become law.

HardyBuckette · 15/03/2022 10:53

@ralanne

There's a difference between refusing interventions and allowing nature to take its course, which is possible just now, and assisted suicide, which was being presented as an answer to the staff shortages in elderly care.
The problem is that wishes to refuse interventions and allow nature to take its course aren't always honoured now even when they've been explicitly spelled out. There's also often an assumption that this is the right thing to do even when the patient hasn't given an indication of their wishes. That's not a good thing. We need to talk about consent.
Blossomtoes · 15/03/2022 10:51

Who decides what constitutes an acceptable "quality of life"?

The owner of that life. Nobody else gets a say.

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2022 10:49

@ralanne

Nonetheless, I'm sure you wouldn't want this to be carried out because of staff shortages. There are other solutions.
The end result would be the same regardless of the reason. Please don’t presume to “be sure” of what I want. People like you are the reason we still don’t have legal assisted suicide.
ralanne · 15/03/2022 10:39

Exactly. Let us do what we can to improve quality of life for all our vulnerable members of society. Who decides what constitutes an acceptable "quality of life"? If a person is cared for with love, as far as possible given opportunities for stimulation, kept physically comfortable, well fed, and free from distress, then why would we think that such a life is not worth living? Our lives and abilities are different, but we all have a right to life, which should be respected.

LethargeMarg · 15/03/2022 10:29

@ralanne

There's a difference between refusing interventions and allowing nature to take its course, which is possible just now, and assisted suicide, which was being presented as an answer to the staff shortages in elderly care.
Yes and doesn't solve the issues of staff shortages in LD care. Plus you could argue quality of life for some LD children and adults isn't fantastic but you wouldn't suggest solving this with assisted suicide.
ralanne · 15/03/2022 10:24

Nonetheless, I'm sure you wouldn't want this to be carried out because of staff shortages. There are other solutions.

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2022 10:16

@ralanne

Because you fear that you will not be cared for kindly? Because of fear of pain?
No. Because I don’t want a life with no quality. Life’s more than just having a heartbeat.
ralanne · 15/03/2022 10:15

Because you fear that you will not be cared for kindly? Because of fear of pain?

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2022 10:12

@ralanne

There's a difference between refusing interventions and allowing nature to take its course, which is possible just now, and assisted suicide, which was being presented as an answer to the staff shortages in elderly care.
I know. That’s why I want assisted suicide made legal.
ralanne · 15/03/2022 10:08

There's a difference between refusing interventions and allowing nature to take its course, which is possible just now, and assisted suicide, which was being presented as an answer to the staff shortages in elderly care.

Blossomtoes · 15/03/2022 09:53

@ralanne

And I don't agree with slaughtering people because they require help. We should be able to care for people, keep them comfortable, preserve their dignity in the last days of their lives, and not hurry them up because it's inconvenience for us.
A huge number of us would choose to be “hurried up” and are taking steps to try and set it up. Not for anyone’s convenience but because we value quality of life over quantity. I don’t want to be kept alive just because it’s possible.
ralanne · 15/03/2022 09:36

And I don't agree with slaughtering people because they require help. We should be able to care for people, keep them comfortable, preserve their dignity in the last days of their lives, and not hurry them up because it's inconvenience for us.

ralanne · 15/03/2022 09:32

I wouldn't want anyone doing personal care for me under duress. They have to want to be there. But there are so many barriers for people that are willing and able to do this amazing, beautiful work. You only get paid for the hours you are at a house, not paid for travel in between etc etc. if it was well-remunerated and respected then people would do it.

ralanne · 15/03/2022 09:29

Improve pay and conditions. We're going to have to.

LethargeMarg · 14/03/2022 22:05

@Flawedperfection

Hi *@LethargeMarg*, LDs is the main area I worked in when I worked delivering care. It was so rewarding at times, but got really fed up of being hit, spat at, kicked, head butted and scratched.

The funding can be hit and miss- it was pretty good where I worked (for a charity), but is indeed awful in some places. And they find it hard to retain staff, possibly more so than in elderly care.

Yes it's quite relentless at times and also where I work. I think definitely more challenging than elderly care in terms of needing to cope with aggression and injury.
Papertyger · 14/03/2022 21:59

I've worked in this area I've never met anyone who thinks keeping an elderly vulnerable person alive in those states is kind.

It's barbarism.

They are so vulnerable!

Swipe left for the next trending thread