Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do you know any young Christians

260 replies

zope · 13/03/2022 11:13

MIL (in her 60s and religious) recently came to stay with us and I accompanied her to church when we got there i was really shocked by how few people under the age of 60 there seemed to be to the point where I (now in my mid 40s) felt young again. There were a number of small children with grandparents but virtually no one age 10-60. I haven’t been to church since I was a child myself so I was quite taken aback, is this what most churches are like nowadays or was this a one off. Do you personally know any young as in teenagers or in their 20s/30s Christians and do they have many friends who are also Christian? I would honestly be interested?

OP posts:
shrunkenhead · 14/03/2022 11:01

I just don't think it appeals to a younger demographic, unless you were raised/brainwashed into it, in which case you might crack on with it or rebel totally.
It's not seen as particularly cool with friends I know. Some try hard to integrate and make an effort but I think the overriding consensus is a grown adult believing in god is akin to believing in Father Xmas past the age of 8.
I like a good sing song but some churches are a bit intense for me.

SartresSoul · 14/03/2022 10:06

Depends on the church. I once accompanied my Christian friend to a life church and it was fucking awful. They pounced on me and tried to coerce me into joining as soon as they saw me. It was a happy clappy church with Christian rock bands playing to try make it appeal to teens which it did, my Christian friend was definitely not alone. This was about 15 years ago but I imagine somewhere like that is still going strong.

MasterBeth · 14/03/2022 10:04

Who are you? What pre-conceived notions do you have? Have you got any advantage in protecting a particular view? Why does not being a Christian make you an impartial observer?

OMG12 · 14/03/2022 10:00

@MasterBeth

What I think, *@OMG12*, is that it's disingenuous to try and pick apart the basis of an academic study you haven't read by responding to a line or two in the online abstract that you think might serve your argument.
Well I obviously haven’t had time to read it, but I don’t think there’s anything disingenuous about identifying questions that I would seek to answer upon further study of the work ( which I might well do if I have time). Who are these people, what pre conceived notions do they have, have they got any advantage in protecting a particular view (most published academics do) etc. standard questions one should always ask of sources.

Maybe you could assist by answering some of these and the other queries I have raised.

By the way, I’m not a Christian (or any other religion£ so have no “skin in the game” I am just genuinely curious about this.

MasterBeth · 14/03/2022 09:44

@booksandbuns

Yes, I am one. I'm 23 and a Christian. And I go to church every Sunday (unless I'm sick or on holiday), not out of tradition or obligation, but because I love to go there to meet with God, so I make going a priority. I wouldn't describe myself as religious. My church is in a small town and is a non-denominational/charismatic church with people from all ages and backgrounds. A large percentage are families with parents in their 30s/40s and their kids, both younger and teenagers, but there are also some older people and a good number of adults in their 20s.

Quite a few of my friends (who I met at uni) are Christians too; some go to Anglican churches, some to other Protestant denominations and my best friend goes to a Catholic church. Another good proportion of my friends, who I also met at uni, do not have a faith and I'm glad I have that mix.

You are a Christian, a regular church goer, love to meet with God, but are not religious.

What do you mean by religious?

MasterBeth · 14/03/2022 09:21

What I think, @OMG12, is that it's disingenuous to try and pick apart the basis of an academic study you haven't read by responding to a line or two in the online abstract that you think might serve your argument.

Hairbrush123 · 14/03/2022 09:20

@Elsiebear90

I think it’s more common to find young Christians these days who are not white and British, the majority of the practising Christians I know are black or Eastern European. I did know one white British woman who went to church, but she would complain that her church is full of old people. She tried somewhere more popular with black worshipers as they tend to have a younger congregation, but she couldn’t get used to their style of worship.
Can you not be black and British?
Hairbrush123 · 14/03/2022 09:07

I’m 24 and I am Protestant. I wouldn’t say I’m super religious but I do believe in God. My husband does too.

THisbackwithavengeance · 14/03/2022 07:33

@Yerroblemom1923

No. Here it's all over 60s, and parents with primary-aged kids hoping to get them into a "church" secondary school that attend. Needless to say once kids are in the "right" school they don't bother anymore. I know a few under 50s Christians but it's not really deemed cool.
Indeed. My town is dominated by 2 "outstanding" faith secondary schools where you have to attend church and generally be a pillar of the community to have a chance of attendance.

I'm not religious but my DH and some of our friends are so I attend church once a month or so. Lots of young families but no secondary school aged kids at all. Funny that. But then I'm a cynical and uncharitable so-and-so hence the lack of faith.

jimpamdwight · 14/03/2022 07:28

In fact there are 2 parents that are vicars/pastors alone in 1 of my dc's classes at school!

jimpamdwight · 14/03/2022 07:27

I'm a Christian as is my partner. He is very involved in his church and it's a very young demographic, but we do live in a student city. At the dc's school is a c of e primary and there is a huge number of Christian church going families.

I didn't grow up in this city and it's definitely not what I witnessed growing up where I knew no one that went to church!

DockOTheBay · 14/03/2022 07:23

It seems like a lovely community and I would love to be part of it, but I just don't believe and never will.

DockOTheBay · 14/03/2022 07:22

Depends on the church I think. I go to the toddler group at the local baptist church, and they seem to have quite a lot of younger members (in their 30s, and their children). They have a creche at Sunday service, have the toddler group, run events on weekends for the kids and the services are all family friendly.

I imagine its different at a stuffy church where everyone is expected to sit in silence through the service and kids aren't explicitly invited.

SundayTeatime · 14/03/2022 07:19

Meant to add, I live in an area with a lot of people from African or Caribbean backgrounds, and lots will go to church if they’re of a Christian faith. It’s very common and typical.

OMG12 · 14/03/2022 07:19

[quote Thebestwaytoscareatory]@MasterBeth

It's pointless trying to argue with a religious person on subjects like that.

To be religious requires faith. Faith that there is something more than just this life.
Faith that there is a God who has an interest in how you live your life. Faith that the religion and god you just so happen to follow is the right one (out of how many hundreds??). Faith that the hundreds of year old stories you base your life on have been interpretated correctly and continue to be relevant.

Those acts of faith mean that the religious are happy to suspend the need for proof or reason and are prepared to accept an enormous amount on no evidence whatsoever. When you're dealing with someone who is willing to make monumental life choices based on nothing you're not going to change their minds...ever.[/quote]
It’s an interesting post. What’s your view on a “perennial philosophy” certain religions and Gods are manifestations of this based on cultures separated by time and space? Therefore one Source?

Many don’t believe in a personal God as you describe. Many do believe in this as being Nothing or No-thing.

Most who do shape their lives around religion would most likely say they are not basing their lives on “nothing” you are confusing quantifiable data with existence.

Maybe there is a symbiotic relationship between the divine and mankind? “God is dead [because] we have killed Him” maybe the human race is also on course for distinction. Or more likely we will create another God/gods to fulfil a basic human need that has existed throughout history. What makes us so special that out of nearly all of human existence we suddenly see the right way to view the world? Surely this is no better argument than the old one about which god?

But ultimately why would anyone want to change some one else’s mind? How about simple acceptance of different perspectives-evangelical thought processes exist outside of religion.

InMySpareTime · 14/03/2022 07:16

A lot of younger people are accessing church services online since many churches started broadcasting over Lockdowns.
Then they develop their faith in Home Groups or Study Groups. Sunday morning church attendance isn't the whole story for the younger generation, and the church is reaching people where they are (on their phones).

Yerroblemom1923 · 14/03/2022 07:09

No. Here it's all over 60s, and parents with primary-aged kids hoping to get them into a "church" secondary school that attend. Needless to say once kids are in the "right" school they don't bother anymore.
I know a few under 50s Christians but it's not really deemed cool.

SundayTeatime · 14/03/2022 07:03

@garlictwist

I have never met a single person who goes to church, even in my childhood (and I am 38). In fact, I often wonder if anyone goes when I see a church and quite a few near me are closed (one is now a nightclub!).

It's quite surprising to see how many people on this thread go to church. I just assumed it had sort of died out.

A lot of churches don’t look like churches, though. Some churches are very modern buildings. There’s a big Baptist one on my high street and some people don’t realise it’s a church, even though they might walk past it several times a day. Some churches don’t have their own space and rent space in schools or community buildings. Some churches rent theatres or auditoriums.
Ghostmooncup · 14/03/2022 06:58

I know loads. I'm atheist myself but there seems a big network of young Christians around where I live. The church's are not like traditional ones, vibrant and full of young hipster looking types and lots of families. I've only realised through Facebook the links ( who knows who).

It would have been useful being new into an area with a young family to have that ready made community.

Confrontayshunme · 14/03/2022 06:47

Our church is vaguely charismatic evangelical Anglican as well if that helps.

Confrontayshunme · 14/03/2022 06:46

In our church, a service with a very old person might not even be the service young families attend. Every church in our area has at least a handful of young families, but our church has the largest group of 11-18 year olds because parents actively want to send them to a place with more teens. We don't have many 18-28 year olds though because there is no uni in our town.

garlictwist · 14/03/2022 06:41

I have never met a single person who goes to church, even in my childhood (and I am 38). In fact, I often wonder if anyone goes when I see a church and quite a few near me are closed (one is now a nightclub!).

It's quite surprising to see how many people on this thread go to church. I just assumed it had sort of died out.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 14/03/2022 06:35

I'm 30 and I don't know anyone who goes to church. The only religious people I know are Muslim and even they aren't particularly strict.

hedgehog17363 · 14/03/2022 06:31

I'm a 29 year old Christian, as is my DH (31). Half our church is 18-40 year olds I would say. It's non denomination. Outside church I haven't met many Christians my age.

OMG12 · 14/03/2022 06:27

[quote MasterBeth]@OMG12 But as you brought it up… Zuckerman, Miron; Li, Chen; Lin, Shengxin; Hall, Judith A. (15 October 2019). "The Negative Intelligence–Religiosity Relation: New and Confirming Evidence". Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 46 (6): 856–868.[/quote]
Is that the study that states “ There was no support for mediation of the IRR by education” and “ Additional empirical and theoretical work is needed to resolve this issue.”

From the bit I’ve seen it seems to hinge on analytical style rather than intelligence per se. Or at least the authors find this hypothesis “more interesting” which raises the possibility of confirmation bias in my mind.

However, I’ve not read the entire book, assuming you have, what’s your take?

I’d be interested to know how the studies you mentioned previously addressed the points on sample I raised too. You raise a valid point though about intellect and education (assuming that is your position as you said you didn’t raise the point about intellect only education) and if as you suggest the two are separate matters what are your thoughts on why education relates to a reduced occurrence of religious belief? Could this actually be a reflection of the thought processes currently favoured by the educational system of quantifiability and falsifiable hypothesis?