Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think I can make big changes all at once?

35 replies

MsFrog · 13/03/2022 09:10

I am sick of myself and the way I've become. I don't exercise and my diet is starting to get really bad. I'm so tired of feeling sore and stiff and having heartburn and feeling tired. I'm only mid-30s but physically I feel so much older.

I'm so fed up, I'm feeling motivated to change things. But the problem is, I've felt this way on and off for years, and I never stick at things. I start eating a bit better, then stop. I start yoga, then stop. In the past, it hasn't felt that important, but now I'm getting older I'm really feeling the affects of my lifestyle and I'm so irritated by myself for not doing the things I know I should.

AIBU to think I should just go for broke and say to myself I'm going to make big changes all at once? Is that setting myself up for a fall? DH things so, he thinks slow and steady is better, but that's just not worked for me in the past. Has anyone ever made loads of big changes all at once. Tips for motivation and longevity gratefully received!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MsFrog · 19/03/2022 15:31

It's good advice, @GreenOwl, but I've tried it and failed loads of times. I'd make a change, add another, fall off a bit with one of them, abandon the whole thing.

I think small and steady is the way to do it for me, though, now that I've realised it's ok to slip or fail or make a positive change without being carb-free or at the gym 5 nights a week. I'm at the point where I've got to change my mindset to genuinely wanting to be healthier, and hopefully sustainable change will come, with some effort!

OP posts:
GreenOwl · 19/03/2022 15:08

I think it can be too overwhelming to do everything at once. I think you should start one thing at a time, do it for at least a week and then introduce something new. I think it's more sustainable to do lots of little changes rather than one big one.

MsFrog · 19/03/2022 14:06

@jb7445 that's brilliant to hear, well done to you for making those changes! That's exactly what I want - to eat well and live well for it's own sake, for the benefits it brings to my health and not because I'm "supposed" to

OP posts:
jb7445 · 19/03/2022 13:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MsFrog · 19/03/2022 13:25

Thank you @Relentlessrose, I hope this has been my moment of clarity! I really hope to be happier and healthier, and set a good example for my children on how to value yourself

OP posts:
Relentlessrose · 19/03/2022 13:11

Perfectionism is the enemy of progress
Because while you're aiming for perfection you will keep failing. I'm sure if you want this enough then you can get it so long as you are aware of your road blocks which could get in the way, such as perfectionism and fear of failure.

It is possible to have a dramatic change of mind, to have a 'eureka' moment a moment of clarity that changes everything. I wish you well on your weight loss and life transformation journey

MsFrog · 19/03/2022 13:01

I just wanted to come back on this thread to say thanks for all the comments. I've been ill with Covid so didn't end up coming back to it, but everyone's comments really made me think about myself and my motivations, particularly what @FusionChefGeoff said about knowing who you are and what @AuntFlorence said about how a lapse doesn't have to be a relapse.

I've realised that I am very easily put off by "failure" and I need to lose my "all or nothing" mindset. Doing a skincare regime 3x a week is better than never doing one, drinking some water is better than no water, 2 yoga sessions a week is better than nothing, only eating 2 biscuits a day is better than eating 4, etc. I've already been eating better and doing a few extra self-care things here and there.

It doesn't make me feel wonderful to know that I set out expecting failure, and that I'm also a terrible procrastinator, but it's actually been a good thing to learn about myself. Another PP said something about how it's important the way you view yourself, and I'm going to try to take that on board.

Hope the other people who commented find the best ways to move forward with their own goals!

OP posts:
FollowtheLizards · 13/03/2022 11:46

If you decide to go all in, I would get a health check at the doctors first. Also try to work on your mindset at the same time. It can be easy to dwell on not seeing your weight go down on the scales one week, but if your clothes are fitting a bit better, or you've managed to mostly stick to your healthy eating plan, then that's still a big achievement.

Kirstos1 · 13/03/2022 11:38

On the back of this thread i have written a meal plan for next week. I always have the best intentions on a Sunday! I think I will eat well and then the stress of the working week starts and I have inhaled a family size chocolate bar and not noticed. Hopefully commit ting it to paper will help!

hauntedvagina · 13/03/2022 11:20

I find a go big approach is the best one, as you'll see results fast, and this will motivate you. Then slowly over time you can introduce treats here and there and the points when your weight loss would begin to slow.

For a number of reasons my weight spiralled last year. Once Christmas was out of the way, I dieted and exercised hard. This month I've started introducing the odd treat on the weekend here and there. I'm still losing weight but at a slower rate than when I started.

Obviously everyone's journeys are different and this might not work for everyone but personally I needed to see that big initial impact to motivate me. I don't stick to diet plan and I don't count calories. I just reduce my carb and sugar intake.

EIisheva · 13/03/2022 10:22

Op I am in the same position and absolutely loved your opening post because I can completely identify.

15stone
47
fat fat fat fat fat

I think I also need to go for broke

Notallcatsarenicecats · 13/03/2022 10:19

Some people are all or nothing types. Including me. You can do it. Smile

BestInterests · 13/03/2022 10:17

Have a look at the saxenda thread - is working for me. I'm in a similar situation and going for broke

Fatandnearly50 · 13/03/2022 10:15

Interesting thread. I’m in the same boat but older and fatter OP. Desperately need to do something but can’t quite get started.

Will read this thread again in more detail, bits of it are inspiring.

Thatswhyimacat · 13/03/2022 10:14

If you've previously not succeeded the slow and steady way, I don't see any harm in trying the dramatic route. Worst case scenario is it doesn't work for you, but you might find aspects of it stick.

MsFrog · 13/03/2022 10:13

Thanks for all, these so much ringing true, especially the PP who said I sound like I'm already making excuses - that really resonated, it's so true. I feel like I'm fundamentally lazy and I don't actually want to make these changes on a superficial level, because it's such a lot of hard work and I'm shattered all the time from having two young kids and a busy, emotionally demanding (albeit only 3 days a week) job. But that's all just excuses.

What other posters have said about knowing yourself and how to change habits is all good food for thought. I'm so unhappy with myself, I know I'm not living the way I want to and I know the risks for that down the line, so I do want to change, get some exercise, eat way less sugar etc. But I do get very easily defeated, which I hate about myself

OP posts:
Kirstos1 · 13/03/2022 10:10

You are right to take action now, my very poor diet and lifestyle has caught up with me and I'm now on blood pressure medication at 41. The doctor literally said 'you're at an age now where you can't just ignore it'. So I now need to get myself sorted out too!

Midgetwithaplan · 13/03/2022 09:56

I really like the suggestion of trying it for 4 weeks and assessing, that seems short enough that I should be able to commit, while long enough to make some real difference.
My pledges for the next 4 weeks:

  1. no biscuits, crisps, chocolate, cake, chips, alcohol
  2. plenty of fruit and veg, and eating under 1300 calories a day
  3. gym on every day off (I don't get many...)
  4. complete the first 4 weeks of couch 2 5k (have a treadmill in the spare room so can do this on a work day)
  5. drink 2 litres of water a day
ChocolateChocolateEverywhere · 13/03/2022 09:51

There's a book called Atomic Habits about habit change, which I found very helpful. Particularly, it talks about how hard it is to act in a way that doesn't align with how you see yourself. So if you want to change how you behave, you make it much easier to stick with it if you can change how you think about yourself. I see myself as a lazy arse couch potato who sits around and eats too much chocolate. Which makes it hard to be someone who commits to exercise and a healthy diet! I'm working hard now to talk about myself (in my head,
mostly, but to others if the opportunity arises) as someone who exercises regularly, who makes good food choices and who feels great because I do those things. Sounds slightly odd, but it does make it easier to put in the effort.

Although I need now to put the cat down and go to the gym Grin

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/03/2022 09:49

I’m very much all in or out too. I can give up sugar for ages but once I have a tiny bit that’s it, I’m hooked again

AuntFlorence · 13/03/2022 09:41

The mistake we make is thinking that slipping up takes us all the way back to the beginning. But if we have a slip up a 'lapse' if we get straight back into action we don't have to go round the whole cycle, we can get straight back onto the upward cycle of change without having to go back to the precontemplation/contemplation stages.

The best way to change something is to change something. Action begets more action.

AIBU to think I can make big changes all at once?
thewhatsit · 13/03/2022 09:38

I think you know yourself best - some people work better by throwing themselves in at the deep end and others do best changing bit by bit.

AuntFlorence · 13/03/2022 09:36

We are taught that we need to make lifestyle changes, that 'fad' diets don't work that we can't just change overnight.

But IME sometimes you need to make a massive change. You need to reject a way of life completely and step into a new one. Sometimes it is not a side step into a similar career but different job you need, but to go completely back to the drawing board and start a whole new career path. Sometimes you don't need to work with the wardrobe you've got, you need to donate everything and start over from scratch. Sometimes you don't need to just cut down on the pastries, you need to go on a ketogenic diet. Sometimes a drastic change is the perfect thing. It can snap you out of procrastination and into action, and once you are busy eg. Going to the gym regularly or eating a healthy diet, the other lifestyle changes start to fall into place as well. That "fuck it I'm just going to do it" mentality can switch you into a different way of thinking and being. It can bring an urgency to life changes which otherwise might not ever get initiated. And often times getting off the starting line is the biggest hurdle.

The thing I would keep in mind is that this initial burst of activity will only carry you so far, so whilst you have the energy to initiate a big change also put some things in place to 'relapse proof' your changes. Get rid of foods which don't fit your new diet, make some plans for 'swaps' for old diet breaking foods eg. Some good Fakeaway Recipes or a low calorie ice cream option. Whatever usually catches you out.

And if you do fall off the wagon, dust yourself off and get straight back on it. A lapse doesn't have to become a relapse. You don't have to go right back to the beginning you can continue onward with a little bit more knowledge about your triggers and risk factors which could catch you out in future. It's ok if the journey is a big wiggle not a straight line.

Dacquoise · 13/03/2022 09:35

Can you afford a personal trainer? Someone to put you on the right track, guide you until your new regime becomes habitual. Then introduce some other habits like yoga when you start feeling more successful and better about yourself.

I have recently retired, so completely new life. My strategy is to set up new life in increments ie I joined a slimming club and lost excess weight I was carrying, joined two different yoga groups so classes are different and keep me interested and now introducing/joining things I have always wanted to do, but one thing at a time. Group activities are great for motivation by the way as you feel obliged to keep going, especially if you've paid out the fees.

ThinWomansBrain · 13/03/2022 09:34

every one is different - some will respond to a log of big changes and fast results - others may feel defeated and give up.
Why not set yourself a target? 4 weeks of BIG CHANGE, then review. If it's going well, brilliant. If you've had lapses, been defeated by it, revise and go the slow and steady route.

I did make big changes 5 years ago - low carbohydrate diet and excercise. I didn't stick to it - but I did lose about 30kg. I haven't put it all back on - about 5kg, so it wasn't a total waste of time. I keep trying to psyche myself up to doing it again - not quite there yet!