Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you feel about your partner putting on weight ?

89 replies

smoocakes6 · 12/03/2022 21:57

Being vague so as to get honest answers . Does it bother you if they get a but chubby ? Do you find them less attractive?

OP posts:
RoyKentsChestHair · 13/03/2022 12:01

@NeverChange

It depends how much and why tbh.

Up to 2 stone, I think would be ok but anymore than that possibly not. I think it's not just aesthetics but also the health risks and also the attitude that may go with it, I give less of a shore, have let myself go, self esteem, laziness etc.

For medical reasons etc. due to prescribed steroids etc would be different as they have no control over that.

A previous partner lost a lot of weight after he took up cycling & running and tbh I didn't find him as attractive as he got very skinny.

Fir me, I don't think it's about actual size. I think it's more about what I am attracted to day 1. Significant weight loss or weight gain tends to change the person not just physically but their personality too. Skinny ex got obsessed with early mornings, vegetarianism, no alcohol etc....it dominated everything and he just became zero fun.

Yea this. My XP’s weight fluctuated a lot. The most annoying thing was dinner time/eating out etc We went to New York when he was having a healthy eating phase, so didn’t get to try lots of the foods that people associate with NY - pizza, hot dogs from a street vendor, real NY cheesecake etc. For me the main part of a holiday is the food and I felt like we missed out on a lot of stuff that we would have enjoyed if we’d gone any other time! Also meal times - I would cook him low carb xyz, order only kebabs from the takeaway as he wouldn’t eat rice, chips, bread etc so all other options were out. Then he’d go home and order Chinese with his DCs. So annoying. And the cycling/tennis/gym obsession, he’d set multiple alarms intending to go to the gym early, and snooze them all, so I’d lie there awake all morning while he dozed on and off. Then he’d spend the whole weekend out cycling (7 hours one Saturday) and turn up at my house knackered and sweaty and wanting looking after as he was too tired to be any fun.

I much preferred when we could eat out together, hang out watching tv, go for walks etc and just live a normal life. We watched several series of Masterchef Aus and then once he started dieting we had to stop that too as he didn’t want to watch food progs any more. It changed everything!

lugeforlife · 13/03/2022 11:20

@Branster that's the same for me too. Dh is very tall with quite toned arms and runners legs naturally so weight goes on his tummy. He's been up to 15 and a half stone and down to 12 (he's 6 4 so even the highest weight isn't very overweight). I haven't cared.

I did care when he grew a beard and didn't get his hair cut. He looked so unkempt.

I have gone up and down quite a bit. He likes me on the chunky side as he's a boobs and arse guy but genuinely makes me feel beautiful at every weight I've been.

He doesn't like me with short hair though. I tend to keep it bob/shoulder length because of this.

He cut his hair for me, I keep mine for him!

Branster · 13/03/2022 11:14

A little bit wouldn't affect at all how attractive I find my DH to be.
What would bother me would be lack of self care or not trying to keep fit - that would be a complete turn off regardless of size.

NeverChange · 13/03/2022 11:12

It depends how much and why tbh.

Up to 2 stone, I think would be ok but anymore than that possibly not. I think it's not just aesthetics but also the health risks and also the attitude that may go with it, I give less of a shore, have let myself go, self esteem, laziness etc.

For medical reasons etc. due to prescribed steroids etc would be different as they have no control over that.

A previous partner lost a lot of weight after he took up cycling & running and tbh I didn't find him as attractive as he got very skinny.

Fir me, I don't think it's about actual size. I think it's more about what I am attracted to day 1. Significant weight loss or weight gain tends to change the person not just physically but their personality too. Skinny ex got obsessed with early mornings, vegetarianism, no alcohol etc....it dominated everything and he just became zero fun.

Concestor · 13/03/2022 11:12

My DH has developed a belly that he is doing nothing about and I have to say that I do struggle to find him sexually attractive. It's also because he often doesn't shave, and his posture is terrible so he looks like a hunched old man and it's really off-putting.

Whereas I go to the gym, have good posture, look after myself etc.

It might be shallow but it's true.

SilverGlassHare · 13/03/2022 11:03

If DH had a BMI of 50, I think I would find him less attractive. A bit of chub/middle aged spread - not a problem.

R00K · 13/03/2022 11:00

My wife has put on a considerable amount of weight since we met. I no longer find her attractive.

OneTC · 13/03/2022 10:40

OH has put on quite a bit of weight in the last 2-3 years. Comfort eating and inactivity. It isn't what I'd choose in a partner but there's alot beyond the physical attributes that attract me

SecondhandTable · 13/03/2022 10:07

My DH is much bigger now than when we met a decade ago. It doesn't bother from an aesthetic point of view as in I still find him attractive. However it worries me in a 'health implications' way as his BMI is now in the obese range. We have two young kids, I want him to be healthy to have the best chance at a long healthy life. His DGF died of bowel cancer and his DF also died of bowel cancer and the latter was only in his 50s. With this family history and his weight, it does worry me. I also know he hates the way he now looks and worries about it too but he now seems to have just given up on weight loss efforts that he previously would start and not stick with and seems to be resigned to his (ever increasing tbh) weight even though it upsets him. He is a HCP somewhat ironically too but mostly desk based. I am trying to support/encourage him but I don't want to go on about it too much as I don't want him to think I'm having a go at him, or that I don't find him attractive. I also appreciate its sensitive issue for most people and I've never been overweight before and seem to luckily have a fast metabolism so I've always eaten a lot of calorific crap without issue so I can't relate. If anyone has any advice for me I'd be glad to hear it, I love him and just want him to be the healthiest he can be. The only thing that is a personal interest for me is the fact that he started snoring more and more since he got bigger too which massively disturbs me at night and the ENT consultant suggested losing weight might improve that.

Octomore · 13/03/2022 09:52

I don't find overweight men attractive. I am also attracted to men with active lifestyles/hobbies (like my own), so putting on a significant amount of weight would probably indicate that we were no longer compatible. And then there are the health issues.

So yes, I would have a problem with a partner putting on a significant amount of weight.

If it was just a few pounds though? I wouldn't care about that in the slightest.

Bagelsandbrie · 13/03/2022 09:49

Both dh and I have put on about 2/3 stone in the 15 years we’ve been together. It doesn’t bother either of us. We’ve got bigger fish to fry - lots of health issues (non weight related), Ds with severe disabilities, been through losing close relatives to cancer etc etc. It has made us realise that weight really doesn’t matter unless it’s literally impacting on your health (and ours isn’t; we were both skinny to start with and it isn’t creeping up and up).

TheDuchessOfMN · 13/03/2022 09:48

I would find DH less physically attractive, yes.

And also, another reason I find him attractive (physically, emotionally and as my friend) is because he’s physically fit, and we do activities like cycling, hillwalking etc together.
I’d be sad if he became overweight and unfit/lazy and stopped all that.

Bananabutter · 13/03/2022 09:47

Of course. Very few people find being overweight attractive.

MrsGHarrison87 · 13/03/2022 09:45

Doesn't bother me. My husband is attractive to me both skinny and chubby. He's gorgeous, sexy and cuddly.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 13/03/2022 09:44

Same! People keep saying "wait until you get older" but he's already mid-30s and showing no signs of gaining weight.

I don't think people mean mid 30s when they say this!

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 13/03/2022 09:42

My DP put on 2 stone and I didn't fancy him less, but being honest his face looks better slim now he's lost it. However id prefer him half a stone heavier than his ideal weight but it's not up to me.

He has never expressed any concern about me gaining weight but I've been fairly static since he met me, other than the lockdown half stone which I lost pretty quickly. I don't think he would mind as long as it didn't impede sex Grin

NinjaQueen · 13/03/2022 09:39

@flounfer

he has never dated any one over a particular size.

I don't understand the size restriction. Surely the height is relevant? A 5ft size 10 looks very different to a 6ft size 10

He is short and won't date anyone taller than him either so basically only ever dated petite girls.

It worried me when he said that because a year before meeting him I had been much bigger but found a love of exercise which is how I ended up meeting him.

SarahAndQuack · 12/03/2022 23:48

DP was honestly too thin when we first met - she'd got a bit too into 'fitness' and hadn't know where to stop. She then put on a lot of weight when pregnant with DD as she had GD and she took a long time to recover from pregnancy/labour so weight loss wasn't exactly the priority. I think she always looks lovely.

cheapskatemum · 12/03/2022 23:44

It doesn't bother me at all, but it does bother him. It has a really negative effect on his self esteem, it's that I dislike, rather than the fact he's put on a few stones.

SheAndHerAreWomen · 12/03/2022 23:42

I've had 5 kids and only weigh about a stone more than when we met 25 years ago. He, however weighs about 6 stone more, and yes it's unattractive. Man boobs and arse cracks are NOT attractive I'm afraid.
He is unfit and snores like a trooper. Goes on a 'diet' all the bloody time but unfortunately grew up with MIL the 'feeder' so no bloody hope Hmm

ClariceQuiff · 12/03/2022 23:42

but he's already mid-30s and showing no signs of gaining weight.

Not wishing to be the bearer of bad news but mine is 60! Grin

Hawkins001 · 12/03/2022 23:42

@smoocakes6

Being vague so as to get honest answers . Does it bother you if they get a but chubby ? Do you find them less attractive?
Nope, I prefer ladies with "meaty build" besides it's other factors e.g. Personality, open mind, a good conversationalist ect, those areas matter more to me, than how large a person is
FloBot7 · 12/03/2022 23:37

@ClariceQuiff

My husband has a BMI of 15.9 despite eating junk food all day. I'd be quite glad if he started to put weight on because perhaps then the house wouldn't be full of cake and Mars Bars that I have to try to pretend aren't there, since I gain weight at the drop of a hat.
Same! People keep saying "wait until you get older" but he's already mid-30s and showing no signs of gaining weight.
LizzoBennett · 12/03/2022 23:28

I wouldn't find my DH attractive if he gained over 2 stone.

venusmay · 12/03/2022 23:27

@Aniita he's not unhealthy though, he's gained weight but is fit and eats a decent diet. It's not about an "attitude" change at all. Maybe it's just very narcissistic people who care so much about their size.