Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your honest opinions of social workers?

263 replies

founditdark · 12/03/2022 18:03

I am due to graduate with my social work degree and feel ready yet apprehensive to go out into the working world.

However, over the past 4 years, some people have been less than complimentary when I told them what I was doing at uni. Including my dad who had a bad experience with social workers growing up. He frequently tells me 'I hate fucking social workers'.

Is this the norm? Is it something I'm better keeping to myself when asked what I do for work?

Also if anyone has any words of wisdom for an (almost) newly qualified social worker please do post.

Thanks Smile

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 12/03/2022 20:19

I have no opinion on social workers. I don't know any and have never had involvement with one.

dirtyjoan · 12/03/2022 20:17

@Oldh

When I was considering fostering, I was in contact with three social workers. I felt they meant well, but were on a different planet. Not one of them actually had a child. Dealing with social workers later, regarding my mum's care when she had dementia was a different story, they were truly horrible.
Why is it important for a social worker to be a parent themselves?
roxyro · 12/03/2022 20:15

My advice fwiw is do not be gullible especially when dealing with child neglect/abuse. You should always take the side of the vulnerable child, regardless of what the teaching tells you.

Ted27 · 12/03/2022 20:12

As a profession I think social workers are underfunded, over worked, poorly trained and hamstrung by a dysfunctional system

As an adopter I have encountered many social workers. My first SW was quite frankly a bully, lied about me to her supervisor and was incapable of being objective. I moved agencies and had two fantastic SWs, one of whom in different circumstances could have been a good friend.

My son’s SW was a lovely and well meaning but quite frankly cluless. She was a disability SW who knew nothing about adoption. That wasn’t her fault, but if she had read his file properly if would have helped. She was also incapable of seeing the havoc her visits caused.
My son’s brother is in residential care and has had a series of useless SWs, I made three safeguarding complaints about the home he was in - all were ignored. The decision making was appalling and has resulted in a total mess.
I had a fostering assessment done by a lovely, compassionate, knowledgeable SW who actually listened to me.

My advice to you is try and remember why you went into social work in the first place - presumably because you wanted to do some good in the world.
Be compassionate and empathetic, remember that the people you are dealing with are human beings, not case numbers. Remember to listen and learn how to observe
Whether you are a children’s or adult SW, treat your clients as you would want a family member to be treated.
Good luck, its a tough profession.

Simonjt · 12/03/2022 20:12

My personal experience has been poor, but I don’t let that cloud my judgment when I meet new social workers.

As a child me and my siblings were told our mother was only hitting us because she didn’t love us enough, if he were better behaved (we were very well behaved) she would love us more and stop hitting us. I say hitting, that is putting it mildly.

My sons social workers were poor because they never actually had his case for long, one gave his birth mother my address, luckily we have an okay relationship so this didn’t put me or more importantly my son in danger. My own social worker was alright, just very poor at contact due to workload.

My daughters social worker isn’t proving to be great, she keeps referring to her as ‘Sarah’ when her name is ‘Katie’, paperwork is wrong, we were recently given the information of a completely different child and the info pack had material about the birth parents that should never be made available to the adopters, nevermind when its the wrong set of birth parents. Our social worker, not great, not awful, every meeting so far has been cancelled (but he doesn’t bother telling us).

I dread how long it will take to react finalisation with the experience we are having at the moment.

mnetting · 12/03/2022 20:11

I think it depends if they have a positive or negative experience.
My ex was taken from his mother as a baby and placed with an alcoholic who beat him until he was removed again and pulled from pillar to post with various foster families until he was old enough to leave and find his birth mum - a lovely lady who loved him dearly, had 3 other happy children since who lived with her and he missed out on his family for a miserable life of abuse instead.
I don't know why only one child was removed at birth but it was forced and her relationship with the 3 other children shows she was not an unfit mother.
However SW play an important role in the safety of children and that's to be admired, sometimes they get it wrong though and families are left devastated.

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 12/03/2022 20:11

Have had positive experiences and am very thankful for social workers!

louiseofthelakes · 12/03/2022 20:10

Having been a foster carer for many decades I have found that in recent times almost all the good social workers leave. So many good, enthusiastic young social workers that either have to forget their principles or resign and change careers. Sadly so much is about ticking boxes, paperwork, pointless meetings and the real needs of the children get forgotten. As foster carers it sometimes seems no one considers the children anymore and most of our job is fighting the very system that is supposed to protect them. We are very unpopular for not going along with the "party line" and once our current children reach adulthood we too will be leaving.

Oldh · 12/03/2022 20:07

When I was considering fostering, I was in contact with three social workers. I felt they meant well, but were on a different planet. Not one of them actually had a child. Dealing with social workers later, regarding my mum's care when she had dementia was a different story, they were truly horrible.

dirtyjoan · 12/03/2022 20:07

I wasn't blaming service users for that anger btw. It's intrusive and painful because you don't need a social worker if everything is lovely and rosy.

Often anger that is not yours to own will be directed at you. Anger at the situation, anger at others who have harmed them or their loved one, anger at themselves.

Barrawarra · 12/03/2022 20:06

I think the responses on here are fairly reflective of how sw’s are seen in society OP, and much of it is not without foundation. But more often than not, I find social workers to be amazing humans who want to make the world better. What they do when they realise they are working in impossible circumstances, is another thing. Many harden their hearts to cope with the very difficult experiences and decisions they make, with poor support. It is such a shock as you start to practice to see how much you are hated when you are genuinely trying to help. My advice though is to understand that there are broadly good reasons that the people you support will often have a dim view of you. Be patient with this, name it, tell them you realise they have no reason to trust you and you know how hard it is that you have the power you have in their lives. Keep showing up patiently and try to do what you say you will. Be strong with managers who try to give you too much work, leave if they keep doing it - there’s plenty work. Take support from your colleagues, many of whom will be totally inspiring. Leave local authority and work more therapeutically in other services for less money if it’s not your thing. And make a call in different situations outside of work whether to tell people your job, sometimes just ‘I work with children’ etc will do.

isadoradancing123 · 12/03/2022 20:02

Totally 100% agree with your dad

Luredbyapomegranate · 12/03/2022 20:02

I have only had indirect contact. Other than one lazy article I thought they were sincere and hard working. I had some dealings with a couple of very sharp ones, but overall they weren’t the most dynamic group which I think was partly down to burn out and the inertia of the system, and partly that it’s not highly regarded or paid so it doesn’t in often attract the bright and best.

They are much needed though and I’ve heard good things about adoption services recently. If you are smart and ambitious I expect you can move up quickly and hopefully make a difference.

Noimaginationforaun · 12/03/2022 20:01

We worked with two social workers when adopting our LO. They were both very different but both equally brilliant. Our social worker was kind, very thorough, made us feel at ease and supported. Our LO’s child protection social worker was no nonsense, very thorough with court, supportive. They were both exactly what we needed for their roles and we are indebted to them.

dirtyjoan · 12/03/2022 19:59

@founditdark

I am due to graduate with my social work degree and feel ready yet apprehensive to go out into the working world.

However, over the past 4 years, some people have been less than complimentary when I told them what I was doing at uni. Including my dad who had a bad experience with social workers growing up. He frequently tells me 'I hate fucking social workers'.

Is this the norm? Is it something I'm better keeping to myself when asked what I do for work?

Also if anyone has any words of wisdom for an (almost) newly qualified social worker please do post.

Thanks Smile

Lots will have negative views about your profession. You will soon learn who to tell and who to be vague with.

Many people are very ignorant about the role, the responsibilities and powers that social workers have.

Some have also had negative experiences. Don't take this too much to heart. There are those who have genuine reason to be angry but honestly, most people who have social work involvement are very angry about it, even when that involvement is absolutely necessary and actions justified.

Peasock · 12/03/2022 19:57

I think the majority are doing the best they can in a system that's really understaffed with frustrating amounts of red tape, knowing that if they make a mistake (human afterall) its likely they will be thrown to the wolves. I have a lot of respect for them but I wouldn't do the job for a million pounds a year.

seashellsunderthesand · 12/03/2022 19:55

I feel that partly it is a case of the good or even excellent ones can only do so much, the can't magically whisk away underlying issues or necessarily solve problems that require money and imputi from other entities. Therefore the good ones generally aren't able to positively influence people's lives as much as they would like or often as much as the family would like.
The bad ones though, for whatever reason can damage people's lives in such a way that they'll never forget it. The scope for negative outcomes is so much wider and more serious that it makes people very very wary around them.
It's almost as if getting involved with them is like lighting a fire. When they are good they can keep your body warm and at a reasonable temperature; if they are bad they can burn you really badly.

Lessyuck · 12/03/2022 19:55

Social workers give evidence to the court. Let's all hope that the information they report onwards is always completely accurate.

The system is more screwed than ever.

Individual social workers do not have the time to do the job in the way it needs to be done, even with the best of intentions.

HappeeInParis · 12/03/2022 19:39

I think people sometimes have a negative opinion due to some of the high profile mistakes that have been made. But this is all the more reason it's vital to have good people going into social work and to support them.

TheHateIsNotGood · 12/03/2022 19:39

I think the Recruitment process and criteria needs improvement. Too many Social Workers aren't strong enough to be 'up to the job' - so we've got a shortage as so many leave, get too 'stressed out' and go sick, etc.

Although I'd have made a really great SW myself, I was turned down for an MSW solely because I didn't do a 6 month stint of voluntary work during my degree course.

It went to Panel, but still turned down and the Course went ahead 1 person short. I had plenty of experience but as I gave birth in my 2nd year as an LP I didn't think I needed to add to my existing voluntary work experience.

In my 3rd year there were 3 SW Diploma qualified Social Workers studying Social Policy along side us regular students. They were paid wages to study and upgrade their qualifications.

1 was a very strange person, who preferred to follow her sexual predelections than care for her own family. The 2nd was quite nice but had a nervous breakdown due to the challenges that studying might present so quit.

The 3rd was fine, but then she was from Croatia and probably had seen a bit more than Brighton's worst day.

CarConfession · 12/03/2022 19:36

I have a great SW and think she’s amazing! I’ve met several completely useless ones though. They have such an important job and if they aren’t dedicated to it then it can literally ruin lives

theyreallydontcare · 12/03/2022 19:36

My SIL is one and I wouldn't trust her to look after our goldfish. We recently found out that she is a domestic abuser, both of her ex husband and children. Both her children are no contact with her, and she has never met her grandchildren. She is a senior children and families social worker.
Someone who bullied my DC at school has become a social worker. This is someone who I truly believe shows psychopathic traits. I actually felt sick when I heard what she was doing.
So no, my personal experience isn't good, and I worked in HR many years ago for social services in a northern city which has been very much in the news, and some of the stories about the social workers from that time are truly horrifying.

RogerThatBravoOne · 12/03/2022 19:36

Which area are you thinking of going into?

-know your role. It’s easy to get dragged into doing things that aren’t your role and belong to that of other professional’s.
-stay current and keep your cpd up to date. As your case load gets heavier you might pass up on training etc.
-make sure you get frequent supervision and use your team/colleagues for peer supervision.
-remember you can only do what you can do.

That’s some advice from the top of my head. As previously said; there are shit, awesome and average social workers. As there shit awesome, average police, teachers, supermarket workers, doctors etc. The decisions and assessments you’ll be making carry significant weight though so it can be viewed differently if you get it wrong.

Don’t give a shit if people turn their nose up at you being a social worker. I was once with my husband and his friends and wives (meeting them for the first time years ago) and when I was asked about what I do, one woman proceeded to talk derogatory about social workers as a whole and the only person who looked like a dick was her. Most social workers I’ve come across want the best for people and come to the job from a good place. There are still crap ones too though.

Don’t be afraid to say you don’t know and then go away and find out about things. Families appreciate honesty rather than bullshitting/winging your way through. No one knows everything.

Always be honest with your ongoing assessments. Families need to know where things are at and things shouldn’t come as a shock to them where possible.

I’m not going to lie, it’s a really hard job, you’ll work over your hours and be underpaid. Every so often I look at other jobs but then get my head back in the game. It’s aged me, makes me view things differently at time but it’s a great feeling when you make a difference, even if it’s not as much as you’d like!!

GalactatingGoddess · 12/03/2022 19:35

Overworked and stressed!
I've been one, incredibly hard and made me very unwell for my age.
Moving out of it was the best thing I did but at the same time you can't beat it for the opportunity to work with amazing children and help change lives.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 12/03/2022 19:34

I think generally there is limited understanding of what legal powers social workers are able to exercise.

My experience is in ageing and although I’m
Not a SW I worked closely with them. A lot of relatives seemed to think that social workers could remove older ppl from their homes when the older ppl didn’t want to go or force them to accept care because “it was for their own good”. Often tje SW & I would be in agreement that the OLder person would be better off with help but there was no way to force it onto ppl. I’m sure their relatives thought social services were being useless but when someone has capacity thete is little you can do if they don’t want help.

The intricacies of things like the fair access to care criteria are not known to most ppl and why would they be? But it governs whether ppl are eligible for help with social care and most local authorities because of funding pressures can only help ppl whose needs are “critical” if they’re not, often you’re on your own

It’s a thankless job - I’d not touch it with a barge pole