Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your honest opinions of social workers?

263 replies

founditdark · 12/03/2022 18:03

I am due to graduate with my social work degree and feel ready yet apprehensive to go out into the working world.

However, over the past 4 years, some people have been less than complimentary when I told them what I was doing at uni. Including my dad who had a bad experience with social workers growing up. He frequently tells me 'I hate fucking social workers'.

Is this the norm? Is it something I'm better keeping to myself when asked what I do for work?

Also if anyone has any words of wisdom for an (almost) newly qualified social worker please do post.

Thanks Smile

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 13/03/2022 13:17

I come into contact with social workers daily through my work. Just like any other profession, there are some great social workers, some 'ok' social workers and some who are useless. The most common issue we have with social workers is lack of communication. As a school, we are often not told if Children's services have closed a child's case, if their social worker leaves or if a child has to move Foster placements. This causes no end of problems and it's the child who suffers as a result.

Makeitsoso · 13/03/2022 11:51

Oh gosh yes… don’t vote Tory.

NewPoll · 13/03/2022 11:49

I'm with your Dad through biter experience but I would just say, OP, go. Be a social worker. But please make sure you are one of the good ones. Don't be tainted by a tired system and people who should not be in the job.

FloraPostIt · 13/03/2022 11:44

I work very closely with social workers on a daily basis and I have a very high opinion of them in general - the vast majority are kind, funny, tough and clever.

I work with children's services and they are overworked and under- resourced. As a result so much time is spent dealing with urgent situations and children in imminent danger that other things have to take a back seat. I think this is where a lot of the frustration and thinking social workers are 'useless' sometimes from as most families aren't involved at that level. It drives me mad as I'm always chasing for things and there are so many delays once the crisis point is over. But that's the system - not the social workers.

There are some crap ones.

And one thing I've noticed is that the vast majority of social workers I work with (prob 95%) are female. But once you get to management level the proportion of men is much higher - probably around 30%. Which is interesting.

To answer your question OP if I met you I would think you were awesome. I would probably be so gushing that that you'd feel massively awkward and run away.

Good luck!

And don't vote Tory.

tkwal · 13/03/2022 11:15

18:30CloseYourEyesAndSee

I know another family who adopted a little boy who had been abused by his parents. He was covered in cigarette burns and worse. SWs insisted he kept up a relationship with biological parents until he was old enough to refuse (which he did).

Social workers have no power to insist on any contact after children are adopted. Do you think you might have misunderstood the situation?
They do if it's mentioned in court and the judge rules there has to be contact. Plus they tell you that there is a chance that the child will idealise the absent parent(s) if they dont have contact

CHIRIBAYA · 13/03/2022 11:04

I come into contact with lots of social workers through my work. Some have been absolutely brilliant, so well attuned to what is going on and have really turned a situation around. Others have done incredible damage to the families they have become involved with. The vast majority sit somewhere between these two extremes. I wouldn't want their job; I suspect for many of them they don't have the flexibility and funding to work in the way that they know is best for their clients.

Blossombo · 13/03/2022 10:47

@JennieTheZebra Practice Educator - supporting training and newly qualified social workers ☺️

Ikeabag · 13/03/2022 10:31

Real mixed experience. Through work, met some wonderful ones. One in particular, now retired, was a real diamond. But they're rare. Plenty of them are doing their best. A lot of them bear the brunt of frustrations people have that are systemic faults not individual failings. A few years back we got part way through a fostering assessment (our house is not suitable for the task, it's a weird old cottage thing and would require some serious remodelling, can't afford that) and had one decent SW who was suddenly let go for reasons not revealed, and then were assigned the most useless fish I have ever encountered. Felt sorry for any child lumbered with that one. People are people - we all, social workers (or teachers or NHS workers or any other of the many people working to help others) and people using the service, bring our prior experience to the field. You can't change that.

CrispsnDips · 13/03/2022 10:08

As a Foster Carer for ten years, I have found them all really lovely and supportive apart from one who I had to complain about - she was overly critical, talked endlessly about herself, shared information about other Foster Carers which was unprofessional and irrelevant, would ring me at tea time (with five children needing feeding) and waffle on about rubbish. I received some nice support from her management after I had complained 👍🏼

JennieTheZebra · 13/03/2022 09:57

@Blossombo

Student MH nurse here Smile What’s a PE? I tried googling and couldn’t find anything and I’m always keen to learn.

notanothertakeaway · 13/03/2022 09:51

I think many people (1) have unrealistic expectations of what SW can deliver and / or (2) resent SW involvement even when it is required

If, as a nation, we were willing to pay more tax, we could have a well funded system that could really help to support the vulnerable

Nowayhozay · 13/03/2022 09:34

I had a difficult childhood, lots of social workers in my young life.
One of them was fantastic really went above and beyond.
Sadly though the bad experiences left me jaded and I would find it very difficult to trust any now.

Blossombo · 13/03/2022 09:34

I’m a social worker, have been for 7 years. Never worked in child protection, always mental health.

I was a care coordinator and social supervisor and now I am an AMHP and BIA assessor ☺️
I am also a PE, was a designated safeguarding officer for adults and lots of other bits and bobs.

I absolutely love my job. I think the stigma about social work isn’t as prevalent outside of child protection.

Like any job, there are people that are good at it and people that are not. Think teachers! We can all remember teachers that were wonderful and those that probably shouldn’t have been in the job!

Feel free to ask me anything 🙂

MajorCarolDanvers · 13/03/2022 09:20

My work brings me into contact with social workers and they are no different to any other profession. Most are good people - competent, hardworking well meaning, some truly excellent and some need to leave and do something else.

TheFuckingDogs · 13/03/2022 08:55

So many people in my world are social workers. A lot of the older now retired ones were fantastic but were also operating in much easier times than the present day. I also know some really strong younger women who are great social workers in a completely underfunded and dysfunctional system.
I will admit however the standard generally seems to be dropping and it’s often a toss up between teacher/nurse/social worker and I have seen some truly under qualified, naive and not very bright (academically or socially) qualifying in more recent years.

Fandangofran · 13/03/2022 08:46

Like any job - you get good ones and bad ones.

Unfortunately in a job where the stakes can be so high having a bad one can be disastrous

My friend is a social worker - she's amazing and passionate and genuinely cares about the families she supports - she spends ages driving round sometimes in her own time, picking up baby equipment etc for families who have nothing. I really hope she doesn't get burnt out.

In my career I've come across a lot - some start off well and become jaded and ground down by the system - I've had everything from just can't be arsed to openly hostile. In a lot of cases things could have been done but there was no will to get them done.

I've also had a lot who seem to have lost their objectivity - ones who seemed to have a downer on certain parents and seemed determined to take the kids away no matterwhat -in one case the mother had made a real effort to change and willingly jumped through a million hoops and they still recommended removing her kids.

In another the dad was a "cheeky chappie" who charmed the social worker - she seemed to love him - the fact that he was openly using heroin in front of his 5 year old, inviting anyone and everyone into the house while he was out of it and leaving the front door wide open didn't seem to matter. The social worker was determined they must keep the family together at all costs - even to the detriment of the child.

Of course they are human and can make mistakes but in both cases there were several other agencies involved all saying the SW was wrong but they werent willing to even consider the possibility they might be making a mistake because they were so arrogant. They looked down on those workers and were adamant they couldn't possibly know anything or be highly skilled because they weren't "qualified professionals" eg they didn't have a degree

I really fear for the future too because I helped mentor student social workers for a while and what I saw wasn't good (in terms of the training and guidance they were receiving from their tutors)

Mogloveseggs · 13/03/2022 08:13

One was brilliant. The other was ok but disappeared after 2 visits and we heard nothing for 8 weeks. When they finally called to say we had been appointed someone else I refused (had self referred) due to non communication. They reckoned they had called to explain-nope.

Lwren · 13/03/2022 08:03

I've met some I have loved.
Some I have liked.
Some I have been indifferent too.
Some I have disliked.
One or two I've hated.

However the murders of Arthur, Star, Teddie should make us realise how underfunded and understaffed and in need of much more help these folk need.

Good luck, I'm sure you'll be wonderful x

OutdoorHousePlant · 13/03/2022 07:55

As another professional working with them I'm afraid most of ours are totally useless. For some reason our county employs ones without any common sense, for example directing families of under 10s to age 15+ youth groups etc. The service in the county I work in is however under special measures so I can not speak for all social workers. We do have the odd fab one bit getting to them past the front door is often very difficult!

Discodancinggiraffe · 13/03/2022 07:51

The only interaction I have had with a social worker was when we were looking into fostering. At the first meeting at our house she showed up over and hour late saying she knows she is late but does have an excuse. During the conversation she didn't really answer our questions. But told us numerous time how hungry she was. After she left we discussed this and we both got the impression she was wanting us to feed her. A couple of weeks later we had a phone call. She had signed us up to various courses. One was over 200 miles away and we only had a couple of days notice. No discussion with us, we had jobs to go to. She just wanted to steam roll over us. We decided we would not be fostering based on her behaviour. I did not want to be dealing with a distress child and dealing with people like her. We just knew we would not get the support we needed from her.

Dillydallyingthrough · 13/03/2022 07:25

I would have become a social worker, I really do believe its an important job IF done properly.

I worked closely with social workers in a previous role, what I saw was many were incompetent or projected their own issues.

GoodnessTruthBeauty · 13/03/2022 07:23

What's the difference between a Rottweiler and a Social Worker?

With a Rottweiler you get your kids back.

LairyMaclary · 13/03/2022 07:18

The system is fundamentally broken, and most social workers are chronically overworked and unappreciated.

I have a lot of contact with them in my line of work. I’ve met some absolutely fabulous ones, who are empathetic well meaning people with so many valuable contributions to make. I’ve met some who are nice enough, but perform their job in a fairly perfunctory box-ticky sort of way. And I’ve met a sizeable minority who are so unsuited to the job it would be funny if it wasn’t so serious for the people on their case load that they are failing.

I imagine that if you’ve only had contact with the latter, it would give you a pretty dim view of social services and social workers overall.

Porcupineintherough · 13/03/2022 07:01

Oh OP They have virtually no resources to allocate, not enough time and they are damned if they do and damned if they dont and every Tom, Dick and Harry could do a better job. In fact the only thing worse than social workers is not having them.

Coyoacan · 13/03/2022 03:55

My small interaction with social workers was they were totally blind to the reality of people who are not middle-class like themselves.