Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To email school about DD never being recognised…

239 replies

Greyhop · 12/03/2022 12:32

I’m very happy to be put in my place here! DD is pretty quiet, well behaved at school. She is very good academically - but never gets certificates, is never on school council, has never been to headteachers tea party throughout her time at school/happens termly with about 4 children from her class chosen to go along (some children in her class have been 4 or 5 times). This has been fine up til now.

This year she has started to say “I’m not popular”. I’ve supported her with this - saying she may not be sporty etc, but she does well in English. Everyone has different talents.

The school do reading awards. A new thing this year. DD got to her bronze award, and she was first to do so. Since then she has read avidly, in the hope of getting a mention in assembly as first to get to platinum. 2 weeks ago the school was told someone in year 6 is only a few reads away. It was her. She has followed the rules, written reams in her reading diary - worked it all out that she could get to platinum first. I was reluctant to go with this, but I could see how keen she was - and that she was set to get it.

Yesterday, 4 other children got the award before her - in a different year group - and the only way they could have got it was by their teacher allowing them extra reads to beat her.

She is absolutely devastated!!!

I’m too emotionally invested in this aren’t I? I shouldn’t have encouraged her. But I’ve never seen her sob her heart out like this!

I’ve told her we’ll do our own award/tea party at home. She’s now happy. AIBU to vent in an email to the school????

OP posts:
Xerac · 12/03/2022 14:09

I would say something . I think I would enquire as to the process they use to pick their award winners.
I can see a lot of posters are saying that other children must have deserved it more , but I question that. I think other children may be better at self - promoting than others.
I think it's important , because if a child is being ignored and looked over for awards there is a good chance they may be being overlooked in general.

poetryandwine · 12/03/2022 14:07

I love @MrsTSwift’s reply and the replies from all PPs concerned about the quiet overlooked children.

The PPs saying that children need to learn that life is unfair are (up to a point) wrong: to function well children need to know that their efforts matter. That is how they develop a sense of agency. Carol Dweck at Stanford is a leading expert on this. In HE we see the outcomes of childhood practices every day

The Head Teacher sounds appalling. I sympathise with your DD over the reading contest but I don’t like the idea of it at all. The tea parties are much worse. On the theory that the guest lists are probably composed by a PA I would be seeking a meeting with the class teacher to ask about this, very pleasantly. Your DD is likely not the only child affected.

If the answer was not satisfactory I would escalate concerns to an external member (definitely a non-parent) of the B o G and possibly beyond. It is trivial to adults but the idea that this kind of popularity contest should be perpetrated by the HT is simply wrong

Christmas1988 · 12/03/2022 14:06

It’s positive punishment, my son is the same as your daughter, it’s ridiculous! The way they give out Dojo’s and awards to children who haven’t thrown chairs that week or whatever get awards and paise and the good quiet children get sod all.

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 14:06

@Weatherwithme

Yep I had 2 quiet DC and they both hated the reward systems. One had so few points he got told off by his teacher for not having enough in front of the whole class! he hated it every time they were told to show their point cards. He was top of the class, never in trouble, kind and friendly. What else was he supposed to do? I would say something like DD has being trying really hard to earn rewards and is disappointed she has never been chosen, what more should she be doing? I wouldnt call them out on others getting the rewards. It will be because they forgot about her and her behaviour doesnt need improving. They will probably be mortified they forgot about her.
But she was chosen. She won one reading award before and she also got this second one (just later than the kids who read more books). If I understood it correctly. And she was also praised.

I just don't understand the tea party thing. This seems odd to me.

user1506328491 · 12/03/2022 14:06

Given how upset she was I think speaking to teacher at parents evening is fair: it's important she knows you have her back. That said, I would try and get her to keep certificates etc in perspective - let her know the truth that they are often used to motivate kids who struggle

cherryonthecakes · 12/03/2022 14:05

Yanbu to be angry but don't write to the school- especially if you have younger kids there.

This is exactly the sort of experience that quiet types have at school ime. It's much better at secondary when there's less of this sort of thing.

BronwenFrideswide · 12/03/2022 14:05

I don't know how long before the awards were given the kids were that many reads behind the daughter but it seems sort of odd that a teacher would let them cheat? So I find it unlikely.

It says in the opening post - two weeks. The OP has also clarified that her daughter's nearest competitor was 50 reads behind her, the OP's daughter had 10 left to do. You think it is odd and unlikely that a teacher would let them cheat but there is a discrepancy here that needs explaining.

if the school has some established gold, silver, bronze medal sort of thing then some will miss out.

No-one is doubting that, the doubt is about whether this award has been achieved fairly and it smells to me like it hasn't.

Gemma2003 · 12/03/2022 14:05

Definitely say something. Some kids just get overlooked. My daughter has never got anything her entire schooling. My son won awards every year. The teacher at least needs to hear the effect it is having on her.

Dentistlakes · 12/03/2022 14:05

Whilst I appreciate it’s incredibly difficult to get these things right 100% of the time, I do think schools need to know when they get things wrong. I have in the past raised an objection to something which was incredibly badly and unfairly done, resulting in my child being extremely upset and let down having worked diligently in his case for years towards it. The child who the position was given to proved to be completely useless and clearly didn’t give a damn about being given the privilege. Very embarrassing for all concerned.

In the end my child took a different route to make his contribution and ended up bringing a massive advantage to the school both in reputation and resources.

My advice to you op is to allow your daughter to be upset. Make your objection to the school in a clear and unemotional way and ensure they understand how hard and diligently your child worked towards it AND how she did it within the rules. Then you encourage her to achieve and make her contribution in another way. If an appropriate opportunity isn’t already there then she can make her own. What does she enjoy? Can she start her own initiative in school, involve other pupils, lead her own project? Do it on her own terms.

brainhurts · 12/03/2022 13:59

@FairyCakeWings
Yes I agree they could be reading shorter books hence me saying she needs to ask what the criteria was .

Weatherwithme · 12/03/2022 13:58

Yep I had 2 quiet DC and they both hated the reward systems. One had so few points he got told off by his teacher for not having enough in front of the whole class! he hated it every time they were told to show their point cards. He was top of the class, never in trouble, kind and friendly. What else was he supposed to do? I would say something like DD has being trying really hard to earn rewards and is disappointed she has never been chosen, what more should she be doing? I wouldnt call them out on others getting the rewards. It will be because they forgot about her and her behaviour doesnt need improving. They will probably be mortified they forgot about her.

implantreplace · 12/03/2022 13:57

Yesterday, 4 other children got the award before her - in a different year group - and the only way they could have got it was by their teacher allowing them extra reads to beat her.

They took the initiative in all likelihood and asked to read an extra one

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 13:55

The only thing I don't understand is the tea thing. Are the kids invited for achievements or picked randomly? If only the same kids get to go I would ask about this.

As for the award, I feel sad for your daughter but if the other kids read more the deserve it.

And I agree with what Febrier said, build up her self esteem, listen to her ("I am unpopular" sounds more like she is upset about not having (many) friends to me).

implantreplace · 12/03/2022 13:54

Concern

implantreplace · 12/03/2022 13:53

* She is absolutely devastated!!!*

This would convene me more than anything else

JacquelineCarlyle · 12/03/2022 13:53

@Susu49

Yanbu

It's important that children feel they are treated fairly and it's even more important that they don't disconnect from those things which encourage them and give them confidence.

I actually think it's really important you speak to the school about this.

I completely agree with this.
Febrier · 12/03/2022 13:51

This year she has started to say “I’m not popular”. I’ve supported her with this - saying she may not be sporty etc, but she does well in English. Everyone has different talents.

I would try listening to her a bit more. You are offering her reassurance and common sense, but I don't think you're hitting the mark. Be curious, ask her to say a bit more, ask her how that feels. At the moment it's a bit like that situation where someone wants to offload but the listener just offers lots of solutions.
I agree with others who have pointed out that she seems highly extrinsically motivated. You'll be doing her a favour building up her self esteem instead.

TheSunWillComeOut2moro · 12/03/2022 13:49

The awards are working in that they are making the kids strive to achieve, if other kids beat her well that's just how it goes unfortunately. She's 10/11 I'd expect my 4 and 5 year old to have the reaction you describe not someone about to go to high-school. If you contact school she'll get an award not on merit, if that's what you want to satisfy her go for it.

VioletOcean · 12/03/2022 13:48

Could always make her a certificate!

mogsrus · 12/03/2022 13:47

Don’t children go to school anymore, just to learn things? Sounds like it’s just a - me me me & Why why why. glad I’m out of it all,

uhtredsonofuhtred1 · 12/03/2022 13:45

I was your daughter at primary school and in your position I would 100% say something. I worked really really hard at school and achieved excellent results, I was usually either 1st or 2nd high scorer on tests but was definitely not a show off. I was quite shy and super well behaved. In my whole time at primary I got sent to the head of year once and I cried all night at home because it wasn't even my fault!

Anyway, by the end of year 6 I'd had enough of working and trying so hard all the time and never getting any recognition so going into high school I thought "fuck it!!" I chose not to try at all and instead just had fun. Which involved messing around with mates, skipping school, being cheeky to teachers, smoking, not trying in lessons etc. I was a bit of a nightmare to be honest but because I was naturally quite intelligent I still passed all my exams, I got B's and C's which was amazing considering I'd spent most of the 5 years at the park, in the woods or down the beach! I was lucky, lots wouldn't have been.

Zaccat1 · 12/03/2022 13:45

Mention it. Teacher and parent here. I always try to identify the quiet, conscientious pupils in class as they are rarely recognised by ‘the school’, despite numerous staff lobbying for this.

Hankunamatata · 12/03/2022 13:45

I like star of the week. Our teachers tend to give them for manners, kindness, helping others, being a good friend, following class rules- never for academic achievement.
As for reading they use AR and each person gets awards when read so many words. Struggling readers also use a computer based programme that they get awards for. School tries very much focusing on the best you can be, not comparing yourself to others. Our school doesn't have assemblies

Soontobe60 · 12/03/2022 13:43

@Greyhop

Some of your posts here, really make me question the whole awards/certificates/prize system. It can crush people!! And it’s just extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation is far more important.
I couldn’t agree more. Extrinsic motivation as a way to get children to do things can be so damaging to their self worth.
FairyCakeWings · 12/03/2022 13:41

@brainhurts

I would bring it up at parents evening , ask what the criteria was , say your DD was only 10 reads away and you are puzzled how someone read 50 before she read 10. My money is on they are the children who get stickers galore for the two seconds a day they are good while the good ones get nothing.
It could be that they’re younger children reading smaller books compared to OPs dd in Y6.

It could be that the other year group teacher has told her class that they will consider a poem or a chapter or a short story as a ‘read’ to encourage them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread