Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To email school about DD never being recognised…

239 replies

Greyhop · 12/03/2022 12:32

I’m very happy to be put in my place here! DD is pretty quiet, well behaved at school. She is very good academically - but never gets certificates, is never on school council, has never been to headteachers tea party throughout her time at school/happens termly with about 4 children from her class chosen to go along (some children in her class have been 4 or 5 times). This has been fine up til now.

This year she has started to say “I’m not popular”. I’ve supported her with this - saying she may not be sporty etc, but she does well in English. Everyone has different talents.

The school do reading awards. A new thing this year. DD got to her bronze award, and she was first to do so. Since then she has read avidly, in the hope of getting a mention in assembly as first to get to platinum. 2 weeks ago the school was told someone in year 6 is only a few reads away. It was her. She has followed the rules, written reams in her reading diary - worked it all out that she could get to platinum first. I was reluctant to go with this, but I could see how keen she was - and that she was set to get it.

Yesterday, 4 other children got the award before her - in a different year group - and the only way they could have got it was by their teacher allowing them extra reads to beat her.

She is absolutely devastated!!!

I’m too emotionally invested in this aren’t I? I shouldn’t have encouraged her. But I’ve never seen her sob her heart out like this!

I’ve told her we’ll do our own award/tea party at home. She’s now happy. AIBU to vent in an email to the school????

OP posts:
FairyCakeWings · 12/03/2022 17:50

@Snowbell99

They might count ‘reads’ as sessions of reading, especially for younger or lower ability children.

Maybe a child could read 2-3 pages of a book at their level twice a day, and for them, that would count as two reads. Another child would be expected to read a chapter of a longer book to count as a read because that can reasonably be expected for their ability.

It sounds like the mistake the headteacher made was to place importance on who got their awards first instead of recognising every award as an equal achievement, as it should be. It’s a system that appears to be used across the whole of primary so it has to work for 4 year olds as well as it works for 11 year olds and there is no need to add a competitive element to reading.

I don’t think most children in year 6 would usually care so much about this sort of thing in normal circumstances, and I wonder if OP’s dd being so upset about it has to do with how much time in school doing various normal things children in her year have missed because of lockdowns.

TangledNemo · 12/03/2022 17:47

I hate that these kind of threads are used to shit on attendance awards. I was never sporty, artistic, musical or the smartest in my class so I never got any of those awards, but full attendance was something I could achieve, and I did even though it meant missing my favourite auntie’s wedding. To hear people say it’s not a real award is actually quite hurtful.

CaMePlaitPas · 12/03/2022 17:45

This is really sad OP. I'm not sure it's right for you to vent in an email though, I would be more inclined to organise a meeting with the teacher with my daughter present so we could discuss what is going on. I agree that you need to be her advocate and her supporter here, I've been the quiet kid who never got any recognition and it really does hurt.

NeverForgetYourDreams · 12/03/2022 17:44

@Snowbell99

By the way, I am only noticing this now, but isn't it sort of insane that she only had two weeks left to go and was way ahead but still had to read 10 more books? Or am I mixing something up?

10 books are so many to read in just two weeks. Even though books for children are thinner children read more slowly too. I am a fast reader (but I read them properly and don't skip anything and I like to take many breaks and think about what I have read) and I read a book every two weeks. Usually 350 pages or so.

I mean I have other things to do and kids have school and friends and hobbies so 10 books in two weeks seems kind of unhealthy like they are encouraging the kids just to read parts of them to answer the questions.

The whole award seems kind of odd. As does the tea party thing.

Some kids read fast. Our DS did the holiday reading competition run by local library 3 times over the summer one year. That's 30 books over the summer. He's a bookworm. Did get a special award from the mayor though !
ResurrectionInfinity · 12/03/2022 17:43

@Snowbell99

By the way, I am only noticing this now, but isn't it sort of insane that she only had two weeks left to go and was way ahead but still had to read 10 more books? Or am I mixing something up?

10 books are so many to read in just two weeks. Even though books for children are thinner children read more slowly too. I am a fast reader (but I read them properly and don't skip anything and I like to take many breaks and think about what I have read) and I read a book every two weeks. Usually 350 pages or so.

I mean I have other things to do and kids have school and friends and hobbies so 10 books in two weeks seems kind of unhealthy like they are encouraging the kids just to read parts of them to answer the questions.

The whole award seems kind of odd. As does the tea party thing.

Her nearest competitor was 50 reads behind her, but did it in the time. I’m guessing that a ‘read’ is a reasonable amount for a primary child to read in an evening, hence the limit being there to prevent them ruining their eyes.
raspberryjamchicken · 12/03/2022 17:42

@Littlemissprosecco

But it’s the teachers and the awards which create the unfairness which we parents have to deal with!
I and most other teachers I know keep a list to make sure everyone gets a fair share of awards. Maybe the ones that aren't are new to teaching and haven't figured it out yet.
NeverForgetYourDreams · 12/03/2022 17:42

Our primary school always had head boy and head girl in year 6. Two different chosen each term so 3 head girls and 3 head boys.

When it got to my DS year they made two girls head girls each term so no boys at all

I wrote an email saying whilst I was in no way expecting my son to be head boy, how worthless all the other boys must have felt. Never got a reply though

Our DS only won an award end of year 6 but they gave him and another kid the wrong awards. My son never played chess but won that award. The other kid was bad at maths but a chess genius. C'est la vie !

Theunamedcat · 12/03/2022 17:39

Conversation with ds teacher "im concerned ds is putting in a massive amount of effort and its being ignored is there anyway of rectifying this?" (Teacher) well he seems resilient (doesn't moan loud enough when he is being bullied) I'm sure he can understand that other children need extra help and support (few weeks later) ds doesn't seem to be making much effort anymore is everything OK at home? "Umm yes Hmm pretty sure he just needs encouragement at school he will be fine" (months later) he STILL isn't putting the effort in would you like to refer to.the early help hub get yourself some support we always feel home life has a huge impact on school life "im not being rude here but I work 40 hours a week my son is fine at home if he isn't fine in school perhaps YOU can try some strategies to encourage him in school time? (School call in there Councillor to do a "wellbeing check" on ds) WELL unnamed he said he doesn't like school at all why do you feel that is? Hmm? We feel there is something he isn't telling us? Something at home maybe? We can't understand why he doesn't want to be here? (In my kindest talking to idiots voice) he has been bullied by the same child for five years you keep this child in his class for five years and for FIVE YEARS he has watched while you reward this child weekly and every year several times a year we have this conversation now your trying to make your ineptitude my problem?

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 17:37

I can't confirm this at all. High school was so different here. You'd only get an award if you'd done something really exceptional and you had to put a lot of work into it. The A+ students got most of the awards. Even in primary school the good kids would usually get rewarded and the ones who disturbed class wouldn't get anything or rarely.

This whole "bullies and misbehaved children are rewarded and my perfect child didn't get anything" discussion here is kind of pointless. Not saying that your kids aren't wonderful but parents usually think that their children are perfect and nice and well behaved in school but they are not there to witness it. I have seen children who were really quiet and nice around their parents throw stuff, kick children and scream during lessons. It's sort of like the "my kid would never get into a stranger's car" thing. The parents of the children who you think misbehave all of the time probably think they are wonderful and perfect too.

katepilar · 12/03/2022 17:35

Sorry your daughter is upset. I think this whole award system is hard on the children, and perhaps on the teachers too.

Littlemissprosecco · 12/03/2022 17:35

Nothing ever changes, that’s why I’m a believer in heads down and get on with it for yourself

Littlemissprosecco · 12/03/2022 17:34

I totally agree

EdithRea · 12/03/2022 17:30

I remember at high school they made a HUGE deal about the end of year award ceremony, about how the local college would really care about who got the awards and we all had to work really hard.

And then on the day, the good kids would sit there, empty-handed, while the vilest bullies would be led to the stage to collect awards - money, vouchers, accolades. The kids with support, the kids who'd been frequently suspended, the kids who threw chairs and swore at teachers, the kids who frankly made everyone's lives a misery.

Awards only exist as bribes for naughty kids. Good kids will always be good, so they'll never win anything. They'll see the badly-behaved kids rewarded for screaming, swearing and stealing with chocolate, days out and gift cards because the school can rest easy knowing a good kid won't ever turn bad.

When my kids started primary I had to give them the bad news - because they spotted it before I did. That kid bites, so he gets Star of the Week. That kid rips other kids' work into pieces, so she wins the English award. End of term "champion" is the kid who got a week's suspension for tearing a sink from the wall. My kids are gobsmacked that the school reward this behaviour, but they learned fast.

High school, nothing changes. The good kids get the occasional House Point, but the ones with hundreds are the ones who barely make it through the week without being manhandled off to isolation. They're also the ones who pocket the end of term Amazon vouchers and the days out to the shopping mall. Good kids? Nothing.

Fucking sucks, frankly.

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 17:29

By the way, I am only noticing this now, but isn't it sort of insane that she only had two weeks left to go and was way ahead but still had to read 10 more books? Or am I mixing something up?

10 books are so many to read in just two weeks. Even though books for children are thinner children read more slowly too. I am a fast reader (but I read them properly and don't skip anything and I like to take many breaks and think about what I have read) and I read a book every two weeks. Usually 350 pages or so.

I mean I have other things to do and kids have school and friends and hobbies so 10 books in two weeks seems kind of unhealthy like they are encouraging the kids just to read parts of them to answer the questions.

The whole award seems kind of odd. As does the tea party thing.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 12/03/2022 17:29

Dd1 is consistently good but quiet and introverted. She got 100% in two of her SATs exams, high results in the rest and still didn’t get a bloody certificate. Dd2 is an extrovert and average academically, she gets lots of certificates. Dd1 is now at secondary and they have a much better set up that enables them to achieve in different ways to get recognition based on meeting clear achievements rather than who caught the teacher’s eye. In Year 6 Dd1 became aware of the unfairness and we alone about it and how teachers use it to encourage dc who weren’t motivated but as Dd is so good already she doesn’t get them. She still occasionally laughs about Jake getting worker of the term because he managed to go the whole term not punching anyone! Different dc need different encouragement and Dd understands that now. I still think it’s a bad approach but primary is over for us this year so I’ll skip merrily away.

GetYourEightYearOldOutOfATree · 12/03/2022 17:23

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ChampagneLassie · 12/03/2022 17:19

I think find things out of school to enter her for - I'm sure there are lots of things she could be doing. By all means speak to school but as others have said they'll ensure she gets stuff and it will feel hollow to her. These school awards are clearly a lot of nonsense and not really on merit at all. It is a life lesson. Life isn't fair and learning to navigate that and seek out areas where you achieve for yourself and your own satisfaction are important

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 17:19

[quote TurquoiseDragon]**@Snowbell99

OP's DD had calculated she was in the lead by a long way, so she was in line to get the platinum award regardless, with 10 reads left to go.

So there's no doubt she will get the platinum award. Then these 4 chhildren are awarded yesterday, so this is where the "before her" comes from. "Before her" doesn't mean she also got the award, it means these 4 children got the award before the DD could.[/quote]
But why is the emphasis in her comment then so much on that the daughter wanted to get it first so that she'd be mentioned in the school assembly? To me it sounds like the first people to achieve it would be mentioned in the assembly and that others could get it later on for finishing the number of books.

Anyway, she won the bronze award previously so she wasn't overlooked and if the four other children read more then it is fair. If the OP is unsure about whether it was fair because she is suspicious about the other kids reading so many books in such a short time she should ask about the rules. But as they are from a different age group it likely had to do with the books being shorter.

TurquoiseDragon · 12/03/2022 17:10

@Snowbell99

OP's DD had calculated she was in the lead by a long way, so she was in line to get the platinum award regardless, with 10 reads left to go.

So there's no doubt she will get the platinum award. Then these 4 chhildren are awarded yesterday, so this is where the "before her" comes from. "Before her" doesn't mean she also got the award, it means these 4 children got the award before the DD could.

wearingtheT · 12/03/2022 17:05

Smart children work out the system. Then the system is a waste of time. if she hasn't worked it out...help her. Personal achievement is the greatest gift you can give her.
I wouldn't worry too much, when they get to secondary it's a different ball game. results are read out, everyone knows who's smart etc. No molly coddling at all.

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 17:05

QUOTE: I'm still not understanding the rules for the platinum reading award -- is a 'read' a book? Or a section of a book? In what way could a teacher have 'allowed' other children 'extra reads'? Do you mean you think a teacher faked results for other children, who hadn't actually read the books they claim to have?

Me neither. Or the tea party.

ChickenStripper · 12/03/2022 17:04

@LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana

I get you. My 9 year old daughter is very bright,exceeds all targets,is kind and polite etc and never gets good work certificates etc. But the children who regularly misbehave get rewarded if they have a good week.
This is the problem - much of it is about "effort" so when a "bad" child does a little bit of something the school want it to be rewarded.
Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 17:03

Agree about the tea party. The tea party is still extremely strange to me.

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 17:02

*first to get bronze

Snowbell99 · 12/03/2022 17:01

@TurquoiseDragon

Yesterday, 4 other children got the award before her - in a different year group - and the only way they could have got it was by their teacher allowing them extra reads to beat her.

For all the people who are saying the OP's DD got the award, this suggests she actually hasn't.

OP says her DD has been sticking rigidly to the rules, so I'm sure if extra reads were allowed, she'd have done that.

So, if I were in OP's position, I would be questioning things with the school. I would also be questioning how children are chosen for the HT's tea party.

How does this imply that she didn't get it? It says "four other children got the awards before her" which to me suggests she did get it but she came in fifth.

The OP wrote this:

"Since then she has read avidly, in the hope of getting a mention in assembly as first to get to platinum."

Which to me implies that she wanted to be the first to get the award but not she is the fifth and upset because of this.

She also mentioned that her daughter was the first to get to platinum so she got that award previously and others must have gotten it after her.