Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do Electricity bill could be £10,000?

288 replies

floridapalmtree · 12/03/2022 10:33

I have read the meter and think we are over 30,000 kw's over. I have been asked for a meter reading and think it's going to come to around £10,000. What do I do give them an accurate reading now? Or wait a year or so to give the correct reading hoping prices will come down?

The reason it is so much over is my mil was living here and had electric radiators on all day in her room and didn't care about the cost as long as she was warm. Plus there is a problem with the boiler and we have had the emersion heater on often continuously to heat water.

I just don't know what to do, any advice?

OP posts:
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/03/2022 16:17

@j89vsd

I've checked friends meter now, the difference is slightly more than OPs :( Friend has been saving for years to get some much needed work done in her house (New carpets and floors, replacing her front door and a couple of windows, repairing some dodgy electrics and plumbing) She has just over £10k saved for this which was just enough to cover it and has been getting quotes excited for it to start. She's devastated that is going to be swallowed up straight away by gas and electric costs. It will take her years to save it again.

Cant help but feel sorry for her.

Why hasn't she been giving meter readings and paying her bills?
LittleRen · 12/03/2022 16:12

I don’t think this is so hard to believe. Do you have more than one electric rad? My MIL has electric radiators and her bill is £600-£700 a month, for just her, being very careful. Electric is so expensive for heating etc.

Kipperandarthur · 12/03/2022 16:12

@j89vsd

I've checked friends meter now, the difference is slightly more than OPs :( Friend has been saving for years to get some much needed work done in her house (New carpets and floors, replacing her front door and a couple of windows, repairing some dodgy electrics and plumbing) She has just over £10k saved for this which was just enough to cover it and has been getting quotes excited for it to start. She's devastated that is going to be swallowed up straight away by gas and electric costs. It will take her years to save it again.

Cant help but feel sorry for her.

But you’ve said up thread that your friend has heating on all the time and air con in the Summertime. Then she’s ignored the fact her bills have been estimated for years.

Basically she’s not been paying for what she uses.

I’m sorry but we all have to pay and give readings or have smart meters.

It’s just all caught up with her and why should she not have to pay for what she’s used especially since she’s obviously extravagant with heating and aircon.

j89vsd · 12/03/2022 16:11

Honestly, I don't think she realised the estimate was that far out.

Would it benefit her to try and do a deal? Offer a lump sum now? She doesn't have a massive income so if they want her to pay by instalments she could only manage about £100-150 a month currently (and that's before all the energy price rises).

I thought if she offered £5k they might take that as a settlement? Then she's still got some money so she can do some of the improvements, and it's more likely she'll be able to keep up with future payments. I know from experience a couple of relatives who've done that kind of a deal on loads and things, but don't really know the ins and outs, I don't want to give my poor friend false hope though.

Hellocatshome · 12/03/2022 16:04

Cant help but feel sorry for her.

It is sad for her but if you live a 'head in the sand' kind of life these are the things that can happen. She knew the meter wasn't being read so what was she expecting to happen?

HisNibs · 12/03/2022 16:03

I believe the 12 month rule on back-billing only applies if you haven't received a bill at all. Op has been receiving estimates but not taken the opportunity to correct the reading. Best thing I can suggest is to speak to the supplier and ask for the outstanding balance to be paid over the next couple of years at least since it's been at least that long since an actual reading was done. I think the supplier is only obliged to do an actual reading every 3 years and since some meters are indoors, Covid may have relaxed that rule a little.

j89vsd · 12/03/2022 16:01

I've checked friends meter now, the difference is slightly more than OPs :( Friend has been saving for years to get some much needed work done in her house (New carpets and floors, replacing her front door and a couple of windows, repairing some dodgy electrics and plumbing) She has just over £10k saved for this which was just enough to cover it and has been getting quotes excited for it to start. She's devastated that is going to be swallowed up straight away by gas and electric costs. It will take her years to save it again.

Cant help but feel sorry for her.

cakeorwine · 12/03/2022 15:57

It is a strange business. I am sure in years time, people will look back and query how it worked.

"So you had a dial in your house"

"Yes"

And that dial measured how much electricity you were using?

Yes

And every few months, you would get a bill from the company saying that they think you have used this much so please pay it?

Yes - but sometimes they predicted what you would use for the whole year and then you would give them the same amount of money each month to pay your year bill.

But how did they know how much you used?

We had to tell them?

And they believed you?

Well sometimes, someone would come round, knock on the door and look at the meter and then tell the company what you were using.

That sounds so old. Have you got any more stories?

Well, let me tell you about how we paid to watch TV

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 12/03/2022 15:56

@40thanniversayfastapproacning

There is indeed a limit on how far back they can charge you. They cannot charge for anything over 12 months ago so you may be able to write off some of this. The issue will be working out how much was used over 12 months ago.
It's not as straightforward as that, as otherwise everyone would refuse to give meter readings and just not pay their bills.
Gazelda · 12/03/2022 15:54

Have you ever changed supplier OP?

amusedbush · 12/03/2022 15:52

@40thanniversayfastapproacning

There is indeed a limit on how far back they can charge you. They cannot charge for anything over 12 months ago so you may be able to write off some of this. The issue will be working out how much was used over 12 months ago.
This simply isn't true - not in the way you've stated.

DH and I inherited our house when his granny died. Probate dragged on and on for almost two years, it turned out nobody had informed the supplier of her death and electricity was being used by the builders we had in to renovate. By the time we moved in officially and got around to switching the power to our own account, it was quite the mess to unpick.

I queried the whole back bill thing with them (basically chancing my arm to get some written off!) and was told that it only applies if the supplier is at fault, e.g. they have not sent a single bill, even an estimated one.

Because we hadn't sent in any meter readings (thinking that my FIL had notified them long before), we had never been at the house when someone came to read the meter, and because the supplier had still been sending quarterly estimated bills, we weren't eligible to have anything written off at all.

Hugasauras · 12/03/2022 15:51

I'm a bit baffled that no meter readings have been submitted in two years Confused Have you not been asked to by supplier? I get regular emails prompting me to send meter readings.

Baaaa · 12/03/2022 15:51

I do wonder how Covid has affected the 'meter reading' business exactly, and we had our old supplier telling us they would be in touch to check the safety of the gas meter soon but no mention of the electric and I had to chase them for the gas meter check as I was irrationally scared it would blow up.

Hellocatshome · 12/03/2022 15:50

According to a quick Google they can send a meter reader OR they can contact the householder and ask for an accurate reading.

They put something on the bills about contacting them with an accurate meter reading so they can always say they they have satisfied this commitment.

MurmuratingStarling · 12/03/2022 15:50

@EvilPea

You are supposed to submit your own readings.We haven't had anyone here to read our meter for years

Ours send someone if you don’t submit them

We get someone reading our meters once a year (circa February,) and we send readings in the rest of the year - May, August, and November.
AngelinaFibres · 12/03/2022 15:49

According to a quick Google they can send a meter reader OR they can contact the householder and ask for an accurate reading. If neither of these things has happened you may have wiggle room. If they have communicated with Ops husband, as the name on the bill, and he has ignored their requests, then the amount they have actually used will have to be paid for. Perfectly fair since the rest of us have submitted readings and paid for what we have used. No different from buying anything else.

Hugasauras · 12/03/2022 15:48

But she has received bills.

cakeorwine · 12/03/2022 15:48

@Baaaa

Wish I hadn't bothered giving them readings now.
I do wonder how Covid has affected the 'meter reading' business.
Tontostitis · 12/03/2022 15:48

I had similar when I moved and MiL 'helped out' by moving with us and staying a month. Between her and her electric radiator and the emersion our first 3 moth bill was over £500 and tat was ten years ago. If you've been hiding from this fir a couple of years then I'd firstly give a lower reading like a PP said and a true one next year and secondly ask MiL to help.

Baaaa · 12/03/2022 15:46

Wish I hadn't bothered giving them readings now.

cakeorwine · 12/03/2022 15:41

This might be useful

A number of scenarios where you won't be backbilled and when you might be backbilled

www.eonenergy.com/About-eon/how-we-service-our-customers/~/media/PDFs/About-Us/Codes-of-Practice/412-the-code-of-practice-for-accurate-bills-back-billing-for-domestic-customers.PDF

This is one example:

A customer’s energy supplier did not attempt to obtain a valid reading, leading to estimated bills being produced. When the supplier did send a meter reader in May 2009, the reading taken was higher than the estimated consumption

Clause applies - YES - As the Code requires suppliers to attempt to obtain a valid reading,
(includes customer or actual meter reading) and when a correct reading is taken, the customer has been undercharged

Whereas:

A supplier’s meter reader is unable to access the customer’s property, but the customer has submitted meter readings that have
been used for billing. In April 2009, the meter reader accesses the property, and the reading taken is far higher than those provided by the customer

Clause applies - NO - As the customer had provided readings that were then used for billing, which were less than actual
consumption.

I suppose it's a question of did you ever submit any readings at all and did the company make any effort to get a correct reading off you?

RandomMess · 12/03/2022 15:41

Ensure they convert it to £ using your old rate for most of the usage. In fact I would do weekly readings so you can evidence how many KWH should be charged at the newer higher rate as you know the high usage was only when MIL was living in your home which was historic.

Have you now got the boiler fixed so you don't have to use the immersion anymore?

Leftleg · 12/03/2022 15:40

If that reading is correct, I would call the supplier and ask when the last actual read was. As it's been at least two years, I would ask them to rebill your account back to the last actual read to apportion some of the usage onto older prices. They should write off any usage over a year due to the back billing rules as long as you have not refused access or ignored letters asking for reads.

Kipperandarthur · 12/03/2022 15:40

If you look up the cost of using an immersion heater based on 2 heating cycles per day (only 2 mind you) based on a 4 bedroom house. The average cost per year is nearly £2,000 per year for this alone.

Factor in two years of this plus the heaters and here’s your answer.