Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep the Aga?

86 replies

UmbriaLover · 12/03/2022 08:20

We are having the kitchen re-done.

DH wants to replace of the Aga with fantastically modern electric ovens/microwaves that cook food quickly, easily, and at low cost without the extreme hassle of an Aga.

DH says:

  1. The Aga costs too much to run (oil... don't ask it came with the house)
  2. It's quicker to boil an electric kettle
  3. We don't live in the country (we live in Fulham) or have a springer spaniel.

This is my ABSOLUTE worse nightmare.

How can I convince DH to keep the Aga?

AIBU to keep the Aga?

OP posts:
UmbriaLover · 12/03/2022 08:51

[quote Plantstrees]Get an Everhot instead - cheaper to run but has the feel of an Aga. Best of both. www.everhot.co.uk/[/quote]
Wow! Thank you. Even Sarah Beeny has one!

OP posts:
UmbriaLover · 12/03/2022 08:47

@ScarletTulips

We have an old oil Aga which came with the house and we love it. We do live in the country and have dogs. As PP says there’s no need for tumble dryer, toaster, electric kettle, slow cooker, underfloor heating. It also makes food taste so much better. Even something as simple as a jacket potato tastes more delicious. There’s a special kind of warmth and comfort that an old Aga emits. Wouldn’t be without mine now. In terms of environmental impact, I’m not sure that swapping it for a whole load of modern electrical items which will have a shorter life span than an Aga, is any better.
You are so right re. the jacket potatoes! Actually I always thought it was the CCC made in the 'mik-ro-wah-vey' as NL likes to say! (Chilli con carne).

Do you know if it is possible to have something similar to an Aga upstairs as well? For the special kind of warmth? What breed of dog do you have though? Does it even depend on breed?

You seem like an expert on the environmental impact of electrical items, so I will present your post as evidence to DH. Thank you.

OP posts:
Plantstrees · 12/03/2022 08:40

Get an Everhot instead - cheaper to run but has the feel of an Aga. Best of both. www.everhot.co.uk/

ScarletTulips · 12/03/2022 08:39

We have an old oil Aga which came with the house and we love it.
We do live in the country and have dogs.
As PP says there’s no need for tumble dryer, toaster, electric kettle, slow cooker, underfloor heating.
It also makes food taste so much better. Even something as simple as a jacket potato tastes more delicious.
There’s a special kind of warmth and comfort that an old Aga emits.
Wouldn’t be without mine now.
In terms of environmental impact, I’m not sure that swapping it for a whole load of modern electrical items which will have a shorter life span than an Aga, is any better.

AuldFox · 12/03/2022 08:38

It’s going to cost a lot more to run this year. Sigh.

parietal · 12/03/2022 08:37

I'd ditch the aga. Massive inefficient and pretentious thing and the ovens aren't even hot enough for Yorkshire puddings.

Modern induction hob and modern oven is vastly better.

UmbriaLover · 12/03/2022 08:32

@tothemoonandbackbuses

The main points of my argument would be: Saves using the tumble drier as it dries the washing Saves electricity for boiling the kettle/making toast Enables cheaper meals to be cooked because the oven is always on In the event of a power cut it provides both heat to the room and cooking (I’m presuming it’s drip feed). You can turn the heating lower or off in the rest of the house because the aga is always on You can buy the oil over summer therefore you pay for it before you use it.
Thank you for your message.

DH says that it cost about £2,500 to keep the Aga running last year, and that it is 'hard to imagine the number of cups of English Breakfast for the tradesmen of Fulham' that could be made for that amount of money.

We send all our laundry out.

OP posts:
Duntelchaig · 12/03/2022 08:31

Oil costs will go down again, you can turn it off in the summer to save a bit and it does heat the kitchen. You’d need to run a radiator or something without one. Electric ovens are expensive to run and dry things out.

tothemoonandbackbuses · 12/03/2022 08:29

The main points of my argument would be:
Saves using the tumble drier as it dries the washing
Saves electricity for boiling the kettle/making toast
Enables cheaper meals to be cooked because the oven is always on
In the event of a power cut it provides both heat to the room and cooking (I’m presuming it’s drip feed).
You can turn the heating lower or off in the rest of the house because the aga is always on
You can buy the oil over summer therefore you pay for it before you use it.

UmbriaLover · 12/03/2022 08:29

@kasho5

Oh no I love our Aga! Ours is electric and DH is already talking about not turning it on next winter because our economy 7 rate triples next month Hmm
Philistine!
OP posts:
kasho5 · 12/03/2022 08:24

Oh no I love our Aga! Ours is electric and DH is already talking about not turning it on next winter because our economy 7 rate triples next month Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread