Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a birthday party invites one- twins

288 replies

MarianosOnHisWay · 12/03/2022 07:43

DD has a set of boy-girl twins in her Year 3 class. Let’s call then John and Sarah (not real names).
John seems to be a boisterous type, I often hear his name from DD at the end of the day in conjunction with who has been in trouble or that he’s done something like pull her glasses off, talk about killer clowns etc. Sarah isn’t one of DD’s best friends but they get on fine.

The popular destination for 8th birthday parties this year (after they haven’t been able to have parties for so long) is either one of two large trampoline/bouncy park type things. We’ve been to around 4-5 parties at these so far this year. Because they’re large places, you don’t hire the whole place- there are members of the public bouncing too.

DD is having her party at one such place. She would like to invite all the girls in the class. However, what has happened at the last few parties like this is- Sarah is invited but the twins’ mum also brings John along and pays for him as a member of the public to enter and bounce. Obviously he doesn’t join in the party room, party food etc.

I get it- they’re twins, what one does the other wants to do. Also maybe mum doesn’t have childcare for John while taking Sarah to a party.

DD has now said she’s worried about inviting Sarah as it will mean John will come. She says at the other parties when he’s been there as a non-party member of the public he’s been rough, deliberately barged into the party members when bouncing, even strangled them, been rude and called out rude things etc. She doesn’t want this to happen at her party.

I’m not sure how to make the AIBU voting because as I see it there are three options:

-Don’t invite Sarah- very reluctant to do this as she’d be the only girl in the class not invited and why should she suffer due to her twin brother’s behaviour?

-Invite Sarah but have a work with mum and say please don’t bring John- so awkward and she may not have the option plus as a member of the public I can’t really control if she brings him?

-Invite Sarah and just accept that it means John coming too, and prep DD to come and report any incidents (again so awkward though? The mum will be sitting there at the cafe place and what will I say “John is playing rough and the girls don’t like it, please get him and ask him to stop”)

Or is there a fourth option??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ikeptgoing · 18/03/2022 08:50

I think this is the option that OP is going for ?
1. Invite half the girls from one class, and half from the other class/brownies etc. Therefore Sarah not invited but also not excluded.

Quite a few of us suggested a version of this- this as DD wants this trampoline place for her party; DD herself is worried about inviting Sarah as it means Twin John will turn up and barge into the play part of the party anyway and DD does not want him there; class politics are you can't invite all the girls (or all the joys) in a class and leave out one, you have to invite partial of the girls (leaving out 3+ girls, preferably more) to do that.

Ahhh I remember these party politics. I wish I had been more firm about not inviting "friends" (who weren't actually close friends) to my DCs parties whose parents brought along unruly siblings who joined in anyway and ruined things. Or that we knew they were mardy and would ruin the party (watch out for that during teenage year parties- don't invite the 'mardy teen' who refuses to join in planned activities!!) ... It would have been so much less stress.

NumberTheory · 14/03/2022 20:13

@Mojoj

I don't see the problem? If John ends up coming and behaving badly, tell his mum to go sort it.
Even if the mother actually steps in and parents her DS when asked, which isn't really sounding likely, it happening once is still going to marr the DD's party. Most likely the mother won't really step up, will half-heartedly tell her DS off and then go back and stare at her phone some more while he does it again.
BluebellsGreenbells · 14/03/2022 18:40

But why should you have the worry of an unruly kid turning up and having to deal with the mother when you really don’t have to?

Your focus should be in the birthday girl and getting food cake etc ready, not having to watch a child that wasn’t even invited.

Mojoj · 14/03/2022 18:38

I don't see the problem? If John ends up coming and behaving badly, tell his mum to go sort it.

AddictedToOlives · 14/03/2022 18:00

Oops, first time I’ve ever commented on a thread before reading all of it (as I was just ditto another poster)
And now I see there was more info about space in car etc so sorry - and I won’t do that again!

But now I’m voting for the invites for split class/Brownies friends
Hope your daughter enjoys her party

GrandRapids · 14/03/2022 17:58

What's with all the 'poor John' comments? Bollocks to John quite frankly!

I'd go with option 5 - just invite a few plus it will save you money.

AddictedToOlives · 14/03/2022 17:34

@Sally872

Not inviting Sarah can't be an option.

Speak to the mum ideally to offer a lift to Sarah so John doesn't come and if that doesn't work then say can you keep an eye on John if you are taking him bouncing as last time he was a bit too rough for my dd and she is a bit nervous about same situation again.

Exactly what I was going to say.

Start tactful - but if you need to then be honest that his behaviour at previous parties makes him unwanted

Satsumaeater · 14/03/2022 17:07

It sounds like climbing or going for the wider circle of friends are the solution.

As for "teacher voice" my son had a joint party once with a friend whose mum was a teacher (probably at a similar age) and she did use her teacher voice and they all sat and listened while they completely ignored me Grin

RockinHorseShit · 14/03/2022 16:32

Ofc you tell them to stop it, but suggesting that as a strategy for dealing with an difficult uninvited kid, you put the onus on the OP to parent him, when she has enough to do is really unfair. It's the lads mothers fault anyway. That's her job & she needs to be told she can't just rock up with him uninvited & let him spoil the party

DisappearingGirl · 14/03/2022 16:25

Umm, I am not a pushover! Nor am I a teacher. But yes if there is a rogue kid at softplay/trampolining etc harrassing my kid or their friends then yes I will tell them to stop it.

RockinHorseShit · 14/03/2022 15:48

I think if you do go ahead and invite all the girls plus Sarah, I would probably go into teacher mode in terms of supervising John. I would spend some time hovering near the kids (as opposed to chatting with the parents). At the first sniff of John being a pain in the butt, I'd put on your best teacher voice and firmly tell him No. And repeat if necessary. Basically parent him if his mum isn't going to. His mum probably won't notice if she's in the cafe area on her phone, but if she does, so what. You're not going to be screaming at John, just pulling him up on any and all bad behaviour.

Do you seriously expect a teacher to step up into professional mode to discipline a child that was not invited to the party, on her DDs birthday Confused

Have you always been such a push over Sad

DisappearingGirl · 14/03/2022 14:03

I've not read the full thread OP! But I read your update that you are a teacher.

I think if you do go ahead and invite all the girls plus Sarah, I would probably go into teacher mode in terms of supervising John. I would spend some time hovering near the kids (as opposed to chatting with the parents). At the first sniff of John being a pain in the butt, I'd put on your best teacher voice* and firmly tell him No. And repeat if necessary. Basically parent him if his mum isn't going to. His mum probably won't notice if she's in the cafe area on her phone, but if she does, so what. You're not going to be screaming at John, just pulling him up on any and all bad behaviour.

*Disclaimer: I'm not a primary teacher but my mum is so I've picked up a good teacher voice which I have occasionally used at softplay etc with boisterous kids with ineffectual parents!! Good luck OP

MrsVoorhees · 14/03/2022 09:47

@rebekuh

Option three

He may be boisterous but he's a little kid.
Dont be so childish and teach your child to be nice and inclusive

Keeping my fingers crossed that you don't have a daughter who you teach this too.

Bunnycat101 · 14/03/2022 09:01

From some of the posts on here I can see why some people turn into complete doormats. Why on earth should the OP’s daughter a) not have the party she wants and b) be forced into amending the guest list because of the poor behaviour of one child. A smaller party might work if she’s happy with that but it is unfair. I certainly wouldn’t be inviting John and one of his friends along knowing the CF mother would bring him anyway as some posters have suggested.

OP the only thing I was going to suggest is you listed climbing as a possibility. That would probably be a bit more controlled as assume you’d have a proper instructor there supervising in a way that the trampoline park wouldn’t.

I’m not doing a whole class party this year because I’ve been appalled at some of the behaviour I’ve seen from the boys at other parties and I don’t want to be responsible for that or risk it spoiling my daughter’s party. Parties aren’t a public service. While I wouldn’t exclude 1/2 children, there shouldn’t be an expectation that you can just rock up, let your kids go feral with no consideration of the birthday child’s enjoyment.

aSofaNearYou · 14/03/2022 08:23

@rebekuh

Option three

He may be boisterous but he's a little kid.
Dont be so childish and teach your child to be nice and inclusive

Or, his parents could teach him not to pull off other kids glasses and strangle them, rather than expecting little girls to "be nice" and put up with it.
Ikeptgoing · 14/03/2022 08:17

The thing is by picking a public place and as they are twins you know that this mum will bring John too. And he'll join in the party. I would either invite less girls and not Sarah to avoid that, as she isn't a BFF close friend and DD doesn't want John to come

If you invite a couple girls from different place you know them from it won't be all the class girls & you can justify that you have limited numbers

Your DD has already said she is worried about inviting Sarah so she clearly doesn't want john there.

I wouldn't be saying anything to johns mum though if you do invite Sarah as there's no way to keep him away from the free for all birthday run around play area without saying something that sounds like you are criticising mum and John.

So I'd bite the bullet and rethink who you invite. Twins often do come as a package - twin politics!- and mum is paying for him herself so in her mind she's doing nothing unkind.

rebekuh · 14/03/2022 08:00

Option three

He may be boisterous but he's a little kid.
Dont be so childish and teach your child to be nice and inclusive

Maray1967 · 14/03/2022 07:21

Option 4 is go ahead as planned but be by the trampolines yourself if he turns up and tell him off yourself/ threaten to call the staff over if anything happens.
I had to do this with DS1 at about that age with a child who had had a very difficult start in life, was being fostered and who other parents left out of invites. I wouldn’t do that but I did sit next to him at the table and stop him hitting other kids with a balloon etc . I did wonder why on earth his mother never stayed because she knew what his behaviour was like.

Pheasantplucker2 · 14/03/2022 02:34

I totally agree @whatafuckingjoke - John’s mum needs to be on it and it’s not ok for him to be hurting anyone. To be clear, I never let my son do that and remove him from the scene as soon as I sense he’s getting overwhelmed.

I just wanted to express another side to all this hate for John’s mum. A lot of parents of ND kids are themselves often undiagnosed ND and struggling to cope. Again, not to excuse the lack of intervention but to give a different perspective.

In summary, fine to place a boundary of no physical harm, but just understand that there might be other things going on underneath that aren’t obvious. And fwiw, she will know the depth of feeling towards John. She may not be able to acknowledge it but she will know his behaviour isn’t ok.

whatajuckingfoke · 13/03/2022 20:52

@Pheasantplucker2 I agree with many of points in your post wholeheartedly. I have an autistic child who masks so well that most people don't realise. It is hard.

But. Regardless of how tired I am, how fed up I am of being on high alert, how much I wish I could just child my child in the doorway of a party and dash off with no worries like everyone else seems to be able to - there is no excuse, none for sitting disengaged and not engaged whilst your child hurts other people.

I am lucky that mine doesn't lash out at anyone other than me and her Dad (and I do appreciate that) she meltsdown and is overwhelmed with anxiety and fear. But if this child does have additional needs it's up to his mum to manage him appropriately and I'm afraid I do judge her harshly for sitting on her backside on her phone whilst he runs riot. It's not ok.

Pheasantplucker2 · 13/03/2022 19:50

I see this from both perspectives. I absolutely agree that girls are being programmed in an insidious way from tiny to excuse boys' bad behaviour as something they need to tolerate because "be kind". And I have two girls who have often been the girls to be sat with the boisterous boy to calm them down, to their own detriment.

I also have a boisterous boy - he has ADHD. And sometimes he is overbearing and seemingly obnoxious and bossy. Underneath it he is the most anxious child possible, who can only cope in situations where he needs to be in control. And he pays the price for this socially, he isn't massively popular in his class and rarely gets asked to parties and play dates.

However, when he is invited, I spend a lot of time beforehand to minimise the anxiety by telling him and showing him (where possible), where he is going, what it looks like, what the plan is, who is going and what he will be eating. I also go over expected behaviour multiple times. I am explicit about what is and isn't appropriate. Most of the time he copes and is socially acceptable to NT people. (He explodes at home because he is like a coke bottle that has been shaken all day, but we manage that). But sometimes he isn't ok. He is now 10 so any parties tend to be drop off. I am open about his ADHD and I tell the host what to expect and that I will be nearby if there are problems, or offer to stay and supervise him myself. Thankfully most parents have been kind and there haven't been any issues.

However, it sounds from your description that John could well have additional needs - maybe they haven't been identified or diagnosed. But I can relate to sitting on my own on my phone, not wanting to engage and wanting 5 minutes of peace and hoping it's not my child causing the scene - again.

I don't think your daughter needs to be in a situation where she needs to deal with John on her birthday. It sounds like there is a solution whereby Sarah isn't invited and will never know that she was the subject of so much controversy.

But to all the posters, please don't be so scathing about being in John's mum's shoes until you have walked in them. It is utterly exhausting and lonely, often soul destroying. I cannot tell you the number of times I have had to deal with my 10 year old hitting me, breaking things and telling me to eff off in private. We have a robust behaviour plan in place, and we are totally on it in public. But I have, many times, sat there and wished I didn't have to be so switched on and alert to any possibility of a melt down. And 95% of the time in public he behaves as any other 10 year old would. So people aren't aware that he has ADHD, just that he's quite lively. But all of that comes at a massive cost to him and to us as a family.

livvymc · 13/03/2022 18:21

Why 10 pages in are people still telling the OP to give Sarah a lift or tell the mum it’s a drop off party?! If you cba reading the whole thread, at least read the OP’s posts! Hmm

NumberTheory · 13/03/2022 07:02

I would not be inviting Sarah. And in order to avoid the singling her out issue, which is unfair on Sarah and will impact class dynamics in a way that will almost certainly be negative for everyone in the class including your DD, I would alter the guest list so it isn't all the girls in the class.

We had a similar-ish situation last year where my kids (who happen to be twins in the same class) wanted an all class party except for one kid who is a bully to them in school. We ended up cutting back on numbers and making it a smaller affair so they could exclude him without it being pointed.

WTF475878237NC · 13/03/2022 03:54

Protect your kid or don't but there really is no need for it to be such a huge drama 🤷‍♀️

^ What? Posting on a parenting forum and getting other perspectives is hardly huge drama. If it winds you up don't think MN is for you.

CJsGoldfish · 13/03/2022 00:59

I never get the 'whole class' thing or 'all the girls/boys'. Why invite children yours aren't really friends with? Is it for the gifts?
What is wrong with good friends only?

Anyway, beside the point...

You cannot invite 15 girls and leave one out. That's cruel.
You also cannot control which members of the public are at a public place.
How about instead of all this angst over what MIGHT happen you make is crystal clear that John is not part of the party. I assume you'll be watching them at all times? Simply do not accept ANY signs of upset from John. If that means you tell him to move away from the party guests or remind his mother to keep him away, then do that. If it is such a problem for your child, why wouldn't you?
What are you going to do if any of the many other children there act as you believe John will? If some random boy, or girl for that matter, acts this way?
Protect your kid or don't but there really is no need for it to be such a huge drama 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread