Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people correct spelling

357 replies

Lockeddownagain · 12/03/2022 06:59

Just reading a thread on here and someone felt the need to correct the spelling of another then put sorry in brackets. They aren't sorry or they just wouldn't have done it. I'm super dyslexic and spell stuff wrong all the time but why do people need to correct it. If you are a spelling corrector would you tell me why you do it?? Thanks

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 12/03/2022 18:41

@cormorantes

There is clearly a need to correct spelling in schools, in editing, in drafting, copy writing etc. I am not sure this extends to mumsnet posts but when your job involves correcting spelling it does become habit.
My job does involve correcting people's spelling. But I'm paid to mark people's essays. I'd never do it on an online forum in a million years: I'm not an internet monitor and have quite enough of that kind of dull duty at work.

It's possible people do this under the misguided notion that it makes them appear more intelligent. It does the reverse. It simply shouts: 'this is the best I have to offer as a counter-argument'. That's aside from showing the corrector up as a rude and obnoxious, not to mention tedious, git.

The only mildly amusing instances are when the SPAG correctors get their virtual red pens to work on others' posts and are themselves wrong. Don't get me wrong, they make themselves look utter twats in any circumstances. But when they cock it up, they epitomise total twattery in a way that's quite satisfying to witness 🤣

Fedup845 · 12/03/2022 18:34

@01Madhairday your DD's manifestation of dyslexia is a sample of one, and different people with dyslexia vary enormously in terms of how much their different literacy skills are affected.

Just because she doesn't struggle with that particular grammatical concept, it does not mean that all others with dyslexia will not.

I don't expect all other dyslexics to have an identical experience to me. My reading age was always much higher than my chronological age, it was just my speed of reading that was slow, but I know that others with dyslexia can have far more difficulties with reading than simply how quickly they can do it. I wouldn't dream of telling those dyslexics that because I personally don't have too many issues with reading comprehension, then their difficulties with it are merely a "lack of knowledge".

AddictedToOlives · 12/03/2022 18:33

someone felt the need to correct the spelling of another then put sorry in brackets. They aren't sorry or they just wouldn't have done it

Think I saw this… (phased was corrected to fazed?)

Just wanted to say that I DO think the person might’ve been genuinely sorry they couldn’t resist the urge to correct (it wasn’t me btw!) but I think they did it because it is a completely different word and not just a spelling mistake.

But the OP’s meaning was still clear due to context so IMO it was still rude and unnecessary to correct.

I just think that two wrongs don’t make a right and we shouldn’t presume to know their intentions when posting

Fairislefandango · 12/03/2022 18:20

How will people learn the correct spelling if nobody tells them?

How will people learn the correct spelling from a random poster on the internet when they have failed to learn and remember it from having read the correct spelling of it (unless it's a very unusual word) countless times during their life and probably had it corrected by teachers, autocorrect and very likely already by other internet pedants? They won't. That's why they're still getting it wrong.

blacksax · 12/03/2022 18:09

How will people learn the correct spelling if nobody tells them?

Madhairday · 12/03/2022 18:01

I write and proofread for a living but I never correct spelling, grammar and punctuation on forums or posts on MN and FB etc. It upsets me when someone posts an emotive post full of pleas for help and the first few replies are corrections, because I can only imagine how the OP must feel to see her distress so minimised.

However, I do take issue with some posts here that claim that there are no posts on Mumsnet that are difficult or even impossible to understand. I've been around here a long time and have read many posts leaving my head spinning. They're generally posts without paragraphs and punctuation and it does make things difficult, even for those of us who edit professionally. If one of my clients wrote a block of text like that I'd query it so that I could get a better idea of what they were saying.

But I still wouldn't on MN, though I've been tempted - mostly when the post in question is hateful, ignorant or blatantly BU...

I really have to grit my teeth very hard for 'should of.' My DD is dyslexic and she says that using dyslexia for that one is no excuse because it doesn't have the shape of the words 'should have' - it's just a lack of knowledge. But then I think about how terrible I am with numbers, and imagine having that feeling over words and then being publicly corrected without being asked. And so I don't do it.

Fizbosshoes · 12/03/2022 15:52

My BIL is (I think) dyslexic. It is sometimes a struggle to read his messages so many words are missed or spelled wrong. Autocorrect can interpret most of the words but he doesn't use it (I've tried putting some of the words in and it does suggest the correct spelling - although I suppose that's not helpful if you don't know you've spelt it wrong)
One thing I do correct is my children's names. He consistently spells them wrong, even though one of them is in the same chat group so he only has to type @ and her name will be listed.

Fedup845 · 12/03/2022 15:46

Dyslexia in action - missing an "an" in my post above. Mumsnet could solve a lot of this debate by including an edit button.

Fedup845 · 12/03/2022 15:44

I might be banging my head against a brick wall, but I would like to flag that I don't like the way in which people on this thread keep referring to dyslexia as if were an all round impairment in cognitive ability.

What you often get with dyslexia (but not always) is exceptionally bright person who struggles to spell.
That's one of the ways that the condition is picked up, when someone's spelling ability and/or reading speed is out of sync with their high performance on other cognitive tasks.

There are benefits to being dyslexic, as opposed to neurotypical, in terms of certain tasks. GCHQ specifically try to recruit dyslexic analysts because of their superior problem solving skills, for example.

Fairislefandango · 12/03/2022 15:38

Definitely agree on not 'fixing' dyslexia.

Oh yes, definitely. But I don't think you can really 'fix' poor spelling and grammar either. It's not very easily fixable in an individual, never mind a population.

A very determined adult with poor spelling and grammar might be able to really improve if they had no dyslexia, plenty of time on their hands and a lot of motivation. But not everyone has that time and motivation.

@IdontWanna - yes, that's exactly where the 'could of' mistake comes from. There's a name for that kind of auditory interference with written accuracy I think, but I can't remember what it is!

I teach MFL not English, but I'm increasingly of the opinion that there is far too much emphasis on writing and accuracy in the early years of learning a foreign language. It puts people off and makes them unwilling to use the language to communicate, for fear of making mistakes.

ldontWanna · 12/03/2022 15:18

@sevensleeps

Definitely agree on not 'fixing' dyslexia. It's mainly the 'should of' error I find mind-boggling (again, as a non-native speaker), as it's not a misspelling but a misunderstanding of what the actual phrase is. So it would feel to me like having someone point out once what the phrase is would automatically lead to 'getting it' and then writing the correct word in the future - because then it would actually make sense! But I take the point that teachers will have pointed it out many times and if that didn't help, having a random poster point it out on a forum won't correct the misunderstanding either.
As a non native speaker all the mistakes are mind boggling for me, because in my eyes they don't mean what I want to say so it's obviously wrong. I do think it's a lot easier for us though, especially if we've learned by seeing it first.

In my opinion(and I'm no linguist ) "should of " happens because of two issues. 1.Most people when speaking tend to use the contraction "should've" (or could've or would've) . 2. The way many people and children speak of sounds like ov . Mix them up together and particularly in speech due to the sound should've becomes should of. Which then becomes habitual and customary to the person and it then translates in writing as well. Especially if they had drummed into them that that "ov/vv" sound is spelled of.

puddleduck234 · 12/03/2022 15:10

@sevensleeps

Definitely agree on not 'fixing' dyslexia. It's mainly the 'should of' error I find mind-boggling (again, as a non-native speaker), as it's not a misspelling but a misunderstanding of what the actual phrase is. So it would feel to me like having someone point out once what the phrase is would automatically lead to 'getting it' and then writing the correct word in the future - because then it would actually make sense! But I take the point that teachers will have pointed it out many times and if that didn't help, having a random poster point it out on a forum won't correct the misunderstanding either.
I think you're right it is mind boggling even to me who's got it 😂. There are things that can be put in place as it is a disability, in work you for example you can ask for extra time on written work, coloured overlays etc. in study you can ask for extra time to bring you up to the same level as everyone else's reading if that makes sense.

The sad part is because it's hidden if you are high functioning getting extra time on exams is seen as "cheating" which of course it's not.

sevensleeps · 12/03/2022 15:09

It is akin to running a white gloved finger over someone’s skirting and sneering that your home is cleaner.
Tbf there was a thread the other week about 'What do you judge in people's homes' and I found it helpful as I'd rather know from a forum what kinds of things people notice than have an actual friend judge me! Blush

oioimatey · 12/03/2022 15:00

I'd rather someone corrected me than not, as long as they don't do it in a snarky way.

Thumpkin · 12/03/2022 14:57

OP, YANBU. I’ve been a teacher of English for twenty years and this drives me absolutely insane. It’s incredibly rude to correct somebody without an invitation to do so unless it is your role to help them (a parent, a teacher, proof reading at work etc) or you know for a fact that they’d appreciate it (husband, sister etc).

It is not helpful to risk embarrassing someone, particularly if you have no idea at all about whether they have dyslexia. It is akin to running a white gloved finger over someone’s skirting and sneering that your home is cleaner.

There are people on here who who fully understand that it’s rude to ask when someone is going to have a baby but who do not grasp that it’s also pretty rude to correct someone’s spelling. If that sounds like I’m stretching it a bit, having trained as a dyslexia specialist and also seen how mortifying it is for professionals to get pulled up in public by their colleagues, I’d say there’s a similar level of mouth / brain engaging needed. Perhaps stopping to think, “Could this be really embarrassing for the person? Did they ask me to get involved? Is there information I don’t know?” might help these pedants.

Nobody died of a spelling mistake.

sevensleeps · 12/03/2022 14:55

Definitely agree on not 'fixing' dyslexia. It's mainly the 'should of' error I find mind-boggling (again, as a non-native speaker), as it's not a misspelling but a misunderstanding of what the actual phrase is. So it would feel to me like having someone point out once what the phrase is would automatically lead to 'getting it' and then writing the correct word in the future - because then it would actually make sense! But I take the point that teachers will have pointed it out many times and if that didn't help, having a random poster point it out on a forum won't correct the misunderstanding either.

Fairislefandango · 12/03/2022 14:44

So whatwouldactually fix the problem? I can see that you're right but in some way it's quite mind-boggling really.

Nothing will fix the problem. And it's a problem that's always existed. Imo some of it is down to how individual people's brains and memories work. I know that's an unfashionable view, and admittedly some of how their brains work will be down to input and influence in very early childhood. Reading a lot helps, but it's not necessarily enough to create an excellent speller. I'm the child of 'wordy', cryptic crossword fans. Dh was (and remains) a hugely prolific reader as a child, and is very bright, but has non-wordy, parents who spell quite poorly. I've been a pretty immaculate speller since an early age. Dh is... ok at spelling. Oh and the internet simultaneously doesn't help and makes poor spelling and grammar much more visible to a huge audience.

The problem in school is that a lot of what is taught does not sink in (in the long term or even the short to medium term). I'm wondering why you find it mind-boggling. After all, people are usually quite comfortable admitting that they remember practically none of what they learned in biology, geography or history at school, or that they're rubbish at maths. But for some reason they don't seem to believe that many people have a similar inability to retain spellings and grammatical knowledge.

There's also the myth that only English-speakers have poor spelling and grammar. Or that this is a relatively recent phenomenon. Neither of those things is true! It probably doesn't help that English spelling is batshit crazy, and that teaching grammar was not really done much in British state schools for generations. But bemoaning the state of a people's spelling and grammar is something that has happened throughout the ages, probably in every country in the world. I once read a glossary created by irritated monks, which was a list of 'infuriating SPAG errors everyone is making these days'. In Latin.

In the end, you have to ask yourself how much it really matters in the grand scheme of things. Getting pissed off and judging people achieves nothing. Some people write well, some don't. In most situations, the most important thing is communication.

puddleduck234 · 12/03/2022 14:39

@sevensleeps "what can fix the problem" honestly understanding the condition and other neurodivers conditions would be a massive benefit. As dyslexia is the way our brain is wired, nothing can be done to "fix" us as there is nothing to fix.

We just think differently, but have many many talents too just Google how many celebrities have dyslexia and you will be amazed by what we can achieve by thinking differently.

(Assuming that's what you were asking 😂)

sevensleeps · 12/03/2022 14:22

@Fairislefandango

Exactly. This is so, so simple and yet the people who profess to be so well educated, just can't seem to understand it.

Or they do but they think their irritation is far more important.

Yes. Thank you.

Believe me, if pointing out errors eliminated even half of the inaccuracy in students' writing (or speaking), I would be overjoyed.

You can't really believe that all those people making mistakes have never read the correct version of any of those words and grammatical structures? That they never had them corrected at school? Of course they did. It didn't fix the problem. Having them pointed out by an MNer decades later when the habits are more ingrained and the brain less adaptable is going to help even less - i.e. not at all.

So what would actually fix the problem? I can see that you're right but in some way it's quite mind-boggling really.
ldontWanna · 12/03/2022 14:04

@EatYourVegetables

Because an occasional error is understandable, but reading “ok hun i wud of done it but iv only just herd Wats going on i hope every1 s fine 2 do jt themselfes anyways da school could be a bit less lachs i daisy with comms” makes my brain hurt.
Does it? Does it really?
Becles · 12/03/2022 14:03

Someone shares this and I agree!

To not understand why people correct spelling
MajorCarolDanvers · 12/03/2022 13:49

What the heck going on with education these days?

Last 2 years have certainly been pretty catastrophic for children and young peoples education.

MajorCarolDanvers · 12/03/2022 13:41

Mostly corrections come across as smug and patronising.

mnetting · 12/03/2022 13:40

I have had people tell me I spelt my name wrong before (not on here) as if that wasn't autocorrect and I'd been confused for 38 years.

Trinacham · 12/03/2022 13:39

I saw the thread you're talking about. I did think the same. I'm pretty sure they didn't contribute to what the thread was actually about either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread