Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people correct spelling

357 replies

Lockeddownagain · 12/03/2022 06:59

Just reading a thread on here and someone felt the need to correct the spelling of another then put sorry in brackets. They aren't sorry or they just wouldn't have done it. I'm super dyslexic and spell stuff wrong all the time but why do people need to correct it. If you are a spelling corrector would you tell me why you do it?? Thanks

OP posts:
Cookiecrumble22 · 13/03/2022 14:38

@BluebellsGreenbells

You are right, dyslexia is a disability that has been diagnosed, by a professional.

But how many people claim depression and can not work? I know a few with this line and get sick notes to avoid being in work and sit at home fully paid. Full recovery and then back on the sick - it spoils it for the genuinely I’ll people who need medical intervention and rest.

Same with dyslexia, having dyslexia and claiming to be dyslexic and totally different things.

It’s also a very misunderstood conditions. Reading a writing aren’t the only signs of dyslexia.

I have dyslexia I went to a special needs school. There was no gcses taken or anything like that. I know I have another learning disability. I don't know what it's called though. All I know is when I was 8 ish I was told i was going to a special school and a bus would pick me up from home and drop me home again after school. All the words I use are quite basic. I don't use or understand hard to pronounce words. There are words on this thread that I don't use some of them I could look up. But then it won't stay in my mind . Things don't sink in. Its very hard to explain as I don't fully understand myself .
Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 14:35

but yes people do judge your intellect if you can't spell properly

Well they are very ignorant then, aren't they? It is possible to be very intelligent but poor at spelling.

What I struggle with is the sheer laziness to NOT BOTHER to find out what the correct spelling is

So a person with really poor spelling and grammar (perhaps due to poor schooling, lower than average intelligence or other disadvantages), should check every word they post on a bloody chat forum so as not to be thought lazy? Ffs.

Lots of people find it hard to retain spellings, even when they have been pointed out numerous times. And they want to be able to enjoy participating in online chat without constantly looking things up or worrying about judgmental arses sneering at them. I find it hard to believe that anyone who thinks themselves worthy to judge others for their intelligence would find that difficult to grasp.

loopylindi · 13/03/2022 14:28

I have no problem with spelling errors here, but shelf fronts in supermarkets or promotional flyers really wind me up if there are errors. Does no one proof read these things. I am that person who would go round taking shelf fronts off if there were spelling errors. Not now, shop on line

puddleduck234 · 13/03/2022 14:19

@BluebellsGreenbells but unless the individual says "I'm claiming to be this when I'm not" you don't know.

Again no one with a mental health illness is going to come into work and tell everyone what's going on in their life - however they will tell a GP who will make the decision to sign them off.

Loubilou09 · 13/03/2022 14:18

I don't feel superior, I don't enjoy putting people down but yes people do judge your intellect if you can't spell properly. It DOES matter and I like to be corrected myself.

What I struggle with is the sheer laziness to NOT BOTHER to find out what the correct spelling is, and for threads like this that sneer at those of us that do correct people instead of saying thanks for letting me know.

I want to be told, I want to look like I am intelligent and appreciate being corrected. I would hope other people would want to improve themselves too.

The classic Lose/Loose - sheer and utter laziness. The amount of people I have "corrected" who say "oh yes I always struggle with that word" and I think well bloody well look it up then, it takes literally less than a second to google....

BluebellsGreenbells · 13/03/2022 14:04

You are right, dyslexia is a disability that has been diagnosed, by a professional.

But how many people claim depression and can not work? I know a few with this line and get sick notes to avoid being in work and sit at home fully paid. Full recovery and then back on the sick - it spoils it for the genuinely I’ll people who need medical intervention and rest.

Same with dyslexia, having dyslexia and claiming to be dyslexic and totally different things.

It’s also a very misunderstood conditions. Reading a writing aren’t the only signs of dyslexia.

puddleduck234 · 13/03/2022 13:53

@BluebellsGreenbells

Would anyone on this thread ask someone using crutches to "speed up" because they are slowing the able person down? Or tell a blind person "you just need to try harder at seeing" dyslexia IS a disability under the equality act. It's is real

I agree, however a lot of people claim ‘dyslexia’ when in fact it maybe something else. Not all dyslexics are bad at spelling, nor are they unable to read. Some people just can’t be bothered.

Who are these people who "claim" dyslexia though? Is that not true of any medical condition or disability?

I'm not going to tattoo "I have dyslexia" on my forehead. Nor am I going to show my diagnostic reports to anyone who asks. I'm not ashamed of my dyslexia and happy to talk about it in real life but not everyone is.

So how do YOU know if an individual is "claiming to be dyslexic" or genuinely dyslexic?

BluebellsGreenbells · 13/03/2022 13:41

Would anyone on this thread ask someone using crutches to "speed up" because they are slowing the able person down? Or tell a blind person "you just need to try harder at seeing" dyslexia IS a disability under the equality act. It's is real

I agree, however a lot of people claim ‘dyslexia’ when in fact it maybe something else. Not all dyslexics are bad at spelling, nor are they unable to read. Some people just can’t be bothered.

ldontWanna · 13/03/2022 12:57

@Fairislefandango

OpheliaThruppsyou are looking at this from the perspective of a neurotypical person who can remember and take on new language rules when corrected.

True, but it's also the case that even neurotypical people vary enormously in how good they are at this. Even among nt, intelligent people fortunate enough to have had a good education, there are still those who are poor spellers.

It's not even about being good at it sometimes. Muscle memory and ingrained habits are a real thing. In informal settings or when speed is required the brain goes to what it knows unless people actually focus and actively try to remember what the rule or difference is.

I'll use myself as an example. I read ominous a long time ago in a book without ever hearing it. I read is as omnious, the voice in my head read it as that and it stayed that way for years until I was talking with someone and they pointed out the right way. I actually looked in the dictionary because I couldn't believe it was wrong, it looked and sounded so right to me. Even now when I know, if I'm reading it in a book or thinking about it my brain automatically reads /says it as omnious and then I have to remind myself it's wrong. It feels strange and alien the right way so it takes a conscious effort to do it that way. Luckily it's not a word I have much use for in day to day life.

puddleduck234 · 13/03/2022 12:20

I think it's apparent a lot of posters on this thread seem to think that poor writing is irritating, slows them down or that poor spellers are claiming to be dyslexic when they are not.

It's absolutely fine to not understand dyslexia, Its a hidden disability so if someone is reaching targets it may look like we fake it. (Hint we really don't and working twice as hard to keep up)

but it's really not ok when there have been plenty of posts on here explaining what it is and what individuals have trouble with to continue to claim they are being helpful or were being lazy etc. we hear these comments all the time, trust me.

Would anyone on this thread ask someone using crutches to "speed up" because they are slowing the able person down? Or tell a blind person "you just need to try harder at seeing" dyslexia IS a disability under the equality act. It's is real. But we also have ALOT of other talent which get pushed to one said because the world concentrates on this one thing we find difficult.

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 10:53

OpheliaThruppsyou are looking at this from the perspective of a neurotypical person who can remember and take on new language rules when corrected.

True, but it's also the case that even neurotypical people vary enormously in how good they are at this. Even among nt, intelligent people fortunate enough to have had a good education, there are still those who are poor spellers.

JustLyra · 13/03/2022 10:44

[quote JudyCoolibar]@Fedup845, if that's what you take from my post, you haven't read it properly. Not once did I suggest that people routinely fabricate dyslexia: as I said, I am very familiar with it and know very well the nature of the problem. I simply expressed my dislike of those people who actually are very obviously fabricating it - and trust me, you can tell. For what it's worth, I don't bother to take them up on it, life is too short and I've seen the reaction it gets on MN; so I don't go in for "unsolicited pedantry", nor I am never "horrible" to them either.

Your post is a classic example of the MN tendency to assume a lot of untrue allegations from absolutely nothing in order to be able to attack someone.[/quote]
It’s amazing that people get through school with u diagnosed dyslexia and have to go though tests if people like yourself can tell if someone has it or not just from an internet post.

I’m surprise you have time to be on here given that you must be run off your feet with people wanting your easy assessments…

Fedup845 · 13/03/2022 10:37

@OpheliaThrupps you are looking at this from the perspective of a neurotypical person who can remember and take on new language rules when corrected.

Dyslexic brains process language differently, and a simple correction will do sweet FA to help, which is why it's best that people refrain from "helpfully" pointing out SPAG errors in an OP's post, unless the error is so grave as to make the post unintelligible (which it almost never is).

OpheliaThrupps · 13/03/2022 10:29

@Babdoc

There seems a lot of defensive anger on this thread, from people who apparently want to continue mangling their grammar and spelling, and assume anyone correcting them must only be doing it out of a feeling of superiority. When I correct someone’s post, I do it from a feeling of sympathy, and a wish to explain the grammar or spelling that they manifestly do not understand, so that they will not embarrass themselves in future - perhaps in a more important context, such as at their work or on a CV. If you saw a woman walking in the street with her skirt caught up in her knickers, surely it is kinder to point it out and let her fix it, than to let her continue embarrassing herself all the way home?
I really like the knicker comparison @Babdoc Grin

I've had my written English criticised (constructively) plenty of times as an adult, by people who knew better than me. It was really helpful, and I think I write better English because of it. I would really hate to think that I was blithely making some mistake and people were just letting me carry on.

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 10:12

I find it really amusing that people actually think correcting the spelling of an adult online will actually help their employability.

As if somehow lessons that didn’t sink in, for whatever reason, during school, growing up, work etc will suddenly sink in when someone corrects them on MN.

Well quite. I've said this in a variety of ways on this thread already, but some people are hard of thinking.

The 'But what if they make the same mistake on a cv?! Shock' people also conveniently ignore the fact that people generally have spellcheck when they are typing a document on their pc or laptop, and will also check their cv or job application carefully, or get someone else to, unlike when they are posting on MN. Having poor spelling and grammar does not mean you are too stupid to grasp the difference in importance between a cv and a Mumsnet chat.

I think 95% of those who correct others' spelling online are smug, disingenuous arses. The remaining 5% are probably misguided, insensitive and perhaps a bit dim, since they fail to recognise a) that it's pointless and b) that the majority of people will find it upsetting, embarrassing or just plain annoying.

ClinkeyMonkey · 13/03/2022 10:05

I can't be doing with up-their-own-arse grammar pedants pointing out people's spelling mistakes. I have to admit, I wince when I see some of the spellings, especially those that appear over and over again, but pointing them out to the person is patronising. Maybe save your comments for the BBC and other media outlets, where SPAG errors are rife and show a lack of professionalism.

As for all this faux altruism - 'Oh, I'm just pointing out someone's mistake to HELP them' - I'm sorry, but I don't believe you. You might even have convinced yourself of your motivations, but I think you're deluded. And I think you're a dick.

Dinoteeth · 13/03/2022 09:58

HQ delete posts that are only made to correct other people's spelling and grammar, so do report them

Seriously - I'm another dyslexic, I can usually tell if a word looks right but sometimes my spell can be too far out for predictive text to correct. If it write (spelling?) After it it actually quite happy for someone to correct it.

MulticatHouse · 13/03/2022 09:53

It's irritating but I wouldn't correct someone.
Lose/loose, discusting,rediculous, rest bite are particularly annoying.

Fedup845 · 13/03/2022 09:48

I am really fascinated by how you "can tell" from a post? Seems I should have saved myself the £750 for a professional dyslexia assessment then, and just had a random pedant look at my Mumsnet posts to confirm my diagnosis?
I suggest you publise this amazingly quick forum post scanning diagnosis technique that you've pioneered. Perhaps submit it for peer review in a psychology journal? It really sounds quite revolutionary.

JudyCoolibar · 13/03/2022 09:40

@Fedup845, if that's what you take from my post, you haven't read it properly. Not once did I suggest that people routinely fabricate dyslexia: as I said, I am very familiar with it and know very well the nature of the problem. I simply expressed my dislike of those people who actually are very obviously fabricating it - and trust me, you can tell. For what it's worth, I don't bother to take them up on it, life is too short and I've seen the reaction it gets on MN; so I don't go in for "unsolicited pedantry", nor I am never "horrible" to them either.

Your post is a classic example of the MN tendency to assume a lot of untrue allegations from absolutely nothing in order to be able to attack someone.

Fedup845 · 13/03/2022 09:25

@JudyCoolibar I find your post extremely offensive. You are implying that people routinely fabricate dyslexia, and that it's possible to definitively tell from a forum post whether someone is dyslexic. In reality, the error may only be minor, as spell check helped the person out for most of their post.

Should anyone who points out that they are dyslexic (in response to your unsolicited pedantry) have to show you their educational or occupational psychologist's report, in order for you to be sure that, yes, you were, in fact, being horrible to someone with dyslexia?

JustLyra · 13/03/2022 09:01

I rarely correct though because a lot of people seem to get extremely offended. No one really cares if you use the wrong version of 'there' in a forum post, but if you use the incorrect one on a CV, spellcheck won't pick it up but a hiring manager probably will and would possibly dismiss your application.

I find it really amusing that people actually think correcting the spelling of an adult online will actually help their employability.

As if somehow lessons that didn’t sink in, for whatever reason, during school, growing up, work etc will suddenly sink in when someone corrects them on MN.

JudyCoolibar · 13/03/2022 08:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Izzabellasasperella · 13/03/2022 02:14

I once made the mistake of using brought instead of bought and two posters decided to correct me but it was done in a very mean girls way.
I would never correct someone's spelling on here. No need for it and it can be hurtful.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/03/2022 01:18

@Babdoc

There seems a lot of defensive anger on this thread, from people who apparently want to continue mangling their grammar and spelling, and assume anyone correcting them must only be doing it out of a feeling of superiority. When I correct someone’s post, I do it from a feeling of sympathy, and a wish to explain the grammar or spelling that they manifestly do not understand, so that they will not embarrass themselves in future - perhaps in a more important context, such as at their work or on a CV. If you saw a woman walking in the street with her skirt caught up in her knickers, surely it is kinder to point it out and let her fix it, than to let her continue embarrassing herself all the way home?
Wrote a long post and lost it, but basically I agree with Babdoc.

I rarely correct though because a lot of people seem to get extremely offended. No one really cares if you use the wrong version of 'there' in a forum post, but if you use the incorrect one on a CV, spellcheck won't pick it up but a hiring manager probably will and would possibly dismiss your application.

Swipe left for the next trending thread