Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people correct spelling

357 replies

Lockeddownagain · 12/03/2022 06:59

Just reading a thread on here and someone felt the need to correct the spelling of another then put sorry in brackets. They aren't sorry or they just wouldn't have done it. I'm super dyslexic and spell stuff wrong all the time but why do people need to correct it. If you are a spelling corrector would you tell me why you do it?? Thanks

OP posts:
FurbleSocks · 13/03/2022 21:27

The only time I do it is when it's sufficiently bad that it prevents me from understanding the meaning. And even then it's (hopefully) clarification rather than correction. It is a shabby habit to belittle someone to make yourself feel better.

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 21:21

So what I’m getting from this post is that it’s only ok to call someone ‘a bit dim’ if they EVER correct spelling or grammar, because of course they couldn’t possibly be doing it because they think they’re doing the person a favour, but because they’re a rampant arsehole.

Pretty much, yep. I've already nailed my colours to the mast on that one - no I do not believe that people correct strangers' SPAG on an internet forum because they believe they're doing the person a favour. I mean... ok maybe the very occasional person might think that - if they've never really given the matter much thought or noticed how badly people tend to take it when they're corrected. But it's almost always smug arseholery imo, yes.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/03/2022 21:00

So what I’m getting from this post is that it’s only ok to call someone ‘a bit dim’ if they EVER correct spelling or grammar, because of course they couldn’t possibly be doing it because they think they’re doing the person a favour, but because they’re a rampant arsehole.

👍🏻👍🏻

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 20:40

Any SPAG vigilante who has hung around on MN quite a bit cannot claim to believe that people are grateful to be corrected, because it's patently obvious that this isn't the case. Corrections are usually met with anger or upset, not just by the poster who made the error, but by lots of other posters on their behalf.

So, what the pedants presumably really mean is not 'People are grateful to be corrected', but 'People should be grateful to be corrected'. But you don't get to dictate what other people's reactions should be.

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 20:19

Do you believe that foreverything?

No, of course not! Sometimes information is of huge importance. Some things really need to be accurate.

Or is SPAG the only thing that cannot be mentioned in a genuine attempt to help somebody increase their knowledge (and, quite frankly, to stop them embarrassing themselves in front of a much wider audience)?

I don't believe for one moment that people's motive in correcting others' language is to spare them embarrassment. In many, or even most, cases it is meant to embarrass them. This is often very apparent from the tone.

And yes, I do actually think that uninvited correction of others' SPAG is very different from pointing out a mistake in facts like the ones you mention. Someone with poor spelling and grammar is likely to have worried and felt embarrassed about that since they were at school, and been criticised for it many times. They can't avoid using language, unless they never speak or write. And yet every time they write or speak, they may be wondering if someone will pick on an error they've made. I'm not sure how you can compare that with getting a fact about Eurovision wrong tbh.

PAFMO · 13/03/2022 20:13

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Sorry but that's just silly. Keyboard pedants picking on random, isolated errors in the tiny corner of the internet which they happen to frequent will not do anything to reduce this. Imagine the numbers of spelling and grammar mistakes made every day online all over the English-speaking web. Pointing out errors (whether 'gently' - i.e. patronisingly - or snarkily) will do nothing to stop people constantly seeing the wrong version.

You cannot make people's English better. You cannot correct the internet. You are not helping, you're just pissing people off for no purpose.

Do you believe that for everything? If somebody communicates something to you where they're obviously mistaken, do you pointedly never mention it?

If somebody wrote about Belgium allying with Russia against Ukraine, Sam Smith representing the UK in Eurovision or Southport having just been declared a city, would you honestly not mention it? Or is SPAG the only thing that cannot be mentioned in a genuine attempt to help somebody increase their knowledge (and, quite frankly, to stop them embarrassing themselves in front of a much wider audience)?

There is far, far too much knowledge in the world for any one person to instinctively know all of it; we all rely on each other to help us to continually learn and improve in that sphere throughout our lives.

It's NEVER done on MN out of altruistic concern for the other person. Ever. It's done to belittle and humiliate in some sort of crass one-upmanship that just proves what a nasty cunt the person doing it is.

Quite apart from the fact, as we've seen, that almost always, the twats doing the correcting know a hell of a lot less than they think they do.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/03/2022 19:41

Sorry but that's just silly. Keyboard pedants picking on random, isolated errors in the tiny corner of the internet which they happen to frequent will not do anything to reduce this. Imagine the numbers of spelling and grammar mistakes made every day online all over the English-speaking web. Pointing out errors (whether 'gently' - i.e. patronisingly - or snarkily) will do nothing to stop people constantly seeing the wrong version.

You cannot make people's English better. You cannot correct the internet. You are not helping, you're just pissing people off for no purpose.

Do you believe that for everything? If somebody communicates something to you where they're obviously mistaken, do you pointedly never mention it?

If somebody wrote about Belgium allying with Russia against Ukraine, Sam Smith representing the UK in Eurovision or Southport having just been declared a city, would you honestly not mention it? Or is SPAG the only thing that cannot be mentioned in a genuine attempt to help somebody increase their knowledge (and, quite frankly, to stop them embarrassing themselves in front of a much wider audience)?

There is far, far too much knowledge in the world for any one person to instinctively know all of it; we all rely on each other to help us to continually learn and improve in that sphere throughout our lives.

PAFMO · 13/03/2022 19:22

@Fairislefandango

If you care so much*@Loubilou09, then you will be positively ecstatic when I point out your unnecessary (and COMPLETELY WRONG) apostrophe inlot's. You're welcome.*

Grin Dammit - how on earth did I miss that?! The one time it's ok to correct a poster's language is when they are the one playing the pedant!

It's too funny, isn't it. @Loubilou09, while you're looking up some basic grammar and SPaG rules (because you need them more than anyone on this thread so far) - do a quick search for Dunning-Kruger at the same time. Educate yourself. Because, I'm sure you'd agree, to not do so would be lazy.
PAFMO · 13/03/2022 19:15

@Loubilou09

I don't feel superior, I don't enjoy putting people down but yes people do judge your intellect if you can't spell properly. It DOES matter and I like to be corrected myself.

What I struggle with is the sheer laziness to NOT BOTHER to find out what the correct spelling is, and for threads like this that sneer at those of us that do correct people instead of saying thanks for letting me know.

I want to be told, I want to look like I am intelligent and appreciate being corrected. I would hope other people would want to improve themselves too.

The classic Lose/Loose - sheer and utter laziness. The amount of people I have "corrected" who say "oh yes I always struggle with that word" and I think well bloody well look it up then, it takes literally less than a second to google....

What's that random "for" doing? We usually say "number" of people, not "amount". That's generally used for uncountable nouns though lazy People have started using it with countables.

You also appear to have lost your comma key.

Graphista · 13/03/2022 18:58

Because they're narrow minded people who like having a way to put others down - which is pathetic

There's a time and a place. I'm a lit grad I'm pretty good at spag but my typing these days needs work and my eyesight is worsening

I also have friends who are dyslexic, dyscalculic, English isn't their 1st or even 2nd or 3rd language!

On here and other sm especially it's a dick move cos people are often typing "on the hop" and not necessarily checking it all.

There's a pedants corner on here for discussing such things which can be fun but otherwise - yea dick move!

With the exception of where it's really hard to understand what the poster is trying to say but it's possible to ask for clarification on a post or just "scroll on by"

As I said my spag is good when I can express it my maths is shit and I can't draw or paint to save my life!

Everyone has different skills and abilities

anxiouslama · 13/03/2022 18:57

Drives me nuts. There is also a colleague at work who likes to flag everyone's mistakes it's so rude and unnecessary. She goes straight to the manager and in team meetings highlights it.

Thing is her work is not always perfect but none of us start on her!

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 18:56

If you care so much@Loubilou09, then you will be positively ecstatic when I point out your unnecessary (and COMPLETELY WRONG) apostrophe inlot's. You're welcome.

Grin Dammit - how on earth did I miss that?! The one time it's ok to correct a poster's language is when they are the one playing the pedant!

MajorCarolDanvers · 13/03/2022 18:41

@BluebellsGreenbells

But how many people claim depression and can not work? I know a few with this line and get sick notes to avoid being in work and sit at home fully paid

Those sick notes are signed by GPs. If you know that this is happening - have you reported this to the police?

Twopenny · 13/03/2022 18:27

My knowledge of spelling and grammar is pretty good. Somewhere between thinking and typing I often make a bit of a mess, though, and though I do proof-read my posts I usually can't see the mistakes in something I've just written, even if I re-read it six times.

I have strategies to deal with this at work. Life's to short to use those on random posts on an internet forum, though - I'd never post at all.

ClinkeyMonkey · 13/03/2022 18:01

Bold fail on the quote. But you get my drift.

ClinkeyMonkey · 13/03/2022 18:01

I care, lot's of people care. It's incorrect, it looks wrong and it makes you look less intelligent.

If you care so much @Loubilou09, then you will be positively ecstatic when I point out your unnecessary (and COMPLETELY WRONG) apostrophe in lot's. You're welcomeSmileSmile

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 18:00

It's great to be kind and nobody likes a bully, but if we get to a point where people never feel able to gently point something out, everybody else sees the incorrect version and many will subconsciously absorb it as if it must/might be correct. The end result is all of the 'should ofs' and the like becoming de facto accepted as 'correct'.

Sorry but that's just silly. Keyboard pedants picking on random, isolated errors in the tiny corner of the internet which they happen to frequent will not do anything to reduce this. Imagine the numbers of spelling and grammar mistakes made every day online all over the English-speaking web. Pointing out errors (whether 'gently' - i.e. patronisingly - or snarkily) will do nothing to stop people constantly seeing the wrong version.

You cannot make people's English better. You cannot correct the internet. You are not helping, you're just pissing people off for no purpose.

Barbie222 · 13/03/2022 17:47

I agree @KittyWithStripes .

drawingpad · 13/03/2022 17:47

care, lot's of people care. It's incorrect, it looks wrong and it makes you look less intelligent.

I mean if anyones looking less intelligent right now it's almost certainly not the people making spelling mistakes...

KittyWithStripes · 13/03/2022 17:40

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Are we assuming that all bad spelling is the result of dyslexia, though? None of the many spelling errors we see all the time are made by anybody without dyslexia? Obviously, there will be typos and stupid autocorrects, but IF it wasn't done by mistake/because of dyslexia and comes from a point of ignorance, would you not want to learn? How is it particularly different from any other error, really?

Just supposing I were to go off on a rant about the USA's reaction to Russia's actions and demand that Trump should put his foot down and start acting like a real leader, I would want people to point out that one particular area of my knowledge that's clearly not correct - better to be embarrassed briefly than allowed to continue indefinitely, IF it were something that I could easily learn and remember.

It's great to be kind and nobody likes a bully, but if we get to a point where people never feel able to gently point something out, everybody else sees the incorrect version and many will subconsciously absorb it as if it must/might be correct. The end result is all of the 'should ofs' and the like becoming de facto accepted as 'correct'.

Whatever the reasons behind it, if a post is full of spelling errors - maybe grammar and punctuation errors too, as well as one massive unseparated paragraph, I will often find it just too incoherent to understand and have to give up. I'm not claiming that the odd error/typo will render it thus, but would people really not want to know that, having posted something and earnestly awaiting responses and engagement, they aren't likely to get anything - not because nobody likes them or is interested in the subject, but because they've just communicated in such a way that they effectively haven't really posted at all?

Again, this.
ldontWanna · 13/03/2022 17:29

@Loubilou09 that's the second time you mentioned LOOKING intelligent. So this is just basic snobbery,all about optics and image?

Just because you(and others) assume someone is less intelligent because of their spelling, that's your failure not theirs.

Just because you(and others) find your worth and value in what others think, while other people don't, that's your failure not theirs.

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 17:18

I care, lot's of people care. It's incorrect, it looks wrong and it makes you look less intelligent.

Some people are less intelligent. Others have other reasons why they aren't great at spelling. Why is that your problem? How does it impact you if a stranger 'makes themselves look less intelligent'? Less intelligent than what/whom, anyway? You?

Loubilou09 · 13/03/2022 16:58

@Dinoteeth

The classic Lose/Loose - sheer and utter laziness. The amount of people I have "corrected" who say "oh yes I always struggle with that word" and I think well bloody well look it up then, it takes literally less than a second to google....

Those kinds of errors are easy to understand and why bothering to Google for a daft chat forum.
Who really cares if it's wrong?

I care, lot's of people care. It's incorrect, it looks wrong and it makes you look less intelligent.
Dinoteeth · 13/03/2022 15:34

The classic Lose/Loose - sheer and utter laziness. The amount of people I have "corrected" who say "oh yes I always struggle with that word" and I think well bloody well look it up then, it takes literally less than a second to google....

Those kinds of errors are easy to understand and why bothering to Google for a daft chat forum.
Who really cares if it's wrong?

ldontWanna · 13/03/2022 14:52

@Loubilou09

I don't feel superior, I don't enjoy putting people down but yes people do judge your intellect if you can't spell properly. It DOES matter and I like to be corrected myself.

What I struggle with is the sheer laziness to NOT BOTHER to find out what the correct spelling is, and for threads like this that sneer at those of us that do correct people instead of saying thanks for letting me know.

I want to be told, I want to look like I am intelligent and appreciate being corrected. I would hope other people would want to improve themselves too.

The classic Lose/Loose - sheer and utter laziness. The amount of people I have "corrected" who say "oh yes I always struggle with that word" and I think well bloody well look it up then, it takes literally less than a second to google....

It doesn't take a second though to completely change muscle memory and for the brain to replace previous information and associations. Took me ages to get the correct spelling of exercise without thinking about it first.
Swipe left for the next trending thread