Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people correct spelling

357 replies

Lockeddownagain · 12/03/2022 06:59

Just reading a thread on here and someone felt the need to correct the spelling of another then put sorry in brackets. They aren't sorry or they just wouldn't have done it. I'm super dyslexic and spell stuff wrong all the time but why do people need to correct it. If you are a spelling corrector would you tell me why you do it?? Thanks

OP posts:
MountainDweller · 13/03/2022 23:29

@XenoBitch I was just answering the original question, which was why do people do it? I do it because it's my job. I don't make a habit of doing it here, unless I don't understand something. I find it tiring that those of us who fight for correct English are sneered at.

XenoBitch · 13/03/2022 23:28

[quote MountainDweller]@XenoBitch, I have so much more! It's such a fulfilling career. Experience as production editor, book editor, project editor, proof-reader, sub-editor, copy editor and writer, working for some of the country's major newsstand publications, plus work in an extremely specialised niche area of publishing. I've been freelance for 25 years and love the variety. People ask me back so I guess I'm doing a pretty good job! [/quote]
Oh, so basically it is along the lines of you feeling superior to whoever dared to spell something wrong?

drawingpad · 13/03/2022 23:26

@MountainDweller

It's actually my job - sometimes it spills over into my social life.

It's actually quite jarring to read things that are not correct. It's impossible not to see them, if your brain works that way.

It's a shame no one cares about getting written words right any more.

I'm actually not too bad at spelling. I'm terrible at explaining. I'm not the most articulate and often struggle to find the correct words to get my point across correctly. I'm autistic and this isn't something that will change. So no, I don't care much for getting written words right, but I do care about getting the overall message across correctly.

MountainDweller · 13/03/2022 23:26

@XenoBitch, I have so much more! It's such a fulfilling career. Experience as production editor, book editor, project editor, proof-reader, sub-editor, copy editor and writer, working for some of the country's major newsstand publications, plus work in an extremely specialised niche area of publishing. I've been freelance for 25 years and love the variety. People ask me back so I guess I'm doing a pretty good job!

JustLyra · 13/03/2022 23:26

@MountainDweller

It's actually my job - sometimes it spills over into my social life.

It's actually quite jarring to read things that are not correct. It's impossible not to see them, if your brain works that way.

It's a shame no one cares about getting written words right any more.

It’s no-ones job to correct people on social media.

Only self appointed jobs exist in that field.

It’s actually quite jarring to see people use spag, when very few (if any) people actively choose to be poor at it, as a tool to kick other people with.

It’s a shame some folks just don’t care about humiliating or belittling people with their self appointed jobs.

XenoBitch · 13/03/2022 23:22

@MountainDweller

It's actually my job - sometimes it spills over into my social life.

It's actually quite jarring to read things that are not correct. It's impossible not to see them, if your brain works that way.

It's a shame no one cares about getting written words right any more.

So, what happens if you see someone spell something wrong? Yeah, nothing.
MountainDweller · 13/03/2022 23:19

It's actually my job - sometimes it spills over into my social life.

It's actually quite jarring to read things that are not correct. It's impossible not to see them, if your brain works that way.

It's a shame no one cares about getting written words right any more.

Dinoteeth · 13/03/2022 23:15

I don't buy the insistence that "It's only an internet forum, why does it matter?" Whydoesn'tit matter if you not only struggle to communicate properly with others across the world using the modern world's main communication method, but you actuallydon't careif you can't? Why would you deliberately choose to be held back, if you didn't need to?

What pish. There is a huge difference between typing stuff on a phone for the heck of it. And typing stuff on a computer with proper keyboard, spell and grammar checker.
The stuff that gets written on MN under a hidden identity is not going to make s blind bit of difference to how I'll get on in life.
Spelling is not all it's cracked up to be.

I've got a Ed Phycoligist report that tells me in not thick. I also have a degree and professional qualifications.
But the Ed Phcologist report gotten at the age of 33 tells me my degree wasn't a flook . I needed to know properly not on a we think, she's probably, I needed to see it in black and white £500 for the privilege.

Interestly my DS is in the same boat I can't decide if I should blow the cash for him to get a proper assessment or not.

XenoBitch · 13/03/2022 23:15

If all you have to bring to the table is the correcting of spelling, then have a good, hard look at yourself.

FantasticFebruary · 13/03/2022 23:12

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

Spelling/grammar mistakes do make me wince, especially if they’re of the very basic type - it’s/its, your/you’re, etc. - and I do wonder why anyone of average intelligence can’t sort these things out. They really are not difficult!

But I’ve only ever corrected anyone once - on a largely male forum where some smartarse had corrected someone else - and made a basic mistake in his own post. I did enjoy that! 😈

The most cringe-making correction I ever saw was on a members-only forum, where many of us knew each other or had at least met, and someone who’d obviously always thought herself superior, corrected - on the open forum when she could have sent a pm - someone who’d used a Latin phrase incorrectly.

Appalling!

Do you think you could have a word with my iPhone? It appears to have been sent to me to make me appear barely literate!!

One I'll 'own up to' is our/are I'd NEVER write the incorrect one, but I frequently type the incorrect one! I forget what it's called, but I was pleased to read it's a 'thing'

JustLyra · 13/03/2022 22:53

I don't buy the insistence that "It's only an internet forum, why does it matter?" Why doesn't it matter if you not only struggle to communicate properly with others across the world using the modern world's main communication method, but you actually don't care if you can't?

Because the vast, vast majority of the time they are not struggling to communicate. It’s usually very obvious what they mean.

JustLyra · 13/03/2022 22:52

It’s possible they feel that if they don’t correct, they’d be quietly condoning the watering down of specifics, or correctness

The use of “condoning” rather says it all really.

People do it because they feel they have the right to “condone” - or not - how people speak and write. Language should only evolve in the way they agree with.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/03/2022 22:51

If you read it out, and it sounds the same, then I can not get worked up about the spelling. Bear/bare, your/you're.. etc.
It is being pedantic for the sake of it. You know what the poster is trying to say. MN is not an academic essay.

It isn't always clear. Why do you think language evolved with so many variations of spellings for homophonic words meaning different things, if only the sound of the word is important in conveying meaning (in the absence of aural tone and context)?

I get that there's a huge spectrum between the stereotypical caveman pointing at everything he sees and saying "Ug, ug" and a paragraph of beautiful, grammatically-perfect prose, but why draw the acceptable balance bar so low?

In most human endeavours, we toil endlessly to improve continually - be it an athlete wanting to shave a hundredth of a second off their time or the most minor little comfort or safety tweaks in cars - why do we care so little when it comes to language?

I don't buy the insistence that "It's only an internet forum, why does it matter?" Why doesn't it matter if you not only struggle to communicate properly with others across the world using the modern world's main communication method, but you actually don't care if you can't? Why would you deliberately choose to be held back, if you didn't need to?

There are many millions of people across the world now who speak English as a second, third, fourth, fifth language, to a much higher standard than a great many native/monoglot English speakers do - and are apparently content for that to remain the case, even down to just not bothering to click on the red line that prompts you of a mistake and gives you the correction. I really struggle to understand why.

Derelicthome · 13/03/2022 22:40

Because they want to discredit and humiliate the poster making the mistake.

Fairislefandango · 13/03/2022 22:40

However some mistakes should be identified and corrected. Elementary errors/misuse such as these are especially irksome because it could be confusing for the reader. “Your” vs “you’re” “Bear with me” vs “bare with me” “Then” vs “than”

They aren't confusing for the reader though, are they. It's always perfectly obvious from context what is meant. Unless, for example, you think that someone is asking you to join them in stripping off when they say "bare with me".

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/03/2022 22:34

I don't think I've ever actually corrected somebody's SPAG on here myself - unless you count using the correct spelling in responding, which I suppose some may take as passive-aggressive antagonistic, e.g.

"Am I just being a marta?"
"No, I don't think you're being a martyr as such...."

I hesitate when responding to people who use text speak, as I personally don't ever do this. Do they think I'm being PA or trying to 'put them in their place' when I respond in full words and sentences? I certainly hope not, as that is not my intention at all.

However, I respectfully disagree that all/most people who correct or seek to clarify spellings are doing so to put somebody down or try to express their perceived superiority. Yes, many are; but by no means all.

Not quite the same thing, but people also frequently do it when somebody uses an outdated term that many now find offensive: yes, you'll get the ones telling the person what a disgusting, hateful human being they are for using such a nasty word, but many others will sincerely respond to the question/issue that has been raised and then, at the end, add "by the way, OP, XX is actually now widely considered to be an offensive term by the people to whom it is used to refer - the accepted term that you should use now is YY." It's said nicely, but in a clear way that the person should learn not to use it again - even if the person has only ever known and used that word and/or has a condition or personal circumstances that make learning language adaptations very difficult indeed for them.

XenoBitch · 13/03/2022 22:33

@roastedsaltedpeanut

I don’t do it on mumsnet, online or in any social settling. I can’t be bothered.

However some mistakes should be identified and corrected. Elementary errors/misuse such as these are especially irksome because it could be confusing for the reader.
“Your” vs “you’re”
“Bear with me” vs “bare with me”
“Then” vs “than”

Misspelled words such as Play date spelled as olaydate doesn’t bother me in the least and I would be annoyed if someone is pedantic enough to correct that!

If you read it out, and it sounds the same, then I can not get worked up about the spelling. Bear/bare, your/you're.. etc. It is being pedantic for the sake of it. You know what the poster is trying to say. MN is not an academic essay.
Morethanwordsonapage · 13/03/2022 22:31

I’d guess it’s to protect a bank of words they hold dear, in other words, language they have learned and built upon, a wealth of words, known correctly. It’s possible they feel that if they don’t correct, they’d be quietly condoning the watering down of specifics, or correctness. But someone is bound to say language changes and evolves. Yes, yes it does. Even more reason to be precise then.

Note, with ‘they’, I mean people like me. And, not sorry. Also, I probably care more as I studied linguistics.

roastedsaltedpeanut · 13/03/2022 22:28

I don’t do it on mumsnet, online or in any social settling. I can’t be bothered.

However some mistakes should be identified and corrected. Elementary errors/misuse such as these are especially irksome because it could be confusing for the reader.
“Your” vs “you’re”
“Bear with me” vs “bare with me”
“Then” vs “than”

Misspelled words such as Play date spelled as olaydate doesn’t bother me in the least and I would be annoyed if someone is pedantic enough to correct that!

FantasticFebruary · 13/03/2022 22:24

@oakleaffy

Edit...I made an accidental mistake in my post. Am happy to be corrected. :)
It made me laugh!! But I've run out of red ink ShockSmile
XenoBitch · 13/03/2022 22:18

I only ever see stuff like this as a way to try and get the upper hand when an argument has failed. It is petty and patronising.

Unless you are writing an academic piece, most people will understand what you are saying regardless of bad spelling.

For the record, I had a ton of red lines under words when I typed this comment.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 13/03/2022 22:14

I used to be regularly ridiculed for my poor mental arithmetic skills when I was younger - is this the same thing? Were people doing it to make themselves feel superior?

NorthSouthcatlady · 13/03/2022 22:12

Constant typos and spelling mistakes are annoying and distracting. Plus the lose / loose confusion is infuriating

ldontWanna · 13/03/2022 22:08

Most posters on here that correct other people's grammar.

To not understand why people correct spelling
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/03/2022 22:01

@ClinkeyMonkey

I can't be doing with up-their-own-arse grammar pedants pointing out people's spelling mistakes. I have to admit, I wince when I see some of the spellings, especially those that appear over and over again, but pointing them out to the person is patronising. Maybe save your comments for the BBC and other media outlets, where SPAG errors are rife and show a lack of professionalism.

As for all this faux altruism - 'Oh, I'm just pointing out someone's mistake to HELP them' - I'm sorry, but I don't believe you. You might even have convinced yourself of your motivations, but I think you're deluded. And I think you're a dick.

Top post. 👏👏👏

I'm amused by a different post upthread which makes references to posters sneering at those who take it upon themselves to offer unsolicited correction of others posts. It's even more amusing to read some people's professed motivation for doing so. 'Out of sympathy' is currently my favourite.

Fellow-MNers really don't need others' sympathy because they've committed the cardinal sin of making a SPAG blooper. The fact that they're not falling over themselves to say a meek 'thank you' won't come as a surprise to anyone other than the corrector (although I'm mildly surprised @Loubilou09 hasn't thanked those posters who kindly did her this service, having claimed that they so much like and appreciate it ...)

Correct others' SPAG, then you might find your manners corrected in turn. That's fine and dandy: you clearly have no issue with doing the same to another poster. And, after all, someone has kindly taken time out of their day to help you.

You should be grateful Smile

Swipe left for the next trending thread