Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ignore this bananas lawyers letter from ex?

160 replies

nomdeplooom · 12/03/2022 00:40

(Namechanged to avoid further bananas behaviour)

Separated from ex husband 11 years ago. Been with partner for 10 years and have two DC by ex- 16&14yold.

To cut a very long story short - Ex has what I reckon is a personality disorder. He's been diagnosed with both severe clinical depression and bi-polar in past, but because of his behaviour, it's hard to know what's true and what's been embellished as he LOVES the dramaaaa.

The past 11 years have been pretty hairy - lots of girlfriends, only one of which stuck around for any real time - no job, mental health rollercoaster, unsettled and struggling on the whole. Lots of anger towards me and my partner. Periods of being very unreliable with contact, but until they were teens, they wanted to see him when he was able to take them, and for spells he was better. You could be certain that the good spells wouldn't last though, and usually it was no money to see them (no job for 10 years), or too ill - both physically and mentally. Most of the effort he made with them was on social media - Loads of daily texts/messages. I'd see his texts and they were embarrassingly - all teenage 'yo girlfiend!' jargon and trying to be 'one of them' - desperately compensation for a lack of real parenting. He still believes that they have a 'magical relationship' (according to his enormous ranting emails).

Fast fwd to covid - lockdown, and eldest's mental health declined and turned out she was self harming. Obviously got her help/support and in talking to counsellor she opened up about her dad and how she was struggling to deal with him - she'd go for the weekend and he'd stay in bed, his moods would be up and down, and she hated his girlfriend, who he split from but was still on the scene. Lots came out she'd never told me. This also triggered conversations with my youngest who felt similarly about her discomfort when staying with him. When lockdown eased off there was a decision to be made about going for Xmas and they eventually said they'd go (it was his turn). I got a call on xmas day asking to be picked up - his behaviour was unstable (lots of gaslighting and 'you hate me etc' - all the things he used to do to me) and it frightened them. After that everything changed - they stopped wanting to see him and they spoke much more about how they felt uncomfortable and unsafe (not in a physical sense, but in the sense that he'd put them in risky situations and didn't take care of them properly).

Because he has so much resentment against me, the kids not wanting to see him anymore has caused an increase in friction. Lots of emails demanding contact, calling me every name under the sun, and he refuses to believe it's their decision - I must have manipulated them blahblah. He pestered them on social media to the extent they blocked him and has refused to take their very valid concerns on board. We've all now blocked him on all platforms and moved home, not telling him our new address. He lives about 30mins away and turned up at their school with letters for them, which school refused to give them. They have regular nightmare about seeing him and I'm arranging counselling as it's really affected them, causing anxiety and stress. Despite this, since they stopped seeing him, my eldest has stopped self harming and got straight As in her prelims.

Today I got a letter (at my work) from a solicitor saying he's concerned about his children's welfare and that we need to put the youngest (he can't do anything about eldest as she's over 16) back in touch with him immediately. They requested a response from our solicitor.

AIBU to toss that shit in the bin and just keep ploughing onward - or does he stand a chance in court? Surely you can't force a 14 year old to do anything they don't want to do! She's adamant she doesn't want to see him and turned down an offer of mediation.

OP posts:
HotDogKetchup · 12/03/2022 08:02

Solicitors will write a letter with (almost) any content their asked. It doesn’t necessarily mean they have a sound legal argument.

Donkeyinamanger · 12/03/2022 08:00

I am glad to see you plan to get legal advice. I think the letter needs a response. You need to keep in mind how it will look to the court if he does take it further. On paper it currently looks like he is a concerned father, who does not know where his DC are currently living, and has genuine concerns for their welfare. You, or a solicitor on your behalf, can respond with an explanation of the true situation, which will make it pretty clear that there would be little point taking this further.

Your DD's are very lucky that you had the strength to walk away, and to keep fighting their corner now.

Liveandkicking · 12/03/2022 07:59

Personally I would ignore him until you actually get taken to court but be compiling evidence e.g letter from GP, school, counsellor. I would also let school know that you are safeguarding your children from their dad because they don’t want to see him and he has severe mental health difficulties which have put the kids welfare in jeapody.
But a family solicitor will advise the best legal route.

knittingaddict · 12/03/2022 07:58

@FancyAFlapjack

There is some naive and misleading advice on here. Your ex-H may well be hoping that you do ignore the letter, which he will then use as ammunition against you - parental alienation is now recognised by family courts(despite being total junk science).

Do not ignore the letter - take it to a solicitor.

The children are 14 and 16. They are old enough now to make up their own minds about contact. If they were younger I would agree with you.
SoupDragon · 12/03/2022 07:45

he's like a dark shadow following us around...

For that reason, I wouldn't ignore it, I'd try to get rid of him properly (legally. Not by murdering him!).

alwayswrighty · 12/03/2022 07:41

@nomdeplooom I agree with @Willyoujustbequiet in that it would be best to drag it out until she is 16.

@Willyoujustbequiet it's interesting that you say dv cases tend to be the ones where parental alienation happens. This is exactly what happened to me I was the victimand as a woman it was very hard psychologically to lose residence of my dd. Alienation happened within 2 years and it has been brutal. The carrot continually gets dangled and then snatched away.

FancyAFlapjack · 12/03/2022 07:35

There is some naive and misleading advice on here. Your ex-H may well be hoping that you do ignore the letter, which he will then use as ammunition against you - parental alienation is now recognised by family courts(despite being total junk science).

Do not ignore the letter - take it to a solicitor.

JudgeRindersMinder · 12/03/2022 07:35

@pinkstinks

Also how dare he send a letter like that to your work. How inappropriate. You might not work there. Can you take a copy and then return To sender as not known at this address??
This was my first thought too.
Lagarthatheviking · 12/03/2022 07:34

Can he prove that you received the letter? Did you personally sign for it?
If not then ignore totally and do not acknowledge receipt….

Refuse to sign for any future letters.
That should drag it out a bit!

MakingProgress2022 · 12/03/2022 07:34

I had this. Abusive EXH. Legal advice was that at at 14, and fully Gillick competent, there is no way child will be forced into contact. Just won’t happen.

Solictor wrote a letter explaining this and stating that if EXH wants, he can make an application to court, but that at this age, child’s wishes and feelings will be the determining factor. Also that if efforts at unwanted contact continue, police will be notified as harassment (EXH was continually trying to make contact).

That shut EXh up. No response.

I’d suggest getting a sol to write a letter.mine cost £170. It was probably the best £170 I’ve ever spent.

ScreamIntoTheWind · 12/03/2022 07:33

I’m sure your solicitor would be equally reassuring

ScreamIntoTheWind · 12/03/2022 07:32

I’d also say the OP is almost certainly in Scotland (the clue is the prelims). The system and processes are different.

A 14 year old will be listened to. Even more so as she’ll be 15/16 by the time it ever got near a sheriff.

He’s got no job. He can’t afford court action anyway. Paying for a solicitor’s letter to make you feel threatened is likely the limit of his means.

ScreamIntoTheWind · 12/03/2022 07:29

There’s also proof that they have reported welfare concerns - from the counselling.

Moodycow78 · 12/03/2022 07:28

Ignore it, she's 14 it won't make it to court and if it does they'll ask her what she wants and take the lead from her

ScreamIntoTheWind · 12/03/2022 07:27

The youngest is 14 and says she feels unsafe and abused by him. Seriously, no sheriff is going to force her to see him. She has the right to decide for herself.

Don’t bother with a solicitor - unless he’s actually taking you to court. You can email the solicitor back yourself to say that both girls have reported serious welfare concerns when in his care and do not want to see him because they will be in situations where they feel unsafe. You look forward to hearing how he plans to rectify this.

A solicitor’s letter is just a letter. Nothing more.

Lynseylou1 · 12/03/2022 07:23

Try not to worry about it, if he does go to court for private proceedings your children would be allocated a guardian who would speak to them and get their views. the court absolutely would listen to the views of a 13/14 year old and as previous people have said no one can physically force a child to go if they don't want to go. if an order was made then you only have to make the children available for contact if they choose not to go then thats their choice.

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/03/2022 07:20

@BigOlDingleSlinger69

I have both professional and personal experience in this area. Children are forced into contact with abusive men. It's a fact unfortunately. Whilst the vast majority of custody cases are settled outside of court of those that do end in proceedings (approx 10%) applicant fathers are more successful than mothers. This is particularly the case where there are allegations of abuse. Domestic abuse victims are 5 times more likely to have false allegations of parental alienation levelled against them - it is recognised as a tool abusive men use to continue control of their victims.

I know of one case where the father had been convicted of sexual abuse, served several years in prison and was still awarded unsupervised contact. The mother was threatened with reversal of residency by CAFCASS if she refused to comply. I've posted about it before.

The recent Dispatches episode Torn Apart about how contact is enforced is an eye opener and demonstrates the broken family court system.

I don't want to panic the OP. Children are listened to as they get older to but in many cases their wishes are overridden for the desire by CAFCASS to promote contact with both parents. For those saying it would never happen with a 14 year old I can assure you it can and does.

Fortunately for the op due to the pandemic backlog the average case is taking 18 months which will mean their dc are far closer to 16. That's if he even attempts it. It's more likely just sabre rattling and empty threats which is so often the case with deadbeat fathers.

By far your best bet OP is just to delay and drag things out as long as you can Flowers

GCAndProud · 12/03/2022 07:19

Just to reassure you, OP, he won’t get legal aid for this, even if he is on benefits. Legal aid is not available for these sorts of matters anymore, unless he is a victim of domestic abuse (if you’re in England/Wales). So he won’t be able to afford to keep going with a solicitor. I would probably ignore for now too but then if you get anything else or a threat of legal proceedings, you will need to reply just to ensure that you look reasonable in the eyes of the court.

Very very very unlikely that they would force a 14 yo to see her father, especially with the clear evidence of his instability.

knittingaddict · 12/03/2022 07:15

@Lockheart

Your solicitor needs to respond to the letter, you don't have to give him contact immediately. Do not ignore the letter. If it goes to court that will not reflect well on you.
Not necessarily. You can pay a solicitor to write anything. It has no more legality than if he had written the letter himself. The op doesn't need to employ her own solicitor to reply either. They aren't in a legal process, but of course op can talk to one if she wishes.
pinkstinks · 12/03/2022 07:14

Also how dare he send a letter like that to your work. How inappropriate. You might not work there. Can you take a copy and then return
To sender as not known at this address??

TheOnlyMrsW · 12/03/2022 07:12

OP are you in Scotland (mention of prelims instead of mocks is something I've only heard there 🙂)? I don't know the ins and outs but do know that some elements of law are different to England if you are........ personally I would take advice from a family lawyer rather than ignore completely just in case.
Regardless of that your ex sounds a complete twunt and you have done everything possible to make sure your lovely DC have the best outcomes. Hope they are both ok Flowers

RantyAunty · 12/03/2022 07:04

I'd keep the letter and ignore him.

He won't do anything. He's too broke and lazy to take you to court.

diamondpony80 · 12/03/2022 07:00

He sounds very like a narcissist ex I know. Not mine thank goodness, but the behaviour sounds very similar, even down to the solicitor's letter about his "concern". I'd ignore. Luckily your kids are old enough to see through him and to make their own decisions.

Baaaa · 12/03/2022 06:58

Could you write back yourself and say you've suggested mediation to her and she had refused that option along with any other contact but knows it is available should she change her mind? I have no idea if that will work but I can't see the point if paying a solicitor if you can just write it yourself.

Beautiful3 · 12/03/2022 06:53

You sound like a great mum, you're putting the children first. I'd ignore it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread