Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Swimming lessons for 4 year old.

89 replies

EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 20:57

My 4 year old is a total non-swimmer. We've been to the pool a few times and she splashes about a bit in the shallows mostly. I've tried to get a feel for swimming by getting her too hold on to the side and kick, or kick while I support her, but I've no idea what I'm doing.

She didn't go swimming due to Covid then we relocated and she's been on a waiting list for months.

Finally at the top of the list. She has a place in a preschooler class for 3-4 year olds. It's in the "small" pool, which is very shallow at one end and up to my shoulders at the deep end. The pool is divided in two for lessons and her class is in the deeper half.

I'm not allowed poolside, I know this is normal and the reasons for this, don't really like it though! The first battle will be actually having her be willing to go in, she won't know anyone . Anyway I'm trying to make her feel excited and grown up.

No arm bands are used. Don't like this either for a total non swimmer in the deeper half of the pool, but I know the reasons for this.

There is a ratio of 8 children to 1 teacher. So there will be 16 children in the pool with 2 teachers and 2 lifeguard watching. I don't like this either ! It seems too many kids!

I've spoken to the teacher about my concerns and she's lovely and I'm sure a great teacher... but I still feel uneasy about it.

I tend to be an anxious parent.... I know this. And I know she needs to learn to swim.

If I could find private lessons with a much smaller child ratio I would , but there doesn't seem to be anything around !

Would you all be ok with these lessons ? Am I being silly?

OP posts:
tiggergoesbounce · 12/03/2022 08:23

Our DS is 4.5 and is only about 96cms at last measure, so we have a "little one" as well.

We luckily dropped upon a class that was 4 children to one instructor in a private pool, but lesson locally are so hard to find, if we wouldn't have found her we would still be on a waiting list for all the others.

Providing they meet the legal criteria for ratio, i would give it a try and see how they get on. If they hate it after a couple of lessons bring them out.
They will deal with non swimmers all the time, especially after lock down and kids missing out
They should know how to make the children feel comfortable.

But i would try this one out before travelling an hour for a lesson.

EezyOozy · 12/03/2022 08:15

@Meatshake Good point about classes being by ability not by age… I did raise this and I was told that since she was four she needs to go into the class I've described, she would in fact be much better off in a younger class/less able with more attention.

OP posts:
Meatshake · 12/03/2022 08:14

The swimming lessons I take my children to dont switch by age but by ability. So my 3 year old is in a parent and child class with a 5 year old who is in my eldest reception class. He can't touch the floor, and he does wear armbands even though I'm in the pool with him.

On the other hand my reception child (5) has moved up from "parent with child", "beginner", "beginner with confidence" and is now in an improver class where she is learning strokes and diving with 5-7 year olds. She swims without armbands or a parent in 3 metre deep water in a class of 8.

I'd feel unsettled at the blanket "no parents, no armbands rule" personally.

HelloDulling · 12/03/2022 08:06

We did one to one classes, with the teachers in the water. It’s very expensive, but they come on so, so much.

EezyOozy · 12/03/2022 07:58

And the first lesson he let go of the side and fell in the water and the teacher was away with another kid and another member of staff had to jump in to pull him out. My worst nightmare came true.

Sorry this happened, it's dreadful. This is my nightmare to... 8 kids per teacher, 16 kids in the pool, 1 lifeguard....

OP posts:
EezyOozy · 12/03/2022 07:57

Thanks everyone, fairly balanced / mixed responses which tells me I'm not being totally unreasonable . The point about minimal learning time per child is also a good one. I'll keep looking for something better (and probably costly)... I may have to send her. Still not 100% sure it's a great idea.

OP posts:
EezyOozy · 12/03/2022 07:55

@RewildingAmbridge yes she is small!

OP posts:
HalloHello · 12/03/2022 07:55

My nearly 4 yo daughter is confident in the water and goes to lessons on her own but would not like to not touch the bottom, that seems really weird! My local pool won't even do lessons for under 8s as they haven't got a shallow enough pool so we have to take her further away for her lessons. She is in a preschool group and is 4 kids to 1 instructor. I definitely wouldn't be happy with your child's set up. Is there somewhere else you can enroll her, or someone who does 1 on 1 lessons maybe? In the first instance, I'd be taking my daughter once a week myself to get her used to the water, and the pool noodles so she gets a bit more confident!

turkeylurkeyl · 12/03/2022 07:52

I think the depth and you not being pool side is ok. Very normal for lessons around here.
But my daughters lessons are 1 instructor to 3 children so 1:8 seems a bit crap in terms of individual time per child, but maybe we're just lucky and 1:8 is the norm.

Ultimately though OP, at 4 I would just give it a go and try and get her swimming.

HoppingPavlova · 12/03/2022 07:49

I don’t think the ratio sounds right. I’m sure it was smaller for mine at that age. There was another swim thread similar to this in the last few days and I recall asking one of my kids who was a swim instructor while going through uni what the ratio was at 3yo and I wrote it there. I think it was 1:5 also with a supervisor looking over all lessons lanes (constantly observe instructor competency and that there wasn’t a kid on the bottom of the pool), but they are out and about atm so I can’t check.

Not your fault at all OP, but yet another hidden Covid casualty - 4yo’s that have missed a few years already and just starting to learnShock. Kids have been the real victims of Covid in so many ways.

Iveonlygoneanddoneit · 12/03/2022 07:46

I signed my son up. 4-1 ratio. Thought It would be fine. He was 3 when he started. And the first lesson he let go of the side and fell in the water and the teacher was away with another kid and another member of staff had to jump in to pull him out. My worst nightmare came true.
I swapped him to the very expensive 2:1 class in a smaller private pool.
He lost confidence after falling in. But he’s now much more confident and actually starting to swim!

RewildingAmbridge · 12/03/2022 07:39

Are you sure she's only 90cm that's very small for a 4 year old , even if that's accurate it means she's only slightly out of her depth and will have a noodle/float

EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 22:17

Thanks @AlmostAlwyn that was helpful!

OP posts:
EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 22:13

My daughter is around 90-95cm tall.

OP posts:
EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 22:11

@Bananarama21 not deck level sadly , quite challenging to climb out even for me!

OP posts:
AlmostAlwyn · 11/03/2022 22:09

*I should just clarify - it's not a "baby pool" as under 3s aren't allowed in the pool at all Smile

Bananarama21 · 11/03/2022 22:07

I've taught in 1 metres deep where I work previously but smaller groups of 6 some kids were fine starting others couldn't. Is it a deck level pool I find that helps.

EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 22:06

@Bananarama21 I've just checked online and it's 1m deep, thank you

OP posts:
AlmostAlwyn · 11/03/2022 22:03

Covid also delayed swimming lessons for my 4 year old, but we started lessons in September/October last year (can't remember exactly) when he was 4.5 in a parent and child class, so I go in the pool with him with the teacher giving instructions. It's a baby pool and he can reach the bottom even in the "deep" end. There's usually about 6 kids in the class and each has their own parent there so it's really nice! My child would absolutely NOT have gone to a lesson like you describe. I just wouldn't have been able to persuade him to go in. He regularly tells me that he wants me to "cancel swimming" (even though he's doing well!).

I guess none of that is very helpful, sorry! Perhaps do some swimming just the two of you for a term and see if they've got a summer course once she's got some experience with you? Most of what we've been doing is getting the kids used to the water (blowing on it, blowing bubbles, blowing a ping pong ball around), jumping in (DS is just now getting comfortable jumping in without me catching him), and putting their heads under (putting their faces in, going under their float), which wouldn't be too difficult to do with her on your own? We just use a normal swimming float for practicing kicking (occasionally a float belt), no arm bands. DS does like his goggles though!

Bananarama21 · 11/03/2022 21:54

I also have a just turned 6 year old in my stage 6/7, so some kids just take to it. I have him in my 4 and he's like a little fish!

Bananarama21 · 11/03/2022 21:52

Hi I'm a swimming teacher, ratio is fine I teach 8 ducklings aged 3-5. We don't tend to use arm bands unless they can barley touch the floor which is rare or they are abit unsteady. Our pool depth is 0.80m can I ask what depth it is? I do alot of movement in the water, walking,turning so they are comfortable and know they can always put their feet down i reinforce this when they start swimming and I get them to kick across ten metres . Some of the stuff they do is brilliant and some of my ducklings have now processed through the programme one is now in stage 4, I've got loads currently in my 2/3s swimming that I taught in ducklings. We do allow parents to sit on poolside though.

FloodTheBathroom · 11/03/2022 21:51

We go with Puddleducks and the parents/carer goes in with them til they are 4 or competent to move up a class. I don't like that ratio, myself, but I guess it must work as that's what they do.

EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 21:46

@NumberTheory you make good points thank you!

OP posts:
EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 21:45

Thank you, there wasn't any mention of a block when I was querying these my concerns, but I can go back and ask.

I'm even looking at the expensive 2-to-1 lessons (I have a three-year-old as well) in hotels etc. Maybe if I could do something like that until they are slightly more competent, then use the council pool lessons afterwards.

There may be something in a private class 45 minutes away so I've emailed about that …… Other than that it might be an hour or more drive each way.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 11/03/2022 21:44

I agree the ratio doesn't sound great.

Your DD won't be the first total nonswimmer they've had. They will have a process for keeping them safe and the lifeguard will be watching. But with that ration I don't see how they're going to get on that fast as the teacher will presumably have to do a lot of one on one work. So a 30 minute class could mean just a couple of minutes of actual instruction each.

Can you watch from a balcony?

Since it sounds like swimming classes are hard to come by, it might be worth trying it for a few weeks and seeing how it goes.

But I think the fashion for learning to swim so young is not particularly useful. There was a time when 6 or 7 years olds were off out playing by themselves and so swimming was probably more important if they ended up playing in water. But I suspect very few kids who get swimming lessons so young are off out by themselves at that age. You could just wait until she's a bit older. The point is to have them swimming confidently and with good watersense by the time they are teenagers - which is when there is a bigger risk of drowning as they go off by themselves, try things out, take risks, etc.

Keep taking her to the pool and improve her water confidence playing with you one on one, but don't bother with lessons until she's 7 or 8.