Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Swimming lessons for 4 year old.

89 replies

EezyOozy · 11/03/2022 20:57

My 4 year old is a total non-swimmer. We've been to the pool a few times and she splashes about a bit in the shallows mostly. I've tried to get a feel for swimming by getting her too hold on to the side and kick, or kick while I support her, but I've no idea what I'm doing.

She didn't go swimming due to Covid then we relocated and she's been on a waiting list for months.

Finally at the top of the list. She has a place in a preschooler class for 3-4 year olds. It's in the "small" pool, which is very shallow at one end and up to my shoulders at the deep end. The pool is divided in two for lessons and her class is in the deeper half.

I'm not allowed poolside, I know this is normal and the reasons for this, don't really like it though! The first battle will be actually having her be willing to go in, she won't know anyone . Anyway I'm trying to make her feel excited and grown up.

No arm bands are used. Don't like this either for a total non swimmer in the deeper half of the pool, but I know the reasons for this.

There is a ratio of 8 children to 1 teacher. So there will be 16 children in the pool with 2 teachers and 2 lifeguard watching. I don't like this either ! It seems too many kids!

I've spoken to the teacher about my concerns and she's lovely and I'm sure a great teacher... but I still feel uneasy about it.

I tend to be an anxious parent.... I know this. And I know she needs to learn to swim.

If I could find private lessons with a much smaller child ratio I would , but there doesn't seem to be anything around !

Would you all be ok with these lessons ? Am I being silly?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bananarama21 · 14/03/2022 20:55

Pythonesque depends on the teacher, can affect outcomes and how much they push them.Sometimes we do adapt the programme and introduce things earlier but on principle it's a good programme. I worked at a private swim school where stage 3s did breathing to the side, I found
the kids struggles as they didn't have a strong enough leg kick and ended stuck up in the stage for ages and got bored. It was good for introducing dolphin and frog leg kick though! That swim school didn't do lengths and having those kids from that swim school move over to our learn to swim they didn't have the stamia albeit good technique. Having taught both I prefer the swim England framework but il introduce things earlier such a breathing and push children where I can to be better. I agree some kids just can't do butterfly and if they can do everything else in stage 7 but
not butterfly to the swim england il sign them off its just using common sense.

Satsumaeater · 14/03/2022 18:52

I think the Swim England framework is more geared to producing swimmers for clubs and beyond (there was a thread on here recently about the need to do butterfly - my ds didn't have to do butterfly perfectly to progress through the stages, but a lot of swim schools are stricter and that does create bottlenecks in the system I think).

When I learnt to swim it was get down the pool any old how to get the badges and I only learnt proper bilateral swimming as an adult. So proper technique is important, but there's a balance.

Pythonesque · 14/03/2022 17:52

But, does the Swim England programme actually work that well???
(I agree that learning doggy paddle is counterproductive for many though)

I grew up in Australia, didn't enter a pool till I was 6.5 due to ear problems, then started lessons over the summer prior to changing to a school that had its own pool thus regular swimming half the year from the start. My sister two years younger learnt at the same time and I don't think it was that long before we were 10-25 m competent. Despite me having poor gross motor coordination generally.

When my eldest started swimming lessons in the UK I found the progression baffling and agonisingly slow. Lessons with my youngest worked even less well (and for various reasons he ended up vaguely water safe but not really a swimmer till a crash course age 13). I have not been impressed by the Swim England programme in terms of it reliably building skills in good progression. A few years since I last looked at it and I realise things changed, but back when my eldest was in lessons they actually taught some things that essentially had to be reversed in the next stage.

The big thing I have come to realise, pondering this over the years, is that when I learned to swim, we had a lesson, then stayed at the pool for a little while and practiced some more. This just doesn't happen in the UK where you need indoor pools and space is at such a premium, so when your lesson is over there's no free swimming, the whole pool is still in lesson-mode.

Bananarama21 · 13/03/2022 13:19

SkankingMopoke The 25% who leave primary unable to swim 25m aren't the DCs who attend swimming lessons at 5yo not necessarily correct many cancel lessons simply because they cannot afford them or they have additional children and can't afford to pay for them all.

SkankingMopoke · 13/03/2022 10:39

@Bananarama21

Troublesometooth frontcrawl 25 metres face in or doggy paddle?

Even before the pandemic, a quarter of children could not swim the statutory 25m by the end of year 6. The report says this will rise to 57 per cent of year 7s by 2025/26 unless some form of catch-up provision is put in place. Statically 1 in 4 children could not swim 25 metres by the end of leaving primary school. So when I hear all these amazing 5 years olds that can swim 25 metres is hard to believe, I'm not saying it doesn't happen, however it's a rarely happens.

Maybe it varies by area? 25m at 5yo may not be the norm here, but it's not unusual. Both my DCs got their 100m at ~5.5yo. DD2 is still currently 5yo (got her 100m in October), and swims in stage 5. They don't get many 5yo in stage 5, but it isn't unusual to see a few 6yo in each class. The swim teachers who also take the school lessons at our pool say that the DCs are usually either already reasonably competent swimmers or still complete beginners by the time they are coming with school. The 25% who leave primary unable to swim 25m aren't the DCs who attend swimming lessons at 5yo.
SleeplessWB · 13/03/2022 08:07

My daughter is nearly 7 and has been following swim England since age 3 (with gaps for covid) without me in the pool. I am not sure of her stage but she swims in the main pool and can confidently swim a length of front crawl or backstroke using proper strokes and breathing. She can also swim underwater and do sitting dives. They never use armbands.

ISmellBurnings · 13/03/2022 07:50

Mine follow the Swim England programme. I’ve just looked at the website. I don’t think I’ve seen mine ever do doggy paddle.

Wish I’d been taught to swim properly.

Bananarama21 · 13/03/2022 07:41

I find it weird that by your own admission you say that 5 year olds can't often swim the width of an Olympic pool unaided. I tell you that my daughter's class can all do that (albeit via doggy paddle, breast stroke and on their backs without using arms)
Looking at the programme and swim England which is the swimming governing body the difference is massive and the programme your on is designed to keep kids in longer.

The doggy paddle which shouldn't be taught and use of arm bands is puzzling to me as a teacher, such a pointless exercise.
She's tried a couple of arms at front crawl but it's not a continuous movement with side breathing yet

That suggests she hasn't been taught to keep her face in long enough to blow all the bubbles out before turning her head. Il leave it now but professional opinion the programme doesn't compare to the Swim England framework, it's frustrating as a teacher when I heard about doggy paddle and use of arm bands its just not necessary.

Meatshake · 13/03/2022 00:20

Where are you getting that she's not got her face in the water? Her face is in the damn water, she pops up to breathe then her face is back in. She's been practicing that since she got to the swim school. Or is there something else I'm missing when you say aquatic breathing? She's kicking her legs, her arms just aren't at that fluid clockwork proficiency yet. But that's because she's only a few weeks in to learning it.

Where are you getting that she's wearing the armbands to learn strokes? As I've said they jump in with armbands, doggy paddle and play a bit to warm up and get used to being in the water, jump out, armbands off, down to business.

I find it weird that by your own admission you say that 5 year olds can't often swim the width of an Olympic pool unaided. I tell you that my daughter's class can all do that (albeit via doggy paddle, breast stroke and on their backs without using arms) and you tell me that your program is better and express concern. Respectfully, I will have to disagree with you and the results from the 6-8 year olds in the next class up who swim their strokes beautifully would suggest that they are at least on a par with your own swim program.

I'm done derailing the thread now.

Snaketime · 12/03/2022 23:44

My DS is 4 and goes to swimming lessons, I am not allowed poolside, he has swimming aids on (a bit like armbands but just the thin circular ones) there are about 10 or more kids in his class (I've never really counted them), 2 teachers and a lifeguard. He has been in this class since he was 3.

Bananarama21 · 12/03/2022 22:10

She's tried a couple of arms at front crawl but it's not a continuous movement with side breathing yet there's no aquatic breathing that's why, she needs to be able to maintain her breathing blowing bubbles and coordinating her arms and legs before she could even think about learning to breathe to the side. Which would be stage 2 level. Meatshake

Bananarama21 · 12/03/2022 22:07

Meatshake I'm an ASA qualified teacher doesnt mean I would reorganise the staging programme. There's a reason Swim England framework works. Check it out on their website you can see the difference. I'm shaking my head at the doggy paddle its just teaching them poor techniques which will become habit and harder to correct when teaching front crawl. Arm bands are bouyoancy aids for swimming to keep a child afloat they shouldn't be used on a child who can swim they reduce moment in front crawl reducing the arm pull movement and recovering hence why they can only do doggy paddle. I'm baffled to be honest. I get my stage 4s swimming down from 2 metres swimming 25metres full front crawl, I'm ouzzled why they do the arm pull and no frog legs. They do breastroke and butterfly in stage 4.

whatajuckingfoke · 12/03/2022 21:25

I have managed to get my children into lessons on their own with a swimming teacher with sole use of the pool, so two children (3 and 6) and a teacher, but I also have to get in too to support the 3 year old when needed who can't touch the bottom.

I had to wait two years on a waiting list though and take a slot at an inconvenient time when it came up though! Unsurprisingly it's quite expensive too.

cigarettesNalcohol · 12/03/2022 21:18

YABU. She'll be fine :)
Without you near by, she might surprise you and be totally ok about the whole thing. You're overthinking it.

Meatshake · 12/03/2022 21:15

@Bananarama21

Meatshake so they aren't actually following the Swim England framework then? Where is the Aquatic breathing if they are doing doggy paddle? We do tiger arms in ducklings with a woggle to touch on it but stage 1 is face in kicking across with a float face in for 5 metres on their front and on their back with a float 5 metres. Our stage 2 we introduce front crawl for 5 metres face in and they learn to swim without a float on their back none of them wear armbands.. Honest as a trained school and learn 2 swim teacher it doesn't sound good and if anything it encourage poor technique for Aquatic and buoyancy (e.g floating, correct body position for swimming) these are the fundamentals which are the starting point for learning to swim. It doesn't sound like they remotely need armbands whatsoever. I actually do more in my ducklings class in terms of buoyancy and breathing than what you have described.
Hmm interesting, I'm having a look at the swim England criteria, I'd say with confidence that she could do all of grade 3, most of grade 4 and 3/4 bits of grade 5. The bit they're missing is the strokes, which is what they're working on now.

Looking at the swim school's website, it's been designed by two ASA qualified teachers.

It's just the warm up couple of widths that's doggy paddle. I think the armbands thing for warm up is a psychological thing more than anything. They all get a bit excited when it's time to take them off and get keen to prove that they can do it. Makes sense because they are young kids in a 3.5m deep pool. A lot of the stuff they do seems to be thought through from a psychological perspective, calling arm bands "swim muscles" and the deep end "the big blue".

They do lots of buoyancy stuff, it's what I meant as part of their widths- they'll go across and log roll from front to back and back again, do push and glides with faces in the water, they play "swim swim freeze" a lot (they float on freeze). Positioning is important, quite often the teacher will get one kid to demonstrate something they're doing particularly well (today it was a girl swimming on her back and being particularly floaty/straight with her tummy up). I know my kid gets reminded frequently to "kick her socks off" and not let her legs drop.

The stroke practice is fairly basic because they're currently new to it. She's ok-ish at breaststroke, can't do arms and legs at the same time with back crawl. She's tried a couple of arms at front crawl but it's not a continuous movement with side breathing yet. I can see the foundations there though so I'm very happy with her progress.

BogRollBOGOF · 12/03/2022 20:30

I couldn't swim 25m until I had 1:1 lessons with an instructor in the water with me.
DM didn't do swimming because it was cold and wet and intermittent school lessons from y2 to y6 (more than most schools have access to now, and many have lost their pools due to reaching end of life and maintainence costs) with an instructor standing at the side, flailing around and yelling into all the background noise of the water, echo and other flailing instructors managed to teach me pretty much nothing. Dyspraxia could be a factor too.

Access to swimming is poor. It costs money and time in transport. It needs willing parents. Practice. Lessons, and getting back to the original theme of the thread, lessons can be hard to find capacity in. Even within a swim school, capacity can be an issue. DS1 lost a year- he was ready to move out of stage 4 in January 2020 and there wasn't space to move him up before March 2020. He didn't get back to the pool until September (better than many) then progress was frozen for a couple of months while children returned to standard and classes stabilised. I finally managed to move him up in the December before he lost another 3 months to lockdown. DS2 was similar, literally passed on 16/3/2020 but still took a while for capacity to open up in the next stage.

Wildly off topic now Grin

1:1 lessons do pay for themselves with the improved rate of progress and contact time. Although we've stuck with group lessons for the convenient time slots, DS1 has dyspraxia and would get stuck on skills when younger (often took 12-18m per stage) and holiday sessions of 1:1 or intensive courses did help boost him.
As he's got older, the swimming content improves, he's got the foundation and naturally actually swims in leisure sessions and they haven't been needed.

Troublesometooth · 12/03/2022 19:58

@Bananarama21

Troublesometooth frontcrawl 25 metres face in or doggy paddle?

Even before the pandemic, a quarter of children could not swim the statutory 25m by the end of year 6. The report says this will rise to 57 per cent of year 7s by 2025/26 unless some form of catch-up provision is put in place. Statically 1 in 4 children could not swim 25 metres by the end of leaving primary school. So when I hear all these amazing 5 years olds that can swim 25 metres is hard to believe, I'm not saying it doesn't happen, however it's a rarely happens.

Face in, front crawl with side breathing. He can also easily do it back stroke.

I’m honestly amazed that some year 6’s can’t swim 25m! I assumed all 5 year olds were similar to the ones I know. We do have an absolutely amazing swim school, but I assumed other areas would have similar.

BogRollBOGOF · 12/03/2022 18:33

@HoppingPavlova

Laugh quietly all you want but it’s a relief to have young kids that are water safe and can swim. Yes, am in Australia and our kids generally swim by 5yo - because if they don’t high chance they will drown so it’s a pretty big incentive. I personally don’t know of any 5yo that couldn’t do the width of an Olympic pool unaided but there would be some, particularly as the demographic is changing. Oddly, immigrants don’t tend to place store on water safety and swimming (which reflects in rescue and drowning numbers), but first gen tends to follow the traditional route of starting water familiarisation and safety as babies.

There were no swim schools around when I was young but there were always a few informal schools in each neighbourhood (known as a backyard pool where someone took some cash) and we had all learnt to swim by the time we started school. Those who were good at it and wanted to pursue it then had training at the Olympic pools (pretty much each metro council had one), but no learn to swim schools to get you to that point like there are now, just Marjorie over in the next street at number 12Grin.

There just aren't the opportunities to replicate that level of experience in the UK. Only the very affluent have the land to have private pools, outdoor/ open water is cold for the vast majority of the year, and there just isn't the public pool provision to pick up the slack. Then the pool programmes are very congested (ironically often with lessons) so the windows avaliable to casually swim for fun are very limited, and you have to go for lessons to get a regular spot.

School swimming isn't standardised in approach but there's about a year's worth of lessons at some point between 7-11. Some do it in a block. Some do it a term at a time.

DS2's y4's just lost half their lessons to Covid issues and donating time to the year above so they got something. Most of our school have extra-curricular lessons and are the better swimmers out of schools in the city. We ended up with half swimming 25m competently, â…”s swimming 25m at all, and 5 or 6 in the class not ready to try. Without Covid issues DS1's year had all swimming or trying 25m but a couple still reaching for the side for confidence. Without Covid, in areas where the access to private lessons, the outcomes for 8-9 yo's is more like the ratios in DS2's class. There just isn't the infrastructure to get more children swimming cheaply.

Culture also affects access to swimming with rates of swimmers differing in different communities.

Bananarama21 · 12/03/2022 18:26

Troublesometooth frontcrawl 25 metres face in or doggy paddle?

Even before the pandemic, a quarter of children could not swim the statutory 25m by the end of year 6. The report says this will rise to 57 per cent of year 7s by 2025/26 unless some form of catch-up provision is put in place. Statically 1 in 4 children could not swim 25 metres by the end of leaving primary school. So when I hear all these amazing 5 years olds that can swim 25 metres is hard to believe, I'm not saying it doesn't happen, however it's a rarely happens.

Troublesometooth · 12/03/2022 18:22

@Bananarama21

ISmellBurnings11Troublesometooth

I teach school swimming aswell as learn to swim its rare we get children swimming that distance at that 5 as they might not have developed a strong enough leg kick its uncommon and rarely happens I've seen it happen about twice. I do have 7 year olds in stage 5s who swim 50 metres so that wouldn't be a surprise. 9 year old could potentially be a club swimmer so wouldn't suprise me those ages are different to a size of 5 year old child though on build and power alone.

At the swim school my child goes to (which most of his school and our village use) the majority of children are swimming 25m by age 6 at the latest.
Bananarama21 · 12/03/2022 18:19

I just followed their link you provided and they have zero clue how to run a swim programme. I'm actually gobsmacked, head out of the water first thing we teach them in ducklings and blowing bubbles kicking with their face in, in stage 1.

NumberTheory · 12/03/2022 18:18

@HoppingPavlova

Laugh quietly all you want but it’s a relief to have young kids that are water safe and can swim. Yes, am in Australia and our kids generally swim by 5yo - because if they don’t high chance they will drown so it’s a pretty big incentive. I personally don’t know of any 5yo that couldn’t do the width of an Olympic pool unaided but there would be some, particularly as the demographic is changing. Oddly, immigrants don’t tend to place store on water safety and swimming (which reflects in rescue and drowning numbers), but first gen tends to follow the traditional route of starting water familiarisation and safety as babies.

There were no swim schools around when I was young but there were always a few informal schools in each neighbourhood (known as a backyard pool where someone took some cash) and we had all learnt to swim by the time we started school. Those who were good at it and wanted to pursue it then had training at the Olympic pools (pretty much each metro council had one), but no learn to swim schools to get you to that point like there are now, just Marjorie over in the next street at number 12Grin.

Royal Life Saving Australia found that even amoung children attending private swimming lessons in Australia, the average age to be able to swim a width of an Olympic pool (25m) was 9+. Less than 10% of 5 year olds could swim over 15m. www.royallifesaving.com.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/37553/RLS_SwimSchoolData_BenchmarkReport_Part1_FINAL.pdf
Bananarama21 · 12/03/2022 18:15

Meatshake so they aren't actually following the Swim England framework then? Where is the Aquatic breathing if they are doing doggy paddle? We do tiger arms in ducklings with a woggle to touch on it but stage 1 is face in kicking across with a float face in for 5 metres on their front and on their back with a float 5 metres. Our stage 2 we introduce front crawl for 5 metres face in and they learn to swim without a float on their back none of them wear armbands.. Honest as a trained school and learn 2 swim teacher it doesn't sound good and if anything it encourage poor technique for Aquatic and buoyancy (e.g floating, correct body position for swimming) these are the fundamentals which are the starting point for learning to swim. It doesn't sound like they remotely need armbands whatsoever. I actually do more in my ducklings class in terms of buoyancy and breathing than what you have described.

Meatshake · 12/03/2022 17:56

@Bananarama21

Meatshake

I would be interested to know the stage your talking about? I've been a swimming teacher for several years and never known that to be the case. I do have 6/7 year olds in stage 4 where they are working towards swim 25metres. I have one 5 year old in stage 5, and the 6 year old in stage 6/7 I mentioned it's considered to be rare they all swim properly no armbands. Also why on earth would a class have arm bands on if they can swim in the first place its completely pointless for the 40 percent of the time. It actuallt alters buoyancy and limits movement, in particular the arm pull in front crawl and backstroke. I'm guessing they are swimming doggy paddle not front crawl?

The flow of the lesson is that they start off with 1 or 2 foam disks, do a doggy paddle esque warm up, practice some skills, then take them off to do widths, strokes, and play games. My kid understands the movements for breast stroke and front crawl but isn't quite there yet. They line up, do some jumping in, swim across and climb out. They're learning the fundamentals for diving (sit on the side, arms out, head down, fall in). At the end of the class they go down to the shallow end to practice swimming underwater and duck diving.

The school run their own grading system, (www.theswimschool.co.uk/swim-grades) but I can categorically state that all of the children in my daughter's improver class spend at least half the 45 min lesson without armbands. Her cousin is in the class and she turns 6 in a couple of weeks, there's a little boy who was 5 at Xmas and my kid turned 5 in November. The rest of the class of 8 are a bit older 6 or 7 I believe.

Bananarama21 · 12/03/2022 17:37

ISmellBurnings11Troublesometooth

I teach school swimming aswell as learn to swim its rare we get children swimming that distance at that 5 as they might not have developed a strong enough leg kick its uncommon and rarely happens I've seen it happen about twice. I do have 7 year olds in stage 5s who swim 50 metres so that wouldn't be a surprise. 9 year old could potentially be a club swimmer so wouldn't suprise me those ages are different to a size of 5 year old child though on build and power alone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread