Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be allowed to invite friends over

110 replies

LonelyInAutumn · 11/03/2022 12:37

So, I'm 23 and I'm in my second year of uni. First year we were in lockdown so wasn't able to make friends. This year, I made a group of friends (7 including me) and this is the first time in my life I've ever had a group of friends and I'm just so happy and excited.

I'm 23 and still live at home (yes I'm aiming to move out but not possible atm before anyone says anything) so I asked my mom if I could invite my friends over and the conversation went like this:

Me: "Mom, would I be able to have my friends over tomorrow?"

Mom: "(silence)... well, I want to say yes but..."

Me: "but what?"

Mom: "I'm just really territorial and I don't want other peoples smells here. I like the house to be clean."

Me: "okay then."

Is this a "normal" response? Also before anyone else asks, I do pay rent/housekeeping, I cook 90% of the meals and I clean the house every sunday (mopping, dusting, hoovering. I do it on sundays because my mom goes to her boyfriends house and it's easier for me to do it while the house is empty) so it's not that I sit at home doing nothing.

AIBU to have asked in the first place?

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 11/03/2022 14:46

I think you need to accept this as one of the downsides to living in someone else's home.

Try to remember your dm is doing you a huge favour by supporting you to live in her house and this isn't something you are entitled to.

AffIt · 11/03/2022 14:40

Honestly, this thread is turning into whatever the parent of an adult child version of a 'cool wife' is: 'yes, my 25-year-old son regularly turns up with a dozen of his closest friends and we don't give a toss'.

Clearly, the OP's mother DOES give a toss, for some possibly very complicated reasons, and the OP is trying to be thoughtful and respectful and find solutions that work for both of them.

Living at home as an adult is not ideal and there needs to be give and take on both sides, but ultimately the person whose name is on the mortgage / tenancy agreement has the final say.

mnetting · 11/03/2022 14:26

My children never have to ask, first I know is when their friends just turn up and in they come.

LonelyInAutumn · 11/03/2022 14:22

@godmum56 I did mention my concerns earlier up the thread. Being worried about having to move back home after leaving uni halls unless I can find a job immediately after graduating. I will have a proper think about it though :)

OP posts:
notacooldad · 11/03/2022 14:21

People of 23 don't usually have friends over if still living with their parents. Meet them in town
Says who?
DS2 often had his mates round. He’d give me the heads up that they were coming over. They would take over the middle room after chatting with me and DH for a bit. It was great to hear them laugh and chat.

My friend and son bought a house recently and she spent time looking for a house that had a separate room downstairs where her 25 year old had enough space for friends could come and chill or play their music.

6 friends doesn’t sound bad at all. It’s a decent number I usually have that many for the ‘girls at my gaf’ night.

Would a coffee / lunch date with one of your friends be a reasonable starting point for her? crikey I wouldn’t want to be that friend. I’d feel like I was being examined or interrogated or something. Why would I want to go for lunch with someone’s mum when it’s the op I’m friends with. What if mum doesn’t like me at the end of the lunch. It’s a massive backfire!

I’m surprised though at 23 mum doesn’t know any of the 6 friends already.

godmum56 · 11/03/2022 14:20

[quote LonelyInAutumn]@godmum56 if I could move out sooner, I would. I understand you need to earn a certain income to be considered. Even working part time combined with maintenance loan may not be enough for me. Not to mention, my savings are going on driving lessons atm so by having a license opportunities for employment are better :)[/quote]
uni halls of residence or housing?

AdrianCanChaseMe · 11/03/2022 14:18

7 people is a lot to have over all at once particularly staying over night.

If you want to invite whoever you want over, you need to move out on your own. But it seems like you understand that already

incognitoforthisone · 11/03/2022 14:17

It's not so much the saying no that's not normal (although I do think most parents would be fine with their adult child having a few uni friends over) but the reason she's given.

She appears to think having people at the house will contaminate it in some way, and no, that's normal at all. That's essentially an OCD behaviour.

My mum's neighbour has OCD and she won't let people in the house because they might ask to use the bathroom and she can't handle the idea of someone else using her loo and 'making it dirty'. She knows it's super irrational and silly, but she can't quite overcome it.

GoldFigure · 11/03/2022 14:15

I think moving out for your 3rd year might be a really good idea. It would give you a chance to grow your wings a bit but it's time limited. The perfect chance to try moving out without it being a huge commitment. Most uni students default back home after, for a while, and parents expect it because you wouldn't have fully moved out IYSWIM. A less scary way for you both to trial living apart.

I think your mum is a bit unusual, but people are and we can only cope with what we can cope with. Friends will understand not everyone can host. Just be the person who organises stuff out sometimes - cinema , meals. If you are keen to cater and have transport, some country parks have BBQ areas you can hire in the summer.

Blossom64265 · 11/03/2022 14:13

Since she is going to be away, it is hard to see why you couldn’t at least have a few people over.

That said, even though you paying some rent, if you can’t actually afford to move out, that means she is still subsidizing you and it remains her home, not a communal space. If you were in a student hall or a shared house, you would have more freedom.

LonelyInAutumn · 11/03/2022 14:12

@godmum56 if I could move out sooner, I would. I understand you need to earn a certain income to be considered. Even working part time combined with maintenance loan may not be enough for me. Not to mention, my savings are going on driving lessons atm so by having a license opportunities for employment are better :)

OP posts:
godmum56 · 11/03/2022 14:05

No its not normal. I get that your Mum has problems but well its odd that she doesn't mind the smells at her boyfriend's house? Are you sre its only OCD? is there no way that you can move out sooner? your Mum sounds a bit controlling to me.

Rno3gfr · 11/03/2022 14:02

I’m normally inclined to agree with whoever owns the house but that does sound like a very daft excuse!! She doesn’t want other people’s smells in the house- that made me laugh out loud. I do think it’s unreasonable since she’ll be out anyway and it sounds like you’re quite respectful with the house. I’m 24 and I get that I must be so frustrating for you not even to be able to invite friends around when she’s not in...my mum is a bit like that too (although I moved out when I was 18).

I’d understand if she were home and just didn’t want a group of people to descend upon the house while she’s trying to relax but that’s obviously not the case. You’re young adults, not a group of reckless teens!

Ozanj · 11/03/2022 14:02

If you do the cleaning then her saying no because of the mess is a nasty thing to say. Research how much a professional cleaner would cost in your area and tell her you’re deducting it from your board.

tunnocksreturns2019 · 11/03/2022 13:59

@Mischance

When mine were late teenagers/young adults I used to welcome their friends with open arms - at least I knew where they were and what they were doing? Smile

Honestly your Mum is being unreasonable here. It is clear that you have form for taking care of the home, and that you are not a drunken layabout.

I think it is significant that this is the first time you have had a group of friends and can't help but wonder if your Mum might be a part of that. Could you talk to her about it again and reassure her - no smoking, no mess etc. And if she is not even going to be there then she is being very unreasonable - you cannot live her OCD life.

I agree with this post.

Also you are doing most of the cleaning for your household, cooking nearly all meals AND paying rent and yet you still can’t have friends over?

If you were my DD I’d probably make you guys a cake to enjoy - seeing as I don’t seem to have to do much else! And I’d love meeting your friends.

I think you need to move out asap, but also that your mum may not cope when you do. But please don’t let that stop you.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/03/2022 13:55

It isn't normal, but I wonder if your dm has her own issues, and she has the right to feel safe in her home.

I think the solution is getting your own place tbh.

Wimpeyspread · 11/03/2022 13:53

My god there are some weird people on here! No wonder people grow up with relationship problems

SleeplessInEngland · 11/03/2022 13:53

A) That's a really weird thing for your mum to say. Is it in character? Is she a germ-phobe/clean-freak?

B) That said, inviting 6 friends over is quite a lot (albeit not a crazy amount). Maybe it'd just be easier to meet at the pub?

LonelyInAutumn · 11/03/2022 13:52

@HumourReplacementTherapy I can see what you mean 😅

OP posts:
LonelyInAutumn · 11/03/2022 13:51

@RockinHorseShit thank you for your perspective. You sound awesome :)

OP posts:
HumourReplacementTherapy · 11/03/2022 13:48

My DS's are 20 & 22 and the thought of seven of their mates descending on me doesn't appeal Grin
In the summer it would be ok but we've not really got room for 8 men and their trainers in the house.
It kinda stopped really once they started going out out. Occasionally for prinks about a dozen or so would descend for a few hours but they were loud and messy.

RockinHorseShit · 11/03/2022 13:48

That's the point though @LonelyInAutumn I really am not at all open to it, I hate it, but I put my own shit aside & do it for my DD as I have respect for the fact that she is a young adult & does have a say

LonelyInAutumn · 11/03/2022 13:45

@RockinHorseShit I wish my mom was more open to guests/partners like you 😅 It did make me sad that she wasn't interested which makes me worry for future relationships as my mom (and future partner) is important to me

OP posts:
balalake · 11/03/2022 13:43

Considerate and reasonable to have asked, strange response. I could understand anyone not wanting visitors in their house currently given Covid 19 is still with us, but not because of the reason given.

RockinHorseShit · 11/03/2022 13:38

When I was with my ex bf it was very hard. My mom refused to meet him (even in a public place) so he wasn't even allowed to come over during the day for some lunch or something. Having people over has always been a difficult thing for me if I'm honest

I'm sorry, but as someone who also doesn't like visitors, your DM needs to fucking get over herself. That is a disgusting way to treat you & as much as I understand your DMs need for space, I could never do this to my daughter.

DDs BF stays here frequently & both DH & I wanted to meet him because A, he's important to DD & B, it was important to us to suss him out too. She's an adult at 19. Your DM really is treating you very badly, especially when yiu pay your way too. My DD doesn't yet, but I still wouldn't even think to treat her like she's a 5 yo with no say

Swipe left for the next trending thread