Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not push my child in to sport

111 replies

Backtothefutureagain · 11/03/2022 09:55

Ds is just about to turn 6
He goes to a swimming class once a week
We tried him with football when he was 4-5yo and he enjoyed it for a month or so as he was with his friends but suddenly he didn’t want to go any more and he is still adamant he doesn’t like football, no interest when it’s on tv or if dh says let’s go and play football etc
Ds has become really in to his gaming, wanting to play on the switch a lot (was Dh’s console) which we allow with time constraints
My dh is concerned hes going to be a “gamer” rather than out playing sports with his friends. He’s always trying to suggest different sports clubs to ds and feels like we’ve somehow failed him!! I keep trying to reiterate to dh that ds is only 5 and there’s plenty of time for him to find sports he enjoys but if he isn’t in to sport I’m not really that bothered. AIBU in my opinion?
We try to keep him otherwise active, go out to the park etc when we can and he’s forever running around.

OP posts:
Saracen · 11/03/2022 12:29

You say he runs around with friends at the park. That is really good exercise, easy to facilitate, more natural socially than sport, and allows for creative play. Keep going with that.

I think our society is a bit too consumed with competitive sport. Not everyone enjoys it. If I were you, I'd keep offering your son a range of experiences to see if there's anything he loves, but not specifically sport.

Thisismynamenow · 11/03/2022 12:27

As a child my parents forced us to learn how to swim (life saving skill) and heavily encouraged us to partake in a martial arts (learn to defend ourselves).
They never forced us into other sports, and i eventually got into netball at around 7/8 then got really into martial arts at 9. my brother went into football at around 8/9 too.
At 5 we were soley focused on toys (computers weren't really a big thing until we were about 10 maybe).

Maybe just try lots of different sports with him to see if he likes any? If not its not the end of the world so long as he exercises in some way.

AlexaShutUp · 11/03/2022 12:21

I would add, it isn't just about physical health benefits. Exercise has a huge impact on mental health. I wish I had understood this when I was younger.

Sally872 · 11/03/2022 12:19

I would be bothered about a sport but I would want him to have some sort of hobby to make friends outside of school and socialise. Could be beavers, drama, karate etc.

I think it is about making friends rather than keeping fit if you are doing that in other ways.

Gaming is fine when older but if that is his only thing getting him off the console and socialising face to face may be more difficult.

AlexaShutUp · 11/03/2022 12:19

Sorry, but I think yabu. As a very unsporty person myself, I wish I had been encouraged as a child to find some sort of physical activity that I loved. DD wasn't interested in any traditional sports but she does have a very active hobby that ensures she gets lots of exercise.

There is no inherent virtue in being sporty for the sake of it, but there are tremendous health benefits from learning to love physical activity of some sort. I'm with your dh, keep giving your ds opportunities to find something that he enjoys.

reluctantbrit · 11/03/2022 12:16

I think there is far too much pressure on boys to enjoy football in this country, there are tons of other sports out there.

I think a child should do some activity which keeps them active. That can be sport or a group like Beavers. DD helps with a Beaver colony and she feels exhausted keeping up with them for one hour.

He may not be a person who likes team sport. You could look at gymnastics, judo/karate, park run, dance. DD's dance school has boys-only classes for modern or jazz plus there are lots in Musical theatre classes. Some also do classical ballet.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 11/03/2022 12:13

I would never push a child into football, or any other specific sport - but I would encourage them to try out new sports and activities and trying to find new skills and experiences that they might love. There are so many sports out there - using the term loosely to cover non-competitive activities that build strength / fitness / skills - it's hard to imagine a child that wouldn't be interested in one of them. There's a lot to be learned from sports as well as the physical benefits, and you'd likely be setting him up for a more active future too.

SartresSoul · 11/03/2022 12:13

It’s important to be active but you can do this without being involved in specific sports. He already does swimming which is great, maybe try park run at the weekend?

My eldest isn’t sporty at all, he’s always hated sports. He loves swimming so does that every week and we go running together too so he keeps active. He’s top set for everything except PE, he just doesn’t like sports. He is a gamer but it doesn’t affect him academically or anything, he knows school work comes first and as I say he’s top set for everything.

PourSomeLove · 11/03/2022 12:12

My son went to football at that age. He was never that bothered with it but enjoyed seeing his friends there. He always preferred gaming though. We didn’t push anything and he gave up football at about 10 along with Beavers and swimming. He got really into PC gaming from 11 and is still a big gamer at 18. He’s made lots of online friends from it and has met some in real life. He’s not into sports but he does run regularly and does weights so he’s fit and healthy. Out daughter has never been into sports apart from swimming but gave that up at 10. She likes gaming too but has other interests like art.
Their dad loves football and will watch literally any sport. I’m sure he’d have loved the kids to be interested but would never have pushed them into it. It’s not important as long as they’re active.

SockFluffInTheBath · 11/03/2022 12:08

My DS loved swimming and was really good at it. He always hated football and rugby. Follow his lead, why should he be miserable every Saturday morning just because someone somewhere thinks he should be playing football/other team sport? Maybe take him swimming an extra time each week if that’s what he enjoys.

GlitteryGreen · 11/03/2022 12:08

I think it's right not to force it but equally I'd say it's good to encourage him from time-to-time as as you grow older sport and activity becomes less and less comfortable if you're not used to it/conscious of yourself.

CookieMunch · 11/03/2022 12:06

Yanbu in that it’s totally your choice how you raise your child. But I also agree with your DH. Personally I do encourage my kids to have hobbies outside school as I feel it’s good for their well-being. I also have a ‘gamer’ kid and I feel it’s even more important to get him out of the house and off his consoles because he easily becomes obsessed with them. It doesn’t have to be sport though. There’s beavers and scouts, arts clubs, dance, musical instruments, coding clubs (these go down well with my gamer kid!), drama clubs. The danger with the gaming thing is that he’s turning down other things he may enjoy and benefit from so that he can game more. My son asked to stop one of his activities recently and I told him there would be no gaming that evening if he stopped his activity. Otherwise he’d happily do only gaming and his social development and well-being would suffer. He definitely gets enough gaming hours in as is!

Noisyprat · 11/03/2022 12:03

Your 5 year old DS has 'really become into his gaming', not surprised gaming is highly addictive. IMO he's starting young.

You say that you 'time limit', how much time is he spending on gaming? everyday? every other day?

Personally, my DC did sport from a young age and we tried everything until they found something like liked apart from swimming which we view as a life skill so they did that until they were very able swimmers. I just think you need to be careful about giving in too quickly to him, it takes time for a child to get into a sport and there are so many advantages.

Mariposista · 11/03/2022 12:01

The swimming is important - he doesn't need to be competition standard, but swimming is a life skill and every child should be able to swim confidently, as you never know when he may end up in water unexpectedly.
Get rid of the screens - no good for him at all.

Moyny · 11/03/2022 11:55

@gannett

My dh is concerned hes going to be a “gamer” rather than out playing sports with his friends. He’s always trying to suggest different sports clubs to ds and feels like we’ve somehow failed him!! I keep trying to reiterate to dh that ds is only 5 and there’s plenty of time for him to find sports he enjoys but if he isn’t in to sport I’m not really that bothered. AIBU in my opinion?

Your DH needs to come to terms with the fact that his son just might not be sporty. Plenty of kids aren't. Plenty of adults aren't. It's fine. If he ends up more into computers than football, what's wrong with that?

And trying to force a kid into sport when they don't like it is just going to build negative associations with it. Exercise is beneficial of course, but the end goal should be that it's something he wants to do of his own accord - which might not be until he's an adult. Again, this is fine.

I was a tremendously unsporty kid who mostly just wanted to sit and read in peace. Have unexpectedly become a fairly sporty adult but it's no thanks to school/parents constantly trying to force me to be active as a kid, which I deeply resented.

Yes, I found myself wondering whether this man would be quite so insistent on his son being ‘out playing sports with his friends’ if his son were a daughter. I loathe all sports, individual, team, whatever — playing or watching. I walk and cycle everywhere, and I’m fit and active. Sports shouldn’t be a ‘should’.
sparkle17 · 11/03/2022 11:55

Try him again in 6 months with a new thing. 6 months is a long time in a child's life. But as long as he is getting plenty exercise nothing to worry about really

Beamur · 11/03/2022 11:55

@Backtothefutureagain

Yeah I’m probably not going to get mother of the year award then I guess
😄 I think at this age we let DD play a few games. She's 15 now and seems ok. Being active is enough at this age. As long as he's a healthy weight and gets exercise daily you're good. Elite sports might need commitment from a young age and football can be horribly competitive. Personally I'm not convinced getting into football is all that great for a lot of boys. There's tons of other sports and hobbies out there. My DD wasn't sporty but has always been active and has finally in her teens, found something she loves doing.
TrendingNowt · 11/03/2022 11:54

5 is too young for gaming, so YABU to allow that.
But YANBU in that he has plenty of time to try different sports to see what he likes. Cut the gaming our and he might like other things more

Hoppinggreen · 11/03/2022 11:51

DH was desperate for DS to be into football like him but he just wasn’t. We tried a few sports with him but nothing grabbed him until swimming in Y6 and then Basketball in Y7. Unfortunately after swimming was cancelled for so long due to Covid we couldn’t get him back into it but he still loves Basketball and plays in the school team and a local one. He also uses our home gym with DH and we all play table tennis and Badminton together
So it’s not fair to write your son off as un sporty or try and force him into a sport he doesn’t like just because DH does. It’s just not for everyone and your DS is so young, he has yet to find a sport he really likes

londonmummy1966 · 11/03/2022 11:50

The dead hand of football - the only possible sport for a boy. I agree with the PPs who say that there a re lots of other sports out there from martial arts to athletics that he could try instead. How about Junior Parkrun? It is very friendly, he'll have lots of older boys there to look up to and he can watch his progress week by week with his chip times. Its free and an activity you could do together or he could do with his dad.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/03/2022 11:43

The advantage of keeping on encouraging him to try different sports and activities is that they will help him physically for years - I see kids who weren't encouraged/facilitated when little and they have very, very little core strength or awareness of their bodies/posture. This then makes any physical activity beyond day to day things difficult and uncomfortable, which means they're less likely to enjoy it/do it, which then increases their risk of injury, etc, etc...

It's not right seeing 11 year olds slouched, heads forward, lower back arched and legs unable to hold them up properly to the extent that they are practically walking on the inside of their ankles and sitting on a school chair causes them pain. But there are so many like that. And then they panic if they get a little bit out of breath and hyperventiliate because they've come to believe that feeling your heart beating means they're about to die.

At five, he's young enough that consistent encouragement to keep trying things that challenge him physically aren't going to be as difficult as they would be at ten or thirteen. Or forty.

And apart from being out in fresh air, communicating and working as a team, perhaps winning, etc, there are other advantages - he learns that consistently working even when something is challenging/slightly uncomfortable does have rewards. In the case of sports/exercise, he gets fitter/stronger/flexible/more able. That endorphin rush - the bit that makes you feel relaxed and happy after a good session/game/whatever - is a reward. Sleeping well is a reward. Having two hours in which you do not need to think about anything else, just focus on what is important right now is a reward. Having the strength to run faster, climb trees better, stand up longer, carry a schoolbag, stay on a bike on more uneven ground, dive into the pool without a sharp stinging slap as your skin hits the water, do your laces up or be able to get your coat on without help because your joints/muscles are more flexible - all rewards.

It may be that it takes a while for him to find something he really enjoys, but even the act of trying different things is good. Maybe he'd enjoy martial arts, maybe dance, maybe something else as he gets older - but keeping on trying so that he potentially finds something that is right for him is a good thing.

ineedsun · 11/03/2022 11:42

@grey12

You have either a team sport (the usual suspects) or a more individual sport like martial arts, dance, fencing,......

Sports are good. "Gamer" is not a sport 🤷🏻‍♀️ nothing wrong with it but you can't compare apples with hammers!

Have you heard of esports?
LizzoBennett · 11/03/2022 11:41

Agree that five is too young for gaming.

Seasidemumma77 · 11/03/2022 11:37

Out of my 4dc, three of them have always loved sports and were keen to try different sports until they found their passion. One dc is now a semi professional rugby player, 1 dc is a black belt kickboxer, 1 dc is into weightlifting. Then I have 1 dc who has zero interest in any sports, loves gaming. I've encouraged him to learning coding, and got him interested in building remote control vehicles. I keep trying to find ways to take his interest in gaming and use it as a tool to learn new skills.

pickingdaisies · 11/03/2022 11:35

Without knowing what the time constraints are it's hard to say if it's too much - mine only got to see the console at weekends when they were little. They took it in turns, one watching, one playing. And a "nice" game is just as addictive as call of duty.
But competitive sports like football aren't for everyone. I'd be keen to find something he enjoys, for the getting out and socialising as much as anything. Beavers, gymnastics, dance, singing, taekwondo, skating, there's a lot of stuff out there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread