Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not push my child in to sport

111 replies

Backtothefutureagain · 11/03/2022 09:55

Ds is just about to turn 6
He goes to a swimming class once a week
We tried him with football when he was 4-5yo and he enjoyed it for a month or so as he was with his friends but suddenly he didn’t want to go any more and he is still adamant he doesn’t like football, no interest when it’s on tv or if dh says let’s go and play football etc
Ds has become really in to his gaming, wanting to play on the switch a lot (was Dh’s console) which we allow with time constraints
My dh is concerned hes going to be a “gamer” rather than out playing sports with his friends. He’s always trying to suggest different sports clubs to ds and feels like we’ve somehow failed him!! I keep trying to reiterate to dh that ds is only 5 and there’s plenty of time for him to find sports he enjoys but if he isn’t in to sport I’m not really that bothered. AIBU in my opinion?
We try to keep him otherwise active, go out to the park etc when we can and he’s forever running around.

OP posts:
Concestor · 11/03/2022 15:21

Sounds similar to my son, who is now hugely into karate aged 7 but doesn't like any other sport. It's fine, not everyone is sporty, but we do need to be active as you say.

AuntFlorence · 11/03/2022 15:17

I think pushing children into a hobby or interest rarely works (and only does when the parents happen to pick something their child would have been drawn to anyway, but just need a bit of help initially to get into the habit of going or doing it). I do think it is our job to expose our children to as many different opportunities as we can afford (with money or time). If he doesn't like football, maybe take him to a drama class or buy him a harmonica or take him bird spotting or fishing or do some junk modelling or baking. There is nothing intrinsically better about being sporty and having other interests, so long as you get enough physical activity for your body to be in its best condition. Maybe you could encourage him to do some of the more active games on switch? There is a dance one I think. Of course taking screen breaks is really important. During the lockdowns one of my DC became screen obsessed but actually that resolved through peer influence at school and she is really into sports now. At 5y it's very soon to right Him off! Expose him to as many opportunities as you can, sign him up for everything on offer until he finds something that gels.
What about martial arts? My (now football obsessed) kids at that age wanted to be ninjas far more than they wanted to be footballers. Interests change and grow. But if you give into too much Screen time they may never get the opportunity to discover the other possibilities out there.

BeerKegs · 11/03/2022 15:14

your husband is right. A 5 year old shouldn’t be on the road to becoming a gamer. YABU

Moonface123 · 11/03/2022 15:05

l loved all sports when l was younger and still very active now, but my youngest son was never that keen, he would come out for a walk and liked cycling but not interested in anything else. Now he is 16 he runs, cycles and lifts weights so not being sporty doesn' t necessarily mean they end up a couch potatoe.

ChairCareOh · 11/03/2022 14:46

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

incognitoforthisone · 11/03/2022 14:33

imo children should do one structured sport and one art activity per week.

Or, considering we're talking about a five year old here, perhaps he can just run around playing games with his friends in the playground and get his crayons or play-doh out when he feels like it?

I personally don't think a six-year-old needs to do an organised sport or physical activity. Important for him to be active, of course, but he can be active by riding a bike, climbing a tree, building a camp in the garden, throwing a ball against a wall, dancing around his bedroom to his favourite music or any number of other things, in addition to his swimming lessons. And I'm pretty sure he'll be learning things like teamwork and structure from his PE sessions at school.

Like others have said, if you think he isn't getting enough variety from school and his normal play, then how about something like Beavers or Cubs or whatever? Then he'd do a mix of activities, learn teamwork and other skills, and have the chance to try out different things. But he'd probably also get to do some badges that play to his existing strengths and interests too, so it's a good mix.

I didn't like organised sports when I was a kid at all, but I was more than happy to play really active, physical games at Brownies!

Kite22 · 11/03/2022 14:06

I haven't voted as it isn't a clear cut one way or the other thing

I don't think you need to be pushing him into a sport, but having outside interests and activities is useful for physical, mental and emotional development. And while I have a fairly casual attitude to the use of consoles compared to many people, I wouldn't want a 5 year old spending the bulk of their time gaming.

I agree with this ^
I think 5 is a bit young to be involved in too many clubs / activities and particularly team sports anyway, but I also think it is too young for gaming.
I had swimming as non-negotiable when mine were that age and then they started Beavers at 6. Scouts in general has been fantastic for all of them, and is active without necessarily having to be particularly sporty.

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/03/2022 13:58

He’s 6! They barely understand team games at that age. Your DP should not force it, could put him off for life.

In the meantime get him into the habit of being active - swimming, biking, Cubs, baby climbing, walks, dance is good for little kids, yoga maybe. Activity and fresh air is important, team games aren’t - and he’ll either be into them or he won’t.

bruce43mydog · 11/03/2022 13:54

it will be good for you to push while hes young so he learns about exercise and also being part of group activities,

i dont agree with mindless computer games for children while they are young they need to know that exercise and team work are part of life,

so yes op to answer your question definatly push him into hobbies that are going to benefit his future lifestyle.

SheilaWilcox · 11/03/2022 13:48

I'd avoid gaming as long as you can, because by the time they're teenagers, it can make them pretty anti-social.
It's hard here in the UK though, because often the weather is so rubbish, you're looking for something to do inside.

Maybe some 'active' app's that encourage getting out and about like geocaching or Pokemon Go.

Sport isn't the be all and end all, but you can encourage rather than push.
Getting into good, active, healthy habits is easier to influence now.

Enjoy parkrun.

BogRollBOGOF · 11/03/2022 13:46

With dyspraxia and ASD, team sports are not enjoyable to DS1. He does do swimming, martial arts, Scouts and junior parkruns (plus 5k in the summer). They cover all the benefits of traditional team sport and at 11, he's doing a lot more than most of his classmates now because he's not been driven heavily into one thing or faced a lot of competition.

DH and I are not "sporty" as in team sports. We are active though. I suspect DS's dyspraxia came via me. PE was torturous at school, but out of school I danced (badly Grin ), but in adulthood that led to fitness classes, yoga, adult ballet, circuits, then running. DM hated swimming (too cold) and I failed to pick it up at school. I learned later in the teenage years motivated by the physical section of the DoE award... now I do open water swimming.

DS2, unlike the rest of us is motivated by team sports and plays with a football team. He also does the same range of activities as DS1.

Team sports aren't the be all and end all. Doing something is important and for younger children gaining a range of skills and experiences helps them to find interests that they can keep up and come back to through life.

bellamountain · 11/03/2022 13:44

Your DS sounds very normal, I think most kids will become gamers given the chance. 5 is also very young, we tried my 5 year old at football and after a couple of months he wanted to stop, which he did. Now he's nearly 7 he's starting to show an interest again. Are there any tennis clubs near you? They are usually good fun with all sorts of games involved and less competitive at a young age?

Mischance · 11/03/2022 13:40

Putting pressure on children to take part in sport is counter-productive. It just puts them off.

If you want him to get exercise take him for walks, bike rides, keep up with the swimming and get a trampoline. Climbing wall near you?

Some children/people are not remotely interested in sport and that is just fine. He will get plenty at school especially when he gets to secondary.

I do not think it is either gaming or sport - there are lots of other choices.

Dads often want to get their boys interested in their sports - but there really is no reason why the children should share their interest.

balalake · 11/03/2022 13:39

Good luck OP with junior park run. Hope the first of many.

Gonnagetgoing · 11/03/2022 13:37

@alfagirl73

I don't think kids should be forced into a sport they don't like, but I also think a lot of kids/people are written off as "not sporty" based on their experience of just a few sports. Most of my life I've considered myself "not sporty" - but the sports on offer, say, when I was at school, were extremely limited and just not my thing (plus sport at school was a horrendous experience generally).

I'm now getting really into fitness etc... and have discovered areas of sport that I love but that never occurred to me to try before. Not all kids will be into football or more "mainstream" sports - but may discover that they have a real talent/love for a different sport/event/activity - there is so much out there.

@alfagirl73 - you're similar to me - sports at my school was very limited too! One sport I did like, volleyball, we only tried for a short time then stopped!

I'm similar to you, got much more into fitness and sports that I like that weren't like the traditional ones - I hated hockey and netball!

It'd be great if yoga and other traditional classes, like self defence, aerobics etc was factored into school sports, maybe it is now!

Gonnagetgoing · 11/03/2022 13:34

I personally don't think there's that much wrong with him not being into sport and you shouldn't force him. Gaming is his thing and unless a sport comes up that he's really interested in I wouldn't bother pressuring him into anything.

When I was younger I joined a gymnastics club but had a slight eye issue and they wanted us to be professional gymnasts so I left. Similar with swimming and a swimming club but we were taken regularly as kids by DPs anyway. I also did horse-riding from 9 but stopped when I was 11 as I found better things to do. Did ice-skating but not as a sport more social. Played tennis in park but again social. I can ride a bike and did a lot of that and playing out when younger.

It depends if you want it to be enjoyment or on the level of more competitive etc.

I know someone who regularly played football, basketball as a child/teenager, years later, does nothing. I also know 3 sisters who did running/hurdling etc at a local athletics club as children/teens - years later nothing.

saoirse31 · 11/03/2022 13:31

I'd definitely try and get him into team sport. 6 year old is v young to be deciding it's nothing but gaming tbh.

alfagirl73 · 11/03/2022 13:20

I don't think kids should be forced into a sport they don't like, but I also think a lot of kids/people are written off as "not sporty" based on their experience of just a few sports. Most of my life I've considered myself "not sporty" - but the sports on offer, say, when I was at school, were extremely limited and just not my thing (plus sport at school was a horrendous experience generally).

I'm now getting really into fitness etc... and have discovered areas of sport that I love but that never occurred to me to try before. Not all kids will be into football or more "mainstream" sports - but may discover that they have a real talent/love for a different sport/event/activity - there is so much out there.

babyjellyfish · 11/03/2022 12:59

Neither of you is being unreasonable.

I completely agree with your husband that it is a good idea for your child to have a hobby he enjoys which involves moving his body and interacting with other kids and not looking at a screen, and it is worth taking the time to find one that is right for him. It absolutely doesn't have to be a sport though. What about music or drama?

The only sporting activity I would make my child do until they were at least competent is swimming, so they are at less risk of drowning on holiday, and you're already doing that.

Backtothefutureagain · 11/03/2022 12:55

@Saracen

You say he runs around with friends at the park. That is really good exercise, easy to facilitate, more natural socially than sport, and allows for creative play. Keep going with that.

I think our society is a bit too consumed with competitive sport. Not everyone enjoys it. If I were you, I'd keep offering your son a range of experiences to see if there's anything he loves, but not specifically sport.

Thank you this was basically my point of viewSmile
OP posts:
Backtothefutureagain · 11/03/2022 12:54

Thank you for those suggesting junior park run, it’s something we can do together so we are going to do it this weekendGrin

OP posts:
GlitteryGreen · 11/03/2022 12:52

@Bromse Totally agree and not at all saying OP's son does nothing but sit around, but just that without sport/conscious effort, those opportunities do tend to evaporate as you grow older though.

Eg in 5 or so years, he won't really be running around or playing (actively) as much, by himself or with friends. So it's good to have a sport to fall back on if you can find one you like as it keeps you active without being a chore.

godmum56 · 11/03/2022 12:52

YANBU definitely. All my life I have been an active person and still am....dog walking, gardening DIY and so on. The only sport I have ever enjoyed is archery. He will be in teams to do other things and can learn social skills in other ways....I think people take to team sports because they are team players and not the other way around. I think pushing kids into ANYTHING just wastes time, energy, potentially money and everybody's patience and emotional currency. From what you say he gets exercise and fresh air....I'd be exploring your DH's reasons for his concerns...I'd put money on it at least having something to do with his self image!

Bromse · 11/03/2022 12:47

The op hasn't indicated that her child does no exercise, even though he would often prefer to be online. He swims, runs around and plays with friends. There are many ways of having exercise.

GlitteryGreen · 11/03/2022 12:37

@AlexaShutUp

Sorry, but I think yabu. As a very unsporty person myself, I wish I had been encouraged as a child to find some sort of physical activity that I loved. DD wasn't interested in any traditional sports but she does have a very active hobby that ensures she gets lots of exercise.

There is no inherent virtue in being sporty for the sake of it, but there are tremendous health benefits from learning to love physical activity of some sort. I'm with your dh, keep giving your ds opportunities to find something that he enjoys.

I agree with this completely.

I did lots of music lessons etc but was never encouraged into sport (outside of swimming lessons and school netball) as I just didn't have a natural interest. But I really wish I had been as it's the easiest way to keep fit in an enjoyable way, and I was a chubby child, so when I got to 10ish it was like the window to start sport had been missed as I just didn't feel comfortable joining in with all the slimmer and more capable children. Team sport was just alien to me after I started secondary school, and I didn't even join any at university as I was conscious. I will definitely be encouraging my child to find a sport they enjoy, even if they have to try a load to find one.

Also sport gives access to another group of friends, which is such a good thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread