Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not push my child in to sport

111 replies

Backtothefutureagain · 11/03/2022 09:55

Ds is just about to turn 6
He goes to a swimming class once a week
We tried him with football when he was 4-5yo and he enjoyed it for a month or so as he was with his friends but suddenly he didn’t want to go any more and he is still adamant he doesn’t like football, no interest when it’s on tv or if dh says let’s go and play football etc
Ds has become really in to his gaming, wanting to play on the switch a lot (was Dh’s console) which we allow with time constraints
My dh is concerned hes going to be a “gamer” rather than out playing sports with his friends. He’s always trying to suggest different sports clubs to ds and feels like we’ve somehow failed him!! I keep trying to reiterate to dh that ds is only 5 and there’s plenty of time for him to find sports he enjoys but if he isn’t in to sport I’m not really that bothered. AIBU in my opinion?
We try to keep him otherwise active, go out to the park etc when we can and he’s forever running around.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
boyblue · 11/03/2022 22:56

Physical activity is vital for young children. If they don't learn core skills they find it harder and harder as they get older. Then they are rubbish at sport compared to peers. So yes it's a good idea. Any sport,

stevalnamechanger · 11/03/2022 21:06

Sorry but I would insist on a couple of sports in addition to liking gaming .

I don't think it's a healthy hobby

Zwellers · 11/03/2022 20:49

Forcing him to do sport would be cruel. Some kids just are not sporty. I was forced to do sport as a child on the basis it was good for me. Most miserable times of my childhood

hotpinkkettle · 11/03/2022 20:48

I have no interest in organised sport. Never have. At school the only sport I was any good at was shooting, and you can do that lying down.

I have no interest in gaming either. It has never held me back.

AuntFlorence · 11/03/2022 20:42

I absolutely think there is a place for gaming, but it's about balance. So long as your child has time reading books, playing with toys, outside, socialising, exercising (could be climbing trees or chasing butterflies or whatever, doesn't have to be formal) then I absolutely believe there is space for gaming.
My kids absolutely love to go out to the arcade as an occasional treat, we all have a go on the driving games and shooting games. I don't see the problem with screen time in 5y olds so long As they have some balance. Being a gamer is not intrinsically bad either. So long as it is gaming for pleasure and not a gaming addiction. Offering alternatives and making sure there are time limits, helps to keep it in balance as one interest and not their only interest. It can actually be a really good way to escape your stresses and unwind, yes gamers get a bad rep, but I would rather my children be into gaming than drugs or alcohol or joy riding. It's not evil. I am happier now that my gaming tween is also showing more varied interests ofc, but I can also see that gaming was a brilliant coping strategy when the world was shut down. It got her through a lot of scary, lonely, difficult times and she learned some admirable digital skills. If she ends up with a career in engineering or coding or whatever it will be the seed that was planted playing mine craft in lockdown

HoneyItIsntGoodLuck · 11/03/2022 20:39

I get both sides of it.

My DB and I weren’t into sports at all. Our DM used to really try to encourage us, but we just weren’t keen. Our DF wasn’t into sports at all, so it was a losing battle for her.

Now, with our kids - DH is really into it. We have basically let them try anything and everything, and then stick with the ones they enjoy. Tennis, football, rugby, floorball, hockey, ballet, jazz dancing, gym, mountain biking, swimming, diving, netball, horse-riding, and I’m sure I’ve forgotten a few over the years. DH’s mantra was - at least one team sport and one individual.

Tennis, hockey, netball and horse-riding have stuck.

My DC are both a lot more confident and outgoing than me, and I know that a lot of that is down to being actively engaged in sport, making friends through teams, being good at some sports, etc. Like it or not, being good at sports does have social caché.

I look back now, and realise why my Mum (who obviously loved her sports growing up) was so keen for us to do it. It is good for kids.

But it’s about finding the right one for them, that they genuinely enjoy, and want to do.

My DC also do music and other cultural things - it’s not all about sports - that’s not healthy when they’re young, either.

thewhatsit · 11/03/2022 20:24

I haven’t actually stated how much gaming he has so reducing it to what?

Well no but you said he is really into it and asks a lot..? Presumably if you were talking about once a month or so it wouldn’t be worth mentioning?

I was assuming he’s playing multiple times a week. Maybe I’m wrong.

Backtothefutureagain · 11/03/2022 18:54

@cadburyegg

I would reduce the gaming tbh, he's too young to be "into" that kind of thing

If he's generally active then it's fine. Would your DH be saying the same if you had a girl I wonder? Why is it always boys that are expected to be "sporty"?

My DS7 does swimming and beavers, he did a sports club after school til it got cancelled recently. I've suggested other clubs to him including football, he's not interested, says he just wants to come home after school. Fair enough imo

I haven’t actually stated how much gaming he has so reducing it to what?

I agree with the boys must be in to sports thing. I’ve said from day 1 I’d be happy with him playing an instrument, reading books and doing drama club, I couldn’t care less if he wasn’t in to sport. Dh has other views obviously.

OP posts:
ineedsun · 11/03/2022 18:29

Too young to be into gaming but not too young to be into swimming / football / horse riding etc? Hmm

cadburyegg · 11/03/2022 18:08

I would reduce the gaming tbh, he's too young to be "into" that kind of thing

If he's generally active then it's fine. Would your DH be saying the same if you had a girl I wonder? Why is it always boys that are expected to be "sporty"?

My DS7 does swimming and beavers, he did a sports club after school til it got cancelled recently. I've suggested other clubs to him including football, he's not interested, says he just wants to come home after school. Fair enough imo

phoenixrosehere · 11/03/2022 18:03

As long as your child is active, it’s fine.

I’ve been a gamer since I was a kid but I was also in school clubs (art club, sewing club, chess club, service club, chorus) ,Girl Scouts, and doing dance lessons. When I wasn’t doing those I was riding my bike around the neighbourhood and school was about a two mile round trip walk (1/4 of it hills). Once it was dark, and homework was done, I was playing games or reading a book.

My dad wanted me to be in sports but the competitiveness of sports put me off of them and being shouted at when I made a mistake.

As an adult, I go on hike, garden, do diy, read, watch documentaries and walk everywhere, and go to the gym on top of gaming.

Gaming doesn’t automatically mean slacker and gaming can be a possible field of work later down the road if he is still interested.

ineedsun · 11/03/2022 17:35

@reluctantbrit
That’s great for your daughter and I totally agree with you about playgrounds for older kids.

What I hate is this notion that kids have to do something organised for their active time to be of value and the fact that quieter kids who are into reading, engineering, computers, film, cooking, comic books etc are viewed as somehow less developed than kids who are in a football team or go swimming. It’s really demeaning.

Of course it’s good to be active, everyone knows that but the way sport and competition is shoved down kids throats is awful (and in my case turned me right off any activity till I was in my twenties or thirties).

Blossom64265 · 11/03/2022 16:56

There is a separate issue about providing social activities for kids. It is important to recognize that if your child isn’t naturally sporty, the odds of building great friendships with the kids at those activities are low. The places where my child has made her best friends have been activities she was excited to attend. Those are the activities that will attract kids who have things in common with your child. They will get one another’s jokes and have a million things to talk about.

Backtothefutureagain · 11/03/2022 16:49

@AuntFlorence

One of the best gifts we can give our children is the gift of boredom. That is where their creative mind comes alive. If they never have unstructured time, if they are always being stimulated mentally, they do not learn the internal processes to entertain themselves. These are the building blocks of creativity, entrepreneurial thinking, idea creation, scientific innovation, problem solving, etc. Time unscheduled is not time off from their work, because their work is play actually play time is their most important time in. It is how they process what they learned in their clubs and conversations and class rooms. When we constantly fill that time we are not giving them the gift of constant stimulation, we are taking away from them the gift to be bored
This is beautifully put and I agree with you 100%. I dont know if maybe my op reads the wrong way or people are jumping to conclusions. I’m not saying my son sits on the sofa playing on the switch all day and therefore doesn’t do anything else and has no interest in sports because of this. It’s just the one thing he really shows interest for (really in to Mario in everything now - Mario lego, Mario stationary etc etc). My husband has taken this as a sign he’s going to be a gamer with no other interests and no interest in leaving the house Grin of course these are stereotypes. We 100% encourage creativity and time outside playing its just the nagging from my husband to “get him in to x y and z” that irks me a bit
OP posts:
reluctantbrit · 11/03/2022 16:31

@ineedsun

Eugh…

I hate this assumption that everyone should ‘do sport’ as a child.

The enforced nature of it all put me off till adulthood when I realised that you don’t actually have to compete with anyone, even yourself in order to be active. This notion that team sports and competition are good for you, only benefits some people and shows no appreciation for the fact that everyone is different. Similarly ‘you must do something creative’. What’s wrong with just playing? Go out on your bike, build a den, jump on a trampoline, make a cake, read a book, build something on minecraft, dance in the kitchen.

Give kids the chance to be who they want rather than put them in a box for organised ‘fun’

Nobody says it has to be a team sport or even competing. I actually think what offered in school and in after school activities is far too much traditional sport which very often is a team sport. It's a lot more difficult to find affordable sports which are different.

DD hates team sports, can't throw a ball but loves dance, horse riding and did gymnastics and swimming.

It's important to be active, it doesn't matter how. With PE in school seen as not very important and if at all being the team sports, lots of children are put off being active as a teen. If they do something they like earlier, they are often on track to stay active even if they stop or swap activities. There was recently an article that councils sell off adventure playgrounds now. Where do children go and play if there is nothing for them? Too many playgrounds are just for really young ones. If you have a tiny garden or live in a flat you don't have space for a trampoline or climbing frame.

DD is now 14 and PE is just every second week in secondary. Hardly enough to be active. I am glad that she found activities she likes early on as getting a teen to try something new is a nightmare.

Being active doesn't mean you can't slump and watch TV, play games, read a book or just hang out with friends.

ineedsun · 11/03/2022 16:13

Eugh…

I hate this assumption that everyone should ‘do sport’ as a child.

The enforced nature of it all put me off till adulthood when I realised that you don’t actually have to compete with anyone, even yourself in order to be active. This notion that team sports and competition are good for you, only benefits some people and shows no appreciation for the fact that everyone is different. Similarly ‘you must do something creative’. What’s wrong with just playing? Go out on your bike, build a den, jump on a trampoline, make a cake, read a book, build something on minecraft, dance in the kitchen.

Give kids the chance to be who they want rather than put them in a box for organised ‘fun’

AdrianCanChaseMe · 11/03/2022 16:09

Not every child likes group sports. But that doesn't mean they can't be active.

My eldest DS is very solitary and enjoys swimming every week, riding his bike whenever he's out and does rock climbing lessons.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 11/03/2022 16:04

In some ways, the less sporty the child, the more important it is.

I really agree with this. A sporty child can slot in easily at any age. An unsporty child really benefits from finding an activity they like and building up.

Fairislefandango · 11/03/2022 16:01

I think the sport and the gaming are separate issues. As long as he's active, he doesn't need to be pushed into a sport. There are also lots of other hobbies which are neither sport nor gaming.

5 is too young to be doing much gaming at all imo. It's highly addictive, and can mould young brains. The easy excitement and endorphin rushes that games provide can easily make other activities seem less appealing. The game designers deliberately design them that way - and not just the Call of Duty type games, but all games.

Hankunamatata · 11/03/2022 15:55

As long as he is actively doing something for an hour a day doesnt matter if its sports. Sometimes it's just finding stuff they like. My boys have done as afterschool activities beavers, gymnastics, hockey, bmx, rugby, basketball etc

Blossom64265 · 11/03/2022 15:48

I’m a distinctly indoor reading a book or doing a craft project kind of person, I also love games.

I think kids need to have a regular physical activity, but it doesn’t need to be sport in the traditional sense. Some kids are more suited to individual pursuits like rock climbing, yoga, or archery. He might also prefer something like dance or gymnastics. These are just as legitimate ways to keep the body active. Competitive sports, especially competitive team sports, aren’t a necessity. It’s about finding something he enjoys that gets his body moving.

chesirecat99 · 11/03/2022 15:39

I'm with your DH. Exercise is important. It doesn't have to be a sport (eg dance or an exercise class) or even an organised activity, it could be walking, swimming and cycle rides with you, however, when your DS gets older and doesn't want to do family activities but is too young for the gym, it helps if they already have a regular hobby they enjoy that involves exercise. In some ways, the less sporty the child, the more important it is. If they hate the common sports played at school (and all the competitiveness that goes along with it), the earlier they find a form of exercise they enjoy, the better.

DaddyAmil · 11/03/2022 15:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

thewhatsit · 11/03/2022 15:27

I don’t see why it has to be gaming or sports, there are many other options.

DS hates sports and I won’t push him but neither would I be happy for him to be gaming so young. Things he and his friends do for extra curriculars include:
Drama groups
Art groups
Chess club
Music lessons
Etc

AuntFlorence · 11/03/2022 15:24

One of the best gifts we can give our children is the gift of boredom. That is where their creative mind comes alive. If they never have unstructured time, if they are always being stimulated mentally, they do not learn the internal processes to entertain themselves. These are the building blocks of creativity, entrepreneurial thinking, idea creation, scientific innovation, problem solving, etc. Time unscheduled is not time off from their work, because their work is play actually play time is their most important time in. It is how they process what they learned in their clubs and conversations and class rooms. When we constantly fill that time we are not giving them the gift of constant stimulation, we are taking away from them the gift to be bored