Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fit in because I'm working class

233 replies

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 09:48

I'm from a working class background and I grew up with little money. I did very well academically and managed to go to a top uni and get a good degree, despite not feeling like I belonged. I've worked hard for 15 years to establish my career in a competitive industry with no financial support, which has resulted in a lot of stress and debt over the years.

I work in an industry that's generally full of wealthy, middle class people who dont seem to have any anxieties about life or financial limits (despite the salaries not being that much). I've recently started a new job and feel really out of place, like I do at every job. My colleagues have very different lifestyles and conversation topics to me. Eg. House renovations, skiing holidays, private schooling, second homes in Europe. I'm 36 and 'still' rent a small flat with a friend, which seems to surprise and provoke pity amongst my colleagues. Most had property bought for them/got deposits from their parents years ago and speak like this is standard practice. I rarely go on holidays and don't have any expensive hobbies as I've been trying to save for a house deposit for many years.

To get to this point in my career I've really struggled financially and mentally and I'm pretty tired. I dont feel like im seen on the same page as everyone else at work and think it also affects my career progression. I just wonder if I can ever belong here.

OP posts:
missingeu · 11/03/2022 10:56

Be proud and be you.

The majority off people I know who have the 2nd homes, holidays skiing, private school are mortgaged up to the eyeballs and paying it all on credit.

Be proud of what you've achieved and try not to compare - as you don't walk in thier shoes.

Grenlei · 11/03/2022 10:55

I should add that my career progression has been terrible - despite excellent academics - because I didn't have the right connections via my dad's golfing buddies, or my mum's pals at the yacht club, or people I went to prep or boarding school with or sailed with in Cowes week Hmm. Plus I didn't look or sound 'right'. I mentioned on a curly hair thread the other day I was told more than once that my hair was unprofessional.

I've come to terms with it now, I'll never have a glittering career and I would have been financially better off as a plumber or other skilled trade than in my professional role ith my Oxbridge degree. C'est la vie I guess.

LakieLady · 11/03/2022 10:54

OP, this is so sad. I get how you feel, a little.

I come from a very working class background, lived in a council flat etc but passed my 11+ and got a scholarship to an independent school. Most of my class had ponies and went ski-ing, we didn't even have a phone or a car. I felt really excluded and I'm disappointed that that things haven't improved in the subsequent 50+ years.

However, that was one of the things that radicalised me politically, and that has stayed with me ever since.

You've got where you are entirely on your own merits and are probably better at your job than most of those who get their jobs because of social networks and the old school tie. You deserve it and I'm sure you will rise above it.

If it's making you desperately unhappy, do you have skills that are transferable to the public sector? I suspect you might be much happier there, it's much more egalitarian and accepting.

Rummikub · 11/03/2022 10:51

Some of the responses on here really remind me about those who say it don’t see colour/race’

You should and recognise how much harder it is for certain sectors of society to achieve and make it.

UnsuitableHat · 11/03/2022 10:49

OP, all you can be is yourself, and it sounds as though that's more than enough. Easier said than done I know, but try to resist the urge to compare.

Grenlei · 11/03/2022 10:49

I completely get it OP. I went to Oxbridge in the early 90s from a comprehensive school in a fairly deprived part of London. I absolutely didn't fit in there and honestly never really have anywhere since either although to be fair after my uni experience I have never been quite so acutely aware of it.

I do find work colleagues with their kids at public school (paid for from the family trust fund) or their new million pound house largely paid for with money inherited from Granny quite irritating. We have regular catch up calls (as we all WFH) which usually descend into bragging about what they're spending, where they''re going for a city break etc. It is tiresome and quite tone deaf.

That said, outside of work most of my local friends (who are more similar in terms of working class background) are all better off than me too, albeit less braggy - they run businesses with their husbands and all do very well. I'm used to being the poor relation now, even though I'm the one with the professional job - albeit that it doesn't pay as well as having your own construction business! (they are always surprised I'm not paid more)

gingerhills · 11/03/2022 10:48

I said YANBU because it is perfectly understandable why you feel a bit out of place. But I think you need to grow a thick skin. You don't need to be the same as these people. You don't need to feel less than them or as if you ought to emulate them. You don't have to like them or admire them.they are just colleagues.

I've spent enough time around these people to know I will never have anything in common with them however rich I became, because I don't give a stuff what your kitchen looks like or how many holidays you have or what you drive. Just can't care. They are perfectly nice people but of a pretty closed type. Feelings are never discussed. Ideas are never discussed. There's zero in depth interest in the arts, books, music. It's quite a surface focus - all very jolly and positive and enjoyable. I don't doubt they have great lives. But you are not inferior to them in any way.

Just get on with your work, forge strong working respect with them, get on at a superficial level and make sure you keep busy with people you really connect to outside of work. Maybe keep an eye out for someone who isn't so driven by material wealth and hasn't grown up in its cocoon, or has but knows it.

beastlyslumber · 11/03/2022 10:45

[quote Gazorpazorp]@beastlyslumber I’d give up everything I own to have my Dad recognise me and my Mum see my son grow up. OP should be thankful for what she has rather than wasting her time envying boring (and rude!) people who drone on about money.[/quote]
Of course. I'm sorry you're going through this, and wish you the best.

But I think you're missing the point about the class disparities and discrimination being discussed in this thread. Class isn't just about money, it's about connections, lifestyles, knowing the 'right' ways, having the codes to access the important elements of a career or workplace. And then being told that class is 'all in your head' or just 'envy' when you're stopped from getting ahead because you weren't able to join the company ski trip or you didn't go to the same prep school as everyone else in your office.

seekinglondonlife · 11/03/2022 10:44

@Shadowmallow, they ALL have connections and you are the only one who doesn't? What are you doing to try to break into circles? How are you networking?

Waddlegoose · 11/03/2022 10:43

I am middle class but my parents were quite frugal. One of my best friends from work is from a working class background and honestly I never really think about it.

I would feel a bit off with people talking about ski trips and private school too, I wouldn’t even say that’s middle class more upper middle / upper class.

I think you need to stop thinking of this as a barrier and a difference. It might be more in your head than you think. Surely there’s some things your have in common?

UmmOk · 11/03/2022 10:42

Own it OP. I’m proud to come from a working class background, it opens my eyes to real hardships and life experiences that many won’t understand.

This isn’t a you problem at all. I completely understand what you are saying, but own it. You are capable just as much as everyone else, despite your background.

seekinglondonlife · 11/03/2022 10:42

@flounfer, really, 2 or 3 London properties in their 30s? Why are all of MN then claiming they are priced out of London? I really don't think your social circle is in any way representative of average earners.

Rummikub · 11/03/2022 10:40

[quote Gazorpazorp]@beastlyslumber I’d give up everything I own to have my Dad recognise me and my Mum see my son grow up. OP should be thankful for what she has rather than wasting her time envying boring (and rude!) people who drone on about money.[/quote]
There’s a difference between individual circumstances and societal differences.

Even the Tory government are recognising the need to level up.

maddy68 · 11/03/2022 10:39

@Shadowmallow

Essentially, I can't do anything for them in the workplace, so why am I of any use to them?
Your response says it all to me. You are putting up barriers for yourself This is in your mind.

They may have different outlooks on life but that's fine and it's interesting listening to others perspectives? Ask them about it? Then say what you're doing. They will also be interested. But you seem very dismissive of them.

Rummikub · 11/03/2022 10:38

I used to be accused of having a chip on my shoulder if I called out racism.
Since BLM it’s good to see others calling racism it out too.

Gazorpazorp · 11/03/2022 10:37

@beastlyslumber I’d give up everything I own to have my Dad recognise me and my Mum see my son grow up. OP should be thankful for what she has rather than wasting her time envying boring (and rude!) people who drone on about money.

Hillarious · 11/03/2022 10:37

@baroqueandblue

Just be nice to them and if they say they're off skiing and you can't afford to do that say what you are doing , whether it's going to the pub or saving to pay the gas bill.

I suspect you can't imagine how it feels to be the person who took that advice and frequently experiences colleagues' social inability to deal with how lost they feel in such conversations. Then they stop trying and avoid you. It's real and can be very painful and confusing. You feel like you're putting them in an awkward position by speaking openly and honestly about how your life is in the kind of areas you suggested. People who can't imagine themselves in your position (and there are many of them in the kind of environment OP probably works in) feel oddly confronted and they will then choose to speak predominantly with those they can 'identify with'.

Class only exists in your mind really

It's actually unethical and downright dangerous to dismiss the OP's concerns in this way, because it's actually much more real than you care to acknowledge Hmm

From the responses received, it's easy to see who truly understands what the OP is saying and how she feels. For many of us, it's the same, for others, they are oblivious.
Rummikub · 11/03/2022 10:37

It’s similar to Muslims who may not participate in pub culture or smoking.
There’s been a few articles about this.

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 10:35

Essentially, I can't do anything for them in the workplace, so why am I of any use to them?

OP posts:
Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 10:34

@seekinglondonlife

This isn't a class issue, it's a money one. Presumably if you had more money, you would fit in better as you would be able to access these luxury services (if you wanted).
It's a class issue too, because all these people have handy connections made through private schools, know how to network, and have been raised on certain lifestyles and a certain standard of living they want to maintain, and they seem to prioritise this and other people who are similar. I dont really have any interest in these things and would never be someone I'm not. All I want for in life is some housing security and the ability to get away now and again to go walking/hiking.
OP posts:
PulseFinger · 11/03/2022 10:33

There have been a lot of tone-deaf responses so far, showing a complete lack of understanding or empathy for the situation OP describes. On the one hand, OP’s achievements suggest the system in the UK is a meritocracy, but the inequality of access to inherited wealth means others enjoy a level of financial security and a lifestyle which isn’t accessible to OP despite their achievements and hard work. More importantly, in my experience, many of OP’s colleagues will be living free of anxiety about their financial future, which is a real privilege.

There are a whole host of unspoken assumptions and social cues amongst colleagues/friends with a similar background of financial security and to tell OP to be glad they pulled themselves up by the bootstraps and not to compare themselves to others is totally unreasonable. Unfortunately, class (or family wealth) does still have a massive impact on financial security and housing, regardless of academic achievement and career progression - all the “this sounds like a you problem” stuff is unhelpful and quite unkind.

Rummikub · 11/03/2022 10:32

It’s all those subtle differences that if you belong dont register.I experienced similar at uni due to race and class.

Now I opt out of conversations bar being mildly interested. I know I’m good at my job (after years of feeling not).

That elite programme talks about the ‘secret code’.

baroqueandblue · 11/03/2022 10:31

Just be nice to them and if they say they're off skiing and you can't afford to do that say what you are doing , whether it's going to the pub or saving to pay the gas bill.

I suspect you can't imagine how it feels to be the person who took that advice and frequently experiences colleagues' social inability to deal with how lost they feel in such conversations. Then they stop trying and avoid you. It's real and can be very painful and confusing. You feel like you're putting them in an awkward position by speaking openly and honestly about how your life is in the kind of areas you suggested. People who can't imagine themselves in your position (and there are many of them in the kind of environment OP probably works in) feel oddly confronted and they will then choose to speak predominantly with those they can 'identify with'.

Class only exists in your mind really

It's actually unethical and downright dangerous to dismiss the OP's concerns in this way, because it's actually much more real than you care to acknowledge Hmm

LoopyLoz1234 · 11/03/2022 10:31

I was like this too. Even to the point where my manager brought me in and had a word with me about how I spoke because apparently I would occasionally drop my T’s or I said words that they didn’t understand ... Hmm it really upset me but I was so young that I didn’t have the balls to take it up with them so I tried my best to conform. However whenever I would be around my family I felt like I couldn’t fit in either because I had to revert back to the ‘old me’. It was hard and in the end I just decided to be me.
I do remember when I started one question a colleague asked was ‘so are you a skiier or a snowboarder?’ where as I had never been skiing or snowboarding and still haven’t.

My advice is to just be yourself, it’s good to be surrounded by those that aren’t from the same background because you get to share life experiences. I always make sure I’m representing the working class whenever topical subjects come up (benefits, council estates etc) and they are keen to listen and it makes me feel like I’m educating them about our real world.

Just be you.

flounfer · 11/03/2022 10:31

My neighbour is selling her flat for 800k to a cash buyer who's buying it for her child. That's the 4th property on my road to be purchased by parents for their dc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread