Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fit in because I'm working class

233 replies

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 09:48

I'm from a working class background and I grew up with little money. I did very well academically and managed to go to a top uni and get a good degree, despite not feeling like I belonged. I've worked hard for 15 years to establish my career in a competitive industry with no financial support, which has resulted in a lot of stress and debt over the years.

I work in an industry that's generally full of wealthy, middle class people who dont seem to have any anxieties about life or financial limits (despite the salaries not being that much). I've recently started a new job and feel really out of place, like I do at every job. My colleagues have very different lifestyles and conversation topics to me. Eg. House renovations, skiing holidays, private schooling, second homes in Europe. I'm 36 and 'still' rent a small flat with a friend, which seems to surprise and provoke pity amongst my colleagues. Most had property bought for them/got deposits from their parents years ago and speak like this is standard practice. I rarely go on holidays and don't have any expensive hobbies as I've been trying to save for a house deposit for many years.

To get to this point in my career I've really struggled financially and mentally and I'm pretty tired. I dont feel like im seen on the same page as everyone else at work and think it also affects my career progression. I just wonder if I can ever belong here.

OP posts:
Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 12:01

@ladycarlotta

Disturbed by how many replies minimise your feelings or place the blame on you as if you are just being chippy or negative. Particularly outrageous the posters asking whether this career is for you if you object to working alongside the privileged!

It is reasonable to notice and be troubled by these differences, and particularly the detrimental effect being an 'outsider' has had on your career and your lifestyle. But, you have also done an amazing thing. And I don't know what your industry is but it needs you - it needs more working class people, more first gen immigrants, more POC, etc etc etc. It's shitty to be the one leading the charge, especially if the culture really hasn't changed, but also you really deserve to be there, and you are making a path for the next generation which will hopefully be more diverse. The labour of altering the status quo should absolutely not be your responsibility, but your presence there is very valuable nonetheless. Good luck, OP, you are important.

Thank you. I'm surprised too, I have no animosity or jealousy and not saying my colleagues are wrong for being wealthy at all. I have made some great friends from all sorts of backgrounds through work. I'm just acknowledging that this is the way things seem to be. I'm not trying to fit in or desperate to be accepted into these circles. I'm just aware there are differences that can be awakward to navigate at work, isolating and limiting.
OP posts:
Nevermakeit · 11/03/2022 12:01

I think you have a chip on your shoulder and you are exaggerating the difference.
Most people nowadays have not had things 'given' to them by their parents. And also, you need to remember that people seem to lead luxurious lives but scratch below the surface and they have zero savings!
I also think what you describe is more age difference than class difference (schools, house renovations etc are typical of people in their late 30s'40s).
Am also a bit surprised at the vast discrepancy between their income (private schools etc) and yours - ie surprised they can afford quite that much luxury when you seem to have very little. Do you not even go on holiday? Or nice restaurants? See films? You could talk about all of these?

seekinglondonlife · 11/03/2022 12:00

your neighbours.

astoundedgoat · 11/03/2022 12:00

Just to add to the above, I don't think you're being over-sensitive as such, but something jumped out at me up thread - one person said "mimic" and there's something to be said for that.

My daughter went skiing recently (sorry!) and accidentally ended up on a red slope and got scared. I asked her what happened/did she cry, and she said yes, she had a bit of a cry, but it was hidden behind her mask, so nobody saw, and in the end it was fine because she just copied the people who were better skiers than her. It seemed like such a great analogy for, well, LOTS of things in life!

You say your colleagues have a lot of "soft skills" that they learned growing up, right? Learn and copy them too.

A friend started work somewhere where everyone skied regularly and went as a group, and he had never been and didn't want to make a show of himself, or say "I can't ski.". So he booked a cheap trip on his OWN to learn in private for a slightly scary and intense week, and then next time the "Oh Dan... we were just talking about Chamonix this year... do you ski?" conversation happened at lunch, he was able to say "yes, I do". And he went with the group that winter and it was fine.

I know you're saving for a house, but some of these things qualify as investments in your career progression. Not buying a horse and having kids so that you can send them to Harrow, but look around at the things people do to fit in, from the chocolate they have on their desks to the places they go on their holidays.

If you WANT to fit in, look at where you can blend (without having to spend £100k!).

Also, get 6 sessions a career coach who knows your industry. I promise it will help. Seriously. You colleagues might have has this kind of support organically growing up, but you can 100% pay for it and get it now. You sound very much like you need a mentor who staddles that professional/how you feel inside divide.

stayathomer · 11/03/2022 11:59

I think the poster above who made the point about finding common ground was spot on- a book, a film ... I also think you might be hearing more than is going on. We have a second property, a flat we bought in the boom and couldn't sell. We bought a very cheap house (just over 100k euro) and rent out the flat. The people who speak of skiing might have gone once as a trip of a lifetime. And you dont know who got help from parents, maybe only one or two did while others nodded along. My sil used to have the biggest chip about me growing up middle class. They were poor growing up and every comment she made was 'I bet you never had to x.' She didn't believe the first time I went abroad was as a teenager or that we didn't have bikes, rolled her eyes when I said we didn't get the toys they did as kids and laughed when I told her we had the same car and said ours must have been new. I felt shit all the time around her, laughing and rolling her eyes and talking about me not having a clue. They did have a different life- first time I experienced money issues was as a married adult and they lived on 2 parents on minimum wage, 1 pt. I acknowledged this but was trying to show her there wasn't the difference she thought there was. She's gotten well over it and we get on great now. Try and stop reading things into things that don't matter when you're in work. You've worked hard and are on a similar wage

seekinglondonlife · 11/03/2022 11:58

@flounfer, I didn't say that you said it was representative. I assume your neighbours with their 3 London homes by the age of 30 are in the vast minority. The OP said that neither she nor her colleagues have particularly well paid jobs, so they are very unlikely to be their neighbours. Despite most MNetters claiming that everyone they know got houses bought for them, the statistics do not match. These people are in the minority.

soootiredddd · 11/03/2022 11:55

And just to add, even if someone's parents helped them with a house deposit, that doesn't mean that they are continually receiving handouts from their parents forever and ever. Having a bit of help with a lump sum for a deposit is not the same as having your parents finance your life, or inheriting huge amounts of cash to live off

ladycarlotta · 11/03/2022 11:53

Disturbed by how many replies minimise your feelings or place the blame on you as if you are just being chippy or negative. Particularly outrageous the posters asking whether this career is for you if you object to working alongside the privileged!

It is reasonable to notice and be troubled by these differences, and particularly the detrimental effect being an 'outsider' has had on your career and your lifestyle. But, you have also done an amazing thing. And I don't know what your industry is but it needs you - it needs more working class people, more first gen immigrants, more POC, etc etc etc. It's shitty to be the one leading the charge, especially if the culture really hasn't changed, but also you really deserve to be there, and you are making a path for the next generation which will hopefully be more diverse. The labour of altering the status quo should absolutely not be your responsibility, but your presence there is very valuable nonetheless. Good luck, OP, you are important.

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 11:53

@NellyBarney

First of all, be proud of yourself. Secondly, take the long view. Many of your colleagues had help from their parents. If you choose to have children, you will hopefully be able to give them more support/advice than your parents were able, and so on. You also don't seem to be in a relationship/marriage. From a financial perspective, there is a huge advantage to having a two income household.
I'm in a long term relationship but we don't live together. We can't afford to buy together and better off financially staying where we both are than rent together too.
OP posts:
soootiredddd · 11/03/2022 11:52

"In my opinion, if you have to work for all your income in order to afford to live, you're working class"

OP, this is a very odd definition of working class and not one that is widely used. Yes, it would differentiate the aristocracy and titled, but the vast majority of middle class people also have to work for all their income.

TatianaBis · 11/03/2022 11:51

In my opinion, if you have to work for all your income in order to afford to live, you're working class.

By that definition a huge swathe of middle classes are working class.

And some working class families can and do help their kids financially, particularly immigrants from cultures where it's the norm.

Rosehugger · 11/03/2022 11:49

I think that people who say "class doesn't exist any more" consist solely of people who are stuck in a middle-class bubble without a huge variation of people

Definitely.

5128gap · 11/03/2022 11:48

There is nothing wrong with being WC and nothing wrong with having to achieve everything through your own efforts rather than hand outs. Quite the reverse. Its a very positive thing that you should be proud of. You need to stop feeling inferior to people who are simply luckier because their parents are wealthy and were able to give them advantages. Embrace your class and be proud of it. Unless your colleagues are a bunch of closed minded snobs unable to see beyond people exactly like them, your class should not be a barrier to fitting in. You fit in at work through shared goals, contributing to tasks with others, support, humour and yes, socialising. But surely not every colleague goes skiing and horse riding?

bluedodecagon · 11/03/2022 11:47

@Shadowmallow I don’t think people are dismissing the impact of the class system or disbelieve that class partly determines how successful you are in a career, it’s just that this is not a plausible belief system for someone in their mid 30s. There are tons of successful working-class people in many industries. I think the issue is that this industry seems to be one where there is no financial reward. You said that you are sharing a flat in your mid 30s. To me that’s not typical. Usually professionals will live in a small studio or flat but sharing, especially if you’ve spent 15 years in the same industry, seems unnecessary.

The problem seems to be that you’ve picked a very low paying career that doesn’t sound like it’s particularly merit based. I’m really curious to know which career this is because even careers in the arts or in publishing, the working class people that I seen who are truly talented by their mid 30s have connections, mentors or a group of similarly working class people to work with.

Can you say more about the industry? Because it sounds like this is a formal industry dominated by the upper middle classes but there is no opportunity to progress on merit and there is nothing creative or interesting in the role that would draw people to you regardless of class?

What on earth do you do?

TatianaBis · 11/03/2022 11:46

@Rosehugger

Even that is still not more than 50-60% private school

Only 50% from private school? Well, that's just fine then. No diversity issues to worry about there. Nothing to see there, nope.

Didn't say there weren't diversity issues, my point was that there must therefore be people around outside the background OP describes if 40-50% are not private school alumni.

(And that's assuming she's in the civil service which is the least diverse profession I can think of - it's not true of law or medicine any more.)

thecatsthecats · 11/03/2022 11:46

I'm middle class, working in a charity where the trustees are upper class and the service providers working class, and the service users working class also. There's a fairly standard education strata between the three categories too.

So on the one hand I get handed instructions in Latin (which I do understand) and on the other I have to be careful with my vocabulary/not let slip I have a cleaner because they'll back off from me and give me side eye for being posh etc.

I think that people who say "class doesn't exist any more" consist solely of people who are stuck in a middle-class bubble without a huge variation of people. (my last role was like this - everyone from a variety of backgrounds, interests etc, but they all broadly fit into middle class)

Branleuse · 11/03/2022 11:42

You are going to have to work on not giving a fuck what your random posh colleagues do or think. Youre unlikely to be the only working class person there.

VerveClique · 11/03/2022 11:41

You’re not imagining it up OP.

There’s a huge amount of social signaling that goes on at work and progress does not necessarily happen according to merit because of it.

I feel for you.

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 11:41

@AnnesBrokenSlate

You're not working class. You are a professional with a university education - that makes you middle class and you need to own your status in life now not the status you were born into.

Also, you're in your 30s, I can't believe that you haven't made contacts throughout university and your career. I also don't believe everyone else in your workplace came from privilege or that it means they don't have any anxieties or financial worries. Class doesn't always denote wealth.

My family are working class. I went to an RG uni, etc. I've been in workplaces where my colleagues were landed gentry; had relatives in the House of Lords, etc. I never felt I didn't belong because I was there on merit.

Counselling might help OP. You're framing your difficulties as unsurmountable and outwith your control. You can't control where or how you were born. You absolutely can control how you fit now. And your class should not impact on career progression. An appointment with a career or hr professional might help too.

Thanks. I dont really want to belong to any class club, but unfortunately that's just the way society and then workplace seems to operate still.

I really wouldn't consider myself middle class or care to identify as such. Degree educations are ten a penny now. I think class is more reflective of cultural and social factors and engrained family wealth than income or education level. In my opinion, if you have to work for all your income in order to afford to live, you're working class.

OP posts:
Gowithme · 11/03/2022 11:40

I find the people who get promotions are the ones who are very confident, always talk themselves up, get their face noticed and really push themselves forward. My OH is brilliant at his job, been there years, knows it inside out but he gets on with things quietly on his own, doesn't push himself forward and so gets overlooked.

He is white male but from a working class immigrant family so he could blame it on that - but knowing what the people are like who are promoted over him it is not because they are cleverer or know the job better or are richer or from a higher class - it's because they are very clear that they are looking to move up and always pushing themselves forward making it clear how important they are to the company.

Perhaps you need to stop labelling yourself as working class and letting the fact that you still rent define you in negative ways. Start putting yourself forward, tell people how hard you've worked to get where you are, tell people the trials you've had to go through. Be you but be confident and assertive. You've done amazingly and you don't have to keep quiet because you haven't been skiing and don't own a house yet. People are more likely to be impressed that you have got this far without any support if they are half decent people.

veevee04 · 11/03/2022 11:35

I'm working class born although my dad has a professional job so is my OH but we have worked ourselves up into professional jobs. All our friends outside of work are working class, I prefer their humour and outlook on life.

NellyBarney · 11/03/2022 11:34

First of all, be proud of yourself. Secondly, take the long view. Many of your colleagues had help from their parents. If you choose to have children, you will hopefully be able to give them more support/advice than your parents were able, and so on. You also don't seem to be in a relationship/marriage. From a financial perspective, there is a huge advantage to having a two income household.

Booboobibles · 11/03/2022 11:33

One of my best friends has a very expensive house and plays in a string quartet but she’s actually from the same area as me and just happens to have a nicer accent. She’s really lovely and not snobby at all.

Rummikub · 11/03/2022 11:33

It’s about how others treat you and respond to you. It’s fine to adopt a don’t give a fuck attitude but it can get too much/ overwhelming.

Rosehugger · 11/03/2022 11:31

Even that is still not more than 50-60% private school

Only 50% from private school? Well, that's just fine then. No diversity issues to worry about there. Nothing to see there, nope.