Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fit in because I'm working class

233 replies

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 09:48

I'm from a working class background and I grew up with little money. I did very well academically and managed to go to a top uni and get a good degree, despite not feeling like I belonged. I've worked hard for 15 years to establish my career in a competitive industry with no financial support, which has resulted in a lot of stress and debt over the years.

I work in an industry that's generally full of wealthy, middle class people who dont seem to have any anxieties about life or financial limits (despite the salaries not being that much). I've recently started a new job and feel really out of place, like I do at every job. My colleagues have very different lifestyles and conversation topics to me. Eg. House renovations, skiing holidays, private schooling, second homes in Europe. I'm 36 and 'still' rent a small flat with a friend, which seems to surprise and provoke pity amongst my colleagues. Most had property bought for them/got deposits from their parents years ago and speak like this is standard practice. I rarely go on holidays and don't have any expensive hobbies as I've been trying to save for a house deposit for many years.

To get to this point in my career I've really struggled financially and mentally and I'm pretty tired. I dont feel like im seen on the same page as everyone else at work and think it also affects my career progression. I just wonder if I can ever belong here.

OP posts:
tkwal · 11/03/2022 12:54

I voted YABU because you're being too hard on yourself. You have achieved so much based purely on your own initiative and hard work. You obviously have the qualifications to have got your new job and you will do well because you have instilled yourself with a work ethic. It always takes a while to settle into a new workplace. Until you do ,deal with your colleagues on the basis of how well they do their jobs and not what kind of house they live in or how much their parents paid for their education.
On your personal life..what's wrong with sharing a flat ? You're saving for a deposit. Until you get there you only have to pay half the bills and as a bonus you have company. In fact when you buy your house you could rent a room out for the same reason. Hold your head high Woman, you're doing yourself proud

Tulipomania · 11/03/2022 12:46

OP, I suggest you read Matthew Syed, Rebel Ideas, on the importance of diversity of thinking in business.

I am one of the 'wealthy' middle-class people you describe and in my business we would absolutely welcome you and your different ideas and experiences. It is a poor reflection on your employer that they don't have policies that discourage a monolithic mindset.

Be proud of who you are and let people know about it!

alltheapples · 11/03/2022 12:46

@elbea I know exactly where you are coming from xx

Allelbowsandtoes · 11/03/2022 12:45

@GeneLovesJezebel

I think you need to stop looking for class differences, it really doesn’t matter any more. Just be yourself. Were you like this at Uni, comparing yourself to others ?
I haven't rtft but this is the most ignorant comment I've seen in a while.
Crumbleburntbits · 11/03/2022 12:44

I’m another one who’s guessing that you work in publishing. I met a few posh idiots and some really nice posh people when I worked for a publishing company many years ago.

I didn’t ‘fit in’ because of my looks, the way I spoke, the way I dressed, my religion etc. When I was asked if I’d ever been skiing, I said I slid down my front path in the ice and did that count? I found using humour and being friendly helped a bit towards trying to bridge the huge gap between them and me.

@Shadowmallow I understand your difficulties with your work colleagues and career. My solution was to move into to a completely different career which was better paid and far more diverse.

elbea · 11/03/2022 12:42

We go to a nursery group for toddlers who are starting pre prep next year. I often don’t know what to say to people and feel like a bit of a moron. Today there was a twenty minute chat about skiing. I was born to teenage working class parents, we were lucky for a butlins trip! My daughter gets to do all the things I desperately wanted but couldn’t like swimming lessons, holidays, ballet but relating to people is hard sometimes.

blameless · 11/03/2022 12:42

@Shadowmallow

As one of the sandwich generation (financially supporting both parents and children), I was never talking about builder's bills, the expense of private schooling, the cost of tennis lessons because of my child's precocious talent etc.

Are those conversations what really entrenches inequality as opportunities for promotion and pay rises find their way to those who really 'need' them?

astoundedgoat · 11/03/2022 12:39

I called it above with publishing too! It's so abysmally badly paid, and fully caters towards people who doing have to work for a living - I follow a lot of book people on Twitter, and saw an amazing literary agency job last week in London - PART TIME at 29k pro rata. WTAF?

Do follow Sam Missingham on Twitter and ASK FOR HELP. Get a career coach, look actively for the emotional and networking training that your colleagues got for free. Someone else above called it "social capital".

I'm financially secure, but not British and not from the same sort of background as a lot of my friends. My Dad grew up without enough to eat, and experienced the same gap you're having now.

He was terrified of poverty and saved everything so we never had anything at all - he handled money very very differently to any of my peers, or any of the families of my friends now as an adult, and I have HUGE gaps in my own "social capital" and have exposed mortifying naivety on many occasions. I cover it up with being "foreign". :)

So I know what you're feeling up to a point. But the big thing that would have helped my Dad is a career coach to show him how to navigate his professional life, and maybe guide him a bit on the money thing too. I know I'm banging on about this, but everyone needs professional support and mentoring and your own family doesn't have the experience to give it to you, so you have to pay for it.

DameHelena · 11/03/2022 12:38

@GeneLovesJezebel

I think you need to stop looking for class differences, it really doesn’t matter any more. Just be yourself. Were you like this at Uni, comparing yourself to others ?
But if conversation is about things the OP can't talk about, and her living situation means they react with surprise and pity, it kind of DOES matter. I get you, OP. I grew up working-class, in terms of both having no money and 'cultural' things like watching ITV and not being expected to go to uni, and when I did get to uni and met middle-class people for the first time it definitely set me apart. I'm older now and basically live a middle-class life, but there are still these differences and I'm always at least slightly aware that I'm not really 'one of them'.
AdoraBell · 11/03/2022 12:38

Haven’t RTFT so apologies if I’m repeating but OP instead of focusing on class focus on your achievements.

Bromse · 11/03/2022 12:34

@PinkNails1

The middle class posters here need to realise that social class has long last effects. It doesn’t matter if you’re all on the same wage - MC people are given house deposits etc which means that they never have to worry about saving up for a house, car, house renovations etc. Mummy and daddy just throw money at them even when they’re adults.
Depends what you mean by 'middle class'. Not all middle class people are wealthy and not all working class, poor. Each class encompasses a wide range of incomes. I'm not a sociologist but even I know that. I've been around working and middle class people all my life and they are all different, the differences not necessarily class related.

People who are so class conscious that they either look down on people or feel inferior to or intimidated by, people have a problem. I wonder if they ever have real friends.

There is also working class snobbery: my mother was a typical example of that. I can look back now and find it quite funny but when I was growing up her sniffy attitude, dreadful fake voice in some circumstances and rules about what was done and not done, made life difficult (not to say often highly embarrassing), for an ordinary girl like me who treated everyone the same and just wanted to be herself. Mum had good points of course, could be lovely.

The op will be all right, she is just unhappy in her working environment at the moment and dissatisfied in other respects but things will change for her. Nothing stays quite the same forever.

Billandben444 · 11/03/2022 12:30

And I don't know what your industry is but it needs you - it needs more working class people, more first gen immigrants, more POC, etc etc etc. It's shitty to be the one leading the charge, especially if the culture really hasn't changed, but also you really deserve to be there, and you are making a path for the next generation which will hopefully be more diverse
Leading the charge?!! Fhs, she's a bit miserable about her status at work and all of a sudden she's an Amazonian going into battle. Phew.

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 12:29

[quote bluedodecagon]@Shadowmallow

Oh please don’t do that thing where the OP is super super defensive and ignores every single piece of advice except the one that reinforces what they believe. Please don’t.

Most of the people on this thread grew up working-class. I know I grew up in a working-class home. We are trying to help you . People are not ignoring you and they’re not dismissing you but you’re frustrated and you are used to not being heard and so your tendency is to shut down and not listen to people.

The reality is that you cannot afford to live with your partner, you cannot afford to live by yourself. Your real issue isn’t that you’re working class, it’s like you’re in a really low paying profession. Plenty of working class people share homes with their partners. Plenty of working class people go on holiday. Plenty of working class people have adventures. I just don’t think this is a class issue. I think this is a you issue. You have decided how working class people should live and are treated and it has combined with your low self-esteem.

One of the biggest disadvantages of being working class is lacking something called social capital. it’s not about connections or going to the golf clubs, it’s about knowing what kind of professions are out there and knowing what kind of opportunities around there and being able to exploit them. A smart working class kid may go into a low paying career and may end up working in the lowest rung in that career because they haven’t got a friend or an uncle who can tell them that there is a much better high-paying job with the same skills that they could be in.

My guess is that this is what you are doing. My guess is that this is a dead end career that only extremely wealthy people can afford to do because it’s crappily paid and working-class people won’t bother to do it because there’s a much better use for their skills. Like publishing!

Tell us what your profession is and we can probably help you get into a job that gets you the life you want.[/quote]
I think some of what you've said is a bit harsh but your opinion is appreciated. And you're spot on with the profession. I work in publishing.

I cant afford to buy because all my money goes on housing and bills, whereas my counterparts don't worry about that because a lot of them were mortgage free at 30 somehow... Almost all of their income is disposable so they're able to have a variety of interests, leisure activities and travels.

OP posts:
alltheapples · 11/03/2022 12:27

@soootiredddd neither DP nor I have received any financial gifts since we were 18 years old. Do you really think we have the same experiences as you?

bluedodecagon · 11/03/2022 12:26

The thing about having a massive chip on your shoulder is that you will always find people online who will defend you and will stoke up your resentment but the question is do you want to be happy and do you want to have a good life?

If you do, take the advice of people who want to help you rather than the people who want you to stay stuck in misery.

There is no professional job that after 15 years experience, you cannot afford to live alone in London. It doesn’t exist. You may not be able to buy but you should be able to afford £1100 a month to rent a one bedroom or studio. Even jobs like teaching and social work present the opportunity to make great money after 15 years.

Arabellla · 11/03/2022 12:24

@soootiredddd

And just to add, even if someone's parents helped them with a house deposit, that doesn't mean that they are continually receiving handouts from their parents forever and ever. Having a bit of help with a lump sum for a deposit is not the same as having your parents finance your life, or inheriting huge amounts of cash to live off
It's more than most people get though.

You can't say you did it all by yourself.

flounfer · 11/03/2022 12:21

Having a bit of help with a lump sum for a deposit is not the same as having your parents finance your life, or inheriting huge amounts of cash to live off

It's not the same but it can be a huge help. My deposit & being able to live at home rent free meant I could get on the housing earlier. This has resulted in me benefiting from asset inflation & I now have 350k plus equity

Xenia · 11/03/2022 12:16

It sounds like you have done very well. I would concentrate on moving to better paid work as despite your top university etc you seem to have ended up in work that does not pay enough. Put that at the top of your priorities.

PinkNails1 · 11/03/2022 12:15

The middle class posters here need to realise that social class has long last effects. It doesn’t matter if you’re all on the same wage - MC people are given house deposits etc which means that they never have to worry about saving up for a house, car, house renovations etc. Mummy and daddy just throw money at them even when they’re adults.

bananamuffin89 · 11/03/2022 12:13

You've done amazing for yourself so give yourself some praise :)
unfortunately, we will always experience judgemental people.. privileged people have no concept of anyone outside of their bubble, so you do your thing, do you work and if the workplace is too toxic just try to look elsewhere for your own sanity.

alltheapples · 11/03/2022 12:13

OP I knew you would get a lot of the answers you have. Chip on your shoulder means you recognise the differences. The truth is we are supposed to pretend if we work hard and smart enough that everyone will be the same. It is not true.

I am surrounded by middle-class friends who all seem to be at the moment buying holiday homes. They talk of the competition for nice holiday homes with one pleased she had secured the last house someone had actually lived in on a much sought after seaside village.

Well off people constantly underplay how much help they get and the difference it makes. Inheritances are common and expected. Financial gifts are also fairly common. Whereas DP and I have worked for every penny we own since we ;left school.

My honest advice is to try and find friends in the same boat. It helps to have friends who understand. And accept you will feel out of place amongst the people you work with who haven't a fucking clue what they are talking about when it comes to this.

bluedodecagon · 11/03/2022 12:12

@Shadowmallow

Oh please don’t do that thing where the OP is super super defensive and ignores every single piece of advice except the one that reinforces what they believe. Please don’t.

Most of the people on this thread grew up working-class. I know I grew up in a working-class home. We are trying to help you . People are not ignoring you and they’re not dismissing you but you’re frustrated and you are used to not being heard and so your tendency is to shut down and not listen to people.

The reality is that you cannot afford to live with your partner, you cannot afford to live by yourself. Your real issue isn’t that you’re working class, it’s like you’re in a really low paying profession. Plenty of working class people share homes with their partners. Plenty of working class people go on holiday. Plenty of working class people have adventures. I just don’t think this is a class issue. I think this is a you issue. You have decided how working class people should live and are treated and it has combined with your low self-esteem.

One of the biggest disadvantages of being working class is lacking something called social capital. it’s not about connections or going to the golf clubs, it’s about knowing what kind of professions are out there and knowing what kind of opportunities around there and being able to exploit them. A smart working class kid may go into a low paying career and may end up working in the lowest rung in that career because they haven’t got a friend or an uncle who can tell them that there is a much better high-paying job with the same skills that they could be in.

My guess is that this is what you are doing. My guess is that this is a dead end career that only extremely wealthy people can afford to do because it’s crappily paid and working-class people won’t bother to do it because there’s a much better use for their skills. Like publishing!

Tell us what your profession is and we can probably help you get into a job that gets you the life you want.

Citabell · 11/03/2022 12:09

It sounds like the work culture isn't for you, perhaps consider a different organisation? Why aren't you invited to things though, do you let the fact you're very aware of their different upbringing factor into how you engage with them?

imjustanerd · 11/03/2022 12:04

@GeneLovesJezebel

I think you need to stop looking for class differences, it really doesn’t matter any more. Just be yourself. Were you like this at Uni, comparing yourself to others ?
It really does still matter actually.
flounfer · 11/03/2022 12:02

@seekinglondonlife

I assume your neighbours with their 3 London homes by the age of 30 are in the vast minority.

I'm completely aware of that. However that bubble exists which is the privilege the OP is referring too about her colleagues.

Despite most MNetters claiming that everyone they know got houses bought for them, the statistics do not match.

I'm not sure who has claimed that, certainly not me but assistance from the bank of mum & dad is very real.

Swipe left for the next trending thread