Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fit in because I'm working class

233 replies

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 09:48

I'm from a working class background and I grew up with little money. I did very well academically and managed to go to a top uni and get a good degree, despite not feeling like I belonged. I've worked hard for 15 years to establish my career in a competitive industry with no financial support, which has resulted in a lot of stress and debt over the years.

I work in an industry that's generally full of wealthy, middle class people who dont seem to have any anxieties about life or financial limits (despite the salaries not being that much). I've recently started a new job and feel really out of place, like I do at every job. My colleagues have very different lifestyles and conversation topics to me. Eg. House renovations, skiing holidays, private schooling, second homes in Europe. I'm 36 and 'still' rent a small flat with a friend, which seems to surprise and provoke pity amongst my colleagues. Most had property bought for them/got deposits from their parents years ago and speak like this is standard practice. I rarely go on holidays and don't have any expensive hobbies as I've been trying to save for a house deposit for many years.

To get to this point in my career I've really struggled financially and mentally and I'm pretty tired. I dont feel like im seen on the same page as everyone else at work and think it also affects my career progression. I just wonder if I can ever belong here.

OP posts:
stayathomer · 11/03/2022 14:53

There are so many conversations at work I can't contribute to (traveling is nearly always discussed and I've never been abroad).
So ask them about their holidays and steer it towards places you'd like to go in the future or what you're gonna do your next day off or whatever Flowers

stayathomer · 11/03/2022 14:50

The middle class posters here need to realise that social class has long last effects. It doesn’t matter if you’re all on the same wage - MC people are given house deposits etc which means that they never have to worry about saving up for a house, car, house renovations etc. Mummy and daddy just throw money at them even when they’re adults.
Nope! We were mc. In college I lived off savings from the summers I'd worked in school and evening work from college. When I was stuck with rent I went to the college and the lady had your attitude- your parents have chosen not to help you, you qualify for nothing. My parents were mc because they bought cheaply in a nice area before house prices went up and my dad was an insanely good saver and worked 2 jobs. It didn't mean he had thousands to spare.

Citabell · 11/03/2022 14:42

There are so many conversations at work I can't contribute to (traveling is nearly always discussed and I've never been abroad).

Can you initiate conversations?

Admittedly my first job from school was overwhelmingly working class, I grew up with an addict on a council estate and spent childhood being bullied for wearing hand me downs, not having the right clothing labels, never going on holiday, being horrible about how thin I was (my hair was also really thin and bad condition as looking back we were malnutritioned), just generally children know don't they. This wasn't an overly affluent area either so it wasn't out of the norm even. I studied for a degree before I left and my first job as a civvy was in the city- I couldn't believe I'd landed it but I do empathise as I felt embarrassed about now owning a house, having not travelled growing up etc; but I moved jobs about a year after and although many still grew up in affluent families we all get on well. I opened up for a social mobility workshop they were doing and people were really supportive and since then fuck it I've felt proud about how well I have done for myself. They're normal people too, and now that we are financially very fortunate I don't feel middle class at all either.

DSGR · 11/03/2022 14:35

I could have written your post and unless people have gone from abject poverty to somehow breaking through into the middle classes on intelligence and hard graft alone, it can be difficult to understand/sympathise.
OP, I was you and bit by bit things have improved. I carried on saving but only managed to buy when I met DH.
The thing you have to do is learn not to care.. others will always have more privilege than you. I take the mick out of my posher colleagues and they laugh at me.. we can still be good friends. You do have to stop feeling sorry for yourself, accept there are no handouts and keep striving for what you want

Newnamefor2022 · 11/03/2022 14:24

@JudgeRindersMinder

You’ll probably find it easier to fit in if you remove the 5lb bag* of McCains from your shoulder
Does it make you feel better to direct an unnecessary, unpleasant dig at the OP?
flounfer · 11/03/2022 14:17

What I'm trying to say is that plenty of middle class families give their kids £5k or £10k towards a house deposit

It's a bit more than that

"64 per cent of parents who said they had offered financial assistance with the deposit, the average contribution amounted to £32,440."

"14 per cent of parents saying that they gave their grown-up children more than £50,000 towards their home."

soootiredddd · 11/03/2022 14:01

@alltheapples where did I say that I had received any financial gifts? I haven't. But even so, no-one has the same experiences anyway, and that's not even what I was trying to say (and I think you know that). What I'm trying to say is that plenty of middle class families give their kids £5k or £10k towards a house deposit, and that doesn't mean their kids then 'don't have to work' in order to live. Just that the task of saving up their house deposit was made a bit easier. That's a million miles away from people who spend their whole lives living off 'family money' and not having to worry about earning a proper income.

(Me and my DP saved up all of our house deposit. And we both had large student loads to go to university. We were fortunate enough to go when fees were only £3k and not £9k but still came out the other side with ~£20k debt each).

blushi · 11/03/2022 13:55

I'm in my 20s and currently experiencing the same thing in my first job since university. There are so many conversations at work I can't contribute to (traveling is nearly always discussed and I've never been abroad).

It really knocks your confidence and makes it hard to bond with colleagues, and I just feel like an outsider. Some people would just own it but I don't really want to open up about growing up in poverty, there's still a lot of shame around it for me.

One thing that I noticed when I started was for working from home equipment I had to pay for it out of pocket and then wait 4 weeks for it go through expenses so I could get reimbursed. For most of my life I simply would not have had money to spare for this and I think it's the type of thing nobody had even thought about as it just wasn't on their radar that some people don't have any disposable income

Bromse · 11/03/2022 13:48

@incompetentcervix

I'm very similar to you. I don't fit at work and I spend my time worrying about money / paying off historical debt . It's hard. I go on caravan holiday to wales and my colleagues look at me like I'm an alien
Surely you don't have to tell them everything.
QuizzicalEyebrows · 11/03/2022 13:48

I think you work in an environment where this is quite noticeable and these colleagues like the safety of the world they're used to.

All you can do is change jobs really to a more normal environment with a healthy mix of people.

You'll start going a bit bonkers if you stay there because it's a strange little bubble you work alongside.

You don't have a chip on your shoulder at all you're just very observant and notice all the small details.

JudgeRindersMinder · 11/03/2022 13:43

You’ll probably find it easier to fit in if you remove the 5lb bag* of McCains from your shoulder

Chickychickydodah · 11/03/2022 13:41

Be proud of what you have achieved. If people don’t accept you then they aren’t worth knowing 💐

incompetentcervix · 11/03/2022 13:38

I'm very similar to you. I don't fit at work and I spend my time worrying about money / paying off historical debt . It's hard. I go on caravan holiday to wales and my colleagues look at me like I'm an alien

mysweetlemonpie · 11/03/2022 13:30

Try 'fitting in' when you're mixed race/black Sad

Honestly just hang out with the nice colleagues - ignore the rest.

Don't give up the opportunities your brain and talents have provided you.

nitsandwormsdodger · 11/03/2022 13:23

Mindset is everything
The only thing they really care about is if you are good at your job particularly the bits that affect them and be a pleasant collegiate person
Then it’s the same as any work place gravitate towards the ones you click with ignore the knobs
Check yourself- make sure you are not building or looking for barriers because you will find them if you are determined

BlondiesAllDay · 11/03/2022 13:21

Oh ffs I hate the class system. It needs to die!

I genuinely don't see class. I just see people I get on with and people I don't. My mum used to remind me, quite frequently, that we were lower middle class. I never really understood what it meant. Still don't really, but I think what she meant was, we're not well off (lower) but my dad wears a suit to work (middle class) Hmm

bluedodecagon · 11/03/2022 13:21

@Shadowmallow

I’m sorry that you think I was harsh but I literally stood up and cheered when you said you were in publishing because I knew it.Most people on the thread who guessed a profession guessed publishing because it is the worst industry to work in.

You have to understand that you are working in an industry in which only wealthy people can work. It’s a socialite profession full of incompetent toffs. Your experience is that “middle class” people work in a low-income job and then their parents buy them a house outright. But you have to understand that that is not the norm even for upper middle-class people. Most middle-class people choose higher paying professions, for a start. That’s usually the point of going to a good school! Or they marry investment bankers at said school. They may get deposit help from their parents but their parents usually don’t have to pay for their entire lifestyles.

You have to leave this industry. The twatty culture, the low pay, the disrespect: it will all go away once you move out of publishing.

This is such an easy fix. Get a career coach and transfer those skills over into an industry that will respect you and will pay you well. You are 36 years old and you cannot afford to go on holiday. you cannot afford to live with your partner. It’s not worth it.

I am so glad for you. You are not delusional. You don’t have a chip on your shoulder. You are correctly assessing the culture of the industry in which you were in. But you have to understand that that industry is an anomaly. It’s not that class doesn’t matter anywhere else or that having upper-class parents isn’t an advantage, but you are in a uniquely terrible industry where there is no merit based promotion at all and the pay is TERRIBLE. There is not one professional job out there that would not be an improvement on what you are doing right now. You’d probably make more money as a PA.

BigSkies22 · 11/03/2022 13:20

I've been listening to a variety of podcasts (been doing lots of decluttering and decorating, for context!) on social mobility and class. Professor Selina Todd wrote Snakes and Ladders a few years ago, and talked about the hidden injuries of class, cultural capital and various other elements which seem very pertinent to your situation OP. And she actually cited an example of a woman who had worked hard on herself in terms of becoming well-educated, got a professional job, cultivated the 'right' hobbies, but couldn't break through the glass ceiling because she couldn't afford to go on the kind of holidays and outings that her better off peers used to network and make their next promotion happen.

I guess you just have to make a virtue of your strengths and position. If someone appears surprised you're renting, you can just pivot silkily and say, 'Yes, I'm aiming to buy somewhere I can get away easily for weekend hiking. I really like hiking in the .... area, do you know it? ' Or, 'Yes, and I"m really looking forward to being able to decorate as I want. I absolutely love x designer's style, what sort of thing do you like?"

zafferana · 11/03/2022 13:06

YANBU if that's your experience OP. No one can tell you that you're wrong to feel the way you do! Try not to be hung up though on class differences. Whoever you are and whatever you achieve in life, there will always be people who are more successful, wealthier, have nicer things or greater advantages in life than you. It's true of those people you work with too - I'm willing to get that they too meet people who make them feel the way that they make you feel - because that's life. There is always someone who's doing better, who's got a nicer car, a bigger house, more money. Hold your head high - it sounds like you're doing great and don't allow yourself to suffer from imposter syndrome. You're not an imposter. You got there without anyone's help - that's bloody amazing.

QuinkWashable · 11/03/2022 13:05

Class has nothing to do with money and actually going skiing is costing way less than the summer package holiday that my DP parents want us to go on. Going to the theatre is cheaper than going out for dinner. You don’t have to ride to be able to engage in a conversation about horses.

I think you're slightly missing the point (and horses - well, I'm in Ireland - lots of people can have an engaging conversation about horses here, of all backgrounds)

I do sympathise with OP, but I think she's overthinking and needs to dive in.

I was raised in the countryside, with very little, and now am doing well for myself, albeit in an industry that has a wide range of backgrounds (although majority male which is its own challenge).

The issue i have, and I lean on my foreign-ness to hide, is that I don't know what so many things are or how they work - prep, pre-prep, the aforementioned ski holidays, private healthcare - all of this is something I've had to research and learn about, whereas to those raised with money it's just the water they swim in. And it is tough, I've found that keeping my mouth shut a lot of the time saves embarrassment, and then pushing myself forward and inviting myself to whatever helps other times.

Franklyfrost · 11/03/2022 13:04

I don’t think you’re wrong. These differences do exist. However:

  1. there are human connections that can be made outside of class or wealth.
  2. Don’t try to fit in, work out what you want and what you can do without measuring yourself only against others. Do you want to go skiing? Are you feeling lonely? How happy are you with your accommodation? Is your job rewarding? There will always be groups that exclude others. There are also groups that aren’t the middle class clique which might welcome you.
Alcoholabuse · 11/03/2022 12:59

@AnnesBrokenSlate I agree
‘ You're not working class. You are a professional with a university education - that makes you middle class and you need to own your status in life now not the status you were born into.

Also, you're in your 30s, I can't believe that you haven't made contacts throughout university and your career. I also don't believe everyone else in your workplace came from privilege or that it means they don't have any anxieties or financial worries. Class doesn't always denote wealth.

My family are working class. I went to an RG uni, etc. I've been in workplaces where my colleagues were landed gentry; had relatives in the House of Lords, etc. I never felt I didn't belong because I was there on merit.

Counselling might help OP. You're framing your difficulties as unsurmountable and outwith your control. You can't control where or how you were born. You absolutely can control how you fit now. And your class should not impact on career progression. An appointment with a career or hr professional might help too.’

I grew up WC with a single mum on benefits, but privileged that we were encouraged to get a good education - local dive of a state school but always encouraged with extra curricular activities that usually the ‘posh’ kids took up. The local city choir was free and athletics was 50p a session. I was taught that if anyone makes you inferior due to background/money they have zero class.

I went to an ex-poly and got myself into a medium size company that it didn’t matter what grades you had or where you came from having a work ethic, willing to learn and being able to get on with everyone propelled me forward.

Working at uni meant that I was able to go ‘travelling’ in the holidays - I budgeted £20 a day for a month to go around Europe. Went backpacking around Asia on even less and even all the ‘posh’ kids were slumming it too. I loved travelling as sitting around a table with a cheap bottle of local spirits nobody cared what your parents did for a living, or what school you went to or how much money you’ve got in the bank.

I’m still in my twenties but got friends from all backgrounds. I can hold a conversation with anyone. My best friend went to private school not that I knew that for the first two years at uni. My other best friend went to Cambridge but we went to the same shitty primary together.

I’m going skiing with her friendship group next season but we also still predrink wine from Aldi, go to whetherspoons and go clothes shopping in the sales.

Inverted snobbery is something that I find hard to be around as I shouldn’t have to announce that I went to state school, grew up poor and the holiday I just went on was because I was staying with family just because people will judge a book by the cover that I’m ‘posh’/middle class.

Class has nothing to do with money and actually going skiing is costing way less than the summer package holiday that my DP parents want us to go on. Going to the theatre is cheaper than going out for dinner. You don’t have to ride to be able to engage in a conversation about horses.

I drive a banger of a car, the only people ask why I drive a banger are people from ‘WC’ backgrounds.

UnconditionalSurrender · 11/03/2022 12:59

There's a sort of club where some people who are mc with money like to belong- its all golf, rugby, tennis, sailing, skiing, private schools. There are people who are into these things individually and there are people who are into them because that's what mc people are meant to be into. Only mix with your sort.
There's plenty mc people who aren't into any of that. DH and I would be solidly mc I think - 2nd generation university educated. A couple of degrees each. We don't want in that club. and are not interested in any of those things. My SIL and BIL who are less educated and but have more money so desperately want to belong they do all that stuff.
You just need to happy in your own skin and with your own choices. Would you want to be in that club anyway?

tkwal · 11/03/2022 12:58

astoundedgoat

Does that job allow working remotely, pretty sure I could do that Smile

fruitbrewhaha · 11/03/2022 12:56

So you're very academic, hard working with a top uni degree but on shit pay. Do you think this is really the issue? You mention you've debt from building up your career but after 15 years it doesn't sound like it's paying back.

Why don't you look for other opportunities? You're 36 but you don't earn enough to be able to go on holiday or do fun hobbies. While you don't to go horse riding wouldn't it be nice to be able to tell people about a trekking holiday in India or some other interesting place? Or at least having an interesting life to live (rather than tell people about)