Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fit in because I'm working class

233 replies

Shadowmallow · 11/03/2022 09:48

I'm from a working class background and I grew up with little money. I did very well academically and managed to go to a top uni and get a good degree, despite not feeling like I belonged. I've worked hard for 15 years to establish my career in a competitive industry with no financial support, which has resulted in a lot of stress and debt over the years.

I work in an industry that's generally full of wealthy, middle class people who dont seem to have any anxieties about life or financial limits (despite the salaries not being that much). I've recently started a new job and feel really out of place, like I do at every job. My colleagues have very different lifestyles and conversation topics to me. Eg. House renovations, skiing holidays, private schooling, second homes in Europe. I'm 36 and 'still' rent a small flat with a friend, which seems to surprise and provoke pity amongst my colleagues. Most had property bought for them/got deposits from their parents years ago and speak like this is standard practice. I rarely go on holidays and don't have any expensive hobbies as I've been trying to save for a house deposit for many years.

To get to this point in my career I've really struggled financially and mentally and I'm pretty tired. I dont feel like im seen on the same page as everyone else at work and think it also affects my career progression. I just wonder if I can ever belong here.

OP posts:
WeirdArchitecture · 12/03/2022 12:59

Odd about the 'pity' part of your OP.
I am MC, grew up riding, education focused, typical set up - but Im still renting at 48 and none of my MC peer group give a shiny shit. They know I chose to pursue art over money, and that my interests in life are a bit less....prescriptive. But I never feel out of place with my more 'straight laced' or monied friends.

I think it's about who you are, what you identify with. You are perceiving difference and those differences are an issue for you and your self esteem, perhaps. Do you feel like something of an imposter?

I honestly doubt anyone pities you because you rent from a landlord instead of a bank Grin. Renting suits many people, regardless of class or profession. Some inherit property, some purchase more than one. Some lead a more bohemian lifestyle and don't give a damn. Does it matter?

Attitudes towards money and work do vary between social groups (I prefer that description to the word 'class') and maybe you feel at sea due to having experienced a different kind of upbringing and/or values.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 12/03/2022 12:35

If this thread was reversed and this was someone middle class looking down their noses at someone who was working class, people would be all over it. But it's OK the other way round is it? Who are you all to mock other people's hobbies and lifestyles? What business of yours is it if they chose to go skiing or riding? Or spend their money on holidays? FFS. Judgemental load of shit.

Shadowmallow · 12/03/2022 12:27

@bluedodecagon Yeah I'm looking to leave the publushing industry. A lot of what I do at the moment is digital, and I also UX design experience as I've helped to research and build some educational tools and apps over the past few years. Thinking of moving my career more in that direction.

OP posts:
Shadowmallow · 12/03/2022 12:24

@SuitcaseOfWhine

Similar situation with me OP. Was a child of single parent who worked 50+ hours a week and still did not have enough money. I never invited my friends over as the house was falling apart. I guess it did affect me and I've always felt out of place, but when my mother asked me what my childhood was like the other day, I said it was pretty good and I felt very loved despite my mother's long hours (I compared my life down against what other kids on my estate had). I have known middle class kids who never seemed to be happy and had drug and anger problems. Many never lived up to their parents expectations and it completely crushed them.

That said, I do feel like I don't belong in my public service role and didn't feel like I fitted in at uni. I thought due to the pay it would be all working class people in public services, but I soon realised that MC people can take these low paid roles because their lives are incredibly subsidised by parents. The worst was when one sat with the service users who were on benefits and talked about how stressful their renovation on their house was, but was looking forward to getting their massive 55 inch TV. Grin

I have noticed that MC colleagues seem to go through the ranks a lot quicker despite making some terrible decisions. Where I work the MC people seems to have the confidence and vision to change things, the WC people correct the faults afterwards (despite highlighting them and getting ignored or being called obstructive). Being WC also held me back at university, I couldn't stay on and do a masters, despite getting a good first and an academic award. The six grand to do a masters seemed too risky without a job in the pipeline after, and PhD's would have had to be funded for me to do them.

So from my experience my inferiority complex has some truth in it and it is not all in my head. I think the MC expect a certain lifestyle and have the confidence, parental expectation and the financial means to get it, whereas WC people have to work harder, learn about MC culture to fit in (my parents didn't know anything about the world of work beyond the roles they do) and make decisions very carefully to make their life work, and they still may not get the things MC people take for granted.

And by the way, never liked the idea of skiing anyway. I couldn't think of anything worse than being surrounded by drunk people on skis talking about wanky restaurants, private education and rental properties.

I relate to a lot of this. Some MC people don't realise the baseline they're starting from gives them a significant head start in life - theyre kind of oblivious to what is their norm. Like the poster above, seemingly missing the point. You don't need to receive handouts, but having solid financial and cultural foundations makes a huge difference. For WC people, shelling out for a Master's for example is seen as too much of a risk. If it doesn't work out, you'll be left in the gutter with nothing and a ton of debt. The stakes are higher. So off to get a job that pays instead of 'following your dreams' or trying to further your career. If you're MC you have a confidence that all will work out, and if it doesn't well, you'll likely have a cushion to fall back on. Not always, but more likely to be the case.

Also bloody love Charlie Brooker Grin

OP posts:
bluedodecagon · 12/03/2022 12:12

@stayathomer

Everyone talking about OP moving publishing companies, is that even feasible? I'm an author and the whole book world is looking for a publishing job (although maybe once you're in you're in?)!! But op, kudos for the job you got and hopefully it'll get you a better paid job in the future (only if you want it of course!!!)Flowers
No, she needs to leave publishing altogether.

How are your digital skills @Shadowmallow?

seekinglondonlife · 12/03/2022 09:35

Sorry @SuitcaseofWhine but I don't think you can blame being WC on not allowing you to progress at uni and do a masters. You obviously didn't have proper knowledge of the loan system if you felt that you had to have a good job in the pipeline before taking one on. And the vast majority of Phds are funded, not paid for by mummy and daddy. I feel this thread is so full of assumptions about "MC people" (who are a broad spectrum in themselves) and I say that as someone who has received zero handouts. Well actually not true, for my wedding my DPs gave me a pots and pan set they had recently bought and their old TV as they were upgrading it. I went to university as a mature student and my parents couldn't tell you the name of my course let alone pay for it and throw in multiple ski trips and a house deposit too.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 12/03/2022 07:36

You need to watch this OP. Very funny and made me realise that a lot of this aspirational talk you hear from other people is all bollocks.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 12/03/2022 07:27

Similar situation with me OP. Was a child of single parent who worked 50+ hours a week and still did not have enough money. I never invited my friends over as the house was falling apart. I guess it did affect me and I've always felt out of place, but when my mother asked me what my childhood was like the other day, I said it was pretty good and I felt very loved despite my mother's long hours (I compared my life down against what other kids on my estate had). I have known middle class kids who never seemed to be happy and had drug and anger problems. Many never lived up to their parents expectations and it completely crushed them.

That said, I do feel like I don't belong in my public service role and didn't feel like I fitted in at uni. I thought due to the pay it would be all working class people in public services, but I soon realised that MC people can take these low paid roles because their lives are incredibly subsidised by parents. The worst was when one sat with the service users who were on benefits and talked about how stressful their renovation on their house was, but was looking forward to getting their massive 55 inch TV. Grin

I have noticed that MC colleagues seem to go through the ranks a lot quicker despite making some terrible decisions. Where I work the MC people seems to have the confidence and vision to change things, the WC people correct the faults afterwards (despite highlighting them and getting ignored or being called obstructive). Being WC also held me back at university, I couldn't stay on and do a masters, despite getting a good first and an academic award. The six grand to do a masters seemed too risky without a job in the pipeline after, and PhD's would have had to be funded for me to do them.

So from my experience my inferiority complex has some truth in it and it is not all in my head. I think the MC expect a certain lifestyle and have the confidence, parental expectation and the financial means to get it, whereas WC people have to work harder, learn about MC culture to fit in (my parents didn't know anything about the world of work beyond the roles they do) and make decisions very carefully to make their life work, and they still may not get the things MC people take for granted.

And by the way, never liked the idea of skiing anyway. I couldn't think of anything worse than being surrounded by drunk people on skis talking about wanky restaurants, private education and rental properties.

stayathomer · 12/03/2022 07:10

Everyone talking about OP moving publishing companies, is that even feasible? I'm an author and the whole book world is looking for a publishing job (although maybe once you're in you're in?)!! But op, kudos for the job you got and hopefully it'll get you a better paid job in the future (only if you want it of course!!!)Flowers

DragonMovie · 12/03/2022 06:36

Actually ignore my previous advice… just read you work in publishing and also read other people’s perspectives on it. It sounds awful and doesn’t sound like you’ll ever earn a decent salary - I’d find a new career.

DragonMovie · 12/03/2022 06:00

Sounds really tough. There are some practical steps you could take to secure progression.

Have you spoken about progression with your line manager? You might need to put yourself on his/her radar for progression.

You could ask for a more senior mentor or coach to coach you into your next role. At some point you would have the relationship with them that would allow you to broach the class issue and ask them for their perspective on it.

You’ve probably had to fight a bit harder than your colleagues for the things you’ve achieved so far and it sounds like that might have to continue. You certainly shouldn’t have to learn to ski or ride a horse to get a promotion.

If none of this works after a set time that you think is reasonable or achievable (eg a year) then maybe look for another company. Company culture will not be the same everywhere.

theculture · 12/03/2022 05:44

I grew up in a working class area with a middle class parent and a working class one who has gone to university so my main experience going up we're working class but I did have a bit of middle class cultural fill in, visiting one set on grandparents, going to theatres etc

I carried on in education etc and even with my bit of middle class influence found it very hard, having gaps compared to other people's experiences., often feeling stupid, boring and ignorant

I ended up working in an industry with people from all over the world and eventually a different country

It is so much more relaxing if you / they can't meet and judge class and background based of all the little tells in accents, clothes, child hood experiences, holiday destinations etc and it really confirmed to me how much of that goes on

Ajay96 · 12/03/2022 05:31

I think I understand where your coming from. Long story short, I'm also seen and judged differently at home and at work. My home town is quite deprived, I was the only one of my friends to go to university and get a professional job, so im constantly classed as the posh one, always getting comments about how they can't believe what I do etc. Although I've done well for myself, im always playing it down as hate the fuss that is made about it, I just want to feel normal etc. People have created this image of me being perfect etc, and is so hard to live up to, so when I do something wrong there's a big fuss made of it. My work is lovely and I get on with all my colleagues, however I do feel we live very different lives. I keep a lot of personal information to myself, and find it hard to engage in conversations. These are mainly due to our differences in likes and opinions. This has left me feeling like I have no real place of belonging as I don't fully fit in to either worlds.

Rummikub · 12/03/2022 03:05

@GiraffesInScarfs

Even the Tory government are recognising the need to level up.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤦🏻‍♀️🙈🤦🏻‍♀️🙈🤦🏻‍♀️😂😂😂

Oh dear. Oh dear, oh dear. You actually think they have any intention of even attempting to do that?! Why on Earth would they?! 😆

I know

I dont think they will- it will be a bastardised version, but I live in hope.

dipdye · 11/03/2022 23:39

Do you still have a working class accent?

perimenofertility · 11/03/2022 23:29

I was scrolling through this thread with interest, wondering what career was exclusively middle class apart from the one working class OP. And when I got to this
"I work in publishing."
I was baffled - I also work in publishing and would say the majority of my colleagues are from a working class background. Perhaps you've just been unlucky with your workplaces, move somewhere else and you'll find a different crowd.

GiraffesInScarfs · 11/03/2022 22:56

Even the Tory government are recognising the need to level up.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤦🏻‍♀️🙈🤦🏻‍♀️🙈🤦🏻‍♀️😂😂😂

Oh dear. Oh dear, oh dear. You actually think they have any intention of even attempting to do that?! Why on Earth would they?! 😆

Laniania · 11/03/2022 22:30

Trooper! Sorry, sleep-deprived.

Laniania · 11/03/2022 22:30

Ha I knew it would be publishing! You're a trouper to have done so well with those salaries in (I presume) London. I admire your persistence but I couldn't be doing with it. I'm a writer and have experienced the industry from that side. Also have lovely SIL who works in publishing. It is like a different world though; I was looking at a job ad the other day for head of non-fiction at one of the major houses and was shocked at what it paid for the skills demanded at that relatively senior level; really brings it home that the people doing those jobs must largely be those who can already afford to.

In my opinion, if you have to work for all your income in order to afford to live, you're working class.

I really don't agree with that; by that definition I would be working class and I'm not. I come from a broke-arse culturally middle class family and to call myself working class would be appropriate in my view.

timetokill · 11/03/2022 22:16

I can echo your experiences and background, same working class (probably lower class actually since my mum was a single mum on benefits with 5 kids in a council flat), I received a decent state school education, top university and reputable graduate job in a competitive industry. And I'm from a mixed race heritage.

Yes I did not fit it with the MC/ UC, trust fund babies crowd (at work), I am / was completely polar opposite, but I took it by the bullocks and owned it. It gave me the best life experience education and nurturing could ever offer - international travel, explorations, adventures, tastes, experiences, arts, culture, history, reading, broadening my horizon, meeting people from all walks of life. My working class/ secondary school friends as still stuck in rut, with the same mentality and behavior as their parents. I have been sensible with money too, and did not get any support to own a property by my 30s. If anything the experience with MC people will definitely enable a better life and privilege for my children (as I am now married with children to a MC man). At first I was bit of a novelty with my MC work colleagues and friends but it passes once you become more acquainted to the new norm.

Mackmama · 11/03/2022 21:37

I have an understanding of how you feel. I did a masters straight after my degree where I could compete academically but I was one of about three out of 45 on the course who didn’t go to private school. I never felt I fit in and it put me off from perusing a career in that field. When the scrap for graduate scheme jobs started, I didn’t get involved and I took a job in local government and suddenly I was among loads of people who were just like me. In 15 years I’ve not encountered anyone I couldn’t get along with on some level, I’m happy and comfortable at work and don’t have any regrets.

As others have said there’s no reason why you shouldn’t carry on doing what you’re doing, you’ve earned the right to be there but if you do decide otherwise then there could be other options for you where you’ll feel happierx

blueshoes · 11/03/2022 21:00

OP, have you posted this before? I seem to recall a very similar thread, down to the examples given.

alltheapples · 11/03/2022 20:53

@Bellalastrasse although I recognise what you are saying, there are plenty of upper middle-class people who are the real thing and happy to exclude and subtly put others down who are not the same.

Flubadubba · 11/03/2022 20:27

OP, it doesn't surprise me a jot that you work in publishing! I am also someone from a working class background who works in publishing, though very much of the less glamourous side (academic books) and I am well enough established to be in an OK paying middle management role. It took me a long time to get there, though, via a RG uni and a variety of crap paying jobs (all.in less glam areas)

Publishing definitely has a diversity issue (not just in race, but also class, disability and a variety of other areas my hands are too tired to type) which is hideously obvious. I have met a lot of the types you talk about over the years, but there are a lot of people like us in non-trade publishers-- definitely.more than you think.

It really, really sucks and it's an issue we need to resolve. Such a skilled workforce should receive better compensation to help level the playing field and diversify the workforce markedly.

flounfer · 11/03/2022 19:42

But telling people how much holidays / kitchen refits cost isn't... classy!

Who claimed that it was?

Although I don't subscribe to the MNs view that someone who talks about money is automatically a degenerate!