Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To rant about Crufts?

36 replies

GreenSnot · 11/03/2022 07:31

I want to rant about Crufts.

Firstly - the judging. Every year the judging is completely biased. Yesterday in the working group when the judge was introduced as a breeder of Samoyed dogs I said to DH immediately “the winner will be a husky type dog”. Sure enough, the winner was the Siberian husky with a similar husky type dog coming second. I think it was the Scottish terrier a few years ago where the breeder was introduced as a breeder of Scottish terriers - of course the Scottish terrier won. It’s ridiculous and so fucking obvious!! I’m in a lot of Facebook dog breed groups and they were all saying which dogs would win the various groups as it goes by who the judge is, who they know and who is friends with who. They were all right! The dogs who they said would win, won. Will the bias and unfair judging ever stop??

2nd point - why the fuck do handlers drag their dogs around by pulling on their necks making the dog run in a stupid unnatural gait? Surely the whole point is to see how the dog moves naturally? Yesterday behind us a husky was choking due to the way it’s neck was being pulled and the Dobermanns were running around looking like they were being literally hung. Why don’t they let them move naturally?! Surely that’s the whole point??

3rd point - still ridiculous levels of sloping backs on the German shepherds making their gait look like the dog is lame. Will this ever stop?!

AIBU? Anyone that agrees with the way crufts works please inform me of why I’m wrong!

OP posts:
GameofPhones · 11/03/2022 07:57

Why are German Shepherds bred with sloping backs?

GreenSnot · 11/03/2022 07:53

I’m pretty sure I heard some subtle booing when the Russian Terrier came on too, which is sickening. I felt so sorry for the handler.

OP posts:
damnthisvirusandmarriage · 11/03/2022 07:51

I agree with you. Plus it’s often sponsored by brands that test on animals. Often beagles.

I hate it.

RJnomore1 · 11/03/2022 07:50

I’m torn because you’re right about the GSD breeding but thst husky was gorgeous and quite the character…

GreenSnot · 11/03/2022 07:50

@DogsNotMen

Have any of you Crufts haters ever been to a dog show? Pedigree dogs who are at Crufts have been health tested, checked, and would be disqualified if found to be suffering from illness

I’ve been showing dogs for years, and although there are corrupt judges, if a dog is a stand out winner to you then it will be a stand out dog to the judge.

Crufts is an amazing experience, I would recommend going and you will change your mind. The dogs are so loved, and most dogs love showing. One of mine would be horrified if I left her behind.

The stringing up part I do agree with though. It’s become really prevalent in my breed just recently and I hate it. It makes for pitter patter movement

I’m going to start a post on “AMA” about Crufts so any more questions feel free to get me over there.

I was there yesterday for the working breeds. To me the obvious winner of the group was the Dobermann. It had a perfect stance (without being dragged) and perfect proportions, perfectly behaved, brilliant example of the breed. The Newfoundland appeared to be a clear winner too, as did the Tibetan mastiff But no … the judge liked his huskys.

The discover dogs area was brilliant and we met a gorgeous Flandres there. Was very touched when I went to meet the Irish Wolfhound but he ignored me as he was more interested in fussing children ❤️

But yeah, the actual show judging part is silly and the bitching that goes on … Christ!

I’ll see you over on AMA

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 11/03/2022 07:49

The Kennel Club is responsible for so much animal cruelty. The whole concept of breeds is dodgy. Fair enough, years ago you needed certain types of dogs for certain jobs, but with a few exceptions (guide dogs, service dogs, working sheep dogs) that no longer applies. The breeds are just human vanity inflicted on an animal. I would get rid of the Kennel Club and all its shitty breed standards. Dogs can still be bred for working, wherethe ability to do the job is paramount, there should be no stupid arbitary standard or type to conform to. It is so called dog loving gone perverse, obsessive and cruel.

DogsNotMen · 11/03/2022 07:44

Have any of you Crufts haters ever been to a dog show? Pedigree dogs who are at Crufts have been health tested, checked, and would be disqualified if found to be suffering from illness

I’ve been showing dogs for years, and although there are corrupt judges, if a dog is a stand out winner to you then it will be a stand out dog to the judge.

Crufts is an amazing experience, I would recommend going and you will change your mind. The dogs are so loved, and most dogs love showing. One of mine would be horrified if I left her behind.

The stringing up part I do agree with though. It’s become really prevalent in my breed just recently and I hate it. It makes for pitter patter movement

I’m going to start a post on “AMA” about Crufts so any more questions feel free to get me over there.

girlmom21 · 11/03/2022 07:43

why the fuck do handlers drag their dogs around by pulling on their necks making the dog run in a stupid unnatural gait? Surely the whole point is to see how the dog moves naturally? Yesterday behind us a husky was choking due to the way it’s neck was being pulled and the Dobermanns were running around looking like they were being literally hung. Why don’t they let them move naturally?! Surely that’s the whole point??

This one's just cunty handlers and dogs who don't like to show. Watch the toy dogs and (almost) none of them will be dragged.

Crufts as an exhibition with the stands and where you can meet all the different breeds etc is fantastic. But I agree show standards aren't always great.

However to the PP who said health isn't considered, it is. And they're changing some of their requirements to ensure all dogs are healthy and only healthy dogs are breeding.

OutsideVoice · 11/03/2022 07:40

YANBU
I’ve always thought that judges should judge outside their group to avoid bias.

As for dragging the dogs around and sloping GSDs, whenever humans are involved in anything there are issues.

Flapjacker48 · 11/03/2022 07:38

Crufts should be banned. The extreme overbreeding of pedigree dogs has resulted to numerous health and welfare problems which the kennel club just ignores or even denies.

millymolls · 11/03/2022 07:36

Kennel club and crafts should be banned for encouraging breeding based on looks and nothing based on health to the breed. Simple.

Don’t support them !