Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give my DD a tablet when she’s two?

112 replies

Sparkles8912 · 11/03/2022 07:31

My DD is 21 months old and doesn’t yet have a tablet for watching shows/ playing games etc. I’m being made to feel a bit of the odd one out by friends and family whose little ones seem to be on a tablet all day. We’re constantly told how clever my nephew (similar age) is for being able to play games etc on his tablet and how much he learns with it and friends have said similar about their DC.

I really wanted to keep screen time to a minimum and not give her a tablet until she’s a fair bit older but now wondering if I’m being unreasonable and depriving her, so considering one for her second birthday.

OP posts:
Momicrone · 11/03/2022 08:53

I wouldn't have any screens in the playroom

Joinedforthis22 · 11/03/2022 08:49

but people seem to think a tablet is much worse than a tv?

They effect the brain in different ways, also they are looking at the screen much more closely. I'm also not sure why you'd have a TV in a playroom though, surely a playroom is for play? To my mind tvs belong in the living room and watching them should be a somewhat shared experience.

Momicrone · 11/03/2022 08:41

Tv and interactive touch screens affect the brain in different ways

girlmom21 · 11/03/2022 08:39

@Thirkettle

Tablets are awful for kids. Yes, they go quiet, which is why they start school unable to speak, hold a conversation and still shit themselves. It wrecks their attention spans and makes them miserable when the tablet is taken away. Those games are designed to be addictive. It's the whole central tenet of mobile game design.

Your family sound classless. Ignore.

If your kid is raised on a tablet from 6 months and has 0 interaction, maybe.

There's a wide spectrum of children. Very few start school unable to speak and not toilet trained.

Those who do either have additional needs or are severely neglected. The latter should have been removed from the family home long before they reach school age.

StayOrGoOrWhat · 11/03/2022 08:38

During the first lockdown, my DD was 2 years old and I stupidly let her use my tablet. She became absolutely addicted and it was scary to see! I stopped her using it after a few months and have reintroduced it a little now that she's 4 years old. She is allowed 10-30 mins a few days a week. I have to say that taking it away was 100% the right thing for her. She went back to imaginative play with her toys.
My older DD is 8 and got a tablet for her birthday. We limit her time on it but she doesn't seem to have the desperation to be on it much like her younger sister.
If you have no reason to introduce one (car/plane journey or hospital stay) then just don't, there's so much time for that later.

Thirkettle · 11/03/2022 08:37

Tablets are awful for kids. Yes, they go quiet, which is why they start school unable to speak, hold a conversation and still shit themselves. It wrecks their attention spans and makes them miserable when the tablet is taken away. Those games are designed to be addictive. It's the whole central tenet of mobile game design.

Your family sound classless. Ignore.

Sparkles8912 · 11/03/2022 08:34

@ForkedIt apparently because when you’re watching tv you’re watching with them on a bigger screen so it’s not so much a passive/ all encompassing activity whereas when they watch on a tablet they’re usually just watching by themselves and aren’t aware of everything else going on around them. But that’s just something I read on a tech account I follow on is that I am on so not sure how accurate it is. I guess it’s all too early to know the impact of screens really.

OP posts:
ForkedIt · 11/03/2022 08:32

To add to my previous message.
I get that some people are totally screen free, but if you are going to allow screen time; why is a tablet worse than the tv?

Sparkles8912 · 11/03/2022 08:32

@Thejoyfulstar yes this is what I do currently, the changing back is always packed full of little toys etc to keep him entertained.

Thanks everyone this has made me feel better, I was beginning to feel like the odd one out. We don’t have tablets ourselves (although obviously spend far too much time on my phone so it is a bit hypocritical!) so I figure the longer we can hold out without getting him one the better as at the moment he can’t ask for something we don’t have!

OP posts:
ForkedIt · 11/03/2022 08:30

My 2 year old has a tablet.
She watches cbeebies on it because we thought it better to have a tablet which can be put away than a big tv on the wall in the play room.

I get the argument against having them on a tablet 24/7 but people seem to think a tablet is much worse than a tv?

Flickflak · 11/03/2022 08:27

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

WlNDMlLL · 11/03/2022 08:23

This just depends on your friendship group. Of the dozen or more 3 years olds I know, none has a tablet - I can say that with complete certainty. I don't buy the argument about learning about using tech either. At pre-school age they need to learn to entertain themselves using what is around them.

MrsMop1964 · 11/03/2022 08:22

I once saw a very young child making pinching movements with their hand on the page of a book as if trying to zoom in. Parent thought it cute but I felt a bit sad that they seemed more familiar with the concept of a touch screen than a physical book.

HoneyFlowers · 11/03/2022 08:20

Please do not get her one. Teach through traditional toys and books.

EarlGreywithLemon · 11/03/2022 08:17

Our 2.3 year old doesn’t have one, and doesn’t use ours (except for grabbing the phone if you’ve taken a photo of her to look at herself Grin). Absolutely no plans to get her one any time soon (by which I mean, many years).

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 11/03/2022 08:09

I don't see the difference really in a child having their own device and regularly using the parents. In the fact the child one is likely to have better parental controls...

Its about limiting the use and not becoming reliant on it.

Its also easy to say 'not to X age' when they are young until they need them for homework in Infant school!

girlmom21 · 11/03/2022 08:07

My 2 year old had a tablet for Christmas. They have a big one at nursery and she loves it but she hardly uses her own one.

She's very clever but that's because of her interactions (and good luck, probably), not because she can move her finger around on a screen.

pinkstripeycat · 11/03/2022 08:04

They can learn from a tablet but they can learn so much more not staring at a screen and having person to person interaction

pinkstripeycat · 11/03/2022 08:03

It’s not clever playing games on a tablet.

It is clever being able to play games and learn without a tablet and let the child use their mind and think for themselves.

I have one child (eldest) who had a handed down game boy at the age of 3 and one who didn’t. Now in their teens the eldest is obsessed with Xbox. He is easily distracted by tech and would let it rule his life if we weren’t strict. The youngest isn’t bothered about tech. He has a very inventive mind and has a much longer attention span when studying.

oblada · 11/03/2022 08:03

I don't care for tablets and my 4 kids (18m, 5, 8 and 10) only use a tablet to watch movies when we travel long distances (well the older 3 do anyway). My 5 yrs old also had Osmo games on the tablet so every couple of weeks we try to spend an hour on it as they are nice interactive games. I don't see any need for anything else to be honest.

popwithit · 11/03/2022 08:02

If you don't ' need ' it yet. Don't use it and don't let anyone guilt you into using it. Wait as long as you can I reckon.

My two year old has way too much time on the tablet. It's not her tablet, it's mine. But I wish she didn't. I'm exhausted and ill a lot, so it sometimes ends up being the only option. She does learn a lot from it and has cool games that also teach her stuff. But I would really prefer if she didn't have as much screen time at all. I just think it's better and more natural not to have as much screen time.

Don't start if you don't have to !

LoganberryJam · 11/03/2022 07:59

The less screen time the better for a child under 3 IMO.

OfstedOffred · 11/03/2022 07:59

My children won't be getting tablets of their own until at least secondary school. I allow them to use mine occasionally (long car journeys etc). Eldest is now 5 and occasionally uses it for phonics & maths games school recommend.

Tablets are primarily for consumption of media, they require minimal skills and children can acquire those skills more productively elsewhere.

LairyMaclary · 11/03/2022 07:58

Not at all. My two year old is in hospital regularly due to repeated bouts of viral induced wheeze. She has a‘hospital tablet’ with Disney + , some interactive books and a colouring app on it, because convincing her she needs to stay on a bed with oxygen up her nose is otherwise very tricky. She has no access to it otherwise.

SelfIdentifiedRightsHoarder · 11/03/2022 07:58

Personally I wouldn't at such a young age. I'm not against screen time, my daughter will watch TV while I'm cleaning or cooking dinner sometimes. She's been unwell this week so she's had a lot more time watching TV than normal. But when we are at home she will happily play independently with her toys, drawing, building blocks etc, but whenever I take her to a friend's house (2 sons, both have tablets) all 3 of them just sit there staring at the tablets or fighting over them and she cries when it's time to put it away for food or because we are leaving. Doesn't seem healthy to me

Swipe left for the next trending thread