Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give my DD a tablet when she’s two?

112 replies

Sparkles8912 · 11/03/2022 07:31

My DD is 21 months old and doesn’t yet have a tablet for watching shows/ playing games etc. I’m being made to feel a bit of the odd one out by friends and family whose little ones seem to be on a tablet all day. We’re constantly told how clever my nephew (similar age) is for being able to play games etc on his tablet and how much he learns with it and friends have said similar about their DC.

I really wanted to keep screen time to a minimum and not give her a tablet until she’s a fair bit older but now wondering if I’m being unreasonable and depriving her, so considering one for her second birthday.

OP posts:
GrendelsGrandma · 11/03/2022 13:00

I agree with you, I can see how they might be the least bad option sometimes (flights, when you're sick etc) but they're not a good thing for very small children. I have a 5yo and nearly 3yo, no tablet tho they watch more TV than is ideal.

Tablet games hack your brain. Watching TV on them means the kids are too close to the screen.

It's harder work to just read books or play but better for them.

Ponoka7 · 11/03/2022 13:00

My GC got kindles at 2 and iPads from 4. They have their uses. The both do dance and we are very outdoorsy. We all have dogs tat are walked with the children at the beach/country parks. I love to take notice of the moon cycles and stars, my youngest GC, nearly 5 is also interested. There's weekends when they rarely go on them. We aren't television watchers, so the children would watch things on their tablet. The youngest is dyspraxic and is learning from hers. Alphablocks etc really help with literacy. We are selective about what they watch. You can do nature and tech, it isn't an either or.

Idontreplytotrolls · 11/03/2022 12:53

Children should be out expanding their mind, Tablets are a good tool but not for this age.

We have so many wonderous things only just left in this world for the moment, a vast majority of our wildlife will no longer around when your child has grown up. Would you rather your child grows up with memories of the wonderful song bird or mammal they found as a youngster that is now extinct or playing games on a tablet.

Nature is a science and it amazes me how indifferent people are to what's around them. How many people walk down our street and are completely oblivious to the black bird chirping away mimicking a police siren and a phone ringing or a tune it heard. Grab some nature books and take your kids outside and go id leaves trees, animals birds. :)

RedWingBoots · 11/03/2022 12:47

Firstly your child doesn't need a tablet for watching TV shows if you need to distract them when out, they can use your mobile phone.

Secondly yes they can have a tablet for playing games like Hey Duggee or practising their letters, but how they will use it depends on how you parent them. So if you allow them to be glued to it all the time you are storing up problems. If you give it to them randomly for short periods but ensure most of the time someone is interacting with them or they are playing on their own with other tangible items then you probably have a good balance.

confettisprinkles · 11/03/2022 12:34

Definitely not being unreasonable or depriving her, DH and I were the same as you with our DD who's now 2.5. I'm of the stance that there's plenty of time for that when she's older, there isn't a need for screen time at this age because they learn so much through playing with toys etc.
I'm not again screen time at all, DD watches tv and knows how to use my phone but I don't see a need for her having a tablet of her own just yet.

Darbishire27 · 11/03/2022 12:31

Of course YANBU. Children need access to IT later on to engage with school, they don’t need it when very young, so long as they have mental stimulation. It may be super-convenient to let little ones amuse themselves on tablets rather than going to the effort to engage in person, but this that what young minds need? There is plenty of evidence that time spent on digital devices shortens attention spans, so very early years on tablets could well be storing up problems later in life.

Rinatinabina · 11/03/2022 12:24

I think people are probably thinking of on the extreme end of allowing kids unfettered access or using them every time they leave the house to keep them quiet at dinner/doctors/supermarket instead of interacting with them. Most people let their kids watch a bit of tele etc, I think it’s when screens are the main form of entertainment it becomes a problem.

I’m definitely not anti screen but I do limit DD viewing time and 90% of the time she understands we watch TV at certain times. I think it would be much harder to get her off a tablet if I gave her one at this age.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 11/03/2022 12:17

We got one for our 2 year old for holidays I think, I can't remember. But it was mainly for holidays, plane entertainment and so we could go to a restaurant or two for adults night, and it was handy by the pool - for a wind down when it was getting too hot and they'd just spent time in the pool. We don't really use them much outside of holidays though.

Vasectomyreversalhopeful · 11/03/2022 12:16

I am definitely not anti screens, they can be a life saver but no 21mo needs a tablet.

Vasectomyreversalhopeful · 11/03/2022 12:15

My DS is 6 and doesn’t have one. We have a family one which he can play a phonics game on and a number blocks game on. He uses it for about 10 mins a day. He watches TV too but on the actual TV and we make sure to balance with other activities.

Disneyblueeyes · 11/03/2022 12:13

In reality I think most parents can be very lazy at times, but we're not perfect are we? Life is going at a million miles an hour at the moment and the world has gone to shit. As long as your kids are clothed, fed, warm, safe, educated, potty trained and not on a tablet 24/7 you're doing pretty well.

Disneyblueeyes · 11/03/2022 12:10

Sometimes you just want some time to yourself so you put the TV on or give them a tablet.
Yes it's lazy, but it's also called being human.

My little girl is sat watching Toy Story 2 while I mess about on my phone.
Then again this morning we've done some crafts and been out in the garden for an hour.

I'm pretty impressed by those parents who don't let their toddlers look at a tablet or phone screen at all until they're 6 or whatever.
I wouldn't call them good parents, I'd call them super-mums. I honestly think most mums aren't like this.
Then again Mumsnet does represent a disproportionate group of mums in favour of the 'do-gooder' mums, I suppose.

LadyMacduff · 11/03/2022 12:10

The screen time argument can be a bit black and white at times.

We have three tablets; one with a bluetooth keyboard that my children like to use to type letters on the screen sometimes. Another one is really just used for audiobooks and music, another that my son uses to watch TV on if he wakes up early. They rarely have them during the day but we do have the TV on a lot in the background. I'm being more mindful of switching to radio at the moment though.

DockOTheBay · 11/03/2022 12:10

My daughter got a tablet at age 4.5. Not as a birthday or Christmas present as I didn't want to make it seem exciting and desirable to play with it all the time. My younger daughter is nearly 2 so she has used the tablet as well.

They use it for a phonics game, and she plays cbeebies playtime Island and a Hey Duggee game. Its limited to 30 mins per day (turns itself off after this time) and she probably plays it on average 2 days a week.

Littlehouseinthebigcity · 11/03/2022 12:05

We have one tablet in a family of four, officially it's mine and the kids (2 and 4) know that but they are occasionally allowed to use it for age appropriate games (mostly just the CBeebies app). I don't want them to have their own for a while but am happy for them to use mine as and when

LimeSegment · 11/03/2022 11:57

My dc aged 3.5 and 2 don't have a tablet and don't use my phone. I don't judge what others are doing as every situation is different and they will all end up tech addicts anyway.

But for myself, I prefer them to play with toys. They have so few years to be kids and play with toys, why rush through that? It's also to make my life easier, to avoid tantrums and tears when I would tell them to put it away. If there isn't one in the house and they've never used one, they can't miss it.

Skyeheather · 11/03/2022 11:56

Our 6 and 2 year olds do not have tablets and have never had a go of ours or our phones. DP thinks it's best to keep them away from screens as long as we can. Our 6 year old does use a tablet at school occasionally but has never asked for one, yet.......

Rinatinabina · 11/03/2022 11:47

@ForkedIt

To add to my previous message. I get that some people are totally screen free, but if you are going to allow screen time; why is a tablet worse than the tv?
I think it’s because being on a tablet is a solitary activity. Dd does watch tv but we do talk to her about whats going on whiles she’s watching.

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/11/211108130847.htm

ChairCareOh · 11/03/2022 11:36

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

SatinHeart · 11/03/2022 11:34

We have one tablet in the house and young DC sometimes watch things on iplayer on it or do drawing on the paint app. But we are very clear it belongs to mummy and daddy not them! They have to ask to use it and the answer is definitely not always a yes.

I don't see the need for young DC to 'own' that kind of device tbh. A family one is plenty.

Rinatinabina · 11/03/2022 11:31

DD 2 doesn’t have one and she’s not that interested in mine, she likes looking at pics of her teacher on my phone (theres some serious mutual adoration going on there) but thats it. Bloody loves the tele though, not sure throwing a tablet into the mix would be helpful.

I think if as PP said she had long stints in a hospital or on a plane I probably would but otherwise we read books and play with her (and try to get her to entertain herself). There are a whole bunch of things like fine motor skills which will be neglected if they are on tablets for too much of the day plus the damn thinks are addictive (totally addicted to my ipad). When she’s a bit older I probably will and get her using maths and literacy games.

ChairCareOh · 11/03/2022 11:25

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

ChairCareOh · 11/03/2022 11:24

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

tealandteal · 11/03/2022 11:17

My DS started using our tablet around 3, but doesn’t have his own or use it very often. We download a film on to it for long car journeys or sometimes he is allowed to watch it in my office if I have a meeting when my DH is out. Now that he is in school they give him spellings to do which would either need to be done on the tablet, phone or my work laptop so he uses the tablet.

Rosenborg · 11/03/2022 11:15

@Flickflak

Our six and seven year olds have no access to devices.

Anyone who says they need access to understand technology is kidding themselves. Those devices are built so toddlers can understand them and one of my kids won the year level coding prize last year only by using a computer in computer class twice a week.

Kids need to learn to communicate, use their imaginations, entertain themselves, to hold a pen properly and to PLAY.

Two year olds being given devices or device time as a normal part of their daily routine have lazy parents.

👏👏
Swipe left for the next trending thread