Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give my DD a tablet when she’s two?

112 replies

Sparkles8912 · 11/03/2022 07:31

My DD is 21 months old and doesn’t yet have a tablet for watching shows/ playing games etc. I’m being made to feel a bit of the odd one out by friends and family whose little ones seem to be on a tablet all day. We’re constantly told how clever my nephew (similar age) is for being able to play games etc on his tablet and how much he learns with it and friends have said similar about their DC.

I really wanted to keep screen time to a minimum and not give her a tablet until she’s a fair bit older but now wondering if I’m being unreasonable and depriving her, so considering one for her second birthday.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Peachy7 · 12/03/2022 09:00

My nephew wasn't allowed one until he was 8, my niece still isn't as she's 6 and isn't allowed to go on his. They're an easy way of keeping kids occupied. My friends kids are the nicest kids in the world until they're told to get off them. They're designed to be addictive. Give them normal 2 year old toys/books etc

Notbeinfunnehbut · 12/03/2022 08:50

@Thirkettle

That’s quite a disabilist post , children who attend school untrained often have undiagnosed SEN ,

Wheelerdeeler · 12/03/2022 08:42

Those parents are saying that to make themselves feel better.

My almost 5 year old has none, doesn't play games on my phone etc.

He watches TV.

There is no need for personal devices & small screens so young.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 12/03/2022 08:37

My ds is a month older than your dc and he hasn't got one, nor will be getting one anytime soon. If we have had a long day and end up in a cafe or a restaurant and he is really starting to kick off, I let him watch my phone. It keeps him interested for all of 10 minutes.

morechocolateneededtoday · 12/03/2022 07:55

They definitely do not need their own tablet so young. As others have mentioned, tablets do have their uses, particularly when travelling, if in hospital etc to keep them still or distract them. Without a doubt, there is no skill they are missing out on without access to one.

I am first to admit DD (now 5) was exposed to more TV than I'd like, particularly when I was sick whilst expecting DS. She didn't get to watch TV until she was 1 then Cbeebies was on in the back ground all the time. She was a fussy eater and it was this stage where her grandparents thought it was a brilliant idea to use the tablet while feeding her so she would blindly eat all meals. I was too exhausted to protest and we had some awful habits. I put a stop to it all when on mat leave with DS and haven't looked back.

They are now 3 and 5. We do enjoy watching TV, both them and as family but we have parental locks so they cannot watch anything without asking us. We used tablets over lockdown for reading eggs and DD now has a mathletics account from school which she gets access for but that is it. If we go for a meal (or anywhere else they need entertainment) we have paper, pens, dobble and a pack of cards. The last 2 are usually adequate. Now holidays are likely to happen, they will be allowed to watch on planes but we still plan to stop there.

As for skills, both have IT lessons at nursery and school and the lessons focus on a proper keyboard and mouse stills for both of them. They do not deal with touch screens as they are intuitive and children will pick them up anyway

Smellyporcupine · 11/03/2022 23:06

@ForkedIt

My 2 year old has a tablet. She watches cbeebies on it because we thought it better to have a tablet which can be put away than a big tv on the wall in the play room.

I get the argument against having them on a tablet 24/7 but people seem to think a tablet is much worse than a tv?

Mine too. We don't have the tv on in the background all day long like quite a few friends with small kids do. Mine get iPad time and that's it, once a day. We don't watch Tv.

The only negative is with iPad is that they change stuff more easily. That can have pros and cons. Keeps them engaged, but I'm on the fence about whether it affects their attention span.

To me screen time is any screen.

RidingMyBike · 11/03/2022 22:52

You don't have to give them one- it isn't obligatory! DD doesn't have her own and she's six! She didn't watch any tv until around 22 months, then we introduced CBeebies bedtime story. She watched more during the lockdowns though. She now very occasionally (couple of times a month?) goes on our family tablet to do Reading Eggs or the CBeebies games. I don't see any need for her to have a tablet of her own.

tokyo1 · 11/03/2022 20:44

My 2yo DC doesn't have one and I've never had any comments on it either. I'd rather delay it as much as possible. We may play a video on our phones in very rare circumstances like a flight or long car journey but that's as far as it goes. We don't have a TV either so my family think we're very weird but he's allowed to watch it at grandparents but apart from a few glances, he's very disinterested in it when there. Parent how you see fit. Forget the comments.

PaperMonster · 11/03/2022 20:24

Not unreasonable at all. My child had no screen time until she was three - I got called all sorts because of this, was told this was abusive!! Got told I was holding her back as computers and screens were in a child’s future. But, I’d researched and read about the impact of screens in the early years and I felt uncomfortable with her having early screen access. Has it held her back? No. Quite the opposite. She has a natural aptitude for IT and is quite comfortable and proficient in its use. I also don’t put any limits on its use other than a time for screens to go off for the day, so we’ve never had any real issues with her coming off it or being addicted to it.

CyranoCyrano · 11/03/2022 19:42

[quote Foldinthecheese]@CyranoCyrano what a funny response! You haven’t seen the alternative for my children because that would be literally impossible. Just as you have seen children who have used tablets and are still imaginative and good conversationalists, I have met many who are not. I have met many who don’t want to play with friends because they would rather use their tablets, or who can’t sit nicely at a table without having a screen in front of them. I said in my previous post that this is a parenting decision I have made that has definitely been the right one for us. I never suggested that I was speaking for anyone else, just sharing my own experience and perspective.[/quote]
I tnink it’s a funnier response to assume your children are they way they are because of no tablets. You have no idea if this is the case. You are attributing a lot to your ‘parenting decision’ being the right one when equally you could have had controlled tablet use and the same outcomes. That’s all I’m saying.

Foldinthecheese · 11/03/2022 19:23

@CyranoCyrano what a funny response! You haven’t seen the alternative for my children because that would be literally impossible. Just as you have seen children who have used tablets and are still imaginative and good conversationalists, I have met many who are not. I have met many who don’t want to play with friends because they would rather use their tablets, or who can’t sit nicely at a table without having a screen in front of them. I said in my previous post that this is a parenting decision I have made that has definitely been the right one for us. I never suggested that I was speaking for anyone else, just sharing my own experience and perspective.

Newmumatlast · 11/03/2022 19:18

@Lazypuppy

Its not a choice between no screen time and on a tablet 24/7, there is a range. My DD has had one since she was 2, and its great for kids games and her tv shows so i don't have to watch them and can watch my tv for a change! She only normally has it in the evenings before bed and on the weekend days here and there if we are having a day at home. Its easy to limit, but theres no need for them to have it at 2yo.

Remember with all the technology, this is the kids world they will be living in and they will need to learn how to use all these things at some point

Agree. My 2 year old has one. Was never my parenting plan but when I saw what they can do and that you can restrict access I thought why not. She isnt on it all the time. She has games which are mainly educational like numberblocks and finger tracing etc. She can do very simple maths and figures out how to play the apps all by herself. If I want to watch a programme on TV she can watch one on her tablet. And she will need to use tech at school and in life anyway.

I don't agree with kids being on them all the time or as a substitute for parenting but they can be used very well alongside.

CyranoCyrano · 11/03/2022 19:16

@Carpediem15

I was on the bus the other day and this young woman got on with a child of about 2.5 in a pushchair. Straight away she gave him a tablet and she got on her phone and for 45 mins that child was on the tablet, looking at things and then trying to attract her attention to show her something on it. She didn't take a blind bit of notice of him and I just wanted to shout at her, for goodness sake look at your child he wants to speak to you. I could actually see the sad look on his face when she ignored him and he never tried to speak to her again and just watched the tablet. Can imagine this is what he has to do all the time. It is sad.
Again that has nothing to do with the tablet and everything to do with bad parenting @Carpediem15
CyranoCyrano · 11/03/2022 19:15

@Foldinthecheese Well I have seen the alternative. My nephew always had tablets at dinner when he was younger. He’s now 5 and out for dinner last week we had an extremely detailed conversation about dinosaurs, school and his swimming lessons. He is an excellent conversationalist. So he used to tablets when younger and it’s resulted in a child who can behave properly and have a conversation - exactly the same as your children.

He and his youngest siblings also play make believe exactly like your children. I know as I’ve had to participate many times. They have excellent imaginations.

Basically you assumed something about children who use tablets then assumed your children’s behaviour is as they don’t use them. Very lazy way to think about things!

It’s the same as that silly WHO recommendation of no screen time under 2. The study underpinning that recommendation looked at two sets of children- those who watched tv and those who didn’t. It found that the children who watched tv performed worse on a range of outcomes. They didn’t control for mothers education, income status, amount of screen time or anything!!

A study that actually looked at the roll out of television in the US and compared children in towns without television due to delayed rollout and matched them on socioeconomic status and mothers education. They found no statistically significant impact of television on children outcomes.

Thewindwhispers · 11/03/2022 19:14

Don’t do it!!! They’re so addictive and dd’s behaviour is always way worse after being on her tablet, it’s like she loses the ability to regulate her emotions. Friends tell me their kids are the same.

Carpediem15 · 11/03/2022 19:13

I was on the bus the other day and this young woman got on with a child of about 2.5 in a pushchair. Straight away she gave him a tablet and she got on her phone and for 45 mins that child was on the tablet, looking at things and then trying to attract her attention to show her something on it. She didn't take a blind bit of notice of him and I just wanted to shout at her, for goodness sake look at your child he wants to speak to you.
I could actually see the sad look on his face when she ignored him and he never tried to speak to her again and just watched the tablet. Can imagine this is what he has to do all the time. It is sad.

Foldinthecheese · 11/03/2022 18:45

@CyranoCyrano obviously I can’t be sure because I haven’t seen the alternative, but I think tablets can easily become the default, if that makes sense. It’s easier to go out for dinner if the children can take their tablets, so it becomes a habit. At home, it keeps them quiet and entertained, so you say yes more and more.

Because we don’t use tablets, we’ve had to put the effort into encouraging conversations and quiet activities at restaurants, but it’s resulted in children who know how to behave sensibly and we can enjoy their company.

I also think it’s a slippery slope once children start playing lots of games on tablets because they can’t get the same kind of ‘reward’ from other toys. There’s no positive noise when they successfully build a tower of blocks, or fancy animation when they put a puzzle together. It’s natural that they start to prefer tablets and don’t experience the boredom that leads to creativity.

We’re not perfect on this by any means. We download stuff so the children can watch shows or films during long journeys, and during lockdown they played CBeebies games maybe once a week or so. But it has never become a real habit, and I’m not in any rush to make it one.

incognitoforthisone · 11/03/2022 17:33

People who work in big tech apparently don't give their kids devices because they know how damaging they can be.

I'm sure that's the case for some parents who work in tech ... but it definitely isn't the case with anyone I know who does. I know quite a few people who work in tech and pretty much all of them have introduced that sort of thing to their kids from a very young age - but certainly not indiscriminately and they certainly don't use a tablet as a babysitter. The head web designer where I work bought both his children some form of tablet when they were toddlers, because he's aware that they're of a generation where tech skills are going to be universally essential.

But they're basically using them to play little games and puzzles - things like hearing an animal noise and tapping on the picture of the animal, or moving shapes around little mazes and stuff, or reading and maths games for the older one (I think she's four). He also says the older one really benefits from having children's audiobooks and kids' radio plays downloaded on to hers.

I'm not saying a child needs a tablet, not by any means, or that it should always be the go-to device to occupy them. Clearly it shouldn't be. But I think that, as with anything, it's about what they use them for and how the parent supervises. Would I stick a child in front of YouTube? No. Would I let them play a little puzzle game aimed at their age group, or let them try taking their own photos or making little tunes on a music? Yes.

I think the kneejerk response of 'AAARRGGGGH TECH BAD GAMING BAD SCREEN BAD' is probably one that will die out soon. Worth remembering that all the same arguments about tech - that it rots the brain, is addictive, is stopping people from engaging in real life - were also made about reading fiction when the novel started to become the dominant form of literature.

CyranoCyrano · 11/03/2022 17:11

@Foldinthecheese why do you attribute 2-4 to your children not having tablets?

GrendelsGrandma · 11/03/2022 17:01

@danascully really? I guess some toddlers are more easily amused than others. Mine spends a lot of time throwing his socks in the air and playing with stuff from the kitchen drawers. I think once you get a tablet it becomes a rod for your own back as they want it all the time.

Danascully2 · 11/03/2022 16:19

Hahaha I am giggling at the thought of my previous self trying to keep my livewire toddlers occupied by telling them to look out of the window!! It might have worked for about 30 seconds before they were bouncing off their chair... (Which is not to say I am in favour of lengthy daily tablet time, just that it's important to be realistic in behaviour expectations) I would though expect my 8 year old to tolerate some boredom now so it would be reasonable to tell him to look out of the window when he's bored...

GrendelsGrandma · 11/03/2022 16:01

I think at the core of it is the need for distraction, especially when out and about. An important part of kids being well behaved is them tolerating a little boredom and things not being arranged for them. Tablets make it seem like any quiet moment should be filled. They can just look out of the window!

Liverbird77 · 11/03/2022 15:19

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

bruce43mydog · 11/03/2022 14:04

we all have diffrent views on tablets,

personally i dont agree with tablets for children. or the tv. although educational for them, i believe that it is addictive and does them no favours to think the tv is communication.

if i have children there would be limits. i would rather they talked with me about there day and hear what they think of the world than view life through a screen.

Foldinthecheese · 11/03/2022 13:34

My eldest children are six (twins) and they don’t have tablets. I question a lot of things we’ve done as parents, but this is one I don’t. Reasons I’m happy with our choice:

  1. No arguments about access to tablets. They watch TV, but I love avoiding this battlefield.
  2. They are great conversationalists and I feel proud when we can go out for meals and they are happy to sit and chat. They’ve been good company at restaurants since they were about three.
  3. They have incredible imaginations and I think are still quite ‘young’ with their play, in a good way. They’ve spent let of the morning before school making cardboard guitars and speakers for a party their planning to throw this weekend. Before my husband and I woke up, they were in their playroom building a marble run.
  4. Their younger sister is three and follows her brothers’ example, so she doesn’t play with a tablet either, nor does she expect to.

A 2yo absolutely does not need a tablet. And don’t get sucked into the YouTube thing earlier. I see so many people complaining about unboxing videos and how their children don’t understand why they can’t have endless toys. We’ve never had that issue because my children don’t realise those people exist. Don’t do it to yourself!