Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to wonder what Russia is up to in Ireland..

463 replies

Chamomiltea · 10/03/2022 21:59

Reading this was a shock, given recent events... www.rte.ie/news/primetime/2022/0310/1285699-russian-embassy-orwell-road-irish-government/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
yodaforpresident · 11/03/2022 13:51

As I thought,

olympics.com/en/olympic-games/tokyo-2020/medals official Olympic medal table

yodaforpresident · 11/03/2022 13:47

Yes, I know that @DownNative - but you said it yourself, nobody actually notices/ reports on anything other than Team GB - that was my point. Pretty sure it says GB on the leaderboards etc too, but happy to be corrected.

DownNative · 11/03/2022 13:35

[quote yodaforpresident]@MargaretBall and yet for the Olympics there is Team GB emblazoned everywhere and indeed that is the official name of the UK team..........[/quote]
When the athletes come out and to wait, the screen behind them states "Team GB & NI". Most people don't really notice that.

But it is Team GB & NI. For branding purposes on merchandise, its shortened to Team GB.

DownNative · 11/03/2022 13:23

@YerWanIsGettinNotions

Jesus *@DownNative* I've rarely seen so much wrong as everything you've said in your "patiently explaining why Irish people are wrong and you alone have the correct knowledge" manner.

"The name of the State is Éire, or in the English language, Ireland".. doesn't mean "the name of the state is Éire and it's ok to say that if you don't speak English". It's phrased that way around because it's a translation of the law and the Irish language version has supremacy. That means a less literal translation (if it was written with the English language as primary) would say "The name of the State is Ireland and in the Irish language, Éire."

And this is just outrageous:
Using "Ireland" for the southern state was always meant to confuse outsiders, to promote a united Ireland and to act as though the island itself isn't divided into two separate, distinct parts.

It was never "meant to confuse outsiders". That's not how countries select their own names. Ireland has always been Ireland, and the fact of invasion, plantation and occupation didn't change that. It had a name and a national identity of irishness long before Elizabeth I and the plantation of Ulster. Why should a country which has finally reclaimed its independence have to change its own name because partition was the price of home rule? Ireland is no less Ireland just because it had to surrender six counties.

If you take a chunk of Wales in the east and give it over to administration by the government in England, should the rest of Wales lose the right to be called "Wales", so nobody gets confused between Wales and the English county of East Wales?

@YerWanIsGettinNotions,

I'm afraid that several things you've said is ahistorical and can be demonstrated to be so with evidence.

"The name of the State is Éire, or in the English language, Ireland".. doesn't mean "the name of the state is Éire and it's ok to say that if you don't speak English".

On the contrary, it does not prohibit anyone from using "Éire" whatsoever.

It was never "meant to confuse outsiders". That's not how countries select their own names.

Firstly, what I said isn't outrageous by any means whatsoever. The ROI Constitution is testament to that fact with this:

“the national territory consists of the whole island of Ireland, its islands and the territorial seas.”

Indeed, we can see how true it is that the Irish State chose the name of the entire island for itself as part of its anti-partition campaign from the 1940s onwards here:

"When Ireland launched a major antipartition campaign in the late 1940s, the titles used by the British and Irish governments to refer to each other assumed a greater political significance, because a key component of this campaign was to use international organizations to highlight “Ireland's claim to complete freedom of her entire territory.”

Indeed, an Irish Government department (Department of External Affairs) in 1947 made it clear in a letter to all heads of Irish Government departments that their purpose is:

"to prevent the use—not only at International Conferences, but in ordinary Departmental files and correspondence here at home—of expressions which are not in accordance with our external position and may prove embarrassing to us on policy grounds.”

One of the terms they were referring to was the name....."Ireland".

The then top Irish Civil Servant in the Department of External Affairs told an ambassador to use "Ireland" rather than Éire precisely because:

"As you are aware, it is the hope of everybody in this country that the use of 'Ireland' to describe the Twenty-Six Counties will have a definite psychological effect in favour of the unity of this country on both Irish and foreign minds."

That is a practice that has continued ever since to the present day. Brings us right back to the territorial claims over Northern Ireland in the ROI Constitution for many decades.

Ireland has always been Ireland, and the fact of invasion, plantation and occupation didn't change that.

Always? Really? You must know it's pretty easy to debunk that....surely?

Names for the island of Ireland in history:

Inis Ealga= nobleorexcellent island.

Fiodh-Inis= Woody island.

Crioch Fuinidh=remote country.

Inisfáil = Island of Destiny.

Ériu, Banba and Fódla given by the Daanans.

Scotia and Greater Scotia.

And so on. Point is, you were very much incorrect to claim the island was "always" known as "Ireland".

It had a name and a national identity of irishness long before Elizabeth I and the plantation of Ulster.

It has multiple names. But concepts of Irishness and other nationalities did not occur until the 1750s onwards. The American and French Revolutions were the main origins of this relatively modern phenomenon.

In the 5th Century, St Patrick referred to the inhabitants of the island as Scoti which originally meant the peoples of the two main islands in the British Isles archipelago.

Even the Ulster Cycles tells us that the people of the whole island didn't have a common identity or a common name. And the Cycles does contain kernels of truth as shown by DNA evidence today.

Indeed, history is often incorrectly used to assert a common national identity over the people of the past going back hundreds of years.

"history is indeed an important means of criticising traditions and questioning established wisdoms. But there are many good reasons to avoid history becoming the basis of national identity formation and legitimation. It seems wiser to assume that society would be better off with weak and playful identities rather than those underpinned by a strong sense of a common national past."

www.historyandpolicy.org/

Another mistake people also make is assuming the people identified as a racial group by skin colour. This is also a relatively recent modern phenomenon rooted in the Atlantic Slave Trade.

Ireland is no less Ireland just because it had to surrender six counties.

If you were speaking in purely GEOGRAPHICAL terms, then I'd agree with that.

But you are speaking in political terms, so you're incorrect. The Republic doesn't extend to the entire island and that is a political reality.

Surrender? No, the people of the then 1920 Ireland couldn't agree with each other on the future course. What's more, the Government of Northern Ireland had the democratic right to opt out of the Irish Free State. Today, the Government of the Republic of Ireland recognises that the future of Northern Ireland is only for the people of Northern Ireland to decide. That's democratic.

So, the south cannot surrender what is not theirs. Hmm

If you take a chunk of Wales in the east and give it over to administration by the government in England, should the rest of Wales lose the right to be called "Wales", so nobody gets confused between Wales and the English county of East Wales?,

Illogical. England and Wales do not share the same name. Other partitioned states do not usually share part of the same name.

India - Pakistan and India.

Czechslovakia - Czechia and Slovakia.

Germany - West Germany and East Germany.

Note that West Germany did NOT take the name of all Germany for itself during the years of partition.

In fact, Sinn Féin argue that the Republic should be following the example of the German states by not calling itself "Ireland".

Hence, I posted Gerry Adams' words as an example.

I'm afraid you have no valid argument to make there.

Moyny · 11/03/2022 13:18

I think that's right, @BlackAmericanoNoSugar what I read (though I can't remember the source now) was that Russia's number of embassy staff in Ireland was second only to the US's embassy staff numbers, but that it made little obvious legitimate 'sense' because so few Russians live in Ireland, it's not a huge trading partner etc there's no strong connection as there is with the US to explain such a big embassy staff presence.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 11/03/2022 13:15

[quote LadyEloise1]@Sweetmayday re your comment about Prime Time and its revelation that Ireland has the second biggest Russian embassy in the world.
Second to the US.

ShockShockShock
If this is true one has to ask why !!![/quote]
Did they say that? Because the information that I read was that the Russian embassy was the second largest embassy in Ireland (staff numbers) after the US embassy. Which is slightly different. And the size of the Russian embassy staff is suspicious because there are very few Russians living in Ireland and there isn't much travel by Irish people to Russia.

user1496146479 · 11/03/2022 12:53

[quote borntobequiet]At any rate, its the ROI posters who've derailed the thread

Facts are important, and the naming of the separate parts of the island of Ireland particularly so given the general ignorance of the UK population, some of whom still think that Ireland is part of the UK.
Andrew Bridgen, Tory MP and prominent Brexiter, claimed in 2018 that being English entitled him to claim an Irish passport.

[/quote] This with bells on!!
OchonAgusOchonOh · 11/03/2022 12:50

@JaneJeffer

Sorry, I misunderstood. No problem, I knew you did and they're both offensive and dense Grin

Would ye stop talking about egg sandwiches 🤢

I love egg mayo sandwiches despite not particulary liking eggs.
eggandonion · 11/03/2022 12:47

I think there was a small Cork Harbour thing for a while, but I don't know if it still exists... East Cork feels Ancient East, West Cork is more Wild Atlantic.
Kinsale is a bit like Cornwall (I will be in trouble...), Bandon is more where the West begins?
Or Clonakilty.

JaneJeffer · 11/03/2022 12:42

Sorry, I misunderstood. No problem, I knew you did and they're both offensive and dense Grin

Would ye stop talking about egg sandwiches 🤢

Moyny · 11/03/2022 12:40

[quote LizzieAnt]@eggandonion
I always thought Cork was in the south too, but Fáillte Ireland have decided in their wisdom that Cork city is part of 'Ireland's Ancient East'Grin The Wild Atlantic Way begins around Kinsale, ie just over the road. (In fact most of the country is either in the 'Ancient East' or 'Wild Atlantic Way', though there's a small 'Hidden Heartlands' in the middle.)[/quote]
I've a friend who works for Bórd Fáilte, and her account of the various lobbyings and shenanigans surrounding the designations of and publicity for the Wild Atlantic Way and Ireland's Ancient East (the 'difficult second album' of Irish tourism marketing) are fascinating.

There was a big bust-up at one point because Killarney was marketing itself as ' (a) gateway to the Wild Atlantic Way', and Kinsale got odd about it and there was a lot of tourism-related handbags at dawn.

I was living out of Ireland of Ireland, so missed by the launch of the WAW and IAE -- it was a surprise to me to discover that Cork city was even in IAE.

eggandonion · 11/03/2022 12:39

The Victorian Quarter in Cark is going to be the VQ apparently.
The Russians must have to double check their maps a lot with all the rebranding.

eggandonion · 11/03/2022 12:37

Go to a funeral in Northern Ireland, proper egg and onion sandwiches made with real salad cream, nice sliced pan.
None of the chives and mayo nonsense!Wink

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 11/03/2022 12:33

omg Ireland's Ancient East is a new one on me. I'm still reeling from 'The Grafton Quarter'.

LizzieAnt · 11/03/2022 12:20

@eggandonion
I always thought Cork was in the south too, but Fáillte Ireland have decided in their wisdom that Cork city is part of 'Ireland's Ancient East'Grin The Wild Atlantic Way begins around Kinsale, ie just over the road. (In fact most of the country is either in the 'Ancient East' or 'Wild Atlantic Way', though there's a small 'Hidden Heartlands' in the middle.)

LadyEloise1 · 11/03/2022 12:15

@Sweetmayday re your comment about Prime Time and its revelation that Ireland has the second biggest Russian embassy in the world.
Second to the US.

ShockShockShock
If this is true one has to ask why !!!

OchonAgusOchonOh · 11/03/2022 12:10

@Moyny

Sorry, that was to *@JaneJeffer, who has the best ever Mn username. Nought @eggandonion* always reminds me of Sr Michael complaining about the whiffy sandwich passenger on the bus in the episode of Derry Girls where they run away to the gig.
100% agree on JaneJeffer Grin
OchonAgusOchonOh · 11/03/2022 12:06

@Sweetmayday

RTE have a show called Prime Time, I was watching it last night and they were on about it. What they had planned to build was huge, 3 3 storey buildings with underground rooms and 2 other seperate buildings as apartments for staff.They would have had their own independent water supply and petrol supply, so if the Irish water system was contaminated they would not be impacted. Also they show raised concerns about the amount of people employed by the Russian embassy, 30 Russian nationals compared to the 4 Irish nationals in the Irish embassy in Moscow. It's the second largest embassy after America.
They also don't empty locals to do most of the non-diplomatic tasks the way most embassies do. There are issues with visas for non-diplomatic staff at the moment due to covid restrictions over the past 2 years. They're working on working on sorting that out at the moment.
OchonAgusOchonOh · 11/03/2022 12:00

[quote JaneJeffer]@OchonAgusOchonOh I'm talking about people pretending they don't know the name of the country in order to derail the thread. They know fucking well what it's called. That's the nonsense part.[/quote]
Sorry, I misunderstood. And yes, I agree, it's nonsense. It's either done to be deliberately insulting/offensive or they are exceptionally dense.

JaneJeffer · 11/03/2022 11:57

Aww thanks @Moyny. DS said to me one night "why does he stare at people like that, it's weird" Grin It takes a while to get back into the swing of Irish TV. When I returned in the 90's people like Katy French RIP were big celebrities which was baffling as pre-internet you wouldn't have heard of them in the UK.

Moyny · 11/03/2022 11:40

Sorry, that was to @JaneJeffer, who has the best ever Mn username. Nought @eggandonion always reminds me of Sr Michael complaining about the whiffy sandwich passenger on the bus in the episode of Derry Girls where they run away to the gig.

Moyny · 11/03/2022 11:38

It’s the way I tell them. Grin

(I’m relatively newly back home after a looong time abroad, so I’m still feeling my way back into Irish tv/radio. Like Gay Byrne was still hosting the Late Late when I left, which will tell you.)

SolasAnla · 11/03/2022 11:35

@Realitydawning98

How the heck that ever got through first time around!! I’d be concerned that the Russians have planted facilitators on other government departments!
You are giving the Russians too much credit. I dont think the legislation prevents secret underground nuclear fall out shelters. The secret spy school and economic espionage may prompt an additional filing requirement. Why there was no NIMBY from the posh neighbours...

It'll be fine.

Planning problem recognised:
www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/homes-and-property/uk-sex-shop-chain-plans-to-open-big-store-in-o-connell-street-1.198983
😯🙈

Solution organised:
www.irishtimes.com/news/council-sets-out-criteria-for-new-look-o-connell-st-1.353398
😀

Expect to see new legislation where diplomatic missions need permission from the Minister by 2025😏

yodaforpresident · 11/03/2022 11:33

@Arabellla has it!

JaneJeffer · 11/03/2022 11:31

And another Grin because I'm still laughing @Moyny

Swipe left for the next trending thread